9 ms·
Anti Homeless Spikes
- e40 7y agoHonestly, it's getting so bad in the Bay Area, I'm having trouble seeing how this will end. Everywhere I walk in the East Bay (mostly Oakland), there are tents.
- geogra4 7y agoThere needs to be some kind of basic housing guarantee. A society cannot survive like this for long.
- wavefunction 7y agoI am in favor of the notion but it seems like revoking Prop 13 and rezoning the area over the objections of NIMBYists is just as likely to occur and probably prudent whatever else happens.
- scotty79 7y agoNimby should be fixed in the law. Value of your own property should be just your own concern. If whatever happens around it doesn't emit toxic substances or horrible smells or noises and doesn't lower insolation of your property below some minimum levels then you should have no saying in what happens not on your land.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoIsn't that basically how it works in Houston?
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoWe stopped sending people to the RSA conference a couple of years ago because no one wanted to go to San Francisco anymore.
- dry_soup 7y agoIt's truly amazing that an incredibly rich city full of companies trying to "change the world" chooses over and over again to not solve its homelessness problem. It requires no new technological developments, no moonshots, just an ounce of empathy and maybe some raised taxes. But that seems to be too hard.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoMost homeless people don’t really want to address their root issues.
- mlyle 7y agoThe amount of resources going towards the homeless are ridiculously large. The net result is that favorable weather and resource availability draws more people in from other places, and the problem is too large for any individual locality to solve. e.g. The City of San Francisco is spending over $300M/year directly on services towards easing homelessness. This does not count state expenditures focused in the area, private expenditures, expenditures by surrounding areas, and the wealth of indirect expenses. Versus a homeless population of 10,000, this is $30,000 per year per homeless person in the City of SF-- just direct expenses by City of SF. Clearly an overall change in approach is needed-- not just additional resources spent the same way.
- mschuster91 7y agoThe key would be that all US cities/towns/villages take care of their homeless instead of busing them to California. I can see the financial incentive - a bus ticket is like, what, couple hundred tops across the country? while the police, healthcare and other resources in a single year can easily reach five to six figures - but morally it is absolutely disgusting behavior. Ideally federal agencies should take care of this and make sure that every US citizen in need is taken care of where he lives.
- mlyle 7y agoAt the very least we need to strictly regulate programs that bus homeless other places. Yes, there are circumstances where throwing someone on a bus to a locality where he has some family or other connections is the best move for all involved. But we need to make sure that is actually the case, not based on some tenuous connection and a desire to displace the costly individual somewhere else. This isn't enough, though. Even without explicit governmental support to move, homeless people know that there are localities where it's "better" to be homeless and will move themselves.
- almost_usual 7y agoI’ve volunteered at the encampments in West Oakland and it’s painfully sad to see. A lot of the homeless I met were 50+ years old and had lived in Oakland all their life. It was a stark contrast to the homeless in SF.
- scotty79 7y agoSo solution is basically simple. Provide state sponsored flat monthly amount retirement money to all people over 50 and build a bunch of homes owned by the state and rent them exclusively to 50+ at the cost that can be comfortable covered out of retirement amount. It just needs money and that should be easy in richest large country on Earth.
- plumednom 7y agoChange your perspective if you want to help. Those aren't tents. Those are sons, daughters, brothers, sisters, mothers, and fathers with nowhere else to go, with drug and /or emotional problems. Those are soldiers who fought our oil wars and came home broken and abandoned. Those aren't "tents", they're you if you made the wrong choice or had the wrong thing happen to you.
- nine_k 7y agoBrothers? Sisters? Mothers? Sons? Do their siblings, children not want to help them out so much that they end up homeless? I bet most of the homeless have their normal social ties severed, and shame, guilt, hate and other such things keep them away from their former friends and relatives. Also, I bet the great majority of them don't have a job, or another occupation, and lives on handouts and petty crime. Overcoming this first is required to make these people feel like fathers, sisters, sons, etc again, and agree to come back into the society.
