3 ms·
I fail to see how third pary sellers, of which Amazon take a cut, are significantly different that suppliers if traditional retail outlets. The primary differen
by ineedasername 7y ago
I fail to see how third pary sellers, of which Amazon take a cut, are significantly different that suppliers if traditional retail outlets. The primary difference is less risk for Amazon, but otherwise they seem to have a very similar relationship of traditional retail <-> supplier. Not the same, no, but similar enough not to split hairs on the topic when discussing Amazon's market influence.
- ikeboy 7y agoAgreed. Recently Amazon stopped showing addresses to sellers for FBA orders. If you don't even know who your customer is, it's hard to argue you are the retailer.
- brianwawok 7y agoEmails and phones have been gone a while. Essentially all you get is a generic amazon hosted forwarding email address if you want to talk to your customers.
- ikeboy 7y agoYeah, it's the physical addresses that were removed recently. Phones were removed about two years ago if I recall correctly.
- brianwawok 7y agoPhone removal happened in waves. The most recent wave was about 6 months ago. Fba phone numbers went to amazon owned phone numbers with giant extensions
- ikeboy 7y agoIirc, FBA phones hadn't been available for two years, it's MF phone numbers that got proxied to Amazon phone numbers six months back. Then 1-2 months ago FBA addresses vanished.
- 8note 7y agowhy would an address be necessary to call yourself a retailer? if I paid them in cash, the seller wouldn't know my address either
- ikeboy 7y agoIf some other party did have your contact info and marketed to you based on your purchases, controlled the entire transaction, shipped the product to you, etc, each detail makes them more the retailer and the third party "seller" more of a supplier than a retailer.
- Spooky23 7y agoAccording to Amazon, they are very different. A supplier supplies stuff that you sell. When convenient, Amazon asserts that they are mere conduits to the sellers’ inventory. Add FBA, and suppliers are sort of like consigners, except Amazon claims to be at arms length, so as to avoid liability.
- Supermancho 7y ago> According to Amazon, they are very different So what? Thats a given. The question posed is how it is functionally different, not what legal relationships have been used to circumvent standard supply chain regulation.
- 8note 7y agothe more apt comparison is Amazon as a mall for that, I'd say. each store has its own suppliers like how each third party seller has their own suppliers, but they're selling from the same building, amazon
- ineedasername 7y agoExcept Amazon has a much more tightly ingrained relationship with 3rd part sellers than just collecting rent. They can directly influence pricing, decide which products can and cannot be sold, and take a margin of each purchase, not just a flat fee for space used (although they also take that for FBA items). I can't really think of an aspect of the retailer <-> supplier relationship that isn't in effect between Amazon and its sellers.