6 ms·
Obviously it's sci-fi scenario, but the real solution (assuming that you see it as a problem) to overbearing and entrenched government power will probably be se
by keiferski 7y ago
Obviously it's sci-fi scenario, but the real solution (assuming that you see it as a problem) to overbearing and entrenched government power will probably be self-sustaining space colonies.
Experimental governments on Earth are limited by the fact that [large state power] can invade you in a matter of hours for arbitrary reasons, no matter where you on are the planet. Fly off into the deep cosmos, though, and your chances of survival dramatically increase.
- ouid 7y agoI thought the key to sovereignty was mutually assured destruction. You don't need a deep space ship, you just need an ICBM.
- keiferski 7y agoThat is true as well, but acquiring an ICBM seems rather difficult and once you have one, everyone else tends to treat you as a pariah. If I were building a libertarian paradise, I'd probably opt to avoid the whole issue and just leave the solar system.
- alonmower 7y agoI think if you struggle to get an ICBM you're going to have a hard time getting off of the planet let alone out of the solar system
- mandevil 7y agoI can't see how libertarians would actually work in a space colony situation. Leaving aside how self-sustaining a space colony could ever truly be (Charlie Stross has written a lot about that), in a world as fragile as a space colony would be, I see fascism as vastly more likely than libertarian. If literally anyone can push the a button and kill a substantial percentage of the colony, you have substantially more risk from mental health issues, angry people, etc. than you do here on earth. And that leads to repression and using force to assert control.
- nickik 7y agoEven as a libertarian I would argue that libertarianism will not be the guiding principle of space exploration for a long time to come.
- shadofx 7y agoThe trick is to never have more than one human per ship. We would "wear" our space vehicles like an extension of our bodies, in the same way we consider clothing today.
- lisper 7y ago> the real solution (assuming that you see it as a problem) to overbearing and entrenched government power will probably be self-sustaining space colonies Why in the world would you think that the politics of self-sustaining space colonies would not devolve into the exact same (dys)functional states (pun intended) as politics here on earth?
- keiferski 7y agoForms of government have varied depending on time, place, access to technology, population, cultural history, and innumerable other factors. Of course self-sustaining space states will have novel forms.
- bpodgursky 7y agoDynamicism and innovation has always come from the frontier. There's a lot of space out there -- the frontier never closes (well, a speed-bump once we fill up the solar system). So of course individual colonies eventually will fill up, stagnate, and calcify. But we won't run out of land, the way we have on earth, where there's no room for new ideas -- because every useful square foot of land is claimed by a nation-state with guns and rigid ideologies.
- big_chungus 7y agoSome will, some won't. Just like on earth, new forms of government will evolve. What we _do_ know from our historical past is that small communities can do much better at self-government in most cases. It's always harder to screw over your neighbor than a random guy from the other side of the nation, and easier for the neighbor to get redress. More importantly, I don't think the possibility of a bad outcome ought to halt the progress of mankind in perpetuity. Interesting thought: many suspect nations with frontiers flourish due to having an "escape valve". I am curious to see what an unlimited escape valve will enable.
- mulmen 7y ago> Interesting thought: many suspect nations with frontiers flourish due to having an "escape valve". I am curious to see what an unlimited escape valve will enable. Can you expand on this? I think I understand the general implication but it’s not something I have considered before. If you have more thoughts/writing on this I’d like to ingest it. If I understand correctly the idea is “undesirables” can go to a place where they are free to explore their ideas.
- shipman05 7y agoThis future is dystopian (and likely). Sure, there might be a few libertarian or communitarian utopias out there, or maybe even a few safe haven colonies where persecuted groups or sects can live without fear of persecution. But there will also be colonies that are absolute hell for their inhabitants: institutionalized chattel slavery, legalized pedophilia, animal torture, all manner of non-consensual sexual deviancy. Just imagine if guys like Jeffrey Epstein could scurry off to their own solar system and build an entire society based on their wants and desires, far from the reach of international justice.
- walrus01 7y ago"`Freeside,' Armitage said, touching the panel on the little Braun hologram projector. The image shivered into focus, nearly three meters from tip to tip. `Casinos here.' He reached into the skeletal representation and pointed. `Hotels, strata-title property, big shops along here.' His hand moved. `Blue areas are lakes.' He walked to one end of the model. `Big cigar. Narrows at the ends.' `We can see that fine,' Molly said. `Mountain effect, as it narrows. Ground seems to get higher, more rocky, but it's an easy climb. Higher you climb, the lower the gravity. Sports up there. There's velodrome ring here.' He pointed. `A what?' Case leaned forward. `They race bicycles,' Molly said. `Low grav, high-traction tires, get up over a hundred kilos an hour.'"
- pjc50 7y ago> your chances of survival dramatically increase. Well, until something goes wrong and you're in deep space beyond any hope of rescue.
- m463 7y ago> Fly off into the deep cosmos, though, and your chances of survival dramatically increase. It might help to bring an earth ecosystem with you. Actually, I wonder if earth will be in danger when space colonies take place, because they will have the "high ground" and be able to drop rocks for basically no cost. On the other hand, maybe with replicators, the psychology of post-scarcity might change things.