5 ms·
As mentioned downthread, the problem is that's not how big tech hiring pipelines work today. On the margin, Apple hires every qualified software developer it ca
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
As mentioned downthread, the problem is that's not how big tech hiring pipelines work today. On the margin, Apple hires every qualified software developer it can find. If one of their engineers can't get a green card and is forced to leave, that doesn't mean they'll hire anyone they would have otherwise rejected.
- commandlinefan 7y agoThen why place the cryptic ad in the newspaper rather than actually post the job offering where it might be read and applied for by a US citizen? The only reason this makes sense is because they’re _afraid_ somebody qualified will actually apply.
- jakear 7y agoThe newspaper posting is a legal requirement of a company sponsoring a green card application. I'nm sure you'd be able to find these or similar positions online too.
- shadowgovt 7y agoDoes "the company website" count? https://jobs.apple.com/en-us/search?location=united-states-USA https://jobs.apple.com/en-us/search?location=united-states-U...
- Klonoar 7y agoThe comment you replied to, again, pointed this out: they already do that, and attempt to hire every able-bodied software engineer possible.
- esoterica 7y agoThey post the non-cryptic job listings online where people actually read them. The newspaper ad is just a legal contrivance.
- zamalek 7y ago> The only reason this makes sense is because they’re _afraid_ somebody qualified will actually apply. The process isn't cheap and isn't easy. All things equal regarding the employee and candidate, why would they be afraid of finding a suitable replacement? They aren't afraid of finding someone qualified. They are afraid of finding someone who is not. They are not allowed to over-specify the job posting, and are not allowed to require something like years of proprietary knowledge. The employee and the candidate both have to be treated like fresh hires. Edit: for example, in the Jony Ive green card process, a fresh University graduate would be able to displace him as a candidate. All of his experience was proprietary (gained while working at Apple) and therefore ineligible for consideration.
- geofft 7y agoThere is a legal requirement to place a newspaper ad. They also do normal things like post on HN Who's Hiring threads, but the law hasn't been updated for that.
- geebee 7y agoAt what salary? Do any of the people qualified to be software engineers at apple work at google or Facebook, or in universities, or as consultants or entrepreneurs? Do any of them leave the pipeline earlier to become lawyers, physicians or get MBAs? If they can’t hire enough at market rate, then that’s the narkets answer. I see no reason to create a shadow immigration system run through apple’s HR department to help them escape the realities of the market. At minimum wage I’m sure there’s be lots of demand for talented engineers but vert lie supply. At a mil a year demand would fall considerably but supply would sure rise. So again. At what salary?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIt's not a shadow immigration system. It's an explicit, intentional aspect of US immigration policy that you're allowed to recruit skilled people from abroad if you can't fill your staff with Americans hired at market rate.
- geebee 7y agoIt’s a system that allows corporation to decide who is allowed into the us and the circumstances under which they are allowed to remain. A free person could decide not to put up with whiteboard tech interviews, not work on an “agile” team, not program in JavaScript, not work in an open office, and still legally remain in the US. They might have to pass on certain jobs, which is fine. An employer should largely set the terms under which an employee will join and remain in a job, as long as the employee is free to quit. I don’t think an employer should set the terms under which an employee will legally enter and remain in the United States, though I certainly can see why they would find this power appealing and lucrative. I call it a shadow system because it is deeply dishonest, corrupt, and manipulative, and makes decisions about residency and path to citizenship under the cloak of corporate HR secrecy
- geofft 7y agoBut this concept of "market rate" itself depends on the immigration system, which artificially restricts supply. In a genuinely free market, with no immigration system ("shadow" or otherwise - but both are part of the same immigration system), you would find lots of engineers willing to work at what we'd consider a modest salary in the US. The "realities of the market" are that part of why Apple engineering salaries are what they are is because of how national borders got drawn. Had California been an independent country without an open border with the rest of the US, salaries in Silicon Valley would be significantly higher, and people would be saying that "the market" set this rate. If we got rid of immigration restrictions entirely, which are certainly government interference in the free market, we'd get closer to seeing the actual market rate.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoShould a nation's immigration policy be dictated by the needs of the HR department of large tech companies?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoA nation's immigration policy shouldn't force companies to structure their hiring pipeline in some specific way for the convenience of regulators.
- supercanuck 7y agoWho cares what their process is? Apple is sitting on 56 Billion in cash, if they want the talent open the checkbook. There is no good reason they need to “import” talent and limit that talent to 100K. They could also improve their talent development processes and start looking for talent in other areas, Money-ball style. I don’t understand people’s unwillingness to appreciate that these are cost cutting moves and reducing employee freedom of movement (H1-B’s are essentially handcuffed) Let Apple participate in the market for labor, why do we need to bend over backwards for Apple? Let a competitor compete with them, we don’t need to lobby the government to change the rules for an organization sitting on billions of dollars. The median salary of an H1-B is $80,000. To be having this discussion without acknowledging that labor costs is a factor is laughable.
- esoterica 7y ago> Apple is sitting on 56 Billion in cash, if they want the talent open the checkbook. There is no good reason they need to “import” talent and limit that talent to 100K. You are inventing facts out of thin air to fit your preconceived prejudices. The engineers at Apple, both immigrant and local, make far more than 100k/year. America is only 5% of the global population. If you want to hire the best people, some of them will be American and some of them will not. No matter how much you are willing to pay, you have to be willing to hire all nationalities if you truly want the best talent.
- supercanuck 7y agoI'm not sure if you are delusional or stupid, but Apple isn't using the H1-B process to hire the "creme-de-le-creme" of Software Engineers. https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=apple&year=2018 https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=apple&year=2018
- esoterica 7y agoFilter by "software engineer". All the numbers are well over $100k. https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=apple&job=software+Engineer&city=&year=2019 https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=apple&job=software+Enginee... Also don't forget that these numbers only include base salary and not RSUs/bonuses. At tech firms base salary is only a fraction of total comp. Someone who makes 150k base might make e.g. 250k+ TC. The point I am making, that you are repeatedly refusing to acknowledge, is that the H-1B program covers almost ALL skilled immigrants, not just the ones that are hired because they are cheap. There is no alternate immigration program for people making 500k/year. You seem to be making 2 different arguments at the same time, that 1. The H-1B program sucks (because employees are handcuffed to their employers) 2. Therefore companies should not use the H-1B program and only hire Americans. I agree with you on the first point but the second does not follow from the first. Since there is no gentler, kinder, alternative to the H-1B program, companies have no choice but to go through it to hire the people they want to hire, even if their goal is not just to acquire cheap labor. Expanding your hiring pool beyond 5% of the world population is necessary if you want to build a company as successful as Apple. Do you think it's possible to build another Apple by hiring only people whose names start with M? If not, why do you think they can hamstring themselves by hiring only people of a single nationality.