9 ms·
Fact-check: Five claims about thorium made by Andrew Yang
- HorstG 7y agoIt is useless to make claims about a particular fuel without looking at a concrete reactor design. Leftover isotopes for example are very dependent on neutron flux and neutron energy as well as general breeding properties of the reactor. This in turn decides the waste to be dealt with, proliferation risk and possible reuse of leftover fuels from previous generation reactors (which the submission didn't even discuss). Also, the answers lack nuance. E.g. proliferation risk is present through U233, however, U233 seems very difficult to deal with in bombmaking. So at least it's less of a problem maybe.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoIts easy to make bombs from U-233. In fact it is better than plutonium in some rare circumstances. Check out the discussion and cool declassified letter from the Livermore bomb letters here: https://whatisnuclear.com/thorium-myths.html#myth3 https://whatisnuclear.com/thorium-myths.html#myth3
- HorstG 7y agoYes, making the bombs themselves seems to be easy. The difficulty comes from U232-contamination which decays into strong gamma emitters, making handling difficult. However, there seem to be paths for the production of pure U233 from chemically separated Pa233, which one might be doing anyways in a thorium reactor. That would mean a significantly higher proliferation risk, because one would get pure bomb fuel form the normal operations of the reactor. However, I don't know enough about how easy or likely that would be to judge. But in all, you are right, I think. And maybe even more than right.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoI mean to say that making clean U-233 (with very little U-232 and daughters) is easy. Certainly assembling a bomb given pristene weapons material is particularly easy. I'm a reactor designer and study this kind of thing. It's really just a question of how fast you move your Th-232 through a neutron cloud. If you move it relatively quickly and then do your Pa separation you can get very nice U-233 from Thorium. The nice thing here about low-pressure fluid fuel reactors is that you can move material in and out fairly readily.
- Glyptodon 7y agoSeveral things in this FAQ are frequently contradicted, which I'm not sure what to make of.
- HorstG 7y agoThey are not wrong, but also not right in all scenarios. Truth very much depends on the reactor design. Thorium is often associated with Gen4 reactors which are responsible for the claims of superior safety. Not much, but some of the safety benefit comes from thorium. Similar for the claim of less waste: Some reactors have better neutron economy, burning their own waste down to more shortlived and therefore "better" isotopes. Or, by the same mechanism, can utilize existing waste as fuel. Also, continuous loading and separation of isotopes only works well with liquid fuels which is a Gen4 idea. Thorium is more of a side-topic there. On the economic side of whether thorium is cheaper, the submission argues in a very underhanded manner. Yes, fuel is cheap compared to building the plant in all cases. But the fuel cost of thorium is an order of magnitude below uranium due to no enrichment (for light water reactors in the fuel, for heavy water reactors of the water). And possibly (for liquid core reactors) the unnecessary fuel elements production.
- acidburnNSA 7y ago> But the fuel cost of thorium is an order of magnitude below uranium due to no enrichment This turns out not to be true in practice. Uranium-238 is fertile just like Thorium-232. To run a reactor off either of these fertile fuels requires breeder reactor technology, which involves chemical separations and exotic fluids. In practice, this has always been more expensive, even though the U-238 or Th-232 is not enriched. It turns out that breeder reactor infrastructure outweighs the cost reduction in not having to enrich. In fact, this is the primary reason that we don't have any breeder reactors today: it's simply cheaper to mine and enrich uranium than to reprocess. There are political reasons as well, but the primary reason is this economics.
- pfdietz 7y agoThe FRONT END of the fuel cost is lower. But in a molten salt reactor with fuel dissolved in the salt, reprocessing is not optional! The fission products have to be removed from the fuel salt at some point (reprocessing) because the salt is expensive (especially FLiBe). So the back end of the fuel cycle will impose costs that do not exist with today's once through fuel cycles.
- erentz 7y agoYang is to be credited for stating he is open to all possible solutions to the climate crisis, and rightly pointing out that with a crisis of this magnitude no solutions should be taken off the table at this point. Something other candidates are reluctant to do when it comes to the topic of nuclear energy. He shouldn’t be expected to be an expert in the nuances of the technology or fuels. This should always be left to the appropriate experts in the Dept of Energy, etc. The job of the president should be to identify the problem (in this case climate change), and task the appropriate agencies with solving it, which will involve a variety of actions.
- Craighead 7y agoWhat is the half life of the replacement parts of a windmill?
