9 ms·
Grumpy Website – a blog about everything wrong with modern web & tech
- ubicomp 7y agoWonderful website! Can’t wait to regularly follow this.
- andrepd 7y agoThat was my first thought. My second thought is this can't be good for my blood pressure.
- RandomInteger4 7y agoI like the copyright pun at the bottom.
- klez 7y agoYeah, I'd love to read it, but (on mobile, at least) there's infinite scrolling kicking in every time I reach the bottom. Ironic.
- freetonik 7y agoThat’s the internal joke of ours nobody appreciates.
- klez 7y agoI thought so. You may want to make it more explicit :)
- freetonik 7y agoIt being this obscure is part of the joke by now ;-)
- kugelblitz 7y agoAh, ok, wasn't obvious to me, either. I always wonder, if it's legal in Germany, because you need to have an imprint easily accessible (from any page I think). Might not be relevant for here, but am just curious.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BjoernKW 7y agoI can’t see it because of infinite scrolling, which is pretty ironic given the website’s subject.
- freetonik 7y agoSimply click the “refresh” button in the header to easily access the footer.
- fenomas 7y agoIt shows up on individual post pages (click "hyperlink").
- mistersquid 7y agoIn your web inspector, add the following CSS to the <body> display: flex; flex-direction: column-reverse; and that will render the footer at the top of the page.
- skinkestek 7y agoFor the lazy ones: > 2019. All fights retarded.
- generationP 7y agoYour fucking site has an infinite fucking scroll that requires javascript and fails silently if it's fucking disabled.
- klez 7y agoPlease, stay classy.
- nsenifty 7y agohttps://grumpy.website/post/0SzBFLZy9 https://grumpy.website/post/0SzBFLZy9 Not being able to open all drawers at once is actually a safety feature preventing it from tipping over (see Ikea MALM fiasco). I suppose the UX could still be better.
- jacquesm 7y agohttps://www.ikea.com/us/en/customer-service/product-support/recalls/following-an-additional-child-fatality-ikea-recalls-29-million-malm-and-other-models-of-chests-pub4128a7af https://www.ikea.com/us/en/customer-service/product-support/...
- toomim 7y agoIt's an anti-lawsuit feature. The bug here is in the government allowing people to sue drawer makers for overloading them and tipping them over.
- freetonik 7y agoTitle edit suggestion: the authors often cover non-web related technology, and even everyday objects like microwave ovens or furniture.
- Nextgrid 7y agoDone!
- skinkestek 7y agohttps://grumpy.website/post/0Sqvx1C9H https://grumpy.website/post/0Sqvx1C9H > Five other people are reading this doc, right? Wrong! The user with a white avatar is actually a button to start a chat! Why does it look like a user and is placed where all other users are, we’ll never know. > But wait, isn’t there a chat button next to Share? No, that’s comments! What’s the difference? Comments are square, while chat bubbles are oval! > Also, if you ever wanted to check how your stocks are doing, there’s a button for that too. Nice :-)
- coldcode 7y agoIt's Don Norman meets the Muppets! Actually I really appreciate someone collecting collective stupidity in one place. I am constantly frustrated by terrible design and product decisions every day (both at work and in general) that I can't do anything about. Maybe shame will work.
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoIt's just free advertising. After the public is sold on the fact that a certain NEW! feature represents a fix to the thing everyone hates, the manufacturers will have already embedded something new that will keep you idiots buying the next NEW! thing forever. You're all sheep.
- Nextgrid 7y agoThe problem is that I'm not sure it's stupidity. I bet a lot of this BS is caused by "data driven" decisions that maybe improve ad engagement by 0.1% at the expense of everyone else's productivity, but the company considers the 0.1% increase a win. What makes me sad is that it seems like us who appreciate & demand good quality, no-nonsense software seem to be a minority, and the masses don't seem to care. I've noticed most non-tech people just accept their fate, either they've already came to terms with the idea that "tech sucks and will always suck", or they legitimately don't know how the experience can be improved (a lot of things may look absurd to us as developers, but might not to someone not familiar with how those things are built) or that they think software is delivered by gods or equivalent superior entities and that they, the "peasants" have no way to call for change even though voicing discontent in feedback sometimes works and is at least worth a try.
