10 ms·
In the US, we've had decades of (largely GOP) messaging that the government can't do anything properly. A substantial portion of the population believes it. As
by alistairSH 7y ago
In the US, we've had decades of (largely GOP) messaging that the government can't do anything properly. A substantial portion of the population believes it.
As noted in a sibling comment, the IRS could pre-fill forms that would be correct for the vast majority of tax payers (who take the standard deduction/don't itemize, have a single job, and no other edge cases). These people should not be paying TurboTax either way - the forms they need to submit are relatively straight-forward. People who do need a CPA would have to hire one regardless. TurboTax is literally just ripping off average tax payers.
- komali2 7y agoIt's pretty disgusting. Summed up in one of my favorite tweets, which went something like > Gov: you owe us money. It's called taxes > Ctzn: oh ok, how much do I owe you? > Gov: you have to figure it out > Ctzn: oh well, then I owe you 0 > Gov: no, no, we know how much you owe, you have to figure it out, and by the way if you get it wrong you go to jail
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoYou can have the irs figure out how much you owe if your income is simple enough. This is similar to a lot of countries just taxing you at your income sources and not requiring you to file a return. However, the American system has a lot of deductions, exemptions, status modifiers, etc... so you often need to pay less than that, hence the need for everyone to do tax returns.
- nightski 7y agoYou don't go to jail for filing a wrong number accidentally. Only if you are intentionally lying/hiding income. I know people who didn't pay tax FOR THEIR BUSINESS for several years and they settled the debt for much less than they owed and definitely did not go to jail. This is just misinformation.
- roddds 7y agoIt's called hyperbole.
- pricees 7y agoI think you mean tax evasion. Hyperbole is completely different.
- kmonsen 7y agoThis is true, but you can be asked to pay gigantic fines. IRS wanted me to pay more than 50k in fine (luckily they were wrong and accepted that right away). So maybe jail is hyperbole, but it can get pretty serious.
- TheCoelacanth 7y ago50k fine or 50k back taxes plus fine?
- SilasX 7y agoIf that's true, then what's the point of paying business taxes? When the IRS finds out, you just pay less than you would otherwise, and much later.
- nightski 7y agoHaving a tax lien on your business is not fun. Neither is going through the settlement process. You also are not guaranteed a settlement and could end up owing the full amount plus interest. At best they let you pay it over time. At worst they take your property and liquidate it. But jail time is unlikely unless you had malicious intent.
- Craighead 7y agoThe purposefully vauge summation you provided misses the part where the highly influential people lobbied to be able to associate money as speech, use said speech to funnel external funds into a domestic process of government, and ensure that wealthy oligarchs from around the world can continue to steal from the poor while ensuring the same poor think it's the fault of the government, and thus the cycle continues. You and your tweet are not correct and the purposeful lack of nuance tells me you are commenting in bad faith.
- jxramos 7y agoThe thing people misunderstand with the government not being able to figure it out is because there's a huge variety of complexity that is truly individual based. Did you make a contribution to a tax deductible IRA? Did you make a retroactive payment to that account in the following tax calendar year? There's a ton of variables going on here, where the government doesn't have this all-seeing system where everything gets accounted for across the vast array of income sources and employment statuses, dependents, filing status, and all the increments and decrements to those things through time. There's no one central source where all this information is collated and waiting for someone to turn the crank and grind out a number from. Folks have to remember that nothing is implemented by default. The effort to reduce the complexity of the 1040 into 6 new schedules was a great way to factor out those with complicated situations such that the majority of tax payers are oblivious to those nuances. The crux of the matter is that legislators passed into law all these onerous mass of rules to turn various levers to entice and discourage certain things and bite those with progressive tax rates. It is precisely the existence of these rules as to why the government doesn't know what tax valley you land in that huge parameter space. It will not presume to know your specific circumstances but assume that you being aware of your own money and circumstances are in the best position to know these things. At the least one thing I learned is that with tax laws if you have no idea what a thing is it probably in not applicable to you. Needless to say all of this would be much more simple if we just pay a flat tax on all income for all people. Nothing simpler than that.
- tibiahurried 7y agoIt is almost 2020 and cash should be banned and all transactions should be electronic. Shouldn't that hard for them to figure out how much do I owe in taxes.
