7 ms·
France to Raise Pollution Tax on SUVs and Trucks to €22k
- rcMgD2BwE72F 7y agoAnd yet, the most popular French SUV won't be a taxed a single € as part of this super malus (Peugeot 3008 and 5008). Thus tax increase will impact far less than 1% if the sales. It's all PR, nothing concrete.
- isoprophlex 7y agoYeah considering what you say there must clearly be political motivation But contrast a 5008's 120 g/km with the average American gas guzzler doing 350+ g/km. All in all this is a good development imo.
- usrusr 7y agoThe idea of a law without political motivation is absurd. How else would it come into existence? Monkeys on typewriters?
- steve19 7y agoIf that is true then it sounds like a great protectionist measure, so not PR at all!
- lloeki 7y agoThe minister literally said it: > ces véhicules ne sont construits ni en France, ni même par nos constructeurs nationaux "those vehicles are neither built in France nor by our national automakers" https://www.lesechos.fr/industrie-services/automobile/le-supermalus-touchera-entre-10000-et-15000-vehicules-par-an-1153068 https://www.lesechos.fr/industrie-services/automobile/le-sup...
- Gibbon1 7y agoBe a lot better to just put an uniform excise tax on new vehicles based on expected C02 emissions. That would also tend to solve the problem of guys in yellow vests throwing stuff.
- stephaner 7y agoIt's a tax based on number of grams of CO2/km for all vehicles so 3008/5008 are concerned too. The updated tax for 2020 starts at 110 g of CO2/km (previously 117 gCO/km, last year)
- pjc50 7y agoThat's what's actually happening, it's just that Bloomberg have .. misreported it?
- rad_gruchalski 7y agoThat’s fine. As long as it includes emissions already created during production.
- paulintrognon 7y agoFrom the article: > Under a law adopted by parliament this week, cars emitting carbon dioxide above a certain threshold will be subject to a 20,000 euros ($22,240) penalty in 2020 So that seems to be because they don't pollute as much
- lloeki 7y agoAlso, this made me cringe. > In 2020, the central government will give as much as 6,000 euros toward the purchase of an electric car costing less than 45,000 euros. This looks like an anti-Tesla threshold, all the while pushing people to go towards electric cars that either you buy but rent the battery, such as Renault Zoé, or with poor autonomy.
- cipher_system 7y agoI would guess a lot of people don't like the idea of subsidising luxury cars for wealthy people. I can understand that. Besides, aren't Model 3 and the coming Cybertruck below that limit?
- dzhiurgis 7y agoMade in China + whatever Cybertruck is having M3 could go below $25k USD - perhaps 30k euro if you add duties, etc.
- de_watcher 7y agoThe Cybertruck doesn't make sense in EU. It just won't fit into the cities. :D
- lloeki 7y agoIn France base Model 3 is 43600. Any option / road ready fees will curiously drive you just past the threshold.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- growlist 7y agoCall me cynical but - I'm guessing it's a lot easier to punish market sectors in which your own manufacturers are weak.
- sddfd 7y agoThis is why the world is acting so sluggishly to climate change.
- cm2187 7y agoAnd for a cash strapped government to find pretexts to increase taxes.
- Wamou 7y agoOn the other hand, for the sporty versions of some midrange popular cars (Renault Mégane RS, Peugeot 308 GTi...) the pollution tax will amount to almost 50% of the MSRP. I guess car enthusiasts on a budget will be more inclined to buy lighter cars, a segment where French manufacturers are basically non-existent (even if a Twin'Cup is really fun to drive).
- lloeki 7y agoIndeed. I’m clinging to my ‘08 Civic Type-R (MSRP was 30000, 25000 in stripped down version. The tax would be 80-95% of MSRP!) but will have to let it go within five years as level 2 Crit’Air will be entirely forbidden to operate in my city by 2025.
