6 ms·
If customers don’t want this stuff, why isn’t there a competing company offering non-DRM tractors?
by sneak 7y ago
If customers don’t want this stuff, why isn’t there a competing company offering non-DRM tractors?
- wvenable 7y agoWhy was this downvoted? I just made the same comment before noticing this one already done. Competition is what solves these kind of things.
- skywhopper 7y agoSure, but how do you propose to introduce competition into this market?
- Yizahi 7y agoIt will trickle down of course. /s
- rootusrootus 7y agoDeclare John Deere a monopoly and break them up?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mratsim 7y agoI guess, convincing Elon Musk that we need tractors on Mars could stimulate some competition.
- wvenable 7y agoWell the market has already been identified.
- bjt 7y agoThere are nearly three dozen tractor manufacturers in listed on this page: https://www.ranker.com/list/best-tractor-brands/werner-brandes https://www.ranker.com/list/best-tractor-brands/werner-brand.... Deere doesn't have a monopoly. But they do have an incredibly strong brand.
- PerryCox 7y agoBecause the bigger companies forced them out of business or acquired them.
- wetpaws 7y agoBecause there is no competition in the US.
- cpach 7y agoDoes farmers in other countries somehow enjoy a plethora of tractor manufacturers to choose from?
- davchana 7y agoPunjab state of India is pretty much Agriculture based, & have options of Ford, FarmTrac tractors as well as John Deere, Scot, this year models as well as from 1970s; along with local Indian Brands like Sonalika, Preet, Mahindra being equally good or better.
- mythrwy 7y agoMahindra tractors are based on the old International Harvester models I think. They sell them in the US also. They look pretty cool, simple and repairable, but I don't know if they make ones the size of commercial John Deere tractors. All the Mahnindra tractors I've looked at were small.
- davchana 7y agoNo,not as big. All the ones I have seen in Punjab are way smaller, almost the size of an F-150 pickup truck.
- throwaway744678 7y agoIn Europe, Claas, New Holland Come to mind immediately. But there are definitely others.
- lb1lf 7y agoLiving in a rural, Norwegian area, I can remember seeing the following brands of tractors recently - Fiat, Zetor, Case, John Deere, New Holland and Massey Ferguson. I've probably not paid attention to at least a couple more - I am not a tractor aficionado...
- appleshore 7y agohttps://www.opensourceecology.org/marcin-jakubowski https://www.opensourceecology.org/marcin-jakubowski
- bsder 7y agoBecause manufacturing isn't software. It takes a LOT of capital to build a company capable of manufacturing something like a tractor. And nobody will buy it initially because it has an unknown reliability record. Look at the article, the farmers all make predictions about exactly how long those John-Deere tractors will last because they have roughly 40 years of experience working with them.
- xnyan 7y agohttp://www.belarus-tractor.com/en/ http://www.belarus-tractor.com/en/
- jotm 7y agoI think parts availability might be a problem with those, as well as a general lack of knowledge about them. Otherwise, yeah MTZs are simple and easy to fix.
- f311a 7y agoThey are pretty good for their price. The factory is still producing some models that were first designed in the 1970-1980s.
- catalogia 7y agoHow many times must it be demonstrated that "market forces" is not a silver bullet to every problem before people take the hint?
- dsr_ 7y agoMarket forces would work in this situation, if only the situation were different: - if there were an existing competitive market, that would help. - if there were a clear long-term market, that might inspire competition. But in this case, market forces caused the problem.
- catalogia 7y ago> X could solve Y if only Y were Z That's a nice hypothetical, but hardly helps these farmers. The real solution is America's most hated four letter word: regulation.
- deith 7y ago>Market forces would work in this situation, if only the situation were different That can be said every time the market fails to adjust itself.
- gitgudnubs 7y agoThis problem was created by regulation. It's not clear that markets can work when governments grant monopolies, and don't restrict the ensuing vertical integration. The only solution is to grant weaker monopolies.
- floren 7y agoMahindra is selling small and medium tractors in the US now; I don't know for sure but I wouldn't be surprised if they were much more user-serviceable than the American brands people are complaining about.
- kasey_junk 7y agoNote: This story is about heavy duty tractors. Lighter duty tractors are much more competitive marketplace.
- floren 7y agoYeah, Mahindra has some reasonably large tractors on their website, but the really Big Tractors you'll find from say John Deere aren't available. According to Wikipedia they're the largest tractor seller in the world, so maybe they'll expand!
- lostgame 7y agoIf you don't know the answer to that - you may have wanted to think it through a little more. Manufacturing at scale is hard and expensive. John Deere has been doing it for years, creating the most reliable tractors in the world for decades and has only recently decided to bend customers over to give them the ol' in-out-in-out. A new brand would need to start from almost smaller than scratch, and have tens of million dollars of investment to even get started producing their own tractors. Then they'd have the uphill battle of a set of people who are extremely reliant on these machines to trust a new company with no track record with highly mission-critical equipment. It would be an incredibly high-risk investment, with little to no guarantee of success. Instead, as the article says - these farmers are not buying new tractors from anyone at the moment.
