4 ms·
Seattle doesn’t really have that problem, lots of new housing is being built, it isn’t the Bay Area. The problem is affordable housing that has little profit to
by seanmcdirmid 7y ago
Seattle doesn’t really have that problem, lots of new housing is being built, it isn’t the Bay Area. The problem is affordable housing that has little profit to motivate return-oriented developers, and homeless shelters that have huge impacts on the areas where they are placed.
- adreamingsoul 7y agoSeattle does very much have a homeless problem.
- zozbot234 7y agoHousing becomes affordable by filtering down the market, long after it has been built by "return-oriented" developers. Building more and better housing can accelerate this process.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoAnd that happens. However, the flop houses that used to exist when I was in college have been driven out of the market.
- shuckles 7y agoMost boarding houses are not code compliant and would not be buildable today. That might have something to do with it.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoA lot of them were just old houses that were unrenovated. They’ve probably been torn down and rebuilt by now. My first place in the U district (1994ish) was a cheap $225/month basement room with shared bathroom and a small kitchenette. The land lady was desperate to keep non-students out so it wouldn’t turn into a flop house.
- shuckles 7y agoThe kinds of subdivisions that turned large homes into multiple boarding situations is also not code compliant and would require at the very least a conditional use authorization (years and uncertainty) in SF.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIt was allowed in Seattle in certain districts (definitely at Greek row). Not sure about now.
- austhrow743 7y agoWhich brings us back to "The 2019 system is that building housing is illegal without very costly and hard to get permits in most non Texas big cities. If you could just put up housing on land you own and charge however much people will pay for it, this housing crisis would quickly be gone"
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoNobody is going to build a flop house as new construction even in, especially in, Texas. Have you been to Austin before? It isn’t much better than Seattle.
- jcims 7y agoThis seems like a troll question, so apologies, but is it really an affordability thing? What's the average income (public assistance and otherwise) of a homeless person in Seattle? I live in podunk Ohio and a single bedroom apartment is still ~$650 per month. Would they be able to come up with that? Say the government splits it with section 8 or whatever. Same? Is the idea that the public picks up the whole tab and the issue is just that the money just doesn't go as far with current rents?
- Aloha 7y agoI was paying 1900 or so a month in an outlying suburb and that was cheap for the area - the best you're gonna see for a one bedroom within a 20-25 mile radius around seattle is about 1200 a month, a two bedroom about 1500 a month. Public assistance pays nothing, and section 8/housing authority has years or decades long waiting lists.
- jcims 7y agoOK, good info, thank you. So let's say we carpet bomb the area with new housing capacity and cut rents in half. How does that help with the homeless situation? Doesn't really make any sense to me.
- Aloha 7y agoThere is more than one kind of homeless. The mayor of Los Angeles Eric Garcetti recently said something striking, "homelessness is trauma meets high rent"[1]. Often times, decades ago, there was housing on the margins of society - yes, it wasn't very nice, but it was a warm dry place in winter. Often people who are homeless had jobs right up until the time they became homeless, and have marketable skills, but not ones that can pay for a median rent price, Basically the lack affordable housing puts stress on people who are already on the margins or in near crisis and puts them out of the street. Most of the homeless people fit into this category. There is another group of homeless folks though, who are long term chronic homeless, they have other complicating factors, like drug abuse, mental health issues, criminal records that make it hard to rent a home or find a job - often being in the first category of homelessness can lead you to slip into the second category, by simply the on the street. The first group of homelessness would be largely solved with affordable housing and a program to get people into it, Unfortunately for those of us who want to solve the problem the most visible homeless are the chronic variety not the people suffering from a life event. [1] - https://www.marketplace.org/2019/12/23/interview-la-mayor-eric-garcetti/ https://www.marketplace.org/2019/12/23/interview-la-mayor-er...
- bobthepanda 7y ago> Housing becomes affordable by filtering down the market, long after it has been built by "return-oriented" developers. And long after today, most of the homeless people, or the people currently getting displaced, will be dead or gone. YIMBY people don't seem to understand that this response is the housing equivalent of "let them eat cake". People who are at risk of displacement are not really interested in hearing about the affordable housing they might be able to afford twenty years from now if they have to spend the meantime picking between sleeping on the street and leaving. We obviously have to build our way out of an incredibly tight supply. But talking past people and basically ignoring their concerns is not going to get people on board.
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoThe filtering down happens as soon as new housing is built. The yuppie with a high six-figure salary is moving into San Francisco, the only question is whether they get corralled into a gigantic glass yuppie box. If they don't, they're going to pay way too much money to gentrify the Mission or something.
- bobthepanda 7y agoThere is so much demand that the filtering down is not happening, or going downwards quickly enough. This is what I mean when I say: > But talking past people and basically ignoring their concerns is not going to get people on board. Is what you're saying valid? Yes. But if you just act dismissive of other people don't be surprised if they're not rushing to your defense, or even against you.
- esarbe 7y agoThe free market will not solve this problem. Just look at all the major cities in the world; they all have a problem of gentrification and rising prices for housing. Rent-seeking will always drive the prices to the barely-acceptable and thus will make it affordable for a large portion of the population. That portion is either driven to the periphery or denied housing altogether. So no; housing will not automatically become affordable. There are forces in the market that prevent that.
- zozbot234 7y agoThe "major cities in the world" are among the most desirable areas to be in, almost by definition. So no, housing will never be all that affordable in Manhattan NYC. But does it really need to be, provided that resources are being put towards their "highest and best use"? Some people will have to live elsewhere - and NYC has very good subway transit that helps people do just that.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoHomeless people in NYC aren’t generally commuting in from cheaper places in...maybe Mew Jersey? Connecticut? West Chester county? The subway and train there is great, it can allow you to commute from farther out...instead of paying $3k for a one bedroom you can pay $2k instead with a one hour+ commute. But it doesn’t really solve the housing problems at the low end.
- quotemstr 7y ago> all have a problem of gentrification and rising prices for housing We use prices to ration access to scarce resources. Why should housing in the center of a desirable city be cheap?
- zozbot234 7y agoGood question. For that matter, why should high-value housing in the center of a desirable city enrich a bunch of private landowners, and not the surrounding community which creates that value in the first place?
- aaomidi 7y agoBecause it's really expensive to build a house. Who has the money other than massive developers? Of course they want to make €£¥$
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThey and their investors want to maximize their returns of course, why would that be weird? The developers who don’t want to maximize their returns are no longer in business.
- BurningFrog 7y agoAssuming the resulting house is worth more than the cost to build it, you can get a loan for the building cost. This is basic stuff. Surprised that people are not aware of it!