- plumednom 7y ago> Brothers? Sisters? Mothers? Sons? Do their siblings, children not want to help them out so much that they end up homeless? Americans have this "rugged individualism" to our culture. I left my own home when I was still 15, most people at 17 or 18. I live in Istanbul, and the first thing I noticed was the lack of homeless people in this city of 15-20million (depending on with whom you are talking). This is because Turks have a much stronger family structure, and most people live with their parents until they're married at the very least. I'm from San Francisco and have known many of my friends to become homeless over the past 20 years through combinations of, as I stated before, substance abuse, trauma, and a lack of a strong family / social support structure. My closest friend is a homeless violinist hippy in San Francisco (who just returned after 4 years in Istanbul). He keeps tents in 6 or 7 spots around the bay, most of them with breathtaking views. He just likes being homeless. (Brilliant guy. Oliver. He plays mostly in Bart, the Mission, and North Beach. Say hi in any language, he knows it) I also know a lot of kids from my various music scenes who are homeless on purpose. The street punks, for example, find a stronger family structure drinking 40s on telegraph or the haight all day than they ever did in their own middle-class homes. (PS: Fuck the kids on haight. They're basically an aging street gang, I used to be in a band with one of them.)
- tiredwired 7y agoSomeone is profiting selling tents and camping supplies to these people. The more homeless the more profit.
- GycDH6mb 7y agoYou're not wrong, and maybe "hostile architecture" like this is cruel, but damn if I owned a business and I had homeless people setting up tents or loitering outside my door every night I'd probably find a way to stop it too. Spikes are a cheap and easy-to-deploy deterrent. In a similar vein, I volunteer with a pigeon and dove rescue organization, and it's no secret that businesses install spikes on eaves and ledges to deter birds too. Although it always makes me sad to see them, I can understand and appreciate why they do it.
- inetsee 7y ago> I volunteer with a pigeon and dove rescue organization So, you're more concerned about the welfare of birds than you are about people?
- serf 7y agochoosing one problem over another doesn't say much to the person's priorities; perhaps they just thought they'd have more impact in that field. Furthermore, that attitude drives people away from philanthropic work by alienating them about what image their proposed good deed generates. Just do good, any way you find.
- dang 7y agoThat crosses into personal attack. Please don't. Please do follow the HN guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- honksillet 7y agoI have lived in LA, Austin, Honolulu, Cleveland, DC and now Portland, all with homeless of varying degrees. The more permissive we are for allowing the homeless to use what should be shared communal spaces for their personal use, the more they will. The people of Portland (were I live now) have a greater concern for the environment than any other city I have lived in, and yet there is trash everywhere, from the homeless. Recently here they have been building "boulders" near freeway off ramps, which is just a slightly more aesthetic variation of spikes. Frankly, when I see either I think, "good". I know this probably is not a popular opinion but we should not be going out of our way to make it comfortable to be homeless. Not if we care about these individuals and their future. Seattle is spending nearly $100 per homeless person. (This Thanksgiving I was in Seattle and the scenes I was seeing looked like Mad Max, but with more meth.) The resources are there. But for most it is frankly easier to be homeless than to tackle the difficult task of reestablishing a foothold in society. So please, by all means, install spike and boulders, take away stolen carts, and tear down encampments. Some times tough love is the only love.
- saagarjha 7y agoBuilding spikes does nothing to help homeless people, it just makes it hard for them to live. “Tough love” isn’t going to make them not be homeless.
- almost_usual 7y agoGo tell the homeless Mexican guys outside Home Depot in West Oakland looking for work they are not trying hard enough.
- madengr 7y agoHere I thought illegal immigration was a net gain for the American economy.
- wavefunction 7y agoWhether illegal immigration is a net gain for the American economy or not is such a complex subject that basing it off some anecdotal "homeless Mexicans" looking for manual labor post seems... ill-advised. From the perspective of an employer the short-term gain of paying less for labor is attractive and a positive. For Americans who might be competing with "homeless Mexicans" it is likely a negative. And beyond these two simple perspectives lay more complex calculations of benefits and detriments. Measuring the negatives against the positives requires far more data than a single anecdotal post about "homeless Mexicans." At least for me.
- 34523trefds12 7y agoI find this quite interesting. Anti homeless spikes are a problem, but no-one can actually agree on the origin of the image. Spikes are definitely hostile to users of space, but pretending we can just give them housing shows nothing but ignorance. The Twitter user who posted this tweet, refuses to believe the origin (Daily mail) claiming the papers xenophobia is enough to discredit the possibility that this is in China, and not somewhere in the West. It is this attitude that is most alarming, perhaps not unusual on twitter. Pro communist beliefs, splattered with justifications for the so called concentration camps purportedly in China is much more troubling than hostile architecture.