- ratww 7y agoI agree with everything, except with the part that tech people appreciate and demand non-nonsense software. A lot of people in tech enjoy being the "ultimate power user" and are proud of using things that look or feel complicated. You just have to look at HN itself to read trough rationalisations of why software is bloated and why bigger software is probably better. It's never driven by data or by facts, it's purely by anecdotal experience.
- freetonik 7y agoThere’s also a relatively new sister project https://annoying.technology/ https://annoying.technology/
- wodenokoto 7y agoThe "doesn't add up to 6.5gb" is because storage is shared with other services and doesn't pertain to just Google Drive. I agree with Google, that it is more important to show how much overall storage you have left, than how much is being used in this particular service, but there needs to be an overview that can show where storage is used. And clicking around on Google Drive it appears there isn't such an overview. So yes, bad UI, but for different reason than what grumpy website says.
- dwild 7y ago> there needs to be an overview that can show where storage is used. And clicking around on Google Drive it appears there isn't such an overview. If you click on Buy Storage, it does say where it's used. Not the most obvious, but good enough.
- scrollaway 7y agoHonestly Gmail storage should show up as an entry when you look at drive storage stats given that it's shared. They do that elsewhere in the account iirc.
- loopz 7y agoIf the fix is relatively easy, the UI is probably bad. A good UI could show "Other services x.y GB", but didn't. Good UX/UI should provide intuition to the user, especially in more complex circumstances.
- datashow 7y agoI checked this issue before. One of the explanations was that Google Drive also counts history in the space. Not sure whether this is still true.
- gcmrtc 7y agoIf you open more than one draw at a time you would unbalance the drawer and it would tip over, falling on you and possibly injuring your feet and damaging your stuff and the floor. This safety mechanism is not there if the drawer is embedded in a larger frame where tipping over is not possible. Sometimes it's not bad UX, it's just the thing trying to protect you from your stupidity.
- arkades 7y agoThat was the first thing to jump out at me, too. I love crotchety blogs ranting about (whatever screwups), but this one takes a serious credibility hit right off the bat. Ranting about something you don’t understand and being blatantly wrong about it isn’t a great look.
- minot 7y ago> That was the first thing to jump out at me, too. I love crotchety blogs ranting about (whatever screwups), but this one takes a serious credibility hit right off the bat. Ranting about something you don’t understand and being blatantly wrong about it isn’t a great look. Cunningham's Law states "the best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to ask a question; it's to post the wrong answer."
- dspillett 7y agoI thought that was to say "X can't do Y but Z can so X is stupid". You will then get a list of solutions from fans of X. The most common sighting of this in action is OSs (ask "how do I do Y with Linux" and you'll be pointed at documentation, say "Linux can't do Y but Windows can" and you are more likely to get a couple of pre-baked solutions sent your way, and the same works the other way around and with other OSs) but I've seen it work for scripting languages/environments (powershell, bash, ...), databases (postgres, SQL Server, Oracle, ...) and other tools.
- ksec 7y ago>Cunningham's Law states "the best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to ask a question; it's to post the wrong answer." I am amazed there is a law describe this. This is so accurate. I couldn't be bothered to answer questions even if I knew the answer, but I would be bothered to correct it if the answer were wrong.
- fenomas 7y agoMy all-time anti-favorite UI thing like this is Mac dialogs where two different buttons are focused. E.g. when closing a file with unsaved edits, you typically get a dialog with three buttons: [Don't save] Cancel [Save] "Don't save" and "Save" are both highlighted, but in two different ways - and for added excitement, spacebar activates one of them and Enter activates the other. Feeling lucky?
- rado 7y agoFully highlighted button responds to Enter, the most powerful action. The button with a border only is associated with the secondary action, space bar. Makes perfect sense.
- dredmorbius 7y agoRegarding "intuitive": https://invidio.us/watch?v=updE5LVe6tg https://invidio.us/watch?v=updE5LVe6tg (Ellen's Millennial challenge.)
- bsaul 7y agoi’m not sure if you’re being sarcastic or if we just don’t live on the same planet :))
- falcolas 7y agoSeems like a useful feature with terrible discoverability and a lack of intuitiveness. Don Norman would not approve. ;)
- saagarjha 7y agoIt’s off by default, presumably because it takes a bit of effort to use effectively and is thus only useful to power users and those who need it for accessibility reasons.
- bathtub365 7y agoIt makes sense because you’re already familiar with the platform convention. It’s not intuitive. Space bar is a larger key and easier to reach, why isn’t it associated with the more “powerful” action?
- hackermailman 7y agoMy new favorite default behavior annoyance was FF for Android deciding that everytime I clicked an open tab after some short time interval, it would reload the entire page making it extra annoying when you have the massive HN who is hiring thread open and want to scroll through it while on a subway with no connection.
- slig 7y agoMobile OS periodically have to reclaim allocated memory and this happens.
- redmattred 7y agoGet off my lawn!
- webreac 7y agoWhat are these "Hyperlink" that links to a page that do not contain anything more to read. This makes me grumpy ;-)
- ratww 7y agoThey're permalinks so you can share the posts with friends and family :)
- Nextgrid 7y agoThat is unacceptable, URLs and copy/paste are unnecessarily complicated. Better make those social media sharing buttons instead. ;)
- lou_chenyao 7y agoYou cannot add the share buttons for all sites people happened to gonna share with.
- wizzwizz4 7y agoBonus points if you're inlining socmed-hosted images, then using socmed-hosted JavaScript to make those images dynamic.
- dmitriid 7y agoPro tips: - on a phone, long press on that hyperlink. Bingo, you've got your sharing screen to the post - on a PC: right-click, copy. Bingo, you've got your shareable link to the post (Yes, I realise your post is /s :) )
- Nextgrid 7y agoBut long-press and right click are too complicated! /s
- dqv 7y agoI've got one. Sometimes when you start typing on Google, the keyboard drops in the middle of typing causing you to tap a link where the key had been. https://imgur.com/a/v1CGba5 https://imgur.com/a/v1CGba5
- cdoxsey 7y agoThis issue happens in so many places. About to press a button on a page and suddenly something loads up top and the page shifts 50px.
- lordnacho 7y agoAlso when you try to dismiss a notification on the phone, and just as you're doing it a new one appears and you end up dismissing that instead. Boom! Now you don't know what it was. This is on Android BTW, not sure how iOS does it. But instead of the newest notification appearing at the top of the list, maybe it should appear at the bottom. Problem solved.
- RivieraKid 7y agoYeah, I hate this one. A similar issue is in Twitter for Android, I search for an account, want to click on an item and then the list updates. I can't believe this is not fixed yet.
- ensiferum 7y agoHehe at our new office in the kitchen there's a cupboard above the sink so that any person going to the sink will not be able to see what they're doing cause the cupboard is in the way unless you double yourself over so that you can stick your head under the cupboard or are a maximum of 140çm tall. Maybe the design was done by a person who has 2m long arms so that he/she can operate the sink from afar and thus avoid this problem.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kugelblitz 7y agoWhen trying to find more about the website on mobile, I scroll down and I only see a few links at the bottom, but within less than a second new content loads and the links are gone, I will probably need to load all the content before being able to see the credits / about links. That's grumpy-worthy I find ;-).
- LannisterDebt 7y agoloader_status = "die grumpy worthy feature!"; Enter this into console. Happy Holidays.
- synt4x1k0 7y ago[Nikita Prokopov](https://twitter.com/nikitonsky https://twitter.com/nikitonsky), [Rakhim Davletkaliyev](https://twitter.com/freetonik https://twitter.com/freetonik), [Ivan Grishaev](https://grishaev.me/ https://grishaev.me/), [Dmitrii Dimandt](https://twitter.com/dmitriid https://twitter.com/dmitriid), [Andrei Voronin](https://twitter.com/UlyanovskUI https://twitter.com/UlyanovskUI). 2019\. All fights retarded.
- dzamie 7y agoI have JS default to off (saves big on load times, bypasses some "please buy a subscription" things), and thought this was just a weirdly short list of eccentric things until I saw this comment. So, add "JS is required for crucial, rather than merely useful, features."
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIn the spiwit (just watched Life of Brian) of grumpy Christmas, what's with a grumpy single page, lazy loading blog? Paginate the thing. Happy holidays.
- tonsky 7y agoI would, happily, if you could explain me why?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vorticalbox 7y agoTo the Google drive one that storage also includes Gmail and some other Google services too.
- dsego 7y agoThe biggest problem with modern tech for me is that it almost never works as advertised. A lot of times it's just there to tick a box on the marketing material. The most recent example, got myself a new Fuji camera and it has bluetooth and wireless and a smartphone app and theoretically you can transfer your pictures wirelessly (but not over a physical usb cable). I'd rather it didn't have these features, because it's not reliable, sometimes it won't work at all, other times it takes too long to connect, it's a mess and I have no time in my life to deal with this crap anymore.
- da02 7y agoI totally agree. For file transfer on my Fuji camera, I just take out the SD card and grab the files on a SD card reader (+ usb-c adapter) on my phone. (The Fuji wireless app won't let me transfer regular JPEGs or RAW files. Only compressed JPEGS less than 1MB large even though the original JPEGs are ~2.5 MB big.)
- AtlasBarfed 7y agoThe biggest problem with tech is that the "smartphone app" is basically immediately on a (usually steep) decay curve of support. Usually with no basic protocol backup, such as a basic web api, cli, or filesystem interface. Of course that's a feature for hardware manufacturers. No one wants a device used for decades, even though that's exactly the level of support necessary to make IoT successful in consumerland. That apple intentionally breaks things that aren't broken / forces upgrades within its walled garden is even more despicable
- ekns 7y agoHm I was doing something similar, but in the end there was just too much stuff that's broken, all the time: https://twitter.com/everythingisbr2 https://twitter.com/everythingisbr2 In the same vein, I've been thinking of having some universal bug/annoyance reporting tool where you'd tag each annoyance with the software/hardware/website and optionally its version.
- Too 7y agoAssuming you collected those yourself and events happening close to upload. If you have such a high amount of breakages, it means an average user is experiencing several breakages per day. Comparing with my own anecdotal experience I'm not surprised but seeing it all in one place just makes one depressed.
- bagswatchesus 7y agoA lot of things may look absurd to us as developers, but might not to someone not familiar with how those things are built. https://www.bragmyshoes.com/mules-and-slides/christian-dior.html https://www.bragmyshoes.com/mules-and-slides/christian-dior....
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hotz 7y ago`user-select: none` - From MDN docs: CSS property controls whether the user can select text. When the developer uses that on the body tag...
- jborichevskiy 7y agoThis site makes me happy because it reminds me that other people are just as frustrated with stupid UI decisions everywhere. And that most apps are actually terrible by default. Including ones I've built. UX is hard.
- AtlasBarfed 7y agoUX is hard, but adding fashionable trends to UX just to arbitrarily kill off perfectly functioning and well-established interface paradigms really makes things hard. The UX crowd embraces this for the same reason hardware people don't support their software long-term.... it keeps people buying their services at a higher premium.
- prox 7y agoIf you enjoyed that there is https://thedailywtf.com/series/errord https://thedailywtf.com/series/errord Stupid UX / programming decisions documented since 2004
- jborichevskiy 7y agoGreat recommendation - I’ve definitely enjoyed seeing their posts pop up over the years!
- 1ark 7y agoAre they making their own decisions based on those documentation efforts? Scrolls to bottom of page, no prev/next buttons. Scrolls to top, "ah, there they are!" :(
- OrgNet 7y agothose are mostly minor annoyances that can be avoided by switching to a different product... What is wrong with tech is that proper regulations to protect customers have mainly not been written yet or are outdated (mainly for privacy issues). Why don't you suggest alternate products that don't have these problems?
- briandear 7y agoA drawer system is a victim of inadequate regulations?
- OrgNet 7y agono, we are victims of how Google and other companies are allowed to design their systems because the regulations are nonexistent or outdated.... forget about the drawer this is just stupid to think that it is a big problem.
- briandear 7y agoClaiming Reminders can be written in 600 lines of Ruby is pretty ignorant. That reminds me of those posts that claim they could have written <some famous app> in a single weekend. Reminders is far more powerful than a school Todo app programming assignment.
- softwaredoug 7y agoThe git status issue he lists (that it will say it’s up to date with origin/master) is really confusing to folks. Hard to wrap your head that your local “pointer” to that branch is potentially not up to date. Well that really it’s an out of date copy of a remote pointer, known as a reference... That when you “fetch” it’s really updating local copies of remote references. In a world of devs that has to wrap their head around pointers or references, having copies of references, in a distributed system, doesn’t exactly come naturally to most, especially new, developers. This is pretty bad for what should be baseline dev tooling. It’s like having to learn regular expressions just to be able to edit your first hello world program! That being said, git is complex, and trying to idiot proof a complex system with more abstractions only makes it more confusing when the abstraction leaks (which it will)...
- gmueckl 7y agoAbstractions only leak if the system design doesn't match the abstractions properly. Other tools like Mercurial do a better (but not perfect) job because they get more right than git does.
- stevep98 7y agoThis reminds me of the classic ‘this is broken’, which has now been moved to: http://goodexperience.com/tib/ http://goodexperience.com/tib/ Some real gems in there.
- FartyMcFarter 7y agoIf you're paying attention and not too desensitized, you can usually find at least one software bug per day (often a new one).
- jtms 7y agoThe one about complaining about git status “Your branch is up to date with origin/master” Not hitting the network just belies a complete misunderstanding of both the message and distributed versioning systems in general. This message is telling you that your branch is up to date with your LOCAL tracking branch and is absolutely accurate and helpful in this regard. If you fetch and pull new diffs then it will tell you a different story. I wish people would stop complaining about git and just read the very easy to understand git book https://git-scm.com/book/en/v2 https://git-scm.com/book/en/v2 Learn your tools people!
- duckerude 7y agoIf the naively obvious meaning of a message doesn't match the actual meaning of the message then that's a usability issue, even if it's technically correct.
- toomim 7y agoThe point is that this behavior is confusing, not that the behavior isn't written down somewhere in some documentation.
- jtms 7y agoMy point is the message is not at all confusing if have a fundamental understating of a distributed system as opposed to a centralized one. Just because most people want to use git just like you would have with SVN doesn’t mean it isn’t a completely different architecture that is (admittedly) a bit difficult to grok, but far more flexible and powerful
- iamaelephant 7y agoIt is confusing, as evidenced by people frequently being confused by it.
- jtms 7y agoLearn. Your. Tools.
- tzs 7y agoA Chrome UI idiocy: The new tab page in Chrome contains a text entry field that says to search Google or type a URL. But as soon as you start to type in it, it switches the focus to the URL bar. Why the heck do they put in the text field if they aren't going to let you use it!? On a desktop that is mildly annoying. On a Windows tablet it is extremely annoying, because the onscreen keyboard closes when the focus leaves the text entry field. For Chrome startup you can fix this by changing the startup page from the new tab page to a specific URL, and simply give the URL for the Google front page as that specific URL. But Chrome doesn't seem to have a way to set the new tab page itself to start at a specific URL (without installing a third party extension) so you still have this focus changing idiocy on subsequent tabs. A further Chrome annoyance on Windows tablets: if you tap the address bar to bring up the virtual keyboard and then try to paste something by typing CTRL and then V (CTRL on the virtual keyboard acts as a one-shot CTRL lock, so you can invoke control keys with one finger), Chrome somehow loses the CTRL part, and you get a "V" in the address bar. If you then backspace, and try CTRL V again it works.
- eyegor 7y agoI noticed that this site is missing the modern classic "giant modal covering the entire screen". Usually reserved for "log in pls", "subscribe to site/mailing list", etc. And then sometimes the modal doesn't render correctly and instead I just see the whole screen go white/gray. News sites, reddit, twitter, facebook, and tons of blogs are guilty of this.