4 ms·
To be fair, the British Broadcasting Corporation ought to have been a lot clearer about its remit in the past. Take Dirac for example, why was the British taxpa
by gaius 16y ago
To be fair, the British Broadcasting Corporation ought to have been a lot clearer about its remit in the past. Take Dirac for example, why was the British taxpayer funding that development work when H.264 was already widely supported? It's no wonder now that they are being required to make cuts, they had become a huge sprawling monster with a finger in every pie, no matter how relevant.
- NickPollard 16y agoAre you implying that a Broadcasting Corporation ought not to be concerned with technologies for transmitting video over communication networks?
- gaius 16y agoConcerned with? Sure. NIH on the taxpayer's money? Probably not. Not like the BBC ever had its own homegrown tape format or anything, it got it all off-the-shelf.
- NickPollard 16y agoYou could argue that tapes are not broadcasting though - whereas if I recall, the BBC was quite involved with early Television research and development. Personally, as a British citizen and license-payer, I'm quite happy for the BBC to spend money on research and development (if well-thought and efficient; perhaps in this case it was misplaced), and I'm glad that the BBC is pushing technologies like video-over-internet compared to some of the more dinosaur-like traditional media companies. Time to go watch some more BBC4 streaming over IP.
- rodh 16y agoMaybe not a homegrown tape format... but how about Teletext, FM Radio, Freeview, HD on Freeview, iPlayer?
- gaius 16y agoThe BBC invented FM? I was not aware of that...
- bruceboughton 16y agoYour point about Dirac is entirely irrelevant to the OP, which was about the Beeb embarking on a spree of wilful destruction of content. All big organisation have areas of waste but content is the BBC's raison d'être, not something that should be discarded to save money.
- gaius 16y agoThey aren't destroying it just for the hell of it; BBC Online has been cut across the board because they were so wasteful in the past.
- sambeau 16y agoWasteful? I'm an ex BBC Online employee. Most people don't realise quite how few people are involved in the creation and update of the BBC website. When I was there it was generally 2 people per site (and each person was on more than one site). We had a dozen staff looking after a hundred sites using old and borrowed tech and the occasional independent flash developer. The BBC was never wasteful. Don't believe what you read in the anti-BBC press. They have their own agenda.
- imajes 16y agoBBC FM&T and R&D did/does awesome stuff with little resources. It appears to outsiders-who-care that the problem exists higher up, especially with decisions such as adopting Siemens to provide infrastructure support (Talk about locking in what existed 10 years ago with an SLA!), and the perverted influence of people like Highfield and now, surprisingly, Huggers.
- bruceboughton 16y agoTo borrow a phrase, since this government came into power, people seem to know the waste of everything and the value of nothing.
- sfphotoarts 16y agoI don't believe this was OT, the poster made it clear how it related to the article; that the BBC has an obligation to their funders (the British taxpayers.)
- eftpotrm 16y agoThe BBC's mission is to broadcast content. Clearly that future is digital content, I'd argue equally clearly that future is in Internet-style streamed distribution over CDNs rather than in classical broadcasting. This puts the BBC as having a major interest in both optimal storage and transmission of streamed media. Why on earth is it not in the BBC's interest to investigate means of improving its service offering and lowering its cost base through use of improved video storage and transmission technology? To get back to the original point as that's about maintenance of existing content, I agree 100% with those who are saying this is purely political. We have a strong strand in our commercial media which will push relentlessly for the BBC to be cut on all possible fronts because it's impinging on their ability to profit. I'm sorry, but that's rubbish. I watch more BBC than commercial content (and have done for many years) because it's better. You don't have to go very far back in history for the ITV franchise operators to have been lumbering behemoths viewed as a license to print money. The merged ITV that came out of Carlton and Granada was hardly a weak, minor player, nor is the RTL Group backed 5 family or the News Corporation backed Sky network. All are quite capable of building a serious, large-scale rival to the BBC, but they seem to dismiss it as too expensive compared to running repeats of imported clipshows. What the BBC is doing here is absolutely wrong, but they're doing it in response to (government-favoured) self-serving political pressure from their commercial rivals and out of largely reasonable fear that if they aren't seen to do something like this themselves something worse will be forced on them. That is the core problem - excessive political attention being paid to low-quality competitors who think they have a right to the extra profit they'd have if the BBC didn't exist. They don't; I gladly pay a comparable amount for the BBC as for Sky's vastly lower quality subscription offering and the commercial media outlets need to realise this and raise their game.