19 ms·
>"But the extraordinary case draws attention to how dictatorships are increasingly using technology to crush online dissent." Yes, authoritarian regimes contro
by mc32 7y ago
>"But the extraordinary case draws attention to how dictatorships are increasingly using technology to crush online dissent."
Yes, authoritarian regimes control communication. That's been the case for over a century of radio and mass circulation dailies. It's nothing new.
What is new is that even democratic countries are controlling free speech via speech laws or often the private companies engaging in evaluating what's permissible speech and not above and beyond what laws require. To wit what comprises "hate speech". It's basically come to mean "point of view in disagreement with my group's current position which may change in the future"
- wavefunction 7y ago>private companies engaging in evaluating what's permissible speech and not I don't feel this is an issue until you can't spin up your own website/app/platform and allow whatever speech you want. I am interested for any responses as to why I might be mistaken from people who disagree with me, though.
- systematical 7y agoSome of these tech companies are so large and pervasive that they are integral parts of society. The policies they enact with that power can have a chilling effect. Now, whether we should or shouldn't do something about that is another matter. The Government has certainly shown a willingness to regulate industries that got to big for their britches before.
- wavefunction 7y ago>integral parts of society I am not sure I agree with these companies being an integral part of society. I feel pretty confident they could be replaced by alternatives operated by other people and most if not all users would not notice the difference. But I've seen that happen with the early WWW with Altavista, Yahoo, etc. And if they are an integral part of society then I think they should be heavily regulated for things like foreign and domestic propaganda and the promotion of dangerous falsehoods. It's either self-regulation (within legal reason) and whatever they decide is appropriate for their platforms, or they should be heavily regulated with guaranteed free expression as allowed by law.
- systematical 7y agoFacebook, Twitter, and Google. I think they are integral. Sure, you could replace them with different names, but the result is the same.
- UnpossibleJim 7y agoI think if we haven't had any serious conversation about making internet service a public utility, then it seems a bit of a farce to consider talking about companies like these as integral to our modern society. How proper internet service is still held hostage by the likes of Comcast and Verizon is beyond me, with little discussion given while everyone talks about the leverage of these three companies.
- systematical 7y agoDo you consider the press part of society?
- Nasrudith 7y agoThat is a very different question - both dropping integral a very vast and the entire press vs particularly large publishers. The answer is yes but irrelevant as so are embezzlers, serial killers or would a hypothetical few who literally want to actively to destroy every trace of it. The question is vague enough that literal cancer could get both yes and no as answers logically (cases caused by society part of it vs existing independently in species without anything to remotely qualify as a society).
- mc32 7y agoThat's only part of the equation though. People who disagree with PoVs not only want to get people suspended or banned from ubiquitous comms platforms but they also want to doxx them and publicly shame them. I'm not talking about immediate threats of violence or disgusting vile language. But more generic points of view on various contentious topics. But let's take your objection at face value. Let's say a certain Senator has declared the senator wants to break up some certain major tech companies and these companies disagree. Under your take they would be within their rights to suspend or ban or de-rank such candidates given they already have their websites as platforms to comms and moreover that's a non event.
- wavefunction 7y agoI don't agree with doxxing or getting people fired. I am fine with facebook/twitter/etc. de-ranking/suspending/hiding/whatever a candidate who has called for their breakup, even though I support their breakup.
- bilbo0s 7y agoI agree with it all. Here's the thing, you either support freedom of speech and expression, or you don't. Now if you do, then you have to support the nazi's right to speak and express, the abortion doctor's right to speak and express, the senator's right to speak and express, and the beggar's right to speak and express. Everyone's right must be supported. If someone wants to express themselves to my boss via boycott in an effort to get me fired, so be it. That's their right. Just as it's the nazi's right to express himself on the internet to better inform people about the tenets of his ideology. The government must have no ability to constrict either activity. It may not seem like it, but it's actually a good thing that the government can't stop any of these people from doing any of these things. If you want to get the government to disallow any boycotts of companies, then you are not really in favor of freedom of speech and expression.
