3 ms·
What makes you think that rewarding someone with a cookie of actual, monetary value avoids the morale problems inherent in rewarding someone with a cookie made
by timr 18y ago
What makes you think that rewarding someone with a cookie of actual, monetary value avoids the morale problems inherent in rewarding someone with a cookie made of polished lucite? You've still singled someone out as different, created jealousy and division, and alienated the team members who weren't equally rewarded.
The problem Joel is describing is inherent to rewarding individuals, instead of rewarding teams. Ratcheting up the value of the award doesn't solve the underlying problem.
Not incidentally, Google found this out the hard way with their Founders' Award program (http://members.forbes.com/global/2007/0702/028.html http://members.forbes.com/global/2007/0702/028.html):
"Early on Page and Brin gave 'Founders' Awards' in cash to people who made significant contributions....but it backfired because those who didn't get them felt overlooked. 'It ended up pissing way more people off,' says one veteran."
- trominos 18y agoRight. It's vital that incentives are not made to feel like "awards," but are instead seen as part of the compensation structure. (I think that the "incentive pay" Joel's talking about really means "public awards, possibly with cash associated.") "Incentive pay" in the simple sense of "pay tied to performance" is not necessarily divisive if it's handled tactfully and can be a substantial motivational force. I mean, that's what PG's always writing about in his essays—the power of a startup is that it harnesses pay very directly to performance.
- timr 18y agoIf you keep it secret, then I suppose that incentive pay is less harmful. The thing is, do you really want to go that way? I think that the only way that incentives are not harmful is if they're spread evenly across teams and tied to product success in the market. Most people can grasp why the team behind a successful product is paid more. Even then, though, you risk alienating the teams that don't do quite as well for reasons that aren't in their control.