3 ms·
Regarding the GDPR: > 95% of users choose to be tracked in exchange for access to websites and services The GDPR explicitly disallows the practice of conditio
by alkonaut 7y ago
Regarding the GDPR:
> 95% of users choose to be tracked in exchange for access to websites and services
The GDPR explicitly disallows the practice of conditioning access to a site or service on acceptance. Without that it would be rather useless. Once that bit is also enforced (current fines for violation sadly week focused on poor data safety measures and similar) I think the online ad landscape actually may start to change.
- ailideex 7y agoSo if I run an online shop - and someone does not accept cookies - I still have to make it work for them somehow without cookies (or any equivalent technology)? Or am I misreading this? And if I'm not misreading this - how would you approach it?
- alkonaut 7y agoNo. Things you need to do to make the site/service function at all such as your login cookies or shopping carts don’t count. Non essential cookies is what it’s about. Sadly, some sites seem to interpret that (incorrectly) as “well out business is to show news paid for by ads so the ad network cookies are essential”. These are the players I wish would be fined out of business.
- ailideex 7y agoJust for interest sake, do you ever read news on the internet, and if so how do you pay for it? I personally read a lot of news online, most of it is such utter trash that I would not want to pay for it. I have paid for some specific sites intermittently - currently I pay about $20 USD a month to one specific content creator that produces news content - but that is mostly because it is rather niche news that nobody else (that I know of) is reporting on. For the rest of the news I consume I feel that it is of such a low quality that the ad revenue is all they deserve.
- bcrosby95 7y agoWebsites don't need to use personalized ads.
- bestnameever 7y agoThats an odd thing to say. Websites don't need to allow free access either. I can't comment on any particular revenue model but I imagine many websites chose personalized ads as they provide better revenue returns than non-personalized ads. would switching to non-personalized advertisements without taking additional steps support the website enough? Maybe but its hard to say one way or the other without looking at the data.
- bcrosby95 7y agoCorrect, they don't have to offer free access. What they do need to do is pick a business model that is legal in countries they wish to operate in. Things like GDPR doesn't prevent ads. Maybe they make less money off non-personalized ads, but companies can't do whatever they want just because they make more money that way. I don't find it odd that laws can hamper the revenue of certain business models.
- JadeNB 7y ago> Thats an odd thing to say. Websites don't need to allow free access either. I can't comment on any particular revenue model but I imagine many websites chose personalized ads as they provide better revenue returns than non-personalized ads. Another way to get revenue, which doesn't itself transgress against these privacy-focused laws, is to charge directly for providing your service. That's totally legal! Well, but maybe some companies would find that they don't get enough subscribers to fund their business—then the solution, in a privacy-focused environment, is that those business don't exist, rather than that they get a shadow source of funding by accepting bribes for participating in scummy privacy violations. This would be a very different environment from the one in which we live—clearly better in some ways and clearly worse in others—but it's far from impossible.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI dunno, man. As you mentioned, all of the people who implement or enforce GDPR compliance seem to think that "our business model relies on ads" is a sufficient reason to require tracking. Maybe the regulators are just biding their time before pouncing, but I'm not sure why they'd want to do that or what they're waiting for after a year and a half. It seems more likely that GDPR as an ad industry killer was just a piece of HN lore that didn't end up panning out.
- manigandham 7y agoIt's more complicated than that for ads but GDPR is incredibly vague and contradictory to the point that it has major issues in effectiveness. It can be costly to be in perfect compliance but nobody is really is afraid of GDPR risk anymore, especially since most internet companies are not in the EU anyway and are completely unaffected by regional legislation.
- alkonaut 7y agoThe wording was very clearly made to avoid any doubt about “we need to track people to survive on ads”. As I said I think it’s sad that so far the fines have been for data security and not yet for tracking-ads-without-opt-in. I really do hope regulators will take a few high profile sites and make an example with a massive fine for blatant violations. The rule is: if I visit a site then tracking is OFF until I switch it on. Seeing the content can’t be conditioned on accepting, and the default “ok close the popup and show me the article” should always result in the miminum cookies allowed - that is, typically no ad networks at all.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThe basis in GDPR I've seen people use for your position is that consent must be "freely given", and consent isn't freely given if my other option is not using the site. The line of argument seems pretty sketchy on its face; can it really be true that my consent to an employment contract isn't "freely given" because my other option is not taking the job? It's certainly not clearly made to avoid doubt.
- manigandham 7y agoNo it doesn't. The "freely-given consent" clause is incredibly vague and cannot force a business to provide a value to consumers against their choice and/or for free. There are also dozens of workarounds from legitimate use of data to contract-in-effect (like email newsletters). This is an example of the poor legislation aspects of GDPR and other privacy laws that are not based in technical reality.