- nl 7y agoHere's the thing, you either support freedom of speech and expression, or you don't. There are plenty of gradients to freedom of expression - child porn is an obvious one, and German law against Nazi speech is another, and there are things in-between like advertisements for opioids or tobacco. All you've done is restate the absolutist position, without addressing the challenges of that position which include: criminal speech, commercial speech, and the fact the restrictions on some speech have been successfully implemented without all the negative side effects that absolutists claim are inevitable.
- elfexec 7y ago> I don't feel this is an issue until you can't spin up your own website/app/platform and allow whatever speech you want. I mostly agree with you on "website/app". As for the platform, it really depends on the nature and size of the platform. If it becomes an essential platform or if it is a monopoly, then you could argue it has utility features and hence everyone has a right to it. For example, you wouldn't say a power or water company doesn't have to serve you because you can go start your own power or water company. You could argue that twitter is an essential platform since its the primary form of communication for the president. It is a platform for you to communicated with your elected official. Hence twitter as a platform is a "utility" and cannot block US citizens from accessing it and exercising their 1st amendment rights. This actually could be an interesting Supreme Court case if anyone who has been banned wants to ligitate. It could actually be precedent-setting. You could argue that facebook, youtube, etc are monopolies that nearly serve the purpose of a utility and hence you have a right to it. Also, you could argue that these american companies have a duty to follow the "spirit of free speech" in our country even if they aren't legally bound to it. There are arguments to be made on both sides. Unfortunately, it isn't being taken through the legal system.
- wavefunction 7y agoI think if a platform like twitter or facebook have become a "utility" or indispensable to society then they should be heavily regulated and fall under society's control. I replied elsewhere that I am not sure I agree that these platforms have achieved indispensability but leaving that aside if they are integral to society then society should control them. >you could argue that these american companies have a duty to follow the "spirit of free speech" in our country even if they aren't legally bound to it I could not personally argue this in any shape way or form because I don't even know what to base this claim on. Free speech has been restricted historically (often during war-time but also for various populations of people.) It has been restricted for pragmatic reasons (like perjury).
- deogeo 7y agoBecause speech is meaningless without an audience, and people on mainstream platforms don't all know about or agree with those platform's moderation/censorship policies. Sure people shouldn't be "forced to listen to everyone's message", but what if it's a message someone does want to listen to, but the platform doesn't want to transmit? And since they don't even know the message exists, they won't be seeking it out on alternative platforms.
- nl 7y agowhat if it's a message someone does want to listen to, but the platform doesn't want to transmit? And since they don't even know the message exists, they won't be seeking it out on alternative platforms. Are you talking about Fox News not broadcasting the benefits of public health options or CNN not broadcasting something beneficial about guns here? Yes it's a problem. It's unclear it it limited to digital platforms.
- bilbo0s 7y agoIt's not a problem though. Private platforms, whether digital or not, do not have to carry your message. That's also a part of free expression. Fox is free to ignore whomever they choose. Everyone gets rights, not just the platform, not just the user. The user can speak whatever he wants, and so can the platform. There are good reasons for this, it allows for propaganda portals like fox news, but it also allows for real, well researched journalism like propublica.
- nl 7y ago>>> ... since they don't even know the message exists, they won't be seeking it out on alternative platforms. >> .. Yes it's a problem. It's unclear it it limited to digital platforms. > It's not a problem though... You didn't seem to address the OP's issue ("they don't even know the message exists, they won't be seeking it out on alternative platforms") here at all?
- bilbo0s 7y ago
- mistermann 7y agoYour evaluation seems to disregard the relative network sizes and in turn exposure one has on a mainstream platform vs a tiny user created one. This difference seems so obvious to me, I suspect you may only have a limited subset of "issues" in mind, such as the 1st amendment.
