4 ms·
The basis in GDPR I've seen people use for your position is that consent must be "freely given", and consent isn't freely given if my other option is not using
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
The basis in GDPR I've seen people use for your position is that consent must be "freely given", and consent isn't freely given if my other option is not using the site. The line of argument seems pretty sketchy on its face; can it really be true that my consent to an employment contract isn't "freely given" because my other option is not taking the job? It's certainly not clearly made to avoid doubt.
- Thiez 7y agoThere are plenty of things that you cannot consent to under various circumstances. As an extreme example you cannot freely give consent to become a slave no matter how much you would like to (except by going to prison in a certain well known country north of Mexico, I suppose). In many cases you cannot consent to intimate acts with authority figures (e.g. boss, teacher, prison guards). I think in the case of the GDPR the desire was for consumers to be able to make a choice about their data, but such a choice would be meaningless if websites were allowed to make a "click here to consent, or here to close this browser tab" popup, and the "cookie law" shows that this likely the approach that 95%+ of websites would have taken. The cookie popups have shown quite clearly the balance of power between consumers and websites: website owners know consumers will get the exact same deal (accept or fuck off) everywhere else, so the consumers have no real power in this "negotiation". The definition of "freely given" consent in the context of the GDPR was probably written the way it is to correct for this power imbalance.