7 ms·
Fresh Cambridge Analytica leak ‘shows global manipulation is out of control’
- slick50 7y ago"intelligence expert behind the so-called “Steele dossier” into Trump’s relationship with Russia" A political opponent (with the help of a political party..and possibly a president) worked with a foreign government to dig up dirt on an opponent and affect the 2016 election. It didn't work, but the deed has been done. It's scary that a political party can get away with this with impunity. If it would have worked, would we even be seeing anything about it?
- buboard 7y ago> There’s evidence of really quite disturbing experiments on American voters, manipulating them with fear-based messaging, targeting the most vulnerable, that seems to be continuing. Ironically, it's not clear which party they re referring to
- happytoexplain 7y agoIsn't she explicitly not referring to only one party? If she is, why is it ironic that it's not clear which?
- buboard 7y ago> The documents reveal a much clearer idea of what actually happened in the 2016 US presidential election, which has a huge bearing on what will happen in 2020. It’s the same people involved who we know are building on these same techniques,” she said I m confused, were the Democrats being accused of using manipulative social media ad campaigns in 2016?
- filoleg 7y agoNot sure, but they definitely did it in 2012, back when it was considered cool and forward-looking, to the point of bragging about it in interviews[0]. I don’t blame them for doing it at all, but i definitely feel uneasy about a lot of democrats blaming 2016 elections on cambridge analytica and acting like their party didn’t do it themselves, while also bragging about it publicly. Note: I neither support nor am affiliated with the republican party whatsoever. I also don’t think that cambridge analytica scandal affected the 2016 election outcome in any significant way. 0. https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/facebook-data-scandal-trump-election-obama-2012/ https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/facebook-data-...
- StuffedParrot 7y agoDo you accuse people of the obvious a lot? Because manipulative ads seem to be the lingua franca of us politics.
- buboard 7y agoNot accusing anyone
- baq 7y agoNothing ironic about everyone doing it.
- ianai 7y agoActually at this point the game theoretic best move for all parties is to be as manipulative as possible. To change back to a pre-manipulation equilibrium requires overriding effort against these tactics from all players. I’m treating the hostile sources/interests as outside the game in that examination.
- StuffedParrot 7y agoNot ironic at all! If I were a foreign entity pushing for bilateral agreements I would seed paranoia and doubt everywhere I could. The degree of explicit control that comes out of this manipulation is miniscule compared to its destabilizing effects on political focus.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoFear based political messaging has always been the norm. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=riDypP1KfOU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=riDypP1KfOU
- ianai 7y agoIs there anyone seeing people reflect increased skepticism of internet sourced information following this stuff? Like, I learned in HS to discount the validity and value of “stuff I read on the internet” to 0 until I could verify if through alternate sources.
- pixl97 7y agoBut this is also a means to attack people. For example, what alternative sources. Are they also compromised? This falls under the Bullshit Asymmetry attack.
- ianai 7y agoIf you do enough research through multiple, reputable sources trends do emerge. If someone says something radical like the president is a lizard person and every news outlet is pretty convinced he was born in the US to human parents then it’s safe to work with the understanding that he’s a human-as a silly example to illustrate the concept.
- ben_w 7y agoAs a counter example, I thought roughly 25% of Americans thought Obama was not born in America, despite the birth certificate? And that a similar percentage believe the Bible is the literal truth of God?
- filoleg 7y agoWhile I am aware that he was born in the US (Hawaii), i can see where the confusion might come from (aside from willful ignorance and hatred for him as a person), considering that he was the first president born outside of the continental US (Hawaii; and we all know how many continental americans still don’t realize that Puerto Rico is a US territory) and lived in Indonesia between ages 6 and 20.
- meowface 7y ago
- chopchopgoodbye 7y agoIt would seem as though people don't care. Time after time people are told to their face "you have been manipulated" and rather than resolving to be more vigilant they shrug their shoulders and go about business as usual. People of older generations seem particularly indiscriminate, accepting the "credibility" of any source that has a website. I'm not sure if it's a kind of desensitization or if people don't believe it / don't care but it strikes me as tacit acceptance of massive-scale manipulation which saddens me.
- anovikov 7y agoSee, in the present world, the majority of voters have no good prospects - for purely objective, technologically-driven reasons. Therefore, there are only two ways to make society workable - shut down popular democracy, or manipulate. Meaning, there is no way an average American, or even European, would vote for anything which won't be a blatant lie: because it is too grim. Alternatives as i see them are either "democracy with prequalification", limiting voters pool to 1-10% of population (back to good old days, basically), or outright dictatorship (which is unstable). If i were to pick, i'd probably prefer the manipulations route.
- bradleyankrom 7y ago“democracy with prequalification” is not democracy at all
- EETruth 7y agoYes it is.
- anovikov 7y agoWhy not? Just build rules about who gets to vote. It may include certain minimum level of education and/or income and/or property. So that people who are able to decide for themselves, and have a stake in the game, get to vote.