- danans 7y ago> Needless to say all of this would be much more simple if we just pay a flat tax on all income for all people. Nothing simpler than that. That would be a highly regressive tax system that dramatically transfers even more wealth to the already wealthy. But sure, it's definitely simpler. That doesn't make it better.
- jdavis703 7y agoI forgot to file one of several 1099 forms one year. I got a friendly call from an auditor. He explained what the discrepancy was, how I could appeal if I wanted, and what the payment options were. When I told him I'd take an IRS loan (i.e. a payment plan with interest), he advised me it would be cheaper for me to get a loan from family, friends or the bank. This was about as far from being threatened with prison I've ever been... And believe me I've come pretty close to being arrested (during exercise of my 1st & 4th amendment rights on multiple occasions).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 7y ago> decades of (largely GOP) messaging that the government can't do anything properly ... which requires actively sabotaging anything that is being done properly.
- sbierwagen 7y agoAlong the same lines, there used to be three different tax forms: the standard 1040 form, then two progressively more simplified forms for people who didn't want to do itemized deductions. Well, the GOP takes power in 2016, and declares that they will "reduce" paperwork by removing... the two simplified forms! Now everyone has to fill out the complete 1040, which is also now strangely cramped and calls out to a dozen different worksheets, since the GOP also wanted to brag about how the form "fits on a postcard", and it has to contort itself to use every square inch of paper. A miserable experience! I miss the 1040-EZ.
- wool_gather 7y agoSee the sibling comments about Grover Norquist; this wasn't incompetence: there's actually a pretty strong political group in favor of this kind of thing.
- jxramos 7y agoFrom a refactoring perspective this actually made a lot of sense. One source of truth (1040) not three (1040, 1040A, 1040EZ). The complex parts of the 1040 have been refactored into separate functions named Schedule 1, Schedule2, ..., Schedule 6. The problem isn't in the forms its in the laws which necessitate line items in the form to begin with. If you think about it the 1040 has taken on the more simple case as the default and the more complex cases have been shifted into schedules. That's a good thing in my book.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThe new 1040 is not much different than a 1040EZ. Just split over two sheets with a few extra cells for filling in results from optional forms.
- astura 7y agoIt's also anti-tax activist like Grover Norquist’s Americans for Tax Reform who hate automatic filing and prefilled forms too. Their reasoning is if taxes are "too easy" then somehow Americans will blindly accept tax increases so they actually want to keep tax filing as difficult as possible.
- creato 7y ago> Their reasoning is if taxes are "too easy" then somehow Americans will blindly accept tax increases so they actually want to keep tax filing as difficult as possible. It's simpler than that: They want taxes to be a pain in the ass so people hate them.
- ksdale 7y agoI am definitely not a Grover Norquist fan, but I do taxes for a living and a lot of people are VERY surprised at the amount that is withheld from their paychecks, but they never notice how much it is unless something happens and they are required to write a check. A couple illustrations: It's very common for people to owe tax at a lower rate than they did the year before, but be upset because they have to write a check (and this is when the amount is trivial relative to wealth, so it's not because of financial inconvenience). They don't think in terms of tax rates, just in terms of do they owe or not. Owing is worse than not owing, regardless of total tax paid. And these are successful, otherwise financially savvy people. There are also people who try things they think are "tricks" to maximize their refund that are literally just paying more in. They think a giant refund is great, not realizing that it's just money that they could have not sent to the IRS in the first place. Once again, owing bad, refunds good. This is all to say that I believe people are indeed, to some extent, blindly paying more taxes than they would agree to if they had to write a check every month for the amount due. For a lot of people, even people who don't make very much, if they paid their half of their payroll taxes with a check every month, it would be pretty close to the biggest bill they have each month, and it goes basically unnoticed by most people. For the record, I don't have any problem at all with current tax rates, but I know very well what they are, and I think if there was more transparency and education, I don't believe it would lead to people wanting to raise tax rates, but that's just my opinion.
- wool_gather 7y agoThere's also a political lobby (see: Grover Norquist) for the idea that filing taxes must never be made easier, because that will make them more palatable. Combined with their axiom that taxes are inherently bad, the result is an argument that tax filing should actually be as painful as possible. (The surprising strength of this lobby is one possible reason that the "file your taxes on a postcard" idea died a few years ago.)