- yellow_lead 7y agoCan't believe it's gotten this far, that cities need to implement deterences like these.
- ailideex 7y agoThis is nothing new - I have seen similar things since I was about 8.
- drdeadringer 7y ago99 Percent Invisible did an episode on such Hostile Architecture, architecture designed specifically to be hostile toward the homeless. Some related sites: https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/unpleasant-design-hostile-urban-architecture/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/unpleasant-design-hos... https://99percentinvisible.org/article/design-crimes-artist-launches-campaign-highlight-hostile-architecture/ https://99percentinvisible.org/article/design-crimes-artist-...
- lm28469 7y agoOn a related topic: https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-containment-plan/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-containment-plan/
- drdeadringer 7y agoSounds like a plot from 'The Wire'.
- verall 7y agoPosted like 3 tweets down from this guy: https://mobile.twitter.com/Inartica/status/1210970985114959872/photo/1 https://mobile.twitter.com/Inartica/status/12109709851149598... Aaaaaaa! I believe anti-homeless architecture is appalling and Western culture of "the strong (rich) deserve more than others" is the root cause but good lord please go to China and talk to some people before you go repeating propaganda like that...
- cameronfraser 7y agoThis guy has some weird cognitive dissonance. They seem to be supportive of socialist countries, but also of tulsi gabbard?
- joeblow9999 7y agowhy is that surprising? have you read her policy positions?
- cameronfraser 7y agoShe is very far from socialist. She isn't in line with democrat ideologies either. Her policies don't matter, what matters is her history. She is a conservative masquerading as a democrat. For example: https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/13/politics/kfile-tulsi-gabbard-lgbt/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/13/politics/kfile-tulsi-gabbard-...
- joeblow9999 7y agoits amazing how we can all see things so differently. her policies seem ver socialist to me
- joeblow9999 7y agosocialist is about economic policies. your link is about something else
- 7y ago
- thrwaway69 7y agoI don't have a magic solution but I would like to add few thoughts: 1. Homeless people destroy environment and don't practice sanitation on the same level (non homeless folks) That imo is true and we shouldn't ignore it. But why? I have a few explanation depending on the place so it's not an apply all hammer, alcohol & drug abuse/mental illness are one of the reasons why there are homeless in big rich cities (combined with other) but wouldn't that cause itself will lead to people caring less about environment and things that don't directly affect them? When was the last time you were depressed and wanted to hole up in your bed doing nothing? Consider that and with not a good overall health condition, lacking empathy (of course why would they for the society that failed them), poverty mindset and resource constraints with no hope for a brighter future. It's a self destructive mindset. Oh to make it more suitable for HN in analogy, think of those anti homeless spikes as walled garden of the big companies. Imessage? Yeah, you can't connect with your friends anymore after you can't afford an iPhone. Maybe you contributed to society in tax and other spheres and now you can't anymore, you don't deserve whatever crumbles are left there. Of course I am exaggerating. 2. Throw money at them and it will go away. I hope that worked, I really do but that doesn't solve any of the problems. US puts a lot of money more than countries with free healthcare (controlled for population but not size) yet people aren't getting it. The system is dysfunctional or benefits some people more than others due to lack of awareness, discrimination (advertising towards one gender or race is an example), collective empathy, and tendency to put pressure on your career/home/bank as an identity. Maybe those homeless shelters are far away. I don't know but why blame anyone without any evidence or data on those things.
- thrwaway69 7y agoI think we can employee homeless people with the money spent on 'solving' the problem for cleaning and maintaining our environment. They get a job and maybe they can afford some housing now or make free housing structures for those employees.
- mnm1 7y agoCEOs who afaik are 100% not homeless destroy the environment to such an extent as to make what all the homeless in the US destroy seem insignificant and inconsequential. They too lack empathy and have a destructive mindset. I say we address this much more massive problem first and the homeless problem will likely be solved by our actions.
- RickJWagner 7y agoHuh. And what is their defense if the homeless is a fakir? https://sciencedemonstrations.fas.harvard.edu/presentations/fakir-physics https://sciencedemonstrations.fas.harvard.edu/presentations/...