3 ms·
> the real solution (assuming that you see it as a problem) to overbearing and entrenched government power will probably be self-sustaining space colonies Why
by lisper 7y ago
> the real solution (assuming that you see it as a problem) to overbearing and entrenched government power will probably be self-sustaining space colonies
Why in the world would you think that the politics of self-sustaining space colonies would not devolve into the exact same (dys)functional states (pun intended) as politics here on earth?
- keiferski 7y agoForms of government have varied depending on time, place, access to technology, population, cultural history, and innumerable other factors. Of course self-sustaining space states will have novel forms.
- bpodgursky 7y agoDynamicism and innovation has always come from the frontier. There's a lot of space out there -- the frontier never closes (well, a speed-bump once we fill up the solar system). So of course individual colonies eventually will fill up, stagnate, and calcify. But we won't run out of land, the way we have on earth, where there's no room for new ideas -- because every useful square foot of land is claimed by a nation-state with guns and rigid ideologies.
- big_chungus 7y agoSome will, some won't. Just like on earth, new forms of government will evolve. What we _do_ know from our historical past is that small communities can do much better at self-government in most cases. It's always harder to screw over your neighbor than a random guy from the other side of the nation, and easier for the neighbor to get redress. More importantly, I don't think the possibility of a bad outcome ought to halt the progress of mankind in perpetuity. Interesting thought: many suspect nations with frontiers flourish due to having an "escape valve". I am curious to see what an unlimited escape valve will enable.
- mulmen 7y ago> Interesting thought: many suspect nations with frontiers flourish due to having an "escape valve". I am curious to see what an unlimited escape valve will enable. Can you expand on this? I think I understand the general implication but it’s not something I have considered before. If you have more thoughts/writing on this I’d like to ingest it. If I understand correctly the idea is “undesirables” can go to a place where they are free to explore their ideas.
- big_chungus 7y agoSure. The basic idea is that there are always people who just "don't fit in" to society at large. Those people can stay and cause trouble, can be imprisoned, or can go through the safety valve to go live where they won't harm others. It also gives people opportunity for advancement; think of the many stories of families going west to find a better life. It allows societies to preserve a degree of individualism and a shared goal of expanding into the great un-known. I'm dipping my toes into deeper sociological waters here than I'm entirely comfortable with, but there's a broader concept of a "safety-valve institution" that can be viewed as positively helping maintain order or negatively keeping oppressed masses from rising up (the class warfare folks start beating there drums around here). Some more interesting reading: * http://www.ditext.com/shannon/shannon.html http://www.ditext.com/shannon/shannon.html * http://www.ditext.com/robbins/robbins.html http://www.ditext.com/robbins/robbins.html * https://sci-hub.tw/10.2307/2716011 https://sci-hub.tw/10.2307/2716011 The obvious issue is that the treatment of Indians was unethical in the case of America, but space exploration might allow us to get many of these benefits of historical colonialism without genocide. I'll admit that I'm biased favorably towards this idea, as the frontier could, in some cases, be much closer to a libertarian utopia than a more heavily-organized society, but the up-side is that it provides options for those who want more and less state control.
- Matticus_Rex 7y agoIf you look at how path-dependent most countries' forms of governance have been, it's reasonable to assume we'll see something that's at least substantially different.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoIt's ironic that it's easier for HNers to imagine a future of utopian space colonies than it is to imagine wealth being taxed.
- yongjik 7y agoForget self-sustaining space colonies, we don't even know how to build Earth-dependent space colonies. Because there's no plausible way we can build one in near/medium future, we aren't constrained by pesky reality, so we can let our imaginations run wild and claim that it will solve the problem of government power and save mankind. And probably also cure cancer. It's the same pattern as how some startups avoid making money at all cost, so that their valuation can be detached from market reality.