- alistairSH 7y agoYeah, I don't buy Norquist's theory. Making taxes easier doesn't make them any more palatable. Probably the opposite because people would have a better understanding of how much they're paying. Right now, a lot of people mindlessly fill in their needlessly complex forms, and pray they get a refund or don't owe more than $20 or so (because that's all they have in their wallet).
- nightski 7y agoWorst case is you take the standard deduction. After being doubled in Trump's tax bill, it's often the right choice too.
- Consultant32452 7y agoIt's not really about the yearly filing but the withholding. Imagine if employers stopped withholding, each person got their full pay in their bank, and then had to write a check to the govt each month like they pay their power bill.
- dahfizz 7y agoI have had a different experience. Last year I filled out my 1040EZ and was unhappy with the final amount owed. I decided to click through turbo tax who found me a lot of deductions related to student loans and things. I think I only paid like $35 and they saved me over a thousand I would have missed otherwise. And truthfully, it's not a lot of money. I would gladly pay $30-40 just to not have to deal with the hassle of filling out a piece of paper and mailing it and all that. Now that the IRS seems to have a decent electronic system, I'll give that a go this year and see if turbo tax is worth it anymore. Yeah, turbo tax is a pretty scummy company with all the lobbying and deception. I won't argue that. But their product is genuinely good and provides utility to me, and I'm sure I'm not the only one.
- dnautics 7y agoFor non-americans reading this I presume the parent poster means "paying on top of the amount already withheld by the government", not total income taxation.
- jacurtis 7y agoEven most Americans struggle to understand this actually. It shocks me at the amount of Americans that still think the government is gifting them money at tax time. No it is like buying a stick of gum at the gas station, you give the cashier a $10 and he gives you $8 back. That $8 isn't a gift, the cashier was giving you back money you gave him that you didn't owe. The majority of tax refunds are exact this, a refund of your own money that the government took from you, and is now giving back to you without paying interest for holding it for ~1 years
- ansible 7y ago> I decided to click through turbo tax who found me a lot of deductions related to student loans and things. We require any companies who collect interest payments on things like student loans to automatically report that to the IRS. We could then have the IRS fill that in for your tax return automatically. But special interests don't want that to happen.
- marcrosoft 7y ago> messaging that the government can't do anything properly I would love to hear about things the government has done exceptionally better than private companies. Please go on.
- tylerchr 7y agoThe Interstate Highway System, manned spaceflight, and National Parks come to mind.
- virmundi 7y agoThe first is crumbling and a major cause of urban sprawl and global warming. The second has brought some benefits like a microwave, but nothing of any meaningful use. We lack moon bases for example. National parks should be state run. This is a massive power grab by the feds under feel-good logic.
- peterwwillis 7y agoNational Parks exist because we are a nation of united states, not an independent fiefdom of states. All citizens of these united states deserve the same right to enjoy the natural beauty of this country, and no individual state should have the right to remove such privileges from the rest of the citizenry through inaction, nor through lack of management make it less than ideal to enjoy. Conservation of land is a national priority. As such, no state or private entity should be entrusted or made to be solely responsible for the upkeep and management of said valuable resource for all the people. That's why Yosemite Valley's management was transferred from the State of California to the Federal Government. As Wallace Stegner said, "National Parks were the best idea we ever had. Absolutely American, absolutely democratic, they reflect us at our best rather than our worst." (Except for that whole disinheriting the native peoples of their own lands thing... but definitely American...)
- virmundi 7y agoThen there is no limit to the power of the Federal government. If they can say, “We can do a better job than you, person or State”, then can run roughshod over personal and State’s rights. I guess that’s fine as long as they are running over people and States you don’t like. What happens if Trump goes into California and takes over due to the humanitarian crisis that the State brought in itself ie the tent cities?
- danschumann 7y agoI think are more steelman'ed version of the GOP argument is: when government does things badly, they can go VERY VERY badly. It's a risk viewpoint. Whereas the progressive viewpoint letting government do more and more things. The other risk is bloat. Once a government program exists, it is very very hard to stop it and get the funds back ( from a political perspective ). It's unpopular to fire people. When government does bad, it gets more money ( bigger ), to do worse things, or other pathological outcomes. When industry does bad, it merely gets replaced by another company. It's not so much saying that all government is bad, but it's looking at worse case scenarios and balancing risk.
- randito 7y ago> the GOP argument is: when government does things badly, they can go VERY VERY badly. Sounds conveniently like Regulatory capture: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture.