- sjwright 7y agoExactly. The takeaway should be that Yang is approaching this issue from a position of technical merit and not on an irrational emotional basis like most others. This is to his credit. Properly technocratic leadership is rare in the USA and it's beyond time for them to experiment with it. In my opinion the analysis linked to from HN is laughably flawed. It's not exactly wrong, but it's so terse and reductive that it might as well be. For example— while the waste from the thorium fuel cycle could be used to make weapons, but the fuel would always include some Uranium 232 (a gamma emitter) and therefore it's more difficult to handle safely and your entire weapon manufacturing pipeline is able to be monitored from afar by foreign governments.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoTechnically the big gamma emitter is Tl-208 which is in the decay chain of U-232. Careful about downplaying the U-233 weapons potential. Phenomenal nuclear weapons can be derived from Thorium. Here's a good declassified hint from 1966: https://www.osti.gov/biblio/79078 https://www.osti.gov/biblio/79078
- tabtab 7y agoRe: Yang is approaching this issue from a position of technical merit and not on an irrational emotional basis like most others. Unfortunately, politics is not rational. Energy sources that kill slowly but gradually make less news and attention than "death spike" patterns even if their long-term-average numbers are better. If you don't address political patterns, then you will be bulldozed by trolls and demagogues who leverage emotion and vague impressions. If you go on the news with death-rate charts, you'll be ridiculed by the same people who beat up and shunned nerds in school. I'm just the messenger.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoI'm involved in a public education nuclear website. We get tons of questions about thorium so we made a few pages to handle stuff like this. For instance, we have one on molten salt reactors specifically (which aren't always fueled with thorium) [1]. [1] https://whatisnuclear.com/msr.html https://whatisnuclear.com/msr.html And then we have our most popular, the Thorium Myths page [2]. [2] https://whatisnuclear.com/thorium-myths.html https://whatisnuclear.com/thorium-myths.html I love that Yang is bringing the discussion to the capabilities of nuclear technology even if I consider it a bit misguided to focus on the thorium fuel cycle. There's a phrase in nuclear advocacy today: "Come for the thorium, stay for the reactors"
- juped 7y agoThe thing I hate most in nuclear advocacy is the trope of "the new, exciting, safe and economical nuclear reactor based on new, exciting miracle tech!". We have amazing, safe, economical, etc. nuclear reactors. They're called nuclear reactors, and don't need any miracle tech conjured up in some magazine columnist's imagination.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoToday's Thorium "hype" was started by a NASA tech named Kirk Sorensen. He outwardly said nuclear needed a rebrand as early as 2008 and has kind of doubled down on it. Like: "Hey all those problems with nuclear are solved if you split this nucleus instead of that one". I agree with you and don't think this is necessary. We should just try to help people see context in the things they don't like about nuclear. The reactor accidents we all have heard about are hard for anyone to compare with 8 million air pollution deaths per year from combustion. But few people know about the Banqiao dam failure that killed 100,000. I read recently that 60% of American's think nuclear reactors contribute to climate change, when in fact they're among the lowest carbon forms of energy known. It's really mostly a PR issue. Nuclear PR money is tied up in utilities which also all run large fossil assets, so it's rare for them to talk about how low carbon nuclear is.
- Baeocystin 7y ago
- DennisP 7y ago> similar radioactivity at 100 years to uranium-plutonium fuel cycles, and actually has higher waste radioactivity at 100,000 years At 100 years your radioactivity is still dominated by fission products, which are the same in either reactor. At 100,000 years the radioactivity is minuscule with any reactor. But what you don't have with thorium or fast uranium reactors is a lot of transuranic waste, like plutonium. That's the stuff that people think has to be contained for 10,000 years. With just fission products, you're back to the radioactivity of the original ore in 300 years. You do get a bit of very long-lived fission product but it's not much radioactivity. Also, the total volume of waste is about 1% as much as with conventional reactors, since 99% of conventional waste is (mostly) U238, some leftover U235, and transuranics. A molten salt fast reactor will fission all of that very effectively, and a thorium reactor doesn't have the U238 or make as much transuranic in the first place.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoA few points: * Uranium-Plutonium fuel in a closed cycle can burn all the transuranics and have very low radiotoxicity waste as well. * Molten salt fuels are 10x less dense than typical solid fuels, implying an increase in waste volume. They're also water soluble and frequently liquid. This complicates waste disposal and transport. Not terribly, but still. A good summary reference on radiotoxicity vs. reprocessing is: https://www.iaea.org/publications/8359/assessment-of-partitioning-processes-for-transmutation-of-actinides https://www.iaea.org/publications/8359/assessment-of-partiti...
- Gibbon1 7y agoSomething people dislike being pointed out. As far as reprocessing is concerned the best first step in reprocessing spent fuel rods is not fuck with them for a hundred years.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoI'd go so far to say we should just dispose of it all. I used to be all in on reprocessing the waste. Nowadays I only want to do it if it's actually cheaper (which I don't think it will be for many decades). Nuclear has economics issues, not uranium sustainability issues. Uranium from seawater with runoff can power the entire planed 10x over for a few hundred million years. It's borderline renewable. We need to be doing things that make nuclear reactors simpler and cheaper to operate, not more complex and expensive. Disposing of the waste from a once-through fuel cycle is totally doable. We just have to let the world know that the Finns are doing it at the Onkalo Repository, we can do it in WIPP, and Deep Isolation LLC is working on a pretty slick deep borehole option.
