6 ms·
What's Crystal's unique selling point? It's older than Rust, Kotlin, Swift, Nim, or even OCaml, and doesn't really offer anything they don't. More Ruby-like syn
by lmm 7y ago
What's Crystal's unique selling point? It's older than Rust, Kotlin, Swift, Nim, or even OCaml, and doesn't really offer anything they don't. More Ruby-like syntax? Fine, but most people don't particularly like Ruby syntax.
- tbrock 7y agoWell unlike the rust circlejerk apparently people are using it to build operating systems instead of just talking about how one day they might.
- klyrs 7y agoI'm not smitten with the rust fandom either, but at least do your homework https://www.redox-os.org/ https://www.redox-os.org/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shakna 7y ago> It's older than Rust, Kotlin, Swift, Nim, or even OCaml, and doesn't really offer anything they don't. Crystal is only five years old. Nim is 11, Rust is 9, Kotlin is 8, OCaml is 23 and Swift is 5. Basically, Crystal is tied with Swift as the youngest. What it offers right now is a simple porting process for those with Ruby codebases.
- k__ 7y agoI think they meant younger. But, yeah, besides the syntax familiarity for Ruby programmers it doesn't seem offer much that the others do.
- nine_k 7y agoOkay, port your existing Ruby code to a compiled language, giving it multiple times the speed? Maybe three is a slight business opportunity here. Also, give your developers a more productive language that can go where Ruby can't (like OS development), which is 90% instantly recognizable — may also be worth something?
- lmm 7y agoIs it really so hard to port Ruby code to any of the languages I mentioned? Even with Crystal you will still have to make changes to your code, is having to use a slightly different syntax such a big difference? If you've got Ruby code and you haven't already ported it, how badly do you need the speed?
- rvz 7y agoWell it seems most developers here would rather use Ruby + several memory-optimised VM clusters to make their services go faster and destroy their balance sheet than to use a faster language that is efficient in memory and is also blazing fast. A rewrite in (other fast language) from Ruby sounds ridiculous as soon as you include writing a extra FFI wrapper around this you have to maintain so that would be out of the picture and that sounds a lot harder than a semi 1:1 port of the source code. The trouble is Ruby itself is starting to become a sunken cost as a language but is survived because of Rails, thus also explains the countless memory issues that happen when developers use it. So for a stopgap to something sort of better, I would rather port to Crystal or Elixir so I can run on those low-cost VMs and save cash.
- PixyMisa 7y agoSlightly different?
- EamonnMR 7y agoMentally context switching between Ruby and any other language to do the translation actually is kind of a hassle.
- 7y ago
- shakna 7y ago> I think they meant younger. The "even OCaml" is what threw me. Still not quite sure if they meant older or younger from it. > But, yeah, besides the syntax familiarity for Ruby programmers it doesn't seem offer much that the others do. A familiar syntax is a huge benefit in a lot of contexts. There's plenty of Ruby-only shops around the world. Making a faster and statically-typed language accessible to them is a decent niche. Crystal isn't quite Ruby. It has type guarantees that Ruby doesn't, which makes it easier to maintain. The async and parallel stories are also immensely better in Crystal than Ruby. The "Nil is a compile-time error" is also a feature I highly appreciate.
- rishav_sharan 7y agoI am subscribed to the windows support github issue since 2013, so Crystal is definitely older than 5 years. I think its around 7 years old
- shakna 7y agoThe first release, 0.1.0, was in 2014. [0] [0] https://crystal-lang.org/2014/06/19/crystal-0.1.0-released.html https://crystal-lang.org/2014/06/19/crystal-0.1.0-released.h...
- rishav_sharan 7y agoFirst official release maybe. But folks have been using Crystal since before that. This is the Github issue in question; https://github.com/crystal-lang/crystal/issues/26 https://github.com/crystal-lang/crystal/issues/26
- shakna 7y agoNot arguing with it. However, choosing a point in time to check a language's age from is somewhat arbitrary, and first release seemed good enough. The main point was comparative age of languages. Like OCaml which is more than two decades old compared to Crystal which is young.
- steveklabnik 7y agoRust is more like 4 than 9; 2015 was the initial stable release, most people couldn’t really use it for things before that.
- icelend 7y agoWell, ok, so Crystal is 0 years old.
- steveklabnik 7y agoYep, I’d agree with that!
- nlh 7y agoC bindings, strongly-typed, a great concurrency model, very fast, and Ruby-like syntax. That makes it a very unique and appealing language to me (and others). If you / most people don’t particularly like the Ruby-like syntax, then Crystal might not appeal to you. But I can assure you to those of us who like the syntax, the language is wonderful and super fun to work with.
- lmm 7y ago> C bindings, strongly-typed, a great concurrency model, very fast My point is that all this is normal, and all the languages I list have offered it for longer than Crystal.
