14 ms·
Seems to me the shift to "Matchmaking" style online multiplayer has caused a whole lot of problems that weren't that big a deal back in the "community server" d
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
Seems to me the shift to "Matchmaking" style online multiplayer has caused a whole lot of problems that weren't that big a deal back in the "community server" days. I personally think one can blame the rampant toxicity of players on this removal of the community aspect.
- Nasrudith 7y agoThere were plenty of toxic jerks online period with community lobbies. Although if you found a good server or set of them it mitigated the exposure. A big difference experience wise but the underlying problem was the same. Ranked Ladder, PUG Teams, PVP, and especially "griefing mechanics" related to losses for the loser from the stakes can all cumulatively contribute to toxicity.
- nkrisc 7y agoI have to agree. There were good alternative approaches. For example, I used to play Battlefield 1942 a lot when it was current. A lot of the larger communities had public servers, but also private servers that only people who the mods got to know would be whitelisted for. In the more well-run communities, the mods would hang out and spend some time on the public server to keep order, or were at least accessible (via TeamSpeak, often) if they weren't actively on it. Cheaters quickly got banned from the public servers and people who stuck with the community could enjoy the private server where they knew there'd be a good group of people and usually very little toxicity.
- CodeWriter23 7y agoI made some really good friends playing 1942. Guys I met up with IRL, in other states even. The only probs we had were the “defeat the ceiling by flying upside down” pilots and trash talking with other clans could get a little spammy. The rivalry was welcome though and we mostly resolved it by kicking ass on various ladders. And occasionally getting our asses handed to us. WoW coming along and deflating our numbers made me sad.
- nkrisc 7y agoFunny, it was the launch of WoW that got me to stop playing. A bunch of the folks I played with made a guild and left bf behind mostly.
- Mirioron 7y agoThe problem is that there's a huge skill difference in games like League of Legends. Matchmaking has made some players improve so much that if you throw them into community servers then other (weaker) players end up not having fun. This is less of a problem in a shooter, because there are no real penalties for dying (other than score), but in a game like LoL it quickly snowballs out of control.
- danShumway 7y agoMy hot-take as a smaller game designer is that I am skeptical that global competitive ladders are good design. I admit that's fringe, and I'm not going to fight people over it. But I can't imagine myself ever designing a system like that for any of my games. First, I think these systems ignore technical realities, and design has to pay attention to real-world constraints. Blocking cheaters is insanely hard, and almost no real-time games that I know of do it at what I believe is an acceptable level. It's a nice idea that I don't think is technically supported, in the same way that it would be a nice idea if my photorealistic MMO didn't have loading screens anywhere and loaded everything instantly. It's not good design to spend a bunch of effort hinging your game design on something that's not technically possible for you to do. Second, I think these systems ignore player incentives. I think that global competitive ranking encourages the worst of playerbases, that skill is an arbitrary mechanism to optimize on instead of something like how close each match was, or player-reported satisfaction levels, or variety of play-styles, or any other of a dozen other metrics. Third, caring about bots radically shrinks your design space. You can't have exploits, players have to have a "right" way to play, modding has to be more limited. It shrinks the game not only in the sense that it makes your systems more complicated -- it fundamentally shrinks what your game can do as a game, and how your game can evolve with the rest of the medium. Finally, not only is skill not a particularly rewarding metric to optimize on when what you really want is for your players to have fun, most of the problems with automation explicitly only are a problem for competitive matchmaking. If you're optimizing for player-reported satisfaction, you probably don't care if people are botting your game, because successful bots will be optimizing for creating good matches instead of for just winning[0]. Personal plug, with my current project, Loop Thesis, LAN play is the only multiplayer. I only want people to play with friends, and I'm not trying to build some kind of community or network. That decision has simplified my architecture so much, the game is so much more modder friendly, the networking code is so much simpler, everything is nicer, and more stable, and more player friendly, because I don't have to care about bots and cheaters. Future games that I make, even if they include global matchmaking, will not have global competitive rankings. My personal take now has become that 90% of the time these systems are a design antipattern. It's counterproductive. I want players playing my game to have fun. I have to ban bots because they make the game not fun. The reason the bots make the game not fun is because all of my design hinges fun on giving players an optimization problem that I explicitly don't want them to solve in creative ways. The bots are solving the optimization problem too well. So getting rid of that optimization problem, getting rid of the rankings, makes so many other design/engineering problems go away. The bots aren't the problem, the optimization problem is the problem. [0]: https://xkcd.com/810/ https://xkcd.com/810/
- debaserab2 7y agoI see what you mean but I do think in some ways the community servers also insulate and protect a lot of that toxicity and even allow it to be amplified. Being a new player and joining the "wrong" community server can be a pretty toxic experience.
- baby 7y agoI can tell you that there were a huge number of cheaters back in the days as well. The bigger problem now are f2p games were cheaters don’t have to re purchase a game after getting banned.
- celticmusic 7y ago> I personally think one can blame the rampant toxicity of players on this removal of the community aspect. I think this happens way more than people realize. A great example is League of Legends, which is known for its toxic community. They throw you in a game with 4 other people. If 1 of them decides to be an asshole you're stuck for a minimum of 20 minutes + the 10 it took for queue + lobby. So you're FORCED to stay in this game for 30 minutes because you got an asshole teammate. Imagine playing a game of pickup basketball where one of your teammates started scoring for the other team and you were forced to continue playing the game out rather than simply leaving. Of course your community is frustrated. And the response anytime people ask for changes to help with the situation is that they can't because someone might abuse it to save their rank. If it were me, I'd create a system where you get free games and treat it like a currency. If someone is being an asshole, just turn in your token, you leave the game unpunished and you get to flag the player(s) that caused you to do it. I stopped playing the game because of the completely lack of control over your own destiny.
- SerLava 7y ago>If it were me, I'd create a system where you get free games and treat it like a currency. If someone is being an asshole, just turn in your token, you leave the game unpunished and you get to flag the player(s) that caused you to do it. The issue there is that the game has 10 players in it. Say you have only 3 "leave" tokens per month. That's small and will probably only slightly address the issue. If the average player plays 30 games a month, they can leave up to 10% of their games. And if someone uses this "leave" token, can you really punish the other players for not wanting to play a broken match? You can't require them to burn their own leave token. So it's one leave token, and everyone can leave. If 10 players leave 10% of their games... then on average, there's one missing person per game. And most of those games will simply end. Then, when you have 5 losing players, they have 15 tokens between them per month. With 30 games a month, your players can leave very roughly half the games. Matchmaking aims for 50/50 win/lose. You could literally just leave every losing game. And the other team would do this if you were winning. You would only really get a few serious games toward the end of the month when all 5 or 10 people happen to run out of coins. This system would actually probably just make people scream death threats at their own teammates for doing too well because the only proper way to win a game would be to eke it out at the last second. In other words, the toxicity is built in to MOBA gameplay inherently and can only be suppressed.