4 ms·
I've been an instructor for CS courses before so I know what you mean. I never made deadlines anything but absolutely final, which is appropriately not unlike a
by userbinator 7y ago
I've been an instructor for CS courses before so I know what you mean. I never made deadlines anything but absolutely final, which is appropriately not unlike a lot of other things in life --- from what I've heard from others, any leniency just tends to cause more whining. Someone who waits until the last second to do something is not going to do any better if given a tiny bit more time (nevermind the question of how much more?), and in any case procrastination is not a habit we want to encourage.
- defen 7y agoHow about having the student’s score decay as some function of how late they turn it in? If they turn it in before the deadline, they get 100% of their marked grade, if it’s an hour late 90%, a day late 50%, etc (use whatever function you want)
- knzhou 7y agoUsually, delays lead to logistical difficulties. Until every copy of an assignment is submitted, you can't release solutions, assign grades, talk about the problems in lectures or recitations, or really give any feedback whatsoever. I've had excellent courses that ran on your system, but in those cases they had it completely standardized from year to year, and even automated grading systems.
- Dylan16807 7y agoIf you're just trying to solve the bad feelings caused by a really hard deadline, you could do something as simple as "due at midnight, 80% credit from midnight to 6am". Then everyone's still done by class.
- lonelappde 7y agoThis issue only comes up if you have a low caliber class where homework is nontrivial part of the grade.
- knzhou 7y agoMy graduate classes were 100% homework-based almost without exception. When you're doing hard enough physics, it doesn't make sense to demand people do anything nontrivial in an hour, like in a typical exam. Real problems take at least whole days of thought.
- sudosteph 7y agoMy professor for Assembly did exactly that and it felt very fair. However, I think that was only possible because every assignment used an automated grading program, so we could weigh the risk vs reward when deciding if we should spend another day optimizing the code. If an actual person was burdened with grading each assignment, it makes sense to have a harder cutoff that ensures it's possible to grade in a batch for efficiency.
- seditiousseals 7y agoOne of my professors at UCLA has a very lenient policy - you lose 2^(n-1) points, where n is the number of days after the deadline you've submitted. This meant that turning in your assignment one or two days late was no big deal, but turning it in four or five days late would be pretty bad.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoAt my u iversity your grade would decay by 5% a day, if I recall correctly.
- smichel17 7y agoMy university cs department (most of them, anyway) used a system I liked very much: - Due dates are hard (usually midnight) - Everyone gets 3 "emergency tokens", which give you a 24 hour extension on the assignment, no questions asked. Max 2 per assignment. - On occasion, you could get an extension without using a token by speaking to the professor in advance, if you had extenuating circumstances. It was a good compromise between meaningful deadlines and humanity. One particular advantage is that, if you missed the midnight deadline, you knew you were using a town anyway, so there was no pressure to sacrifice sleep to get the assignment in "on time". Most people I knew were happy with it.
- xvector 7y agoEmergency tokens were a lifesaver for many of my college classes. They gave me the freedom I needed to make micro-adjustments to my college/life balance and greatly lowered stress.
- asdff 7y agoIn undergrad most of my profs followed an even simpler system: if you get locked out just email the paper when you can with an explanation. Most professors are pretty accommodating, as sometimes your dog really does eat your homework.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI had one professor in college who went hard in the other direction—she told the class "I don't care if you turn in assignments late", and gave no limit on how late you could be. As a student, it was, well, nice. It was true that it was a bit harder to be motivated to finish a paper right away, but it also made the process far less stressful. When I turned in papers I thought they were the best they could be. Of course, I'm sure there were at least some students in her classes who ignored everything until the end of the term or something, and were quite stressed out at the end...
- bsder 7y ago> I had one professor in college who went hard in the other direction—she told the class "I don't care if you turn in assignments late", and gave no limit on how late you could be. This doesn't work if your class builds on earlier material (most STEM classes). As the professor, I need some feedback as to how well the class understands what I just taught.
- mod50ack 7y agoIt's possible but not in large lecture courses. I took a class with <15 people and our prof was so kind as to essentially let us get in our proofs whenever (which was an absolute lifesaver). But at that scale you of course can tell whether or not people are understanding without the assignments (since everyone is proving things together in class!)
- asdff 7y agoDepends on the stem classes. Most of mine charged ahead with the new material even if the last exam average was 52%, in fact that might be considered a very good exam average.
- godelski 7y agoStudents are going to complain regardless. I had soft deadlines when I graded. Assignments were due at midnight but I told them as long as it was in by the time I pulled their repos (I'd do it first thing in the morning) I wouldn't dock them. A few times I had students complain. I clearly told them that I was already giving them leniency and if they want to attempt to take advantage of my niceness that I'd remove it for everyone. Those students only tried once and it didn't happen often. Students need to learn personal responsibility or they won't have them by the time they enter the work place or grad school. Also if you don't show them humanity then they won't learn this and we slowly lose it in our society. Though I ended up with weird reviews. I got just as many students saying I was their best teacher as those saying worst teacher. I also had a surprising number of students try to turn into me the skeleton code I provided them claiming they did the assignment (they'd add like a line or two). Also had students say I was unavailable even though I lived in my office with my door open (students frequently came by outside office hours) and replied to emails between 9am and 1am. Learned that the complaints don't always match what you're doing and are hard to interpret. Tldr: students will complain no matter what. Just be human. It's easier and less stressful for everyone involved.
- bsder 7y ago> I've been an instructor for CS courses before so I know what you mean. I never made deadlines anything but absolutely final As a CS professor, the one thing I could do that flipped things on their head was running an automatic submission and testing system for any assignment. You're getting 0% or 100%, but you know at all times over roughly 2 weeks exactly what score you are getting. You can resubmit over and over. Yes, I'm going to run extra tests once the deadline passes to make sure no one is punking me, but it's rare that someone who gets 100% on the initial tests doesn't get 100% on the later tests. And, for those of you who think that 0%/100% is a poor programming assignment scoring system--I'll ask you the same question I ask my students: "0%/100% is bad? So which of you are cool with partial credit when I miscalculate your grades?"