- jbverschoor 7y agoLLVM based, and in terms of performance, it's one of the fastests
- dragonwriter 7y ago> C bindings, strongly-typed, a great concurrency model, very fast, and Ruby-like syntax. Ruby’s syntax is a great fit for Ruby’s semantics but—and Ruby is my personal favorite language—I don't see much point for it divorced from that. It's the one thing I like least about Elixir. OTOH, Crystal looks like it may be close enough to Ruby semantics that Rubyish syntax is a plus rather than a misdirection and distraction.
- cosarara 7y agoIn what way is Elixir's syntax like Ruby's? It has "end" on blocks and string interpolation with "#{whatever}", but everything else is different. It's about as close to Ruby as Ruby is to Python (which is to say, not much).
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoI think it really helps that you can write mostly functional code in Ruby by just chaining higher-order array functions, and you can use Pipes in Elixir to do this almost identically -- when you consider the fact that all the higher-order array functions have identical or very similar names and parameters in the two languages. My Ruby code is like 95% chained higher-order array functions. My classes almost never have state. I'm basically writing functional code, and it seems like this is a pretty common paradigm in Ruby. I will say this was HEAVILY influenced by learning Elixir. When not taking external libraries into account, my Elixir code (at least to me) seems almost identical to my Ruby code. I think Python and Ruby are very close. But I personally think list comprehensions are un-intuitive and you can't easily chain higher-order array functions in Python. So although I feel the spirit of my Ruby and Python code is identical, in no way do they look and feel identical. In the same way, I think my Elixir and Python are quite different. Sample size of 1. I know. Just thought I'd share.
- loktarogar 7y agoRuby's syntax is a huge draw for many people.
- disc 7y agoIt's possible that some (many?) programmers enjoy a Ruby-like syntax?
- viraptor 7y agoKotlin - it's on JVM which is a good thing for some and a bad thing for others. It's easier to distribute standalone crystal binary for example. Swift - crystal throws exceptions, swift explodes... Ocaml - the functional approach is not for everyone. Rust - I like rust a lot. But sometimes I want to write something quick and I'm happy to sacrifice some memory and speed to not have to deal with the ownership issues. Nim - the most comparable, I guess it's syntax preference at that point
- imhoguy 7y agoYou can use Kotlin/Native [0] or just plain Kotlin over Java with GraalVM which produces compact binaries. [0] https://kotlinlang.org/docs/reference/native-overview.html https://kotlinlang.org/docs/reference/native-overview.html
- vips7L 7y agoKotlin/native's stdlib isn't feature complete. You have to use raw syscalls to do anything.
- ernst_klim 7y ago> Ocaml - the functional approach is not for everyone. OCaml is pretty general purpose though, it has loops, objects, mutable state. libguestfs [1] and some other codebases (the compiler itself, btw) are written in a pretty imperative OCaml. [1] https://github.com/libguestfs/libguestfs https://github.com/libguestfs/libguestfs
- Jenz 7y agoOCaml somewhat tries to be familiar for OOPs, but it _is_ first and foremost a functional language. Personally, I am learning it now, and I think rather than it being a stepping stone between OOP and FP, it might as well be its own separate and hybrid paragdim; I find purer FP languages like Haskell much more intuitive than the mix of modules, objects, types and classes of OCaml. Though do not get me wrong, OCaml is an amazing language. It just stands rather by itself. Pardon my terrible english.
- unixhero 7y agoIt's for Ruby's developer friendly syntax. That's a huge selling point!
- PixyMisa 7y agoUnique? There are a hell of a lot of computer languages out there. The only unique ones are those that are so bad that no-one ever did that again. The selling point for Crystal is that it has a clean syntax that's easy for Ruby or Python developers to pick up (almost the same as Ruby), but compiles to standalone binaries that run really, really fast. I mostly work in Python because the libraries are a lot more mature, but I use Crystal when I need to produce a standalone binary.
- dom96 7y agoHave you given Nim a try, as a Python developer it seems like it would be right up your alley.
- Shorel 7y ago> but compiles to standalone binaries that run really, really fast. In a world with Go, Rust, D, C++ and C, this part requires comparison with these other languages. Faster than Ruby and faster than Python doesn't cut it.
- Symmetry 7y agoI'm not familiar with all those langauges but I found the inference of union types pretty impressive. foo = ENV["FOO"]? || 10
- RX14 7y agoIt's unique selling point is union types as a part of the type system, with whole-program type inference and flow typing. This has never been done before (as far as I am aware), and it is incredibly powerful and interesting. It's compile-time duck typing.
- mapcars 7y ago>whole-program type inference and flow typing What do these mean?
- c-cube 7y agoIt's very expressive and pleasant (and I never used ruby), while being fast and statically typed. That's a great combination of features. If it were stable, it'd be a serious contender to Go imho.