4 ms·
The only reason the checks and balances were added was because the Founders knew what the Gracchus brothers, Sulla, Marius and Cesar did to the Roman Republic.
by tomjen3 16y ago
The only reason the checks and balances were added was because the Founders knew what the Gracchus brothers, Sulla, Marius and Cesar did to the Roman Republic.
Look there is no way to say this nicely, but if those people can't get over their issues of the lost paradise thats just too bad. There are plenty of hands-on jobs left: snow needs to be removed, toilets cleaned, windows polished, etc.
And no these jobs may not allow you to live a middle class lifestyle in 2010-2020, but they will allow you to live better than in the sixties.
Half of the houses then didn't indoor bathrooms and medical care for something like cancer would be a joke compared to what we can do today.
But hey lets all go and complain.
- knowtheory 16y agoYou are not going to make a wage above the poverty line doing those jobs though. Together the manufacturing sector and unions managed to drive wages and benefits into a local maximum, and were unable to find a way out. Also i further disagree with the notion that it'll let you live better than in the 60s, for a variety of reasons including poorer access to nutrition, lack of public transport, and that society has shifted away from outdoor activities.
- tomjen3 16y agoWhats the poverty line though? Because as a student I live below the one for my country but I live better than my parents did a generation ago and vastly better than my grandparents. As for your second argument you might be slightly right about nutrition (but only on average, its easy enough to live healthy for cheap as several members of this board have done) but the two other things? How does outdoor activities even fit into that?
- doki_pen 16y agoThe problem is, losing the middle class cascades to so many other problems. Most importantly, it shrinks the market and reduces business opportunity. It also has a devastating effect on tax revenue and public services. What made the US the powerhouse that it is is an enormous middle class. We seem to be losing that now.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoCould you explain your thesis in more detail? You seem to agree with tomjen's claim that everyone, poor or middle class, seems to be consuming more now than historically. And this is certainly well supported by the data - modern day poor people consume more than 1960's middle class people. So isn't the purchasing behavior, rather than the label attached to the consumer, what grows the market and increases business opportunity? I.e., isn't it better for a modern day poor person to consume a house, a car, an AC and an X-Box than for a 1970's middle class person to walk to work, live in a smaller house, and suffer in the summer with no AC and entertain themselves with only a legacy mechanical music players? [edit: better for the purpose of creating "business opportunity"]
- chopsueyar 16y agoBetter for who?
- knowtheory 16y agoThe poverty line is actually a defined number. Students do appear as a statistical aberration in most of these counts since they have no income, but they tend to have access to credit and fewer costs than those that are older than them (health care) or those with families. So yes, you're right, but i don't think it matters all that much. Studenthood is a transient state which is designed to eject students after a period of time (and you have to fight really hard to stay a student). Poverty and destitution are the opposite.
- matwood 16y agopoorer access to nutrition Based on studies [1], the above is simply not true. Wal-Mart has for example given more people access to healthy foods at lower prices than at any other time in history. Fresh vegetables and fruits can compete on price with less healthy alternatives at WM. Now, this doesn't mean people will chose them over a bag of chips (they study claims there is statistical significant evidence that people do though), but it has removed price as a fairly large barrier. [1] http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2009-05-16/does-walmart-make-you-skinny/ http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2009-05-16/do...
- knowtheory 16y agoActually that piece really doesn't modulate what i've said. I'd be interested in seeing the distribution of walmarts relative to the levels of poverty across the US. That article even starts with the caveat that there are urban areas which still have a dearth of access to fresh foods. This is an empirical question, we should probably find actual data to back it up.
- matwood 16y agoThat's a good point that WMs aren't everywhere, but maybe they should be?
- chopsueyar 16y agoYou could always do something like Detroit, instead... http://www.detroitagriculture.org/GRP_Website/Home.html http://www.detroitagriculture.org/GRP_Website/Home.html
- sgift 16y agoFollowing your argumentation one should never "complain" that some trend may be a problem (for a group of people), because compared with people living 50/100/300/1000 years ago we all have a great life. Theoretically correct, practically I'll side with the complaining people in this case.
- sokoloff 16y agoDo you think that a lot of the gains over the last 50/100/300/1000 years came about because societies didn't stand in the way of progress in the name of full employment, exactly as that full employment was practiced the day before? I do. It happens that I'm on a pretty favorable part of the curve (in terms of ability and inclination to "work with computers"), so take my thoughts with as much salt as you think is appropriate, but I'm glad past societies didn't turn their noses up at farming, beer and bread making, writing, indoor plumbing, domesticating animals, stonework, bronze, iron, steel, water wheels, coal/oil/nat gas, electricity, the steam and internal combustion engines, telephony, interchangeable parts and the moving assembly line, automobiles, modern medicine, transistors, integrated circuits, etc. I'm sure that all of those innovations caused some significant amount of displacement amongst the established practioners of the "old way" of doing things. Had societies past decided that that displacement was too costly, the life of today's 99th percentile priveleged person would almost certainly be significantly worse than the life of today's actual 1st percentile (un) priveleged person.
- sgift 16y agoStopping progress to support the old ways is (IMO - and there we agree) no solution. But ignoring the short-term problems of said progress with the argument "in the long run we will all be better off this way" sounds a bit cynical to me.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoCould you clearly state what the problem is? Is the problem simply this? "Standard of living has dramatically increased for everyone (some more than others), but some people who only received large increases are jealous of the others who received huge increases."
- Nick_C 16y ago> Half of the houses then didn't indoor bathrooms Just in case anyone gets a wrong impression of life in the 60s, this is not true.