6 ms·
I'm extremely tempted to perform a Reocities style rescue job and handle the takedown notices as and when they come. Might not work for some of the interactive
by notahacker 16y ago
I'm extremely tempted to perform a Reocities style rescue job and handle the takedown notices as and when they come. Might not work for some of the interactive stuff but at least the text can be saved.
- imajes 16y agoAlready started. Email me if you want to help (in my profile).
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoYou realise of course that this is unlawful copyright infringement?
- imajes 16y agoSure. but the goal is to get an archive of it first, we can deal with putting it online at the right moment.
- msg 16y agoWhen you're on your deathbed, you're not going to tell your grandchildren "I sure wish I had upheld the strict letter of copyright law on the internet more." But you might say "remember that time I saved the BBC from itself?" And like Big Fish, it will be almost true.
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoThat may or may not be true, however it is still copyright infringement. It doesn't matter incidentally if you copy it solely for personal use - stopping a rights holder from being an idiot is not a given exclusion. I assume that the downvoters can explain how this is not infringing or how I'm not adding to the thread by noting this fact that some may not wholly realise?
- peterstjohn 16y agoThis is true, but the BBC were extremely grateful for the copyright infringement that has seen the rescue of Q, Doctor Who, and countless other series - they may come to see that again (and to be honest, the chances of the BBC suing are probably very slight).
- Cushman 16y agoCan't speak for anyone else, but I downvoted for the condescending tone more than the opinion.
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoCould you explain how you find it patronising - is it that I'm pointing out they're breaking the law if they use this specific font [file] without a license but you think this is obvious, or that I'm assuming they know they're committing tortfeasance when you feel it's not obvious. There are of course other possibilities, hence why I posed the question, they might be outside the Berne Convention/TRIPS countries and not be bound by copyright law, for example.
- Cushman 16y agoIt's this particular pattern of saying "I assume you realize that [thing I actually assume you don't realize], right?" Well, no. Obviously they don't realize that, or else they disagree on some more fundamental point, or they wouldn't have said whatever they said in the first place— which I assume you actually do realize. So it's a very disingenuous way of communicating. All it really says is "I think I know more about this than you, but I decided not to be nice about informing you," which isn't a very productive way to start a conversation.
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoYou've got the pattern exactly wrong. They mention take down notices which means they are aware of online copyright issues. I was attempting both to confirm that they felt this was tortuously infringing activity and giving the opportunity to respond with their moral justification. >Well, no. Obviously they don't realize that To recapitulate: if they mentioned "take down notices" then they appear to be living in the USA, aware of copyright in online material and cognisant of the Digitial Millenium Copyright Act (just an informed guess) as a minimum; my point was to confirm this and, like I said, dig for a response (without leading them on as to what sort of response to make - moral, legal, technical, political, ...). The question was also serving as a flag for the issue for other readers. So, whilst I'm prepared to entertain an argument that I was being disingenuous I'm afraid your premises are false and thus the reasoned conclusions equally unsound. If you're looking to establish a relevant argument to the content of the thread then perhaps civil disobedience WRT copyright would be the way to go; there are strong arguments that the BBC should back a change in UK law as proposed elsewhere to ensure release of such works in to the public domain.
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoIt is only copyright infringement if they re-publish. Just getting an archive is not infringement, otherwise, you'd be infringing every time you view the site with your browser.
- gwern 16y agoMost people, as they grow up, learn the difference between what is moral and what is legal. Chin up, champ, you'll figure that out someday, and maybe the appropriate use of condescension too!
- JonnieCache 16y agoGentlemen, start your spiders!