- wavefunction 7y agoI don't believe that anyone is guaranteed an audience for their free expression. I don't believe I'm disregarding anything?
- mistermann 7y agoThe guarantee is not the point. If anything is altered by censorship, like ability to get one's message in front of people, it is an issue. Whether your personal ideology considers that problematic has no bearing on the fact that change has occurred.
- bilbo0s 7y agoThe point is, you don't have a right to get your message in front of people. You only have a right to speak your message. You can speak your message in the middle of the street, but the government is under no obligation to force people to stop on the street and listen to your message. Because other people have the right to ignore you. That right to ignore and not associate with you is also part of free speech and free expression. There really are no further guarantees to free speech and expression other than being able to speak and express.
- mistermann 7y agoAs I said earlier: > This difference seems so obvious to me, I suspect you may only have a limited subset of "issues" in mind, such as the 1st amendment. Free speech seems like an unlikely candidate for culture war status (and the ensuing cognitive behaviors), but it seems unmistakable.
- ryukafalz 7y ago>I don't feel this is an issue until you can't spin up your own website/app/platform and allow whatever speech you want. We're already kinda at this point. I don't condone them, obviously, but sites like the Daily Stormer and 8chan have been kicked off several registrars, and at one point one of their hosting providers got kicked off their upstream provider for hosting them. I'm generally fine with social media companies policing their sites, but I get nervous when we start talking about similar things in core internet infrastructure. I think we're setting a dangerous precedent for the future if we do that.
- dd36 7y agoExamples in the US beyond terrorists or terrorist sympathizers? The rules of a platform tend to be transparent.
- catalogia 7y ago> The rules of a platform tend to be transparent. There are a lot of prominent youtube creators saying the rules are vague at best. And the scope of those rules is certainly not limited to terrorism. Terrorism is the boogie man governments and corporations cite when they want people to be compliant, but the bulk of enforcement in practice is against mundane shit like copyright infringement or scatological jokes that offend grandparents with sensitive dispositions.
- Pfhreak 7y agoLGBTQ+ creators come to mind as folks who often get demonitized.
- jellicle 7y agoHN runs at least one story a week along the lines of "I got banned from the app store and no one will tell me why".
- jakelazaroff 7y ago> What is new is that even democratic countries are controlling free speech via speech laws or often the private companies engaging in evaluating what's permissible speech and not above and beyond what laws require. That's not new at all. Here are a few of the many, many examples from the past century or so: - The Comstock laws, passed in the 1870s, criminalized the sending of "obscenity", contraceptives and sex toys via USPS [1] - There was literally a US agency called the "Office of Censorship" during WWII! [2] - The US entertainment industry denied employment to many people suspected of affiliating with Communism in the 1950s [3] - Lenny Bruce was arrested multiple times and eventually convicted for obscenity (saying e.g. "cocksucker" onstage) in the 1960s [4] - During the Jim Crow era, it was a misdemeanor in Mississippi to publish materials advocating social equality or interracial marriage between white and black people [5] - Laws against child pornography have apparently only existed in the US since 1977 (!) but still exist today [6] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comstock_laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comstock_laws [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Censorship [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_blacklist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_blacklist [4] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenny_Bruce#Obscenity_arrests https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenny_Bruce#Obscenity_arrest... [5] https://www.nps.gov/malu/learn/education/jim_crow_laws.htm https://www.nps.gov/malu/learn/education/jim_crow_laws.htm [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_pornography#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_pornography#History
- mc32 7y agoSo It’s even worse because now it’s not only the government which can set rules where we can have some say in what the rules are given we elect the government, but now we are happy to have companies themselves without input from the government “do what’s best for us”.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoWe've always been happy to have that happen. Take the Red Scare as an example: Gallup poll found that popular support for Joseph McCarthy peaked at 50% in 1954 [1]. In other words, a full half of the US population was in favor of companies blacklisting people from employment on the basis of their political views. [1] https://books.google.com/books?id=ViXaw6NSkrYC&pg=PA263#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=ViXaw6NSkrYC&pg=PA263#v=on...