- pjc50 7y agoPeugeot 308 GTi has a "puissance administrative" of 16, right in the high end of the tax table. Presumably because it's a 250hp car. I'm sure that's fun but it's also a really excessive amount of power (and CO2)
- lloeki 7y ago"really excessive" is quite going overboard. Of course you don't need 250hp to go forward. Yet those cars are less that 1% of the sales, blaming CO2 pollution on those is downright ridiculous, especially since they're not driven at wide open throttle all the time, which makes them much less than the stated output overall. For example my 200HP car redlines at 8k rpm, thus the legal pollution (incl. CO2) emission check is evaluated by revving it constantly at ~6k for several minutes, which is absolutely not what daily operation looks like (more like 2.5k~4k, and not even WOT). Case in point my car usually gulps 6~9 L/100km (open road ~ city) but when I picked up the car last week after the mandatory two year legal check, the ECU was reporting over 20L/100km means consumption, which I never ever managed to reach, even when doing some spirited driving for extended sessions. On the other end of the spectrum, this pushes towards heavily downsized engines that operate at the limit most of the time in regular use, putting excessive strain on the hardware, resulting in terrible reliability, constant excessive pollution, and premature wear of the engine. No wonder people have to change cars at 150000~200000km. Comparatively, at 12yo, my car is nearing that threshold and still performs as good as new. I expect it to pass 500000km with flying colours.
- isoprophlex 7y agoYes, glorious. See also []. Where I live (the Netherlands) there is absolutely no need to drive a ridiculous Dodge Ram with a 6 liter engine that emits a bazillion kg co2. However there's a worrying trend of people exploiting some tax loophole to drive them cheaply, with road taxes going down to the level of ordinary passenger vehicles. I'd really like us to implement similar incentives to get these ridiculous things off the roads. [] https://www.iea.org/commentaries/growing-preference-for-suvs-challenges-emissions-reductions-in-passenger-car-market https://www.iea.org/commentaries/growing-preference-for-suvs...
- C1sc0cat 7y agoIf your parent doing the school run a suv does make sense, and don't for get that pickups are used a lot by farmers and I suspect the Dutch farming lobby is just as powerfull as it is in the other eu states and the USA.
- deugtniet 7y agoSchool runs are done by bike in the Netherlands. In addition there are much more practical vehicles that farmers/builders/<insert_mobile_heavy_work_profession> use.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoSuch as? Land rovers /Toyota hilux'es are ubiquitous on British farms. And just because its how your town does it in your country doesn't automatically make it the one best way for every one.
- arethuza 7y agoWhat look like ex-army Land Rovers are pretty common on UK farms and estates, at least here in this part of Scotland, pickups are pretty rare though. Edit: I wonder if this is because of how much of Scotland is used for grouse shooting - a pickup isn't going to be much good for transporting your pampered customers!
- winningforcoins 7y agoHeadline: France raises comparative value of other markets that are not France. Like Russia or China.
- mac_was 7y agoFrance is recently the main Putin advocate in the EU, look at Macrons recent comments about NATO
- deith 7y agoAt least here in Spain SUVs are only driven by middle aged women, the so-called "charos"—I wonder if this tax could be called sexist?
- rad_gruchalski 7y agoAre men forbidden to buy and register them?
- _bax 7y agothe new fascism is green
- pjmlp 7y agoI guess you don't really understand what living on a fascist country actually means.
- betterbeehome 7y agoI doubt you or most people can even agree what fascist means let alone what it would be like.
- pjmlp 7y agoI have the experience of 1933-1974 Portuguese fascism, good enough for you?
- jcoffland 7y agoThe bullshit is that politicians continue to only take action against consumers when the real polluters, corporations and the military, continue to go unchecked because lobbying pays.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI think of that as rubber hose policy. Beat down hapless working class people who have zero power and pretend some good will come of it.
- arethuza 7y agoDo "hapless working class people" buy many SUVs and pickup trucks in France?
- yann63 7y agoFrench here. Yes. There are many "cheap" ones, such as Dacia Duster. I see plenty of them everyday.
- pjc50 7y agoNot only that, hapless working people buying very high horsepower trucks! Edit: the Dacia Duster of sibling comment is about 6"CV": https://www.neowebcar.com/puissance-fiscale/dacia/duster/dci https://www.neowebcar.com/puissance-fiscale/dacia/duster/dci , which puts it in the €3125 band.
