5 ms·
Why is it so easy to create fake accounts on services like Twitter? If they really wanted to provide a service to humans, what is with making it so that a singl
by latchkey 7y ago
Why is it so easy to create fake accounts on services like Twitter? If they really wanted to provide a service to humans, what is with making it so that a single group can create 88k fake accounts on a whim.
- carstenhag 7y agoThe alternative would be the chinese model, where you need to type in your ID number in order to be able to play. Which nobody (rightfully so) wants. Albeit, it seems like there are loopholes: https://www.abacusnews.com/big-guns/gamers-say-they-can-cheat-tencents-id-check-system-games/article/2171959 https://www.abacusnews.com/big-guns/gamers-say-they-can-chea...
- tnolet 7y agoThe alternative could be a Stripe-like model where as you start using your account more seriously, you need to start supplying more serious identification. Gradual identification or something like that.
- secfirstmd 7y agoWhat about people in countries were freedom of expression as a very dangerous concept? You would risk endangering them by forcing them to use identification.
- CharlesColeman 7y agoThis. There are both honest and dishonest reasons to seek anonymity. That tension makes this a very difficult problem to solve satisfactorily, in the context of liberal democracy. The decision is