- simonh 7y agoI disagree this is nothing new, it's an unprecedented intrusion into private discourse but I understand why it doesn't seem to be so. After all, previously private forms of communication such as direct speech are still private and written letters are still roughly as hard to intercept en masse than they were. The only change is in access to new forms of communication. I think that's enough of a change though to constitute a grave new threat even within already oppressive regimes. Public real time messaging systems like twitter and wechat are fundamentally reshaping public discourse. We can't just say that "oh well, just stick to the old ways of communication and you'll be fine". If the fundamental way people communicate changes, then the fact that this change enables unprecedented levels of centralised monitoring and intervention does change things a lot. Even beyond intervention is specific conversations or consequences for individuals, it gives such regimes an unprecedented insight into the opinions and attitudes of their population as a whole and various sub-groups within it and opportunities to shape and act on those.
- tim333 7y ago>grave new threat There are two sides to the story of course. Repressive governments can follow who's up to what on social media and the like but on the other hand encrypted global communications and ubiquitous video make it much easier to expose bad stuff happening. It's interesting to watch the very good movie Lives of Others to get a feel of what things were like as recently as 1984 when it's set https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lives_of_Others https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lives_of_Others
- pell 7y ago>What is new is that even democratic countries are controlling free speech via speech laws or often the private companies engaging in evaluating what's permissible speech and not above and beyond what laws require. So, are you referring to India's last steps to shut down the internet in multiple regions where dissent forms? Or is this about caps on free speech in certain countries? I feel like these things are not on the same spectrum. That said, the power of Google, Facebook and somewhat less so Twitter is scary.
- freeflight 7y ago> I feel like these things are not on the same spectrum. As somebody living in a country with pretty heavy "caps on free speech", Germany, it's very much both on the same spectrum [0]. Because the reasons for those "caps" are very much the same reasons why India shut down the large scale: To reign in dissidence and control the Overton window. The South Korean National Security Act [1] is another, rather blatant, example for this kind of "thought legislation" that also doesn't shy away from straight-up banning and censoring media. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/nov/20/extinction-rebellion-founders-holocaust-remarks-spark-fury https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/nov/20/extincti... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Act_(South_Korea) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Act_(South_K...
- pell 7y agoI am not sure what your example from Germany is supposed to show. The author was not persecuted, his publisher simply stopped selling his book. This seems vastly different to India turning off an entire communication channel.
- freeflight 7y ago> The author was not persecuted, his publisher simply stopped selling his book. If you ignore how that whole episode completely side-tracked from the topic the author was actually interviewed on, climate-catastrophe, and how the German government has been rather opposed to that whole movement, then the end result was very favorable for the German government which originally cried wolf over it. And all it had to do was accuse him of something he actually didn't do, based on an interview that wasn't even publicly published at that point. Or we can just act like him getting depublished for talking sense is a completely rational and normal thing. As such I consider it a rather apt example of how these kinds of "speech caps" can be abused to influence the Overton window. And while it might not be as blunt as just cutting off information access wholesale, it's much more devious in its actual manifestation due to the large-scale acceptance of it, while denying that it leads to any self-censorship.
- anigbrowl 7y agoTo wit what comprises "hate speech" That's a rather specious argument when you have the current example of a democracy (India) simply shutting down large parts of the internet for political reasons, not to mention the widespread deployment of surveillance tech in numerous developed countries. This isn't to say that you don't have a point, but if you're saying it's a more pressing issue than those you might be suffering from a loss of perspective. After all, 'hate speech' is widely unpopular (as opposed to being a highly popular thing suppressed by authoritarian states, and much 'hate speech' treats of the desire to operate an authoritarian state that will restrict or outright terminate the freedoms/lives of the hated subjects.
