5 ms·
A lower climate impact is almost like a luxury item. Sure, a fancy expensive restaurant can afford to do this, and the best part for them is that the whole thin
by dangus 7y ago
A lower climate impact is almost like a luxury item. Sure, a fancy expensive restaurant can afford to do this, and the best part for
them is that the whole thing can be sold as part of the dining experience.
That’s not exactly a solution to the dives and street food joints that couldn’t operate without some form of disposable containers or cutlery. And more importantly, that’s not a solution to the customers of those dives that can’t afford anything more expensive.
On the other hand, I imagine that a portion of waste reduction can simply be a change in habits and doesn’t necessarily cost anything.
I was once trying to explain this sort of idea to a climate change denying acquaintance. I said, forget the environment or the turtles, even if you don’t believe this is harming our environment, why are we using these devices designed to be immediately thrown away? Why do you need a straw with your water/soda but not with your beer? Where does that habit come from?
- nordsieck 7y ago> why are we using these devices designed to be immediately thrown away? I mean, the answer is pretty easy: people have a strong preference for options that help reduce their cognitive load. People prefer restaurants that provide take out containers rather than require they bring Tupperware. People prefer grocery stores that provide bags rather than require they bring their own. This isn't true of everyone - conscientiousness is normally distributed - but it is true for most people most of the time.
- dangus 7y agoThat’s something I’m trying to get at, the wealthy and/or upper middle class have the luxury of having time for that cognitive load of certain “conscientious” activities like that. The upper middle class and wealthy who already harm the environment more by flying frequently or driving a brand new 25MPG Audi instead of a 40MPG 10 year old Nissan Versa aren’t going to save the planet by going to a zero-waste fancy restaurant, and they might be eating at that restaurant to alleviate their own guilt because they know they’re using more than their fair share in the first place. For every one of them there’s 15 people working two jobs and eating at a fast food joint with disposable cutlery because there is no other option that fits their schedule or budget. But they might be less wasteful anyway because they don’t have the money to buy a few thousand pounds of jet fuel.
- thatfrenchguy 7y ago> For every one of them there’s 15 people working two jobs and eating at a fast food joint with disposable cutlery because there is no other option that fits their schedule or budget Very US-centric though, people in most european countries eat at home.
- phonypc 7y agoPeople in the US eat at home too. Do you mean to suggest Europeans eat at home more often? I could believe there's a small difference, but although Europe might not be covered in fast food chains at the same rate as the US, I'd guess smaller eateries more than make up for that.
- nationsobviou 7y agoI, and everyone I know from my European cultural background, cook basically every day. OTOH I have some US friends who I am not even sure know how to cook
- JohnFen 7y agoI, and nearly everyone I know here in the US, also cooks pretty much every day.
- nationsobviou 7y agoThis both enlightens and pleases me :-)
- JohnFen 7y ago> Very US-centric though, people in most european countries eat at home. I'm in the US, and 95% of the time, I cook my own food and eat it at home. So does nearly everyone I know.
- NovemberWhiskey 7y ago> driving a brand new 25MPG Audi instead of a 40MPG 10 year old Nissan Versa I know this is not your substantive point but ... The extent to which CAFE standards have improved mileage even over the past 10 years should not be ignored, and you should check your assumptions about fuel economy. e.g. 2020 Audi A4 gets basically the same combined mileage as the 2010 Nissan Versa. https://fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=29866&id=42220 https://fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=29866&id=4...
- narag 7y agoThat seems a cultural thing. In Spain disposable cutlery would be unthinkable except for McDonalds. Any menu-of-the-day cheap blue-collar bar will have real cutlery and fabric.
- shantly 7y agoIt’s mostly for fast food and take-out places in the US, too.
- Pigo 7y agoI find a lot of the bags and boxes I'm forced to use annoying. I buy one thing at the pharmacy and they print out a receipt that is sometimes 8 feet long (dead serious) and put it all in a bag that I would immediately throw away. I tell them I don't need the bag, but I'm still stuck with these ridiculous receipts full of coupons I don't care about. Purely from an annoyance standpoint, this bothers me a great deal. I know the company/cashiers assume it's expected of them, but to me it's like the gallon sized drinks at fast food chains. It aggravates me that anyone thinks it's necessary. The Amazon packing and boxing situation is a whole other level of annoying.
- glenneroo 7y ago> People prefer grocery stores that provide bags rather than require they bring their own. Definitely cultural, AFAIK most Europeans brings their own bags for groceries and it's just automatic. Otherwise you have to buy a new bag at check-out.
- thatfrenchguy 7y agoThat's because they stopped giving them for free: ~10 years ago we still had plastic bags everywhere in France. Make people pay for their waste, usually it helps reducing them.
