4 ms·
Summary: They debunk some statistics that claim that inequality leads to various social ills but themselves make the far-less supported implications that there
by joe_the_user 16y ago
Summary: They debunk some statistics that claim that inequality leads to various social ills but themselves make the far-less supported implications that there is something "cognitive" about those individuals who now have a large portion of the world's wealth - especially, it's a far leap from statistics indicating those with a university education are paid more to the implication that smart people get paid more.
For however little we understand these things, their claims might be true but what stands-out is the distinction between the standard they hold the critics of inequality to and the standards they hold their sort-of-pro-inequality stand to.
- bryanlarsen 16y agoTo be fair, this is one article in a series on inequality. They come done much harsher on other sources of inequality, such as the American financial system and the Chinese rural to urban migration quotas.
- sedachv 16y agoTake note of this quote from the article: "And their findings about teen births, women’s status and innovation depend on Scandinavia, a region with a mild and sensible culture that is equally evident among people of Scandinavian stock who live in America." The whole thing is basically an elaborate rationalization of racism through the cliche of social darwinism. As much as I dislike stupid people, I hate social conservatives even more.
- kiba 16y agoThe whole thing is basically an elaborate rationalization of racism through the cliche of social darwinism. As much as I dislike stupid people, I hate social conservatives even more. I don't detect endorsement of social darwinism.
- forkandwait 16y agoThat's because you don't know what social darwinism means.... (edit) ... it means that individuals who win the various competitions in society (jobs, attractive spouses, etc) succeed because they have innate superiority in some way, and that we should allow such competition because it somehow propagates excellence.
- m-photonic 16y agoI don't know, to me it looks like the bit about Americans of Scandinavian stock is just a throwaway line that has nothing to do with the point they're actually making, which is that the observed correlations are mainly just a product of the fact that there are a few countries with low levels of inequality that also happen to be exemplars of things like high life expectancy or women's rights. I don't think they're actually making any racial arguments in this article. When they do mention race later on, it's to make the point that the correlations of social problems with inequality don't have any more inherent explanatory value than the correlations with race.
- candeira 16y agoI am writing from memory, but I think the writer of this piece had in mind the following Milton Friedman anecdote: When told there was almost no crime in quasi-socialist Nordic countries, Friedman retorted (I paraphrase) "ah, but we have almost no crime among Nordic-Americans".
- sedachv 16y ago"I don't know, to me it looks like the bit about Americans of Scandinavian stock is just a throwaway line that has nothing to do with the point they're actually making" Then why go out of your way to use such a contentious statement? Why mention this later on: "race is a far more accurate predictor of murder, imprisonment and infant-mortality rates"? What does this have to do with the "cognitive elite?" This is just "fuck niggers, heil nordic ubermensch" stated in different terms. Both the agendas of that article (racism and classism) can much better be explained by the growing gender divide: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/07/the-end-of-men/8135 http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/07/the-end-... Women are better in the knowledge economy than men, and sex is a much better predictor of murder and imprisonment rates than race.
- forkandwait 16y agoOne can assume that most readers of the Economist are in the elite, more or less... and elites have always been fond of expounding on how their status is justified. When it was ok to say "God loves us better", that worked; now the elites justify their status with "scientific" reasoning that "proves" that they deserve their status because of some innate personal feature. Surprise, surprise. While my experience does not a scientific sample make, when I worked in a hardware store for two years (more or less doing my undergrad), I thought that the population was about as smart as the students I went to college with. However, the long term blue collar hardware store employees neither understood how to go to school, or how to mobilize education when they did get acquire some. So... I think there is sytemic, multi-generational differences in access to the training that allows you to succeed in the supposedly meritocratic society we would like to believe we live in. The difference in training is definitely manifest in "pure" cognitive ability, but if your parents don't read to you as an infant, push you to do your homework, or help you to go to college, OF COURSE you are going be dumber by the time you join the workforce as an "adult". Read Bourdieu.