- sillysaurusx 7y agoI think you have had the good fortune not to be targeted by people in a position of power. The loss of perspective is the other way around: Until this has happened to you, you can't fully appreciate what it feels like. "Hate speech" is a deceptive label. Even pg points out that it sounds like a phrase straight out of 1984. Society at large seems to have become turbulent. Everywhere you look, you find people who are practically leaping for any small excuse to tear into someone, tear them down, label them various names, get them fired, and so on. We are fortunate not to have to worry about authoritarian nations. But we still have to worry about authoritarians. They will often use excuses like "It's in the community's interest" to exact punishment that very few are inclined to disagree with. One could argue that if few people disagree with a punishment, then by definition it's fair. I would argue that restriction of thought is a more serious matter. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21550422 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21550422 was an insightful comment illustrating some of the modern decisions that one has to make.
- adamsea 7y ago> We are fortunate not to have to worry about authoritarian nations. But we still have to worry about authoritarians. It is a sad fact that, at the moment, we see someone with political power exhibiting authoritarian behavior (undermining a free press, undermining or disregarding rule of law, judges, etc, deliberately spreading false information, using the system to attack political enemies) — we see someone in office with authoritarian behavior _embracing_ hate speech, both explicitly and implicitly. This is not to say your point is not also a concern or that we should ignore it. Rather, that right now if you look around the world what you will see is the current crop of leaders with authoritarian tendencies (India, Hungary perhaps, Brazil, The Philippines, US) embrace hate speech as a tool to incite their base and sometimes to incite political violence (Brazil in particular). As this is a sensitive subject because it touches on contemporary politics I want to emphasize that I am doing my best to be thoughtful, specific, factual, and nonjudgmental. Factual support for all the statements I made here can be easily found. There have been many articles written about, for example, Bolsanaro in Brazil and Duarte in the Philippines. Lastly I’d like to point out that the topic of the thread is inherently political and I’ve tried to stay on-topic.
- radium3d 7y agoDoesn't free speech also enable lies and immoral ideals to be spread by bots/people too? It seems it's a double edged sword in a way but I don't think censorship is a solution. I don't think there is a solution beyond education?
- ailideex 7y ago> Doesn't free speech also enable lies and immoral ideals to be spread by bots/people too? Yes. I don't think the government should be our moral police nor should it dictate what morals are acceptable. > I don't think there is a solution beyond education? I don't think education should try and instil morals. This seems rather totalitarian to me. Where would these morals come from, how would we decide what morals our children should be indoctrinated with in school?
- Catsandkites 7y agoSo where should morals come from? If not from governance or education? (Honest question).
- ailideex 7y agoParents, family, friends, community - many places - being dictated morality in school from a government seems rather perverse though. I'm sure it sounds great if you also think that nobody with morals that is not yours should ever have political power - but that is not an option and even if it was I don't think that is a reasonable expectation or desire.
- morsch 7y agoSchool is the community kids spend half their waking lives in. Of course they will learn about morals there. Teachers are a big part of it, as is the curriculum. Both are to some degree checked by the democratic process. None of this is new or totalitarian or particularly controversial in practice, since most of morality is not particularly controversial in the first place (in a given community at a specific time). People with divergent morality from the society they live in avoid public schools, one way or another.
- wnevets 7y agoComparing china's control of the actual pipes to twitter no hate speech policy makes you look silly.
- slimsag 7y agoJust because a greater evil exists doesn't mean all other evils are 'silly'. Is it also silly to worry about hate crimes against Muslims in the U.S. because China is committing a greater crime against them?