- djohnston 7y agoim not sure it's useful to hold yang accountable for such technical minutae. i generally believe that nuclear has an important role to play in our mitigation of climate change, but that our bias to remember flash-point events like chernobyl and fukushima will overshadow the far more deadly and ubiquitous proliferation of CO2 and methane that lacks the same "pizazz"
- acidburnNSA 7y agoI just wish he would switch from promoting Thorium to promoting technology development in nuclear. But believe me when I say I'll take what I can get! Heh. I've been whining that HBO hasn't made a miniseries about the 4 million outdoor air pollution deaths every year or the other 4 million indoor air pollution deaths per year.
- sjwright 7y agoI agree with you in principle, but let him focus on thorium during the election process. It's his way of letting us know he's on the correct side of the broader issue without freaking out the hippies.
- sjwright 7y agoAnd it's important to remember that the Fukushima nuclear disaster has caused one confirmed death so far. I'm not saying that it wasn't a horrific disaster, but it's like comparing one dramatic aeroplane accident to the totality of road vehicle deaths worldwide—one plane is newsworthy; whereas the vehicle death toll is normalised and ignored. Worldwide, around 50 to 500 people die in planes each year. Worldwide, over 1 million people die in cars each year.
- remontoire 7y agoDo you remember what else happend that day at Fukushima? 15k people died from the tsunami. Yet people could not tell you anything about the tsunami except that it caused problems at the reactor.
- paulchen 7y agoThe fact that we are discussing thorium here and in many other places suddenly, proves the successful mission accomplished by Andrew Yang. Federal bureaucrats and their aides are forced to do their homework to seriously consider the option and answer intelligently.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoFor sure. I'm really glad this is bringing nuclear discussions to the left. At least the US DOE is already highly knowledgeable about thorium and molten salt reactors. Advanced reactor people at the national labs and elsewhere have been studying this stuff for decades. There are still plenty of us who know the details.
- hgoel 7y agoI don't think that's necessarily true, most of us on HN were probably aware of it as an option for a while considering that the main audience of the site is fairly "tech crazed". I wouldn't necessarily take that to mean he's succeeded in bringing this sort of thing to the attention of the masses. Particularly since any of the other people who pretend to care about the climate haven't revised their weird "no nuclear" policy despite it all.
- chillacy 7y agoActually I'm sort of excited about the reverse: there are many interesting topics I've heard about on HN that are going "mainstream" through Yang: Universal Basic Income, ranked choice voting, next-gen nuclear, a lot of musings on incentive structures and their problems, data ownership, etc.
- samirillian 7y ago> Nuclear energy is already very safe Wat
- acidburnNSA 7y agoIt's about as safe as it gets when you run the numbers. Behold: https://ourworldindata.org/what-is-the-safest-form-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/what-is-the-safest-form-of-energy
- lucb1e 7y agoIt's really sad that this is still news to people. If anything will kill us in the next century, it'll be misinformed decisions based on people that can hold the best speeches and appeal to emotions the most. To answer your question, acidburnNSA already linked something that I trust without clicking based on his other comments in this thread. Definitely check that out and compare the data to fearmongering you've been fed in the past by peers, the media, politics, everything (this is possibly the only topic where I think the media really failed to check the facts over and over again to get to where we are now). I've read other sources in the past that corroborate his comment about it being safe. As far as I read (iirc some sources were seen as self-referencing research and removed from Wikipedia, but never contradicted), it's equally or more safe than every other type of energy we have.
- sproketboy 7y agoI want plants made to Chernobyl specification in leftist areas. Two birds with one stone.
- formercoder 7y agoI’m quite disappointed by Yang’s false claims. I’ve come to accept him as the truth and logic driven candidate who thinks things through. He could have advocated his position without these statements. He should focus on Gen4.
- deevolution 7y agoMy primary concern with any for of nuclear reactors is that they make for very juicey targets.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoEven with all that aircraft-impact resistant, highly reinforced containment, crazy off-grid redundant safety systems, and paramilitary guard force a few hundred strong? Honestly I can see how they might be intriguing at first, but after quick consideration I think most attackers would quickly find something easier to hit.
- paulddraper 7y agoIn real life, the few attacks that have been tried against nuclear power plants have "failed" miserably. [1] It's not terribly hard to shut one down (or at least not much harder than your typical power plant) but extracting/releasing any radioactive material is very, very difficult. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2018/07/06/if-nuclear-plants-are-so-vulnerable-to-terrorist-attack-why-dont-terrorists-attack-them https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2018/07/06...