- bostik 7y agoAs grim as this may sound: it is in fact the original meaning of the word. The words we are more likely to associate with the setup would be "oligarchy" or "plutocracy".
- nyolfen 7y agoit’s almost every democracy that has ever existed. this is like the ‘not real communism’ position
- anovikov 7y agoBut this is how democracy worked from the very beginning. Only free men, property owners voted. The Greeks would call "democracies" of today, ochlocracies, which they deemed to be the worst form of government. Voting of largely irresponsible people with nothing to lose. It's either prequalification, or manipulations to make those voters irrelevant, reduce them to just noise. And of course, in today's world of lies, manipulations are the way to go.
- ourcat 7y agoFrom early posts in the @HindsightFiles feed Malaysia: http://repo.hindsightfiles.com/01012020/malaysia.zip http://repo.hindsightfiles.com/01012020/malaysia.zip Kenya: http://repo.hindsightfiles.com/01012020/kenya.zip http://repo.hindsightfiles.com/01012020/kenya.zip Brazil: http://repo.hindsightfiles.com/01012020/brazil.zip http://repo.hindsightfiles.com/01012020/brazil.zip
- DyslexicAtheist 7y agoIran: (2014-2016) https://repo.hindsightfiles.com/01042020/iran.zip https://repo.hindsightfiles.com/01042020/iran.zip
- dghughes 7y agoThis reminds me of the HyperNormalisation documentary. You're instinct is to verify the information by reading about it elsewhere but it's hard to verify something so obscure.
- scottlocklin 7y agoAlternate title: "the guardian discovers marketing is used"
- cm2012 7y agoI'm a professional ad manager. These lists have 0 value. At scale, it's always better to use algorithmic targeting than uploading lists to target. This is true on any ad network, but especially on Facebook.
- texasbigdata 7y agoWhy? And dont you sort of know the population skews a certain way given the platform you choose (guessing quora differs from bing which differs from coupons in the mail)? Restated, and this might be so off base and tangential that maybe it's not worth answering, but if you were say....something reasonable like a dentist. And you were fairly far along in your practice and had tenure. Let's say in that case your "list" represents a fairly not insignificant amount of the people around you. Say 5%? 10%? Whatever is reasonable. Even in that case the algorithm is better?
- cm2012 7y agoI actually have a subspecialty in targeting narrow business verticals, and yeah, the algorithm is better 95% of the time.
- texasbigdata 7y agoOh cool. Interesting!
- AndrewKemendo 7y ago"There’s evidence of really quite disturbing experiments on American voters, manipulating them with fear-based messaging, targeting the most vulnerable, that seems to be continuing. This is an entire global industry that’s out of control" Lets be clear this is the explicit purpose of the advertising and public relations industry. 1. Create Art (writing, multimedia etc...) intended to influence viewer 2. Distribute Art via Large Scale Channels 3. Hope that people exposed to it take the action you want them to For Coca-cola they want you to "Buy Coke" For AirBnB they want you to book a stay For Politicians they want you to vote for them Politicians have always used the media channels of the day to advertise themselves. So it's extremely unclear what is news here aside from the fact that Politicians are following Corporate levels of sophistication for advertising. I think what it really shows is that Advertising in total is a toxic and corrupting business and should be banned outright for all things.
- CptFribble 7y agoAs long as free speech is considered important, ads aren't going anywhere (note: I consider free speech important). Even if you ban directives from ads (Buy Product Now!) ads can be reduced to simple voicing of opinions on a media channel ("I love product X, you'd love it too, I'm sure!"), which is what most ads are anyways - emotional persuasion, not the old style "Johnny's Canned Beans are the most nutritious!" from the early days of TV. And if you're talking about banning all paid endorsements, I guarantee there will be 10,000 loopholes that look like Citizens United/SuperPAC behavior, where a person performs the advertising speech in public for free, and then is later given gifts and trips and other things for "unrelated reasons" from an "industry interest group." In short, we need to incorporate critical thinking/mental and emotional resilience/manipulation resistance into the educational system, which I'm pretty sure will never ever happen since the Powers That Be are all there precisely because, as you said, they all use the media channels of the day to manipulate.
- franky47 7y agoAdverts are not free speech. Public service announcements on billboards might be, like the band trying to promote their underground concert in town, or an association promoting a cultural event. But you can't put those in the same basket as big corporations paying multiple k$ for premium attention-grabbing spots with fancy graphics to make you dream of things you don't need.
- wrinklz 7y agoThe problem with targeted advertising in free elections is that voters need to know what the candidates are saying everywhere. Transparency is not the enemy of free speech, at least with respect to elections. Either voters need access to all campaign ads (and to whom they are targeted), or targeted campaign messages need to be eliminated, or some combination. Or maybe there's a better solution, but at least let's agree on the transparency problem.