- wwweston 7y agoLet's be real about the contrast here. * China: things you might find "disappear" in discourse include values related to free speech itself, checkered history of the communist party, civil rights, challenges to the authority/policy of the communist party, issues of graft, judicial independence. And political organization/activism to address those issues might get you into trouble where you disappear / are imprisoned or ruined by the state. * Twitter: you can't deadname trans people, use slurs, or threaten violence (and lots of these aren't tightly enforced). You might get your account deleted and have to create another one if you break these rules often enough. Can you think of a single worthwhile form of discourse that's forbidden by Twitter itself? What topics are hobbled to the point where society itself is unacceptably held back from the potential progress that would be unleashed if we just let MOAR SPEACH happen on twitter and those whose glorious intellects have been unfairly silenced were finally unleashed? We're not in US Muslim hate crimes vs China's human rights violations territory, we're in China human rights violations vs the fact that the United States has traffic laws and John Q Citizen gets cranky because he has to actually obey the speed limit damn cops it's a police state grumble grumble. And it does strike me as a bit silly.
- wnevets 7y agoNo, this has absolutely nothing to do with a greater evil. You have a choice on which social media platform you wanna post on. The free market will decide which content policy wins. Lets ask some hong kongers how much choice they have.
- wwweston 7y ago"Hate speech" has specific functional meanings when it comes to legal jurisdictions in which it applies. The idea that it's a tool for arbitrary suppression of disagreement is approximately correct as the idea that any other limitation on free speech (libel, slander, fire in a crowded theater, verbal assault, time place manner, etc) can be used arbitrarily -- which is to say, generally incorrect, although interpretation and application of the law matters (libel or time place manner judgments have been used to mute speech). Additionally, I have yet to encounter any example of reasonable discourse that's being legally suppressed by hate speech laws, but, you know, feel free to make a list of the important ideas that you feel are being SILENCED. Private companies: not that different in the fundamentals, but there are additional issues that lean towards both the right of ownership to speak and restrict speech that comes through them. You likely wouldn't want anyone to force you to repeat ideas you believe are incorrect, or contrary to key personal interests even where narrowly correct, or even lead to effects you find personally undesirable. If freedom of speech means anything, it has to include some measure of judgment about what your personal faculties are used to express, and to some more moderated extent what/how your property is used. There may be balancing concerns in the latter case, but whether we're at that point is another issue. Again, I can think of very little in the realm of valuable discourse that's been walled off here; if there's anything at all, I suspect the relevant mechanism is essentially social values that are held widely enough that contrary expressions bring social consequences, and while you can create some spaces for robust contrary discussion ("safe spaces", if you like), you can't eliminate the kickback from broad social consequences without treading more heavily on other liberties of equal or greater importance to speech. Honestly, if there's any issue at all here, it's that there has never been an EASIER time to express ideas -- even very unpopular ones -- quite widely, and it's the way that these ideas carry widely that's leading to a level of tension that people are still figuring out how to manage. And really, this is the weaponization issues: 50 years ago, authoritarian countries didn't have the capabilities of broadcasting ideas or disinformation into your average household, much less an individual handheld device. A world-of-ends internet means that they do.
- 1000units 7y agoI too am alarmed by these spooky disinformation campaigns. I just googled "what party was abraham lincoln in" and a big box popped up at the top saying "National Union Party". I've never even heard of this party. I assume its a euphemism sinister people use like "Democratic People's Republic".
- baq 7y agodemocracy with free speech fails in special circumstances. it needs an authoritarian component to prevent more authoritarian form of governments from taking over.
- ailideex 7y ago> democracy with free speech fails in special circumstances. like? > it needs an authoritarian component to prevent more authoritarian form of governments from taking over. I don't think so.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoI think what he means is that democracy as understood by most, is basically a dictatorship of the majority. But this is not democracy and won't work for long. Most relatively functioning democracies will enforce certain rules, often in constitutional laws and courts, against the will of the majority or their representatives. This can feel anti-democratic but it really isn't. The rules laid out in a constitution center around making sure the democratic system stays democratic. If a 60% majority decides that the other 40% can't vote any more, that's not democracy. Similarly for many other attempts at weakening the rights of minorities, be they political, ethnic, religious or whatever. Free speech in the US is understood as an absolute right and principle, to the extent that such speech is infringing on other people's rights. Hate speech endangers people. Look at the rising violence since the current president is in power. His rhetoric probably carries some blame for inciting such tendencies. I think it is legitimate to issue some restrictions such that minorities can feel less threatened.