- robomartin 7y agoAn important point is being missed here and in all discussions (and the world-wide hysteria, really) having to do with "let's <insert any proposal here> to <battle|save the earth from|counter|reverse|delay|avoid|reduce> climate change". What's the point? We can't do a thing about it. This is academically simple to derive through analysis of 800,000 years of ice core sample data. Actually, all you need to do is look at the graph. When you do, measure and calculate the average time it took for CO2 to come down by 100 ppm. That number is somewhere around 50,000 years. In other words, 500 CENTURIES for a CO2 drop of 100 ppm. How is this related to my initial claim? Simple: This was the historical rate of atmospheric CO2 concentration reduction WITHOUT HUMANITY ON THE PLANET. Anyone --ANYONE-- claiming that we are going to do <X> to <battle|save the earth from|counter|reverse|delay|avoid|reduce> climate change had to answer a very simple question: How is <X> better than NO HUMANITY ON THE PLANET? If <X> isn't better than no humanity on the planet the rate of change CANNOT BE BETTER than ~50,000 year for a 100 ppm drop. The sooner we start discussing this based on real science the sooner we might be able to decide how to handle reality rather than allowing ignorant politicians and activist from driving the narrative. We are wasting valuable time with nonsense.
- teekert 7y agoHow does this relate to Bill Gates plans? I saw them on Netflix recently [0] [0] https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a25728221/terrapower-china-bill-gates-trump/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a25728221/te...
- Synaesthesia 7y agoTo my knowledge, the reason why Thorium reactors have never been pursued is because there is no way to weaponise them. I’m glad someone is talking about new possibilities of carbon free power generation.
- cm2187 7y ago“Fact checking” seems to be a new synonym for propaganda. I am not sure what trust I should have in fact checking from what looks like an anti-nuclear organisation.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoWhether Thorium or not, geo engineering or not, the bigger point being made by Andrew Yang is that all options should be on the table in this crisis, and yes, I believe it is a crisis.
- AnnoyingSwede 7y agoI wish there was this much backlash against Donald Trumps fictional claim that the sound of wind-turbines caused cancer, but i am assuming that this bulletin was commissioned by someone that rather nitpick on Yang for opening a door, than the current presidents attempt to slam working doors shut. Not to make this political, but Yang brings a lot to the table that others ignore afraid of being scrutinized.
- fsh 7y agoThis is just whataboutism. Trump's insanity doesn't justify giving other politicians a free pass for saying incorrect things.
- AnnoyingSwede 7y agoAgree, that's what it is.
- Grue3 7y agoYeah, let's bring down one of the few candidates who is actually treating climate change seriously with a bunch of nitpicks. Nevermind Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren wanting to shut down the entire nuclear power fleet.
- IshKebab 7y agoI don't get the nuclear fetish. Wind and solar are already far cheaper. I'm sure you're immediately thinking "but they don't work all the time!". That's true but we're still pretty far from having enough wind/solar to turn all other power plants off even when it is windy and sunny. Also the cost estimates of nuclear don't include decomissioning because nobody has actually decomissioned a nuclear power station yet so who knows how much it costs.
- Grue3 7y agoWind and solar are not at the scale we need to replace all the coal and gas plants. Nobody has build enough wind and solar at this scale so we don't know how much it costs to permanently maintain that setup (a lifespan of a solar panel/wind turbine is pitiful compared to nuclear). Decommissioning costs can be considered once the planet is carbon neutral, which it is not right now. Right now the goal is to build up carbon-free energy generation. That said, if you ask the right people [1] they probably can give you an estimate. [1] http://www.japc.co.jp/english/project/haishi/decommissioning.html http://www.japc.co.jp/english/project/haishi/decommissioning...
- nwallin 7y agoThe bit about making nuclear weapons from thorium by products is both true and false. It is true that bucket weapons can be made from uranium 233, but not really. Right now, when we make nuclear weapons from plutonium 239 and uranium 235, it looks like a regular machinist doing regular machinist things on a lathe, except they're doing the work in a glove box. These elements, their contaminants, and their decay products all decay by alpha decay, which is blocked a thin layer of basically anything. As long as it doesn't physically get inside your body, (hence the glove box) it's safe. Uranium 233 from the thorium cycle inevitably is contaminated by uranium 232. Uranium 232 decays quickly into thallium 208, which is a hard gamma emitter. It takes a lot of work to get uranium 233 pure enough to make nuclear weapons out of it. Bodies with the resources to deal with this are already sophisticated enough to enrich uranium 235: the uranium 233 angle is irreverent.