6 ms·
Voting is such a weak control system, that it is obviously not enough. Regular elections pack together so many decision points into so few options that it's bar
by tsimionescu 7y ago
Voting is such a weak control system, that it is obviously not enough. Regular elections pack together so many decision points into so few options that it's barely worth participating.
If we really want to influence politics, we need to get rid of this idea that voting is all that democracy means, and try to get people more organized, try to get many more people to participate directly in politics, get them to talk to their representatives regularly, get them to organize and pool resources together for important causes and so on.
If you can convince 2 people to vote your way in an election, you've had a more meaningful impact on the election than if you voted yourself. If you can convince an elected representative to change their stance on some issue, you've had probably a hundred or a thousand times more impact on policy than your vote alone has.
Until we recognize these things, the people who already do (mostly, but not exclusively, lobbyists and industry groups; and some religious organizations) will continue to effectively control policy.
Would anyone ever imagine that, if say Mark Zuckerberg wanted a particular policy, he would do nothing until the next elections, and then would go to the polling station and vote for the candidate who seems to promise that policy?
- deith 7y ago>If we really want to influence politics, we need to get rid of this idea that voting is all that democracy means, and try to get people more organized, try to get many more people to participate directly in politics, get them to talk to their representatives regularly, get them to organize and pool resources together for important causes and so on. You think people have time and energy for this? If they did they could already do it. Usually you take the good with the bad and vote for the candidate that agrees with you on the issues that you care about the most, or the one that seems more reasonable overall.
- nocturnial 7y agoDemocracy isn't dead because it got defunded. > Usually you take the good with the bad and vote for the candidate that agrees with you on the issues that you care about the most, or the one that seems more reasonable overall. How is that working out in the US? I don't want to make an analysis of what's wrong or right in american politics. If someone got elected with the message they will burn down the house and everything and he doesn't care... I hope you read this message that after this presidency, you cannot go back to business as usual. Even if "you" win in the next election, it's going to be more brutal in the election after that one. The EU countries know this and are already planning for an exit of the US on the global stage.
- tsimionescu 7y agoNot all people, obviously. But I'm tired of hearing that everything would be better if only people voted. People feel, correctly, that voting is not always an efficient way of influencing public policy. However, instead of hearing about all the other mechanisms which exist, they simply conclude that they can't influence public policy and abandon the stage completely. If we want to get more people involved in political matters, helping them find ways to influence what they care about with less effort than it takes right now would be the best way (not that I know what would be a real solution to that).
- vturner 7y agoUs Americans have an impractical revulsion to lobbying and industry groups. Most Americans simply do not have the time and, at least until recently, are not too concerned what someone a state away does. Unfortunately, like you pointed out, voting isn't a frequent enough control mechanism on the authoritarians or simply narcissistic politicians ready to hand out favors. So, what do we do if lobbying and industrial groups are automatically not an option?
- halfdan 7y agoI've been thinking about this for some time. What if: - we vote on topics instead of for parties - party affiliation ceases to exist at the national level (might still be useful for city counsils) - we vote for representatives standing for specific topics & solutions. After elections those representatives form working groups What this would avoid: - huge senates voting on topics they're unequipped to understand - voting the party line Obviously establishing such a system would require a massive overhaul of our governments, but I'd like to think there's something better than the currently existing democratic systems.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoWhat makes you think most people want this? I don't think it's coincidence that most people vote the party line consistently throughout their lives. I think they identify with a party and it becomes a part of who they are. It sounds like you want something that encourages critical thinking. Call me cynical, but I don't think most people want to think critically. https://www.salon.com/2019/10/12/voters-often-parrot-the-party-line-even-when-polls-suggest-otherwise_partner/ https://www.salon.com/2019/10/12/voters-often-parrot-the-par... > Research shows that party has more predictive power than anything else.
- yorwba 7y agoHaving separate working groups make decisions on a single topic each doesn't work due to overlap. If the Committee of Environmental Protection and the Committee of Energy Production disagree about the correct amount to subsidize installation of solar panels, you need some way to arbitrate between them. Even if there's no overlap in topics, they'll still compete for their share of the total budget. It's not like parliamentary systems don't have topical working groups already. If all members of a working group agree on a proposal and it fits within budget constraints, they can get it passed without much friction. Huge senates voting the party line on topics they're unequipped to understand are the conflict-resolution process for when there's disagreement on a topic. Being affiliated with a party is a compromise where you vote with the bloc on topics you don't particularly care about in exchange for having the bloc vote your way on topics you do care about, but they don't.
- 7y ago
- Merrill 7y agoThere is a whole existing structure to influence government decisions and policies. First, there is are the Democratic and Republican party organizations which range from precinct workers up to the national committees. Typically, the only way to get elected to political office is to join and work your way up in the organization of whichever party is dominant in your area. Occasionally talented people join the non dominant party and win office, but it is rare. Second are the numerous groups dedicated to advancing this or that policy. They have members, collect money, organize, and influence elected officials at the local, state and federal level. Third are the various NGOs that work to influence policies in Washington. These include lobbying groups, think tanks, etc. Fourth, money talks. If you aren't contributing to the political organizations and causes you believe in, you have very little influence in a democracy.