- ailideex 7y ago>>> it needs an authoritarian component to prevent more authoritarian form of governments from taking over. >> I don't think so. > I think what he means is that democracy as understood by most, is basically a dictatorship of the majority. If the majority of people are against that more authoritarian form of government, why would they support it? If they are not against it, how would them restricting their own speech help? This argument just makes no sense. Either they support it or they don't - speech restrictions that they supposedly impose on themselves to prevent them from being more authoritarian like they would like to be is just - I don't know - does not make sense to me - some circular reasoning somewhere there. If the majority wants to be more authoritarian, and they would be save for speech restrictions, why would they not just vote to change the speech restrictions?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- odiroot 7y ago> What is new is that even democratic countries are controlling free speech via speech laws Yes, I think this is much worse. We don't expect anything better from the North Korea, Iran, Russia etc. We have intrinsically higher standards regarding our western, liberal democracies. And now we, the citizens of said states, are the slowly boiled frogs.
- growlist 7y agoExactly. It's trivial to prove that Google's results have a strong political bias.
- CommieDetector 7y ago"What is new is that even democratic countries are controlling free speech " Only the US have _true_ free speech.
- puPoh 7y ago"Nowadays you cannot say anything racist without being called racist"
- mc32 7y agoIf someone says racist[1] things (from whichever POV), it’s fair to call out racism. That’s not the crux of the question. Moreover there are other forms of obnoxious speech in addition to racism. Someone could be a vegan and another a omnivore and the both could be offensive. Or it could be about reproductive rights and so on. People should be able to engage in debate even if it’s repugnant to you or to me or anyone. [1] meaning actual racist things not the colloquial “racist” which can mean someone disagreeing on policy among other things.
- fit2rule 7y agoIt used to be, you didn't care about the nationality of the Internet person whose texts you are reading. Its still a little bit like that, but I believe that the contention that 'democratic countries' is even still a thing is pretty banal. Sovereignty is dead. The 21st Century killed it. If you ask your average western citizen whether their government really represents their interests and needs, you'll find a dire scene. Most westerners feel imprisoned by their government, and have zero desire to take responsibility for their government, or their military' actions, as good citizens do. What has happened is that, over two decades at least, maybe a little more, a large portion of the intelligent decadent western public has woken up to the fact that their democracies have failed, and think that the Internet is there to save them. Only to have had it all rubbed in their faces with the Snowden revelations that all technology is flawed and should never be trusted unless you built it yourself. Which is, interestingly enough, the same conclusion one makes in political systems such as democracy. However, this is not an ultimate conundrum, because while it is true that all large human groups are eventually corrupted by smaller groups, its also a driving force behind technological progress. Those with the technology to do so, can still use the Internet to heal society and re-build it in new forms. It'll take a few more big group/small group battles, though, before the tribes finally work out we're all on the same team.
- hhas01 7y ago“To wit what comprises "hate speech". It's basically come to mean "point of view in disagreement with my group's current position which may change in the future"” Citations required.
- usrusr 7y agoControlling communication goes back much further. The oldest example I can think of right now is https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cabinet_noir https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cabinet_noir but I'd be surprised if it didn't go as far back as writing itself.
- buboard 7y agowhile voters are busy arguing online about their "free speech" , their leaders are busy controlling every other aspect of their lives. We live in a world of extensive transit control, capital flow controls, commodities control, banking control, monetary manipulation, visual-data-financial surveillance, data regulations, behavior regulations (i.e. drug/alcohol/vaping prohibitions) and punitive taxation. We have accumulated too many powers in the hands of "our" democratic leaders, and the political parties are being used as weapons against the other party. The Ruler Worshippers have won. In many ways (economic, regulatory, even behavioral) the West is in freedom deficit compared to those oppressive countries. I think it's fair to say the world has stooped to their level.
