3 ms·
I've lately been reading about the notion of "managerialism". The book Confronting Managerialism defines it as "What occurs when a special group, called managem
by wpietri 7y ago
I've lately been reading about the notion of "managerialism". The book Confronting Managerialism defines it as "What occurs when a special group, called management, ensconces itself systemically in an organization and deprives owners and employees of their decision-making power (including distribution of emoluments) and justifies that takeover on the grounds of the managing group's education and exclusive possession of the codified bodies of knowledge and know-how necessary to the efficient running of the organization."
It's a really interesting concept to me, because it's been the dominant business culture my whole life in the US, so it's sort of like a fish discovering water. But once I started looking at business philosophy and history, I realized that there are a lot of other ways to do things. Toyota's example, of course: the managerialism of the big 3 let Toyota go from Japan's post-war decimation to the biggest carmaker on the planet.
I still don't feel like I have a great grip on the alternatives, and especially how to practice those alternatives when managerialism is the norm. But I definitely aim to find out. At least once, I want work at a place that really has its shit together. That gets things done well on purpose.
- api 7y agoAn interesting thing about managetialism is that it's basically what made the USSR fail. The MBA is our exact equivalent of the Soviet "apparatchik." We postured ourselves as the opposite of the USSR but in reality US business culture aped a lot of its bureaucratic structure. I've called it Soviet capitalism for some time now.
- ibeckermayer 7y agoThe author of this article (friend of mine) noticed the same point. See footnote 1: https://reasonandliberty.com/articles/obamacare https://reasonandliberty.com/articles/obamacare
- LaserToy 7y agoSo, I’m not the only person who sees the similarity. I was born in USSR and later moved to USA. Some (many) approaches to management in some very famous and rich companies constantly remind me of Soviet’s approach to management. It does not mean it is bad, but USSR fell apart...
- ljw1001 7y agoI think the problem is both broader and simpler. There's an economic term for it, but i don't recall what it is. Basically, the whole of capitalism depends on the idea that individual incentives (for employees) can be aligned with organizational goals. Often, however, employees realize they can make more money by putting their efforts into getting a bigger slice of the pie instead of working to make the pie bigger. This is always true to some degree, and especially true for big, rich companies with low growth rates. Outside of the economic theory, I suspect that people who make to the executive level are most likely to have engaged in this kind of behavior, since getting promoted is one of the best ways to get a bigger slice.
- einpoklum 7y ago> the whole of capitalism depends on the idea that individual incentives (for employees) can be aligned with organizational goals And here I was thinking it relied on the capital-owners having the state use its centralized coercive power (like the police and the military) to enforce the capital-owners' property rights. Silly me.
- cagenut 7y ago> At least once, I want work at a place that really has its shit together. I'm old enough now that I just skip directly to wishing for powerball numbers.