9 ms·
SamyGO: Open-Source Firmware for Samsung TVs (2011)
- noodlesUK 7y agoWell, this is right on time given the discussion of Samsung screens phoning home ;)
- AdamJacobMuller 7y agoFantastic. I would love a TV that entirely removes all the app features and retains my ability to network control it. I get why TV manufacturers don't want to release a TV like that, but, open-source replacement firmware seems like a fantastic solution. It could really be amazingly simple and meet my needs.
- andkenneth 7y agoThe average consumer wants the smart features.
- technofiend 7y agoThey might want the features but be unaware of the price they're paying. That spyware is a revenue stream that pays the manufacturer dividends as long as the TV is used. All the major brands claim TVs are discounted due to these marketing-included features. They don't actually reveal the discount nor their profit. And most modern TVs have antipatterns that try to bypass consumer choice or punish the consumer for opting out. I'm not disagreeing with you as much as saying the "smart features" moniker papers over things the consumer might use to make an informed choice but those things are definitely in small print or essentially mandatory EULAs. Consumers may want the features but given the choice they might not choose to pay that price.
- Nursie 7y agoMy LG OLED has optional EULAs. You can disagree to them and it will handicap or remove the associated functionality. I have no idea what happens if you refuse them all, but selective activation has worked fine for me so far.
- AdamJacobMuller 7y agoYou can't refuse ALL of them, only the ones related to data sharing. I have all of the optional ones off and the TV works fine for what I need. I'm obviously not using any of the smart apps at all.
- CivBase 7y agoThey can keep selling their "smart" trash to the average consumer. I'll pay extra for a purposely dumb skew. All I want from a TV is a good panel, at least one modern video input (latest HDMI or DisplayPort), and a nice-enough housing to hold it all together. Speakers are nice but not necessary since I'll probably just use something external. I'll even get a separate box to handle all the inputs. No apps. No internet. No voice commands. No virtual assistant. No cameras. No ads. Just a freaking display, please. I will pay extra and I doubt I'm the only one.
- null_object 7y agoI often read statements on HN in reaction to articles like this, saying “I’d willingly pay more for a TV that doesn’t do this...”. Those TVs do exist: Loewe make really nice TVs which don’t depend on internet connectivity to work[1]. And depending on how seriously the “pay more” part is meant, the Danish company Bang & Olufsen[2] make enormously expensive TVs that won’t spy on you, or insert advertisements into your films. [1] https://www.loewe.tv/int https://www.loewe.tv/int [2] https://www.bang-olufsen.com/en/televisions https://www.bang-olufsen.com/en/televisions
- rainbowzootsuit 7y agoNEC industrial/commercial displays make good and dumb lcd displays as well. https://www.necdisplay.com/ https://www.necdisplay.com/
- joking 7y agoAlmost any comercial / digital signage display can be dumb enough, and probably don’t have the user spyware, even the Samsung ones.
- CivBase 7y agoI've never heard of them. Thanks! I'll check them out for my next TV. I still wish mainstream, highly accessable brands would provide the option, though.
- AdamJacobMuller 7y agoI agree (and even said so in my comment). I wish I had better options. Basically I can pay a lot more for a less good panel.
- wh1t3n01s3 7y agoAll the panels mentioned are LCD. I think nowadays the right tech is OLED. Is there any non smart OLED assembler? Also the dimension is a problem because I cannot find anything smaller than 55’’, and all are smart :-( As a monitor I think OLED is (also) better for your eyes. Am I wrong? Sorry for bad English
- dghughes 7y agoHa! A very well timed article.
- caymanjim 7y agoOnly 8 years between the two!
- yellow_lead 7y agoNice beginners page here: https://wiki.samygo.tv/index.php?title=SamyGO_for_DUMMIES https://wiki.samygo.tv/index.php?title=SamyGO_for_DUMMIES This looks awesome and I can't wait to try it out on my TV.
- myself248 7y agoExcept this doesn't appear to be an open-source firmware. From my reading of their wiki, it's a series of hacks and patches to make small changes to the operating environment. All of Samsung's code is still in there, unless I'm missing something. Also this should have a [2012] or something in the title. Most of it is very stale and applies to models no longer sold or popular.
- hannibalhorn 7y agoI have an older (2015?) model I’ve rooted via SamyGO - your assessment is pretty spot on. Still, it does have it’s uses - by rooting I’ve been able to start diagnosing compatibility issues with DLNA servers, for example.