- abyssin 7y agoI don't know how to feel about the meme that governments should target big corporation rather than small consumers. On the one hand, I like it that it makes an environmental message easier to swallow for the masses, because they feel like they're not the ones who have to make an effort. On the other hand, it's quite disingenuous to pretend the outcome is different from simply reducing the amount of energy available to live a materially comfortable life for everyone.
- 7y ago
- throwGuardian 7y agoFrance has a population of ~70M. What do you think contributes more to global warming, 70M flatulent humans, or a few thousand French SUV enthusiasts?
- twblalock 7y agoIf you want to tax pollution, tax fuel consumption or actual tailpipe emissions, not a broad class of vehicles. Which emits more -- a small family SUV or a BMW M3? Governments have taxed vehicles based on weight, width, engine displacement, etc. -- and the automakers adapt. It's very easy to game the system. Just tax vehicles on a model-by-model basis on the fuel they actually use, and on what they actually emit.
- ossworkerrights 7y agoOften you will notice that regulation in EU countries, and the EU itself, are not thought through. Indeed a BMW M3 and many small cars can emit more emissions than SUVs. But I suspect this is more of an eny tax, as in Europe SUVs are not that common and are considered "luxury", despite small cars shrinking to the point where there is not enough headroom on the backseat.
- imtringued 7y agoThe tax is based on emissions. The Bloomberg article is just of a very low quality.
- pjc50 7y agoThat's actually what's happening here, it's just that misleading (nationalist?) reporting has left that bit out. The tax is based on "administrative horsepower", calculated from engine power + CO2 emissions per mile. That is then looked up in a tax table. See my comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21862516 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21862516
- dvfjsdhgfv 7y agoThe headline is imprecise, the proposed law takes this into account.
- imtringued 7y agoThe article only talks about SUV specific penalties which is wrong.
- thomasfedb 7y agoAs a car enthusiast I'm really hoping that we see governments adopting policies that drive manufacturers to provide low and zero carbon vehicles that cover the vast majority of use cases for conventional ICEs. Hopefully if that happens then it will be possible to allow for motorsport and vintage cars to remain in use.
- Karto 7y agoPity. I live in a remote part of France, shaped by hills, forests, and very devoid of public services. Most people don't have too much money, yet every third car you see is an SUV or 4WD, because they actually are quite useful in daily life. My neighbour drives a tiny but nimble Suzuki Vitara with which he does just everything, much of which no regular city car could do. Was he to buy that same car in two years, it'd cost almost twice as much because of those taxes. (damn even the baker drives his deliveries with a Vitara). I see all the excesses around the SUVs, I agree there's a nuisance to be dealt with. But again the government rules with a large and blind PR hammer, and we'll quietly sit under the blow once more.
- pjc50 7y agoSuzuki Vitara is an 8"CV" car: https://www.neowebcar.com/puissance-fiscale/suzuki/vitara/1-9-d https://www.neowebcar.com/puissance-fiscale/suzuki/vitara/1-... which would incur €6250 tax. (It's amazing how well Bloomberg's propaganda has worked here, hasn't it?)
- Karto 7y ago6000 Euro tax for a 15000 euro car. I'd call it significant enough and ridiculous enough to be more than mere propaganda. But you're right, the figures I had in the mind were for the Jimny, not the Vitara. Over 10000 tax for a car that's less than 20000 euro.
- frede 7y agoYour neighbor will be fine. The taxes start at 160 g CO2/km. The Vitara has between 121 and 172 g/km.
- adrianN 7y agoMeanwhile people in urban areas pay a lot more for rent so that they don't need large cars. Seems fair to me.
- Karto 7y agoReduce a complex equation to only two variables ? But that's no the point : expecting fairness isn't practical anyway. :) I'd bet the practical response will be people stretching their car's lifespans way beyond reasonable, pushing them to new extremes of decrepitude and unsafety. There's also no police anyway to keep that in check.
- mariushn 7y agoRelated: Measures to reduce air pollution quickly result in big health benefits https://www.newscientist.com/article/2226280-measures-to-reduce-air-pollution-quickly-result-in-big-health-benefits/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2226280-measures-to-red...