- wayoutthere 7y agoI think what has come out of the postmodern dialectic is the recognition that there are no neutral points of view. Policing “hate speech” is an attempt to address the fact that differences in perspective exist, but there are still some behaviors that are not tolerated because they lead to a breakdown of society. The problem is that reactionaries see it as a loophole that they can use to play the victim while continuing to dehumanize others. Nothing means anything when people argue in bad faith.
- forgottenpass 7y agoI think the act of bringing postmodern tools to the debate was a way of playing the "I win" game by turning the conversation into inescapable morass for those that weren't accustomed to that kind of debate. Whatever the "reactionaries" did in response was yet another step in the evolution of the back-and-forth and no more or less in bad faith than the previous step.
- wayoutthere 7y agoYeah, there is a subtle distinction between “there are no neutral points of view” and “there is no such thing as objective truth”. Postmodernist arguments applied to contemporary politics serve to blur that distinction, which is where the bad faith comes in.
- malvosenior 7y agoPostmodernism is the recognition that all points of view are equally valid (or invalid). Policing "hate speech" and "protecting" society are modern concepts not postmodern ones. I think if you read classic postmodern literature (think Gravity's Rainbow) you'll find a lot of speech that would be considered politically incorrect, possibly even hate speech. That was purposefully designed by the authors to help devalue and level the meaning of all speech as that's a core postmodern principal. Reality Is What You Can Get Away With is another postmodern classic that explores some of these themes: https://www.amazon.com/Reality-What-You-Can-Away/dp/1561840807 https://www.amazon.com/Reality-What-You-Can-Away/dp/15618408...
- Dumblydorr 7y agoI don't think its new for democracies to control free speech, they just have far,far better tools to do so today. Lincoln didn't have the Internet, but he did suppress opposition by suspending habeas corpus and clapping a supreme court justice in irons. Robespierre, the man of the people for part of the French Revolution, which supposedly valued liberty and fraternity, decapitated numerous political enemies until finally he himself became the enemy. I could go on, but humans have been bending and breaking democratic egalitarian rules for centuries. Modern technology is just so pervasive, Putin and Trump can affect the information at everyone's fingertips always with social media and online information. Indeed, any powerful entity can buy anything online: clicks, bots, comments, views, accounts, literally anything they want to say can reach millions of people. This would be ameliorated by ethical and moral information platforms, which we seem to not use and not build for profit reasons.
- malvosenior 7y ago> Putin and Trump can affect the information at everyone's fingertips always with social media and online information. > Indeed, any powerful entity can buy anything online: clicks, bots, comments, views, accounts, literally anything they want to say can reach millions of people. This would be ameliorated by ethical and moral information platforms, which we seem to not use and not build for profit reasons. There's still a marketplace of ideas. Powerful entities will be competing with other powerful entities for bandwidth and attention. The people themselves will decide which messages they wish to pass on and spread and which they don't. If it was as simple as you say, the person with the most money would always win. While that does happen, we can see the from the results of the 2016 election that it doesn't always work that way. Clinton spent far more on traditional advertising and guerrilla internet tactics (c.f. Correct The Record) and didn't win because her message didn't resonate with enough people. Long story short: free will still drives the internet and outcomes. Advertising isn't very effective and when it is, advertisers will be competing against each other for the limited access to that scarce effectiveness.
- mc32 7y agoTrue that tools have improved but also it’s no longer an exception (like wartime exceptions), but an accepted quotidian thing that’s used like propaganda to dominate people.
- eli_gottlieb 7y ago>To wit what comprises "hate speech". It's basically come to mean "point of view in disagreement with my group's current position which may change in the future" Well, in America, sometimes. In other countries there are actual hate-speech laws that designate the central cases and set limits on the corner cases.
- sdinsn 7y ago> "the private companies engaging in evaluating what's permissible speech" They have the right to control how people use their property. It's a completely different discussion than the one about government control