- beerandt 7y agoAt the risk of... whatever: Disposable items (properly disposed of, ie landfilled) can be, and often are, more environmentally friendly than reusable items. Especially if you look at actual real life use, as opposed to projected or design use. Look at a UK LCA of shopping bags: A cotton tote needs to be reused ~173 times without being washed to break even with the efficiency of a single use HDPE bag. (Edit: other alternatives, like LDPE, paper or woven plastic, are also listed as low as multiplier of 2x vs HDPE. I didn't intend to mislead.) If you're not doing a whole load of dishes, it can be more efficient to use plastic or paper plates for a meal, and trash them. The cost of just washing something can be relatively and unreasonably high, environmentally speaking. The green movement has been over reliant on emotional programming (reuse = always good, plastic = always bad, etc) and needs to invest more in actual education. Landfills have gotten an especially unearned negative connotation. Hopefully the new generation of college graduates are getting proper training in conducting proper Life Cycle Analysis'. Not saying reuse is always bad or that we shouldn't be analysing these things, just that they need analysis, and not a collective gut reaction. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/291023/scho0711buan-e-e.pdf https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm...
- nradov 7y agoBanning single use plastic bags is more about reducing litter and water contamination than about energy efficiency. Lightweight plastic bags are particularly bad because the wind blows them everywhere and they often end up in oceans or rivers. This causes serious harm to aquatic environments.
- beerandt 7y agoYes, and that's fine, but it's also somewhat a different problem. One that is better solved with a deposit scheme, redesign, or some other method than tax and ban. (Edit: or the obvious- using biodegradable additives in HDPE at a marginal cost.) Make them twice as thick. Melt a weight into the seam of each one to prevent flying and floating. You'd still be a magnitude ahead of the alternatives. There are alternatives besides banning. They have their problems, but people don't realize what a damn miracle of engineering HDPE bags are. And other disposable paper and plastic items, to a lesser extent.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Sure, a fancy expensive restaurant can afford to do this Looks like a pretty humble vegetarian bistro to me? Far from fancy. And I would have thought someone best places to have a huge impact here might be someone like McDonalds, with their supplier clout they could force suppliers to meet high standards and with their scale it could have a huge impact.
- dmos62 7y agoWhy are you looking to businesses to initiate change? Rally for state regulation.
- chrisseaton 7y agoDoes the state have any expertise in how to reduce food supply waste? Not sure why you’d task them over people who know the problem intimately.
- close04 7y agoThe state doesn't have to tell you how, just to mandate it. See pollution standards where the point isn't to come up with a technical solution but with a measurable expectation.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- macintux 7y agoSetting aside the philosophical question around whether government should be compelling businesses to make these sort of changes, change has to come at all levels, from personal to organizational to government, and businesses can implement change with much more immediacy than government can. E.g., McDonald's shifting to cage-free hens for egg purchases. Regardless of the reasons, that was expected to have a huge impact on egg farming.
- 7y ago
- narag 7y ago...a portion of waste reduction can simply be a change in habits and doesn’t necessarily cost anything. My father had a restaurant long ago. He hired a professional and prestigious cooker (the the title "chef" was not so common then) and the first thing he noticed is that everything was used. There were a thousand tricks to plan the menus so meat not served were reused for broth and so on.
- hobs 7y agoThis is the old way of cooking - waste means you have to go pull it out of the fields or kill it yourself. Honestly, its a sign of a great (and often family or locally run) restaurant when I see they are rolling their menu into the next day in a circumspect way - its a sign to me that they understand their menu very well and know the best ways to present it.
- soneil 7y agoBeing a luxury isn’t necessarily a bad thing. There’s some cost to being a trailblazer, but it opens the trail for others to follow. In this case, being able to pick and choose suppliers who can accommodate their needs is a luxury, but once the suppliers are tooled for that, it’s easier for others with less clout to follow. A lot of changes are chicken and egg scenarios, where the market can’t move without the supply chain, and the supply chain can’t move without the demand. If someone has the means to kickstart that, more power to them. For example, 10 years ago smartphones were a luxury - now I know homeless people who use them to access public services. And I don’t see how we could have got to this point, without starting at “luxury”.
- gumby 7y ago> That’s not exactly a solution to the dives and street food joints that couldn’t operate without some form of disposable containers or cutlery. And more importantly, that’s not a solution to the customers of those dives that can’t afford anything more expensive. Street vendors could dispense into your container or charge you for a disposable one.
- GuB-42 7y agoI don't see it as a solution, more like an experiment. Zero waste is impractical. But having a zero waste restaurant showcases possible solutions for more practical waste reduction.
- dublinben 7y ago>A lower climate impact is almost like a luxury item. Only from the perspective of a citizen of a wealthy country trapped in a mindset of consumerism. Inhabitants of wealthy countries on average consume multiples of what inhabitants of poorer countries do.¹ The easiest way to lower your climate impact is to simply consume less. This doesn't cost anything, and in fact saves you money. ¹https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di...
- derekp7 7y agoYou generally don't have ice in your beer. Because ice makes beer gross (I'd like to find the scientific reason why, but it just does). Soda and water are typically served with ice, and it is difficult to drink it without a straw. Especially crushed ice. Now if you had a lid on the cup similar to car coffee mugs (where the top is indented with a small hole for the liquid to flow through), then that could be a solution for the straws.