4 ms·
Let's face it... the average user should not be downloading executables from the web ever these days, except to use Safari or Edge to download Firefox or Chrome
by crazygringo 7y ago
Let's face it... the average user should not be downloading executables from the web ever these days, except to use Safari or Edge to download Firefox or Chrome. (Or a handful of trusted brands like Adobe, Microsoft, etc.)
There's no trust, accountability, or security. Instead, app stores and package managers provide these things. They're not perfect, but they're waaay better than totally untrusted binaries.
And if you're an advanced user, you can ignore the warning. Or know to download binaries linked from a project's GitHub page, etc.
Let's face it: the "open web" is not a secure or trustworthy place for downloading binaries period, unless you're on a well-known trustworthy site (again -- Mozilla, Microsoft, Adobe, etc.).
- dgellow 7y agoHow does an average user becomes an advanced user in your model?
- snickerbockers 7y agoIs this a joke?
- still_grokking 7y ago> trusted brands like Adobe, Microsoft, etc. Now I'm confused.
- crazygringo 7y agoYeah I thought that while writing it. ;) In other words, whatever brands you know from life experience are a legit product, not malware that will turn your computer part of a botnet. If you're a designer then you know Sketch and Adobe, etc.
- temac 7y agoYet you nearly always blindly download and execute code when you browse, in overly complicated software in which dozen of vulns are found each month, with little hope of that slowing down.
- crazygringo 7y agoBut it's sandboxed. Yes vulnerabilities are found -- nothing in this world is 100% perfect -- but in practice, running JavaScript in your browser is orders of magnitude safer than running binaries with access to your filesystem, hardware, and more.
- temac 7y agoYes and the security mainly comes from the sandboxing, not from some hypothetical stores of websites making random judgments (also I also know that the reputation and blocking of website could depend on the presence of hostile JS, but given what is described here Google judgment seems to depends on quite "random" factors, that should also not be relied upon for JS content) If you want to go toward security, unilaterally disabling parts of the web because of parts of third party legacy OS design is not the way to go, actually I don't see logically how the described approach of Google would yield any interesting true_malware_blocking / false_positive_blocking ratio. And you know what would be even safer? Shutting down the computer when the user attempts to browse the web. Browser vendor should let the OS antivirus take care of its own business -- if I want my complete computer to be taken care of by Google I can go buy a Chromebook... I was saddened by the move of Edge to Chromium engine, but honestly while I used the old one from time to time for very specific purposes, I could not recommend it to anybody. I will still try to make people use FF by default, but I'm starting to think the position of the new Edge will be interesting and it could be good to try to switch some from Chrome to Edge.
- paulddraper 7y agoThe point is that safety comes from sandboxing, not from Google/Apple gods.
- syshum 7y agoI do not trust Adobe, Microsoft, Google, or Mozilla for that matter. Your idea that they are "trusted" is laughable, and it is also dangerous to our liberty and security to believe only these gilded companies should be authorized to say what software is allowed on a given platform We have seen massive censorship as a result of this, with Apps being banned from various app stores not for security but for political reasons
- thristian 7y agoThe thing is, there's a big gap between "mass-market software that can budget for the friction of an app-store release" and "niche software that only advanced, technical users know or care about". It's perfectly possible to have niche software that only, say, accountants care about; or niche software that only bee-keepers care about. It would be really nice (in the "this is why we can't have nice things" sense) if there were a way to distribute software tools to niche audiences without them necessarily needing to be technical audiences. Up until recently, the Open Web has been that system, but it seems Google can unilaterally disable it via their Safe Browsing feature.
- ameshkov 7y agoThis would be true unless the stores you are talking about were not imposing countless limitations. Microsoft store is for UWP apps only, Mac AppStore is for sandboxed apps only, and I’d better not even start with Play store and iOS AppStore restrictions. We need independent stores which purpose is to prevent security issues and not impose additional limitations.
- daveoc64 7y agoThe Microsoft store has allowed non-UWP apps for years.
- PeterisP 7y agoThat's the whole point - the average user should be able to run code from random third party developers only in a sandbox. Preventing security issues requires imposing additional limitations, you can't have your cake and eat it too. Either the apps require serious review (i.e. a much, much higher bar of entry than iOS AppStore), or the apps need to be restricted so that they can't do much, so strict sandboxing. Running unsigned, unsandboxed binaries from a small developer is a big security risk which can't be prevented in a cost-effective manner, so average users have to be warned that it might as well just encrypt their files for ransom.
- danShumway 7y agoI disagree with this on two points: - First, I disagree that every program an average consumer might want or need is available on an app store. - Second, I strongly disagree that app stores provide security, trust, and accountability. App store security is really bad. At best, we have Debian repos, which are clean-ish mostly because nobody cares about writing malware for desktop Linux so the moderation is much easier. At worst, we have Windows store and Android. These platforms are not effective at screening out malware, because content moderation doesn't scale to these levels, and blocking malware is just another form of content moderation. Telling people to trust app stores and not downloaded binaries is like telling them to trust Amazon and not Ebay. You're right, there is technically a difference, but the difference is not big enough to matter. If you download random things from any source, you will mess up your computer. It'll just happen faster with downloaded executables. There is (unfortunately) no shortcut to get around teaching people about security. At some point, native platforms will catch up to where the web was 10 years ago and start doing a better job of sandboxing executables, and then the job of educating users will be easier. We're just unfortunately living in the world where that hasn't happened yet. "Get rid of unofficial software" is counterproductive to what we actually need to do -- to update our native permissions and security models to match modern users' requirements. But even though mass-moderation is a band-aide fix that doesn't even work well right now, it's heavily promoted by companies like Apple, Google, and Microsoft because under the guise of security it gives them a new stranglehold over the common-user software market, which was traditionally un-monetizable by them.
- creato 7y ago> App store security is really bad. Maybe so, but it's still significantly better than native binaries. > Telling people to trust app stores and not downloaded binaries is like telling them to trust Amazon and not Ebay. You're right, there is technically a difference, but the difference is not big enough to matter. If you download random things from any source, you will mess up your computer. It'll just happen faster with downloaded executables. The difference very much does matter. I suspect many people on this website have had the same experience as me: I had to do frequent "maintenance" on my parents computers because they get filled up with IE toolbars and whatever other BS they could find to screw up their computers. After the switch to phones and app stores, this doesn't happen any more. People without family members capable of fixing that sort of old problem are both (probably unconsciously) grateful for the app store takeover, and vastly more numerous than indie software developers grouching about not being able to run any code they like on anyone's computer anymore.
- nolok 7y agoAgreed, and even if there wasn't a Chrome warning, there is then the Windows warning (orange, click yes to bypass), or if dangerous the SmartScreen warning (red, need a few more clicks to really get through).