- okareaman 7y agoI like to do road trips as a hobby and I see a lot of Japanese and other Asian brand tractors in American farming areas,so there is competition
- Vesuvium 7y agoIs that really a problem in the country of the Silicon Valley? Actually, that might be the only thing preventing this from happening.
- tastygreenapple 7y agoJohn Deere has not been making the 'most reliable tractors in the world for decades'. Their products are categorically inferior to Japanese products like those made by Kubota, and frankly I'd trust a Mahindra to go the distance before a Deere. I think Deere was supported by blind patriotism on small/medium farms and really good post-sale support for large operations. I'm pretty sure their unit sales are falling, hardly a sign of a company that's getting its product right.
- solatic 7y agoIn today's market, your argument doesn't hold water. A new brand would need to start from smaller than scratch? So what? People start new companies every day. It would require tens of millions of dollars of investment? So what? We keep being told how capital markets are just sloshing with cash looking for investment opportunities; that one of the reasons for rising inequality is due to the dearth of investment opportunities for the rich to use to seek returns. They'd have trouble finding customers willing to give them a shot? So what? Every startup has this problem. You solve it by differentiating yourself from your incumbent competitor. When your competitor is so hated that they're getting negative press in national news outlets and state legislatures are being pressured to pass laws, your differentiation proposition is practically written for you. I'm sure there are tractor upstarts out there trying to get funding. The question is, if they're not getting funding then why not, and why doesn't anybody know about them?
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> If customers don’t want this stuff, why isn’t there a competing company offering non-DRM tractors? Because modern capitalism is not a system that will magically fulfill customer needs, despite propaganda to the contrary. The way the system actually works is that the wants/needs of the capital-holders take priority over the wants/needs of other stakeholders (e.g. customers and workers). The other stakeholders are often forced to accept minimally acceptable deals, as long as the capital-holders are able to maintain barriers to entry (like large investments in capital). A new market entrant will likely be tempted (eventually, if not immediately) to implement DRM just like Deere has. And Deere can always drop DRM temporarily if it will let them fend off a competitive threat.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> The way the system actually works is that the wants/needs of the capital-holders take priority over the wants/needs of other stakeholders (e.g. customers and workers). The capital-holders did not (in most cases) get a "you are now free to hose your customers" card. The cases where they are free to do so are cases where there is a lack of competition. So "modern capitalism is not a system that will magically fulfill customer needs in the absence of competition". But if there is actual competition, and the wants of the capital-holders take priority over the wants of the customers, that's not going to work out well for the capital-holders.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> So "modern capitalism is not a system that will magically fulfill customer needs in the absence of competition". But modern capitalism, at least in the American context, is a system being drained of competition. Competitors conspire to destroy it by merging and acquiring each other, and the deregulatory economic zeitgeist that's been in force for 40 years means the government has done little to foster it. Markets tend towards equilibrium, and bitter competition is a kind of disequilibrium.
- skywhopper 7y agoBecause it would be really expensive to start a new tractor manufacturing business; it would take years to even get prototypes up and running; you'd still have to prove that your tractors were as good as or better than these 40 year old antiques (which they probably wouldn't be at first); you'd have to be able to make something that could meet safety and efficiency standards of today while giving up the advantages of tight control over maintenance; you'd have to figure out how to compete with the dealer, mechanic, and parts networks that represent a huge advantage of the existing players; and you'd have to figure out how to do all of that without running out of money. It's probably a twenty-year project. You up for it?
- jay_kyburz 7y agoCould you not simply copy the 40 year old tractors almost exactly. Any patents should be expired.
- andybalholm 7y agoNope. If you did, I'm pretty sure the EPA would shut you down. Emissions regulations aren't quite as strict for tractors as for cars and trucks, but they are headed in the same direction. I don't think it's possible to meet emissions without computerized controls. And once you've put hundreds or thousands of dollars worth of electronics on the tractor, it's hard to resist the temptation to add DRM.
- jay_kyburz 7y agoI know nothing about engines and found this article a good introduction about how computer controls help reduce emissions. https://www.pitchcare.com/news-media/diesel-engine-emissions-all-you-need-to-know.html https://www.pitchcare.com/news-media/diesel-engine-emissions...
- jdboyd 7y agoI think that you would have a hard time getting EPA approval if you starting making brand new copies of legacy engine designs. A new diesel tractor engine has to meet EPA Final Tier 4/ Stage IV standards. I don't know what would stand in the way of making a knock off of the 4440 chassis and transmission that uses a new Cummins or other crate engine though.