- tsimionescu 7y agoAgreed, I didn't mean to imply that this would be revolutionary. But people who care about policy shouldn't be told to just vote, they should be told about the other mechanisms of influence as well, which are much more rarely discussed or brought up in this way.
- nabla9 7y agoAgreed. Working democracy is not individual opinion poll. In representative democracy voting in general elections is just small part of political activity. Surprisingly small amount of participation can have huge influence. Within political parties there are many influential positions where things are prepared and organized. When you get your say in the local chapter or some nationwide internal interest group, it really matters. I joined a party in my country. While I participate very little I do it steadily. I have probably 5000x to 10000x more influence in politics than average voter who only votes. Maybe 3-5 times a year I vote online or go to meeting where representative are selected or agendas are set and vote for someone or propose someone to some position. I don't do any work myself. I just find out the people I want to do the work for me. I donate little bit or send a encouraging email to someone who I want to become more active. Surprisingly small amount of grassroots political activity could completely change politics. It's just that people like to spend hours in the internet complaining about politics instead of taking part of it.
- amelius 7y ago> Voting is such a weak control system, that it is obviously not enough. Regular elections pack together so many decision points into so few options that it's barely worth participating. Yes, and then there is populism, which is in many places the biggest threat to democracy. What is happening in the space of phones/social media looks a lot like populism.
- someguydave 7y agoCan you define the word “populism”?
- dri_ft 7y ago> Yes, and then there is populism, which is in many places the biggest threat to democracy. You think that a political movement defined by its emphasis on the people is a threat to the system of government whereby the government is chosen by the people? I mean, just breaking down the two words etymologically should suggest a link between the two.
- vorpalhex 7y agoPopulism is a form of government of catering to the whims of the majority, often by hurting some non-majority group (immigrants, etc). Like letting a board of directors loot a companies coffers, it is only a short term strategy that leaves a country poor and broken.
- dri_ft 7y agoI don't like it any more than you do, but 'catering to the whims of the majority' seems more like an inevitable consequence of democracy than a threat to it. It's practically written into its definition.
- vorpalhex 7y ago> an inevitable consequence of democracy This is why we don't typically practice direct democracy and instead have safeguards. The idea you're getting at is typically called "The Tyranny of the Majority" and is something the US founders were very cognizant of. It's why we have a split congress (house/senate), why we have the rights in the way we do (not given by the government but granted a priori to the government) and so on. Populism can be a result of democracy, but is often times a way to subvert democracy and instead install a dictator. Thus why it's derided (on top of it's direct consequences) and why we should have safeguards in democracy.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Regular elections pack together so many decision points into so few options that it's barely worth participating. > If we really want to influence politics, we need to get rid of this idea that voting is all that democracy means, and try to get people more organized, try to get many more people to participate directly in politics, get them to talk to their representatives regularly, get them to organize and pool resources together for important causes and so on. >> get them to talk to their representatives regularly The average US representative represents more than 700,000 people. If people talked to their representatives regularly, representatives wouldn't be able to vote -- or sleep. Assuming "regularly" means "once a year", the poor representatives would be meeting upwards of 2,000 people per day. I think this is related to the problem you identify in your first paragraph, that a US election packs too many decisions into too few options. The main issue is size: at the scale of the US, there are too many decisions for democracy to be able to resolve them. Democracy is a high-involvement, high-consensus approach that works on a small scale.
- jonhohle 7y agoWhich, I believe, is why states rights and autonomy are so important. The federal government wasn’t intended to be a behemoth overseeing half a billion people. It wasn’t to have any authority other than that afforded by the constitution. The balance was intended to be controlled locally at the state level. When recently reading about the recent Supreme Court decision regarding the individual mandate I saw that 26 or so states were in support. That sounds great: to enforce at the state level. When it’s not a violation of human rights issue, I’d love for states to pursue these goals, then document and communicate them, build communities of ownership around them, and if/when they fail, provide experimental data to other states interested in pursuing that path. Some states are better at this than others, but I would like to see increasingly liberal policies at the local level and more conservative policies at the federal level (personally).
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoWell, that's the problem with states' rights. The states then can do abhorrent stuff cause it's their right. It's one thing if the state doesn't want people to be on the cell while driving. It's a whole 'nother issue when you have "blacks-only water fountains"... And having rights means you can do horrible things cause it's your right. I'm not sure whom I trust more: the state or the feds. At a state level I see elected officials' religion seeping in everywhere, and that frankly terrifies me.
- Shivetya 7y agovoting becomes weaker as the government gets bigger because you end up with an enormous not elected bureaucracy that in many cases is answerable to no one, especially the voting public. worse it is self perpetuating , growing with each cycle, and siphoning off a lot of wealth and energy that could be used to make things better. in the US there are nearly eight million full time employees of federal, state, city, and local, governments. A good number wield no real power but you get into the administrative levels and then you find those who do wield it. voting is like choosing what flavor icing you want on your cake but you have no guarantee of a cake. to truly make voting impactful more of the administrative state needs to turn over each cycle as well. hell some government agencies have their own courts
- chiefalchemist 7y agoAgreed on voting. The Dem + GOP cartel has a stranglehold on the process, the market if you will. Their collusion (e.g., gerrymandering) has resulted in a system that perpetrates their lens and their power. Put another way, just because you get to vote doesn't mean it was a true democratic process.