- cpuguy83 7y agoCompetition also plays a role here... not that there should be competition in filing simple tax returns... but competition often leads to better goods/services. There is not much to incentivize a government run program to be better other than the current administration cracking the whip so they can get re-elected.
- thenewnewguy 7y agoPeople tell me this, but I've been waiting for years in the US for competition to make our healthcare cheaper/better than other countries, but it never seems to come.
- mumblemumble 7y agoSure, but that argument just doesn't track. Both parties are similarly aggressive about big government programs and spending. The real variables are what they want to spend money on (health care or national security or schools or the Farm Bill or whatever) and where they think the money should come from (tax the beneficiaries of these programs or tax their children and grandchildren unto the tenth gener-- er, finance it with debt). Different stories get told during election season, of course. One of the most perplexing things about politics, though, is the way that everyone generally acknowledges that all politicians are shameless liars, but not during election season, when the person who's hawking the tastiest-looking pile of horseshit is speaking God's truth, and it's just all the other politicians who are shameless liars.
- EGreg 7y agoThe funniest and most ridiculous thing is when they cut taxes so they need to cut back on federal agencies so they cut the resources OF THE IRS so now the IRS can’t afford to audit rich people and their staff, only poor people. Perhaps it was intentional? (By the same people who complained the IRS was targeting them for audits.)
- formercoder 7y agoBased on empirical evidence the government is terrible at doing pretty much anything. I don’t remember the last time I had a logical, efficient, pleasant, and cheap interaction with a US government agency. I happen to have those with private companies all the time.
- krtong 7y agoYou can go further back to the founding of the nation for why this is. It didn't start with the GOP. Things that would be nationalized in other countries like the railroads have always been private in america. Even when Alexander Hamilton and George Washington had taxpayers of New Jersey pay for the country's first manufactories in Paterson, they were all private industries. Abraham Lincoln privatized all the railroads and telegraph lines after the civil war. (We had nationalized them for the war effort, so taxpayers paid for thousands of miles of railroad that was handed off to railroad companies.) You can even go further back, before the united states was even a thing and look at mercantilism, where merchants/private industry ran the country, but it was understood that they were subservient to the nation, economic growth's sole purpose was for national defense, and you took care of your citizenry because they were your troops. Thanks to the civil war, the 2nd industrial revolution, the gilded age, globalism, america has taken more and more turns towards 'every man for themself' and not giving a shit about the country, so obviously well-intentioned privatization of public utilities makes less and less sense.
- sneak 7y agoI don’t think it’s quite as simple as “not giving a shit about the country”, as much as it is the simple fact that different reasonable people can have different opinions about collective ownership. Recall that both companies and countries are abstractions; they are not real. Some people (reasonably) think that it is logically impossible for a country to own something. Others (reasonably) think it is logically impossible for a corporation to own something. Reasonable people disagree on these things sometimes.
- krtong 7y ago>Recall that both companies and countries are abstractions; they are not real. Money is fiat. family is fiat. When you think about it everything is fiat. Plus, everyone thinks they own things. Im sure you'd be really upset if I took your paycheck and said you didnt own it. It's basic psychology. Even dogs get really upset when you give their bone to another dog. But anyway, that's way too abstract for a real discussion. I'm specifically talking about the psychological effect of the civil war and how it affected important people like supreme court justices and tycoons, because if people want to understand how we got here, it's important to understand how and why decisions were made from a cultural/psychological/economic perspective.
- s1artibartfast 7y ago>A substantial portion of the population believes it. I think it is somewhat disingenuous to suggest that these people were simply duped. The average person has tons of exposure to government incompetence in other arenas.
- kbutler 7y ago> In the US, we've had decades of (largely GOP) messaging that the government can't do anything properly. A substantial portion of the population believes it. What are your top 5 well-run federal government programs? Slate likes these: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2014/04/the-top-dozen-federal-government-programs-in-history.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2014/04/the-top-dozen-fe... Includes things like land grants, patents, and highways. Mother Jones likes transfer programs (for efficientcy measured by % of funds transferred, rather than effectiveness of achieving stated goals): https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2012/01/chart-day-federal-programs-surprisingly-well-run/ https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2012/01/chart-day-fed...
- kbutler 7y agoYeah, I couldn't come up with any either.