- GordonS 7y agoI have a 2013 Samsung smart TV, ut it hasn't had any updates for 3 years. What benefits could I expect by using SammyGo? Would official apps, like BBC iPlayer and Amazon Prime continue to work?
- dylan604 7y agoIsn't this pretty much exactly how the Canon DSLR MagicLantern works? The microcode on the chip is not modified in any way. The ML firmware just provides a different method of using the existing instructions on the chip. Remove the card with the ML code, and the camera returns to the original operational mode.
- missosoup 7y agoYou can make magic lantern permanent and not require a card.
- wh1t3n01s3 7y agoSame in some old samsung TVs, you could flash hacked fw with special cable
- 7y ago
- deeblering4 7y agoTo the webmaster: Here are a few notes on the copy that might help it read more clearly. > SamyGO is a project for legal reverse engineering and research on Samsung Television firmwares which is Open Sourced, partially. We try to fix problems that in the firmware. We don't want money from you. We make this modifications for us and ourself but you are allowed to join us. SamyGO is a project to legally reverse engineer and research Samsung TV firmwares. We try to fix the problems that exist in the stock firmware. This project is free and open source. We don't want money from you. Instead, we make these modifications for ourselves, and encourage you to join us by contributing further improvements.
- victor9000 7y ago> We try to fix problems that in the firmware. What?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- _eht 7y agoEnable deduction mode.
- flafla2 7y agoClearly, these (minor) grammar issues are predicated on an ESL background. This package is very respectable and relevant to the #1 post on HN as of this morning [1]. Why disrespect the OP in the light of legitimate engineering? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21899491 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21899491
- axaxs 7y agoThis feels like a bad translationparty(if that even still exists). The last sentences in particular make it feel scammy. On that note, I don't understand what pride foreign companies take in writing their own English. I'm an engineer, not great at English even, and would do it for free likely. I can't imagine it could be that expensive. Here's how I would word it: SamyGO is a project that allows anyone to legally research and reverse engineer Samsung TV firmware. We will try our best to fix problems submitted to us that are found to exist in the stock firmware. This project is completely free and open source. We encourage you to join us by contributing your findings and improvements.
- anonymousiam 7y agoIs it just me, or is this site now gone? I can see some content in Google Cache, but I am wondering if this site has been taken down by a DMCA request. If so, it's a bogus request because no "circumvention" has occurred, just reverse-engineering and alternative (and free) firmware.
- jvolkman 7y agoWorks for me.
- purpleidea 7y agoThe project looks really dead, but it would be nice to have either a revival, or a new alternative. I'd like to get a new TV, but I don't want the junk proprietary stack that it comes with. Ideas?
- myself248 7y agoIf I ever buy a TV, my plan is to simply use it as a big HDMI monitor. Slit open the side of the HDMI cable and cut the Ethernet wires therein. Never connect it to my wifi. If other wireless networks are ubiquitous by that time, open it up and neuter their transceivers too. Any internet functionality will come from a device I trust and control, with only the display portion handed to Spysung.
- jsmeaton 7y agoHang on - HDMI can do Ethernet? That was news to me.
- lightedman 7y agoYup, been in the spec for a while. Video cards try to install drivers for it now days. I always stop that garbage.
- kuzimoto 7y agoThere are virtually no devices that actually support it, at least as of about a year ago.
- gregmac 7y agoI was trying to find an "HDMI condom" (equivalent to the usb ones [1]) but came up dry. Does such a thing exist yet, or is there just no market? Is it possible to use something such as an HDMI splitter to accomplish the same thing, or can those pass Ethernet as well, and how would you be able to tell? [1] https://int3.cc/products/usbcondoms https://int3.cc/products/usbcondoms
- 7y ago
- walterbell 7y agoLG TVs are based on WebOS, which is based on OpenEmbedded. Has anyone tried modifying LG TV firmware? https://www.webosose.org/ https://www.webosose.org/ https://github.com/webosose https://github.com/webosose >... HTML5, CSS3, and JavaScript. For web app development, you can use Enact, a React-based application framework optimized for webOS OSE, as well as other modern web application frameworks ...native technologies including Qt ... architecture based on Node.js and Luna Bus > In addition to the openness as an open community to developers, webOS OSE also pursues openness to other technologies, especially open source ones, such as Qt, Chromium, and Yocto ... now taking a step further to other verticals targeting smart and connected products, such as robot, smart home, and automotive
- heavyset_go 7y agoPretty sure newer Samsung TVs run Tizen. Edit: Yep, Samsung TVs released sometime after 2015 ship with Tizen[1] [1] https://developer.samsung.com/tv/develop/specifications/tv-model-groups/ https://developer.samsung.com/tv/develop/specifications/tv-m...
