5 ms·
I sometimes struggle to reconcile the consequences of our actions on the planet with the fact were we all basically randomly put on this planet and never really
by dmix 7y ago
I sometimes struggle to reconcile the consequences of our actions on the planet with the fact were we all basically randomly put on this planet and never really "choose" to be here. And pretty much every other species and even many non-living things depend on massive amounts of resource consumption (usually in the form of mass murder of weaker species or co-opting the surrounding environment for mass automated nutrient extraction processes). Even the most harmless things engage in at least some manipulation of the world around them.
Take coral reefs for example, they are a massive self-interested survival mechanism that over a very long period co-opted some part of of the ocean floor near costs, largely existing as feeding grounds of countless exotic species who uniquely benefit from the arrangement. An arrangement which wouldn't normally be there without massive manipulation of the environment by millions of different fish and plant species.
Then we have humans who by some random luck of the draw are capable of mass exploitation of resources, often at the detriment to the environment but largely until recent times in very sustainable way.
Humans didn't choose the terms of the survival game which we were given for our own short existence and there's a billions other planets out there which are 'pristine' in an idealistic environmentalist perspective.
Our responsibility we give to our own environment, which is a relatively modern phenomenon is interesting to consider in this context. It will always be largely our doing but also our decision to do something about it (or not). I don't mean to suggest any of this justifies the destruction of habitats and hurting our own long-term odds by over-consuming. But I still feel like this trillion-mile-high context is glossed over in many of these environmental diatribes and the endless drumbeat to protect it which we've all grown up with in modern times.
- shakna 7y ago> But I still feel like this trillion-mile-high context is glossed over in many of these environmental diatribes and the endless drumbeat to protect it which we've all grown up with in modern times. I'd guess, because in the end, it isn't really relevant. Sustainability isn't really about living in some kind of partnership with nature, it's making sure that our exploitation of resources doesn't reach a point at which our species experiences dramatic loss. We can't reasonably move to another planet. Barring breakthroughs in terraforming or the invention of FTL engines, we're stuck here. Which means we need to continue to live here for the foreseeable future, and we don't want to cross that tipping point and screw over the up-and-coming generations. We've become largely dependent on a series of things that won't be able to continue to exist in their current form. We will continue to exploit and manipulate the natural world. We just need to change that manipulation so it can continue to persist. We're not talking about reducing our consumption of power - we instead talk about more efficient or less damaging ways to consume it.
- ThomPete 7y agoI think its important to undrstand that we are the resources. Oil was useless before we found ways to get it up from the underground and refine it to energy and the thousands of products we use in modern society, coal was useless before we found ways to turn it into energy, concrete etc, uranium was useless before we found ways to use it, stainless steel and i could go on.
- shakna 7y agoI think the answer to "What is Earth's most valuable resource?" is frequently answered with "the people". By common folk, dictators, and ordinary politicians. I'd put that into the common knowledge pile.
- ThomPete 7y agoNot in the climate debate. In that humans are seen as the problem, a cancer if you like, that destroys nature.
- shakna 7y agoThey are also seen as the solution in the climate debate. That the tools and technologies that can be deployed by the ingenuity of humanity can change the landscape to suit us. It's a problem both caused by and solved by humanity. Which is why focusing on this part of the topic is largely irrelevant to the debate.
- ThomPete 7y agoMostly by those who are called climate skeptics, the GTs of the world, the Erlichs consider humans the problem and want us to live a very different way or for there to be less of us. You claimed it was common knowledge, its not.
- afthonos 7y agoI don’t worry too much about our responsibility to our environment; I leave that for after we have any sort of semi-coherent approach to our responsibility to ourselves. The human species will be destroyed by its own inability to control its impulses long before it does damage to “the earth”. In that way, the context you mention is almost irrelevant, except as a recognition that life isn’t fair—we didn’t ask to be here, we didn’t plan for our level of foresight, and we couldn’t have known that building our economies around certain resources would lead to global catastrophe. But, as you mentioned, these are the cards we have to play. We have to do the best we can with that. :-/
- Joeri 7y agoWhether climate change is disastrous or not is a value judgment. The asteroid that wiped out the dinosaurs was disastrous for them but beneficial for us. Radical climate change will be beneficial to some species, but humanity isn’t likely to be among them, as our civilization is rather fragile and built on the assumption of a stable ecosystem. It is self-interest that should drive us to “protect” ecosystems from exploitation and radical change. I believe the reason this isn’t discussed much is because it is assumed to be common knowledge.
- roenxi 7y agoHumanities adaptability is on par with that of the cockroaches. Give us 30 years of prep time and we can cope with nearly anything climate change is predicted to throw at us. The difficult assumption isn't that we have a stable ecosystem - we survive in a very broad range of ecosystems. The one that risks killing modern societies is the assumption that cheap and abundant energy is available. Sufficient energy could overcome any challenge.
- jacquesm 7y agoSufficient energy could over come many challenges, but an abundance of energy also allows the creation of new issues. Case in point: the age of cheap oil. Without that abundance in energy there would have been no crisis now, and we'd be looking at a much lower number of people on the planet. If you want to change 'sufficient energy' to 'sufficient clean energy' then the needle will shift, but maybe not as far as you'd like: even then there is a limit as to how much energy we can get rid off once it has been used and turned into heat.
- ThomPete 7y agoThere still is no crisis and nothing scientifically demonstrated with regards to the climate we cant handle.
- ncmncm 7y agoUncertainty does not favor inaction. Claiming otherwise is fundamentally dishonest. "The instruments say our jet engines are overheating. Let's wait to be certain, instead of heading for the nearest airport. Who knows, it might be nothing!" Said nobody ever.