21 ms·
The 5% figure is out of _total US retail_, not online retail. Just the fact that Amazon is now measured up against all retail is kind of frightening.
by einpoklum 7y ago
The 5% figure is out of _total US retail_, not online retail.
Just the fact that Amazon is now measured up against all retail is kind of frightening.
- gen3 7y agoAnd yet it still pales in comparison to Walmart.
- einpoklum 7y agoIt doesn't pale. It's like a quarter or WalMart in terms of US sales, if I'm not mistaken.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cbcoutinho 7y agoIt's not quite _all_ retail though. The author excluded market segments that Amazon doesn't participate in - cars, gasoline, etc
- adventured 7y agoRetailers of that size - vs domestic retail share - are common globally among developed nations because the economy of scale is required to compete. The alternative in a global economy would be to shut down access to your market to keep the foreign retail giants out. Otherwise they would come in and decimate your smaller, less competitive retailers. It's why just two grocers (E.Leclerc, Carrefour) in France have 40% of their grocery market. Throw in three other retail companies like Auchan Holding and you have total retail dominance by just a few players. It's why Schwarz Group and Aldi are so large in Germany and why Tesco has total sales equal to ~12% of all retail spending in the UK (domestically they're larger as a % than Amazon is in the US for example). If you scaled Tesco up, UK economy scaled to the US economy, they'd be larger than Walmart.
- simonh 7y agoInteresting, thanks. I think market structure differences matter. As I understands it in the US Walmart can have an effective monopoly in an area by being the only big supermarket within reach. The area might only have a population that can support one big store and Walmart get to be it. That’s much harder to pull off in the UK due to our denser population. This pits Amazon more directly against Walmart in particular in the US, because the package delivery model lets Amazon address the same markets as those big regional Walmart stores without having to build a big regional store. In the UK there would be very, very few areas where the main choices are Tesco and Amazon, but there are a lot of people in the US who’s main choices are Amazon or Walmart. Does that seem right?
- RobPfeifer 7y agoWhy’s that frightening? Over the last 20 years they’ve disrupted a bunch of incumbents through better customer experience and ruthless execution. I think Amazon’s lack of clear moral position on key issues is concerning (and potentially frightening) and I’d actually argue that Wal-Mart has been much more clear on where they stand on things, but I’m curious if you simply think a company disrupting a major industry is scary beyond simply change happening “quickly”.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tanilama 7y agoWhy is this frightening? It seems to me only shows that online shopping is just a fraction of US's retail market, with the largest player only takes up 5%.
- throwaway5752 7y agoThis places them a distant second to Walmart's 9% share of all consumer retail sales.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoIs 5% a distant second from 9%? I guess but - what are the growth curves of these two businesses?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]