- wadayaknow 7y agoAre there any open source alternatives to Tizen? Also anyone attempted to reverse engineer the new Samsung 4k uhd TVs? I have constant network issues + obvious privacy concerns
- dastx 7y agoTizen is open source and backed by the Linux Foundation. I think what you really want is a way of installing the OSS version onto the TV.
- wadayaknow 7y agoThat is indeed what I really want
- imposterr 7y agoIf anyone wants a truly dumb modern 4K TV, without going through weird hoops to get one, I would recommend the Dell C5519Q [1]. You can get it for under 1K USD at CDW. [1] https://www.dell.com/en-ca/shop/dell-55-4k-conference-room-monitor-c5519q/apd/210-arev/monitors-monitor-accessories https://www.dell.com/en-ca/shop/dell-55-4k-conference-room-m...
- electrograv 7y agoSorry to say, but looking at these specs and price, this is not even in the same ballpark as the image quality offered by modern flagship TVs — which you will get (and should expect in 2020) in this price and size range, and also have the ability to be used as non-smart TVs for the privacy-conscious[1]. For the same price, you can buy the latest brand new 55” OLED TV from LG, which has absolutely spectacular picture quality in every respect (including fantastic color calibration capabilities), raw pixel response times better than any “PC gaming monitor”, and even input lag (overall end-to-end latency) rivaling or beating many gaming monitors today[2]. Nothing else even comes close, aside from Sony models (also in this price range) which also use LG’s OLED panels. So rather than hacking your Samsung or buying an inferior Dell monitor meant for PowerPoint presentations, a far better solution is to just stop buying Samsung TVs. In addition to their deceptive marketing and other issues like intentionally bad (over saturated) color calibration out of box, they are designed to be impossible to correctly calibrate due to always-on tone mapping. They do this because they think it makes their TVs look better, and they’re fighting a losing battle against OLED TVs which Samsung does not have any answer to at the moment[3]. Tone mapping that cannot be turned off is a cheap software trick that compromises the accuracy of the source material in hopes of making their TVs have a higher contrast appearance than their hardware is actually capable of (but it does cause artifacts and other downsides, even in regular streaming content). [1] If you’re really concerned about privacy, LG’s TVs allow you to decline all the terms of service and still use them as “old fashioned TVs” with just the non-smart inputs like HDMI. I’ve tested this on my new LG C9, and it works great. [2] Objective measurements of the LG C9 OLED series: https://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/lg/c9-oled https://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/lg/c9-oled [3] Samsung (and everyone else) is way behind LG’s OLED tech, until they manage to get micro-LED technology to scale up and reach affordable prices. Micro-LED will be superior even to OLED, but right now it is not a production reality, and exists only as multimillion dollar display tech demo prototypes. One other possible alternate to OLED is dual layer LCD, but I don’t think anyone is seriously pursuing that for consumer TV use due to their power and heat issues.
- ribalda 7y agoA bit off topic: Any idea about how to install apps from two countries in your Samsung tizen TV. As a expat I want to see TV from my home and host country. If I change the country from my TV all the apps are uninstalled :(
- netsharc 7y agoAh, I hate the stupid "convenient" localization. I remember reading an American being angry that Google's homepage came up Arabic because he was in Kuwait. Recently I was in a foreign country looking up hotels in my home country, and even though I earn money there and was planning to spend it in that country, Google Maps was showing me hotel prices in the foreign currency. I was even logged in and had defined where Home and Work in Google Maps...
- nenadst 7y agomaybe something like https://pi-hole.net https://pi-hole.net and/or some firewall rules could be used to stop all the offending traffic ? Sounds easier than cutting physical lines.. Anybody using this and having success ?
- gdm85 7y agoIf I remember correctly you need to make a donation to access some firmwares, but I cannot tell whether you can access the source after the donation.