5 ms·
This is a really neat project but it’s also not really a solution to anything. First, it doesn’t solve for the scenario of person pointing a gun at you and tel
by dangus 7y ago
This is a really neat project but it’s also not really a solution to anything.
First, it doesn’t solve for the scenario of person pointing a gun at you and telling you to access your top secret files for them. That will defeat most forms of security and so if physical access is a concern you probably shouldn’t be logging in at your local coffee shop.
Second, a thief who wants your computer for its monetary value isn’t interested in its contents. Your normal drive encryption and screen timeout restrictions have you covered there. They’re gonna wipe your computer, sell it, and move on.
Institutionally purchased hardware is often equipped with zero-touch provisioning (such as Apple Device Enrollment). These products can be bricked at the hardware level they moment they touch the Internet. They’ll need a new logic board, i.e. new soldered on storage, i.e. they’re not even necessarily worth stealing.
Third, the idea of a magnetic connector’s removal locking or bricking your computer seems awfully inconvenient. That’s gonna be constant false positives without a gain in security.
If you’ve got someone who is after you to obtain your secret company info and knows enough to cause mayhem, you’ve got much bigger problems than whether or not your screen is going to lock. They’re also probably going to use social engineering, targeted malware and spyware, not brute force physical access.
- jefftk 7y ago> it’s also not really a solution to anything It's a solution to situations like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross_Ulbricht#Silk_Road,_arrest_and_trial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross_Ulbricht#Silk_Road,_arres... , where the laptop is taken by people who (a) can legally seize it, (b) can legally search it, but (c) probably can't legally compel you to produce passwords. (Not endorsing this usage!)
- koheripbal 7y agoCases like this in countries that do not have due process laws makes the use-case even more compelling.
- dangus 7y agoIf they don’t have due process laws they can throw you in jail until you produce the decryption password, and if they turn on the computer and it’s wiped they’ll throw away the key. If there is no due process, all bets are off and your best defense is to be uninteresting to authorities.
- ianbooker 7y agoThings are not always black and / or white. The rule of law, in reality, is rather a continuous variable then a binary one. And even if: A kill switch can simply hide / erase some things and present some weak evidence..
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ShakataGaNai 7y agoThe author of the article clearly had that or something very similar in mind when he wrote this piece. It reads exactly like that story (I had the same thought as you). It's a very good solution for people who don't know you have something like this. Clearly if the FBI (or whatever) knew of the USB kill device, they'd take a slightly different snatch and grab approach. However if the adversary doesn't think or doesn't know you have something like this, then it can be used to great effect.
- slipheen 7y agoAbsolutely agreed. I've read that LEO in the USA specifically try to grab laptops / phones while they are unlocked. This seems to be designed as a defense against that threat model.
- Timpy 7y agoI agree I think it's a neat project, however you can't say that it's not a solution to anything. The introduction describes a thief snatching and running with your laptop just after you've logged in to your online banking. I think that's a good example of something this solves, even if it's a really narrow use case. Slippery sloping your way to "gun pointed at you" is like saying the lock on my front door doesn't solve for anything because there's a glass window right next to it. BusKill is better for coffee shop thieves than it is top secret gun blazing spies. Regardless, k_sze posted somewhere else in this discussion xkcd 538 (https://www.xkcd.com/538/ https://www.xkcd.com/538/) and I have to agree with him.
- RIMR 7y agoYour first point is moot, because a person could point a gun at you even when you don't have your computer and demand your passwords, or even kidnap you and force you to log on somewhere else. This solution doesn't aim to prevent that kind of thing. Your second point is moot, because the intent is not to protect the hardware, it is to revoke access to data. A self-destruct protocol is not about preservation of property. Your third point is moot, because the intent is not to be convenient, the point is to create a dead man's switch. You're thinking about this from a Consumer/Enterprise standpoint, but that's not what this is for. This would be great for political activists in oppressive countries, as an example.
- miles 7y ago> This is a really neat project but it’s also not really a solution to anything. Knowing your encrypted data is inaccessible to a thief is a huge relief, and may have saved this man's life: A man working at Starbucks had his laptop stolen. He was killed when he chased down the thief. https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/01/us/oakland-laptop-thief-starbucks-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/01/us/oakland-laptop-thief-starb...
- papreclip 7y agoSome faith in the Oakland PD to actually work property theft cases might have saved his life
- hackmiester 7y agoIn my experience with the priorities of police departments in general, this faith would be misplaced. Not that a laptop or data is worth your life (usually).
- amelius 7y ago> Second, a thief who wants your computer for its monetary value isn’t interested in its contents. They could blackmail you, sending you an email with a bitcoin address you should transfer money to or else the data will go public.