3 ms·
Do people really need Ghee specifically? Or do people need "clarified butter" If you just want "butter that doesn't burn", here's what I do. 1. Melt butter in
by dragontamer 7y ago
Do people really need Ghee specifically? Or do people need "clarified butter"
If you just want "butter that doesn't burn", here's what I do.
1. Melt butter in a pot. This separates butter into its three fundamental parts: solids (floating at the top), oil (in the middle), and water.
2. Heat until all the water at the bottom vaporizes.
3. Pour remaining mixture through a coffee filter. This removes the solids (which easily burn).
Milk Solids burn at 350F, making raw butter unsuitable for frying. The goal of clarified butter (and Ghee is a type of clarified butter), is to raise the smoke-point to roughly 450F (roughly equivalent to canola oil).
Normal butter will burn before the mallard reaction (Mallard is roughly 400F). But clarified butter burns AFTER the mallard reaction. The mallard reaction is what makes the slightly-sweet nicely cooked meat taste.
Similar reactions occur in vegetables, meats, breads, etc. etc. So its very important to use oils which burn at higher temperatures (450F+: Clarified Butter, Canola Oil, Soy Oil, Peanut Oil).
Some fats, such as normal-butter, bacon fat, or olive oil burn at 350F. So you end up with a "burnt" taste from the burning fat before the mallard reaction even takes place.
--------
Ghee is a particular "cooked butter" taste. Its a bit more difficult to make (and more expensive than) simple clarified butter.
If you're sauteing, frying, or whatever with butter, its important to know how to clarify it. Or I guess use Ghee (but that's more expensive / time consuming).
- kop316 7y agoTo be honest, I didn't know there was a difference. I was more looking for a substitute for shortening, which I think clarified butter can do? Or just ghee?
- dragontamer 7y agoAll fats can substitute for each other depending on recipe. It will taste different but it's really fun to replace fats with other fats. Ex, bacon grease works in more recipes than you'd expect. Just memorize their smoke points, the point where a fat begins to burn. Shortening has a very high smoke point, but that is only relevant if you expect the temperature to go above 400F, such as the mallard reaction (aka the taste of fried / saute food). You'll learn pretty quick when a fat burns quickly. Olive oil and bacon grease burn at really low temperatures and will create a thick cloud of smoke as it burns. Look up the smoke points of fats if you are worried. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:Smoke_point_of_cooking_oils https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:Smoke_point_of_cookin...
- ericd 7y agoReally interesting, thanks for the brain dump! What do you look for to know when your pan is preheated enough to eg sear meat well if you don't wait for a little smoke?
- dragontamer 7y agoI do actually wait for a little smoke. It's a very consistent measurement of pan temperature. If I choose a 450F smoke point fat, like canola oil, I know that the pan is 450F when it starts to smoke. I got the reaction wrong earlier, mallard is 300F or so. Caramelization is 400F
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoClose- wikipedia says 280°F to 330°F - see my comment above. But in that case, like I say in my longer comment, it doesn't make sense for olive oil to catch fire "easily", like you say in your previous comment. What olive oil are you using, if I'm not being too nosey? Sorry if I sound defensive- I'm just really surprised. olive oil is very common where I come from :)
- dragontamer 7y agoWell, certainly not "catch on fire". Just emitting enough smoke to maybe set off a smoke alarm (but otherwise not really harmful in my experience). Light smoking is fine (and is good for gauging temperature), but heavy smoke will have a burnt taste and is an indicator that you were "cooking too hot". I don't cook with olive oil too often, so I can't say I remember the brand. I looked a few things up, and it seems like different olive-oils have different smoke points. https://www.jonbarron.org/diet-and-nutrition/healthiest-cooking-oil-chart-smoke-points https://www.jonbarron.org/diet-and-nutrition/healthiest-cook... According to this, some olive oil has a smoke point of 320F / 160C, but other olive-oils can have a smoke point as high as 468F. I don't know why olive oil has such a different range. I guess I'll experiment with olive oil more. It is quite possible that olive oil here in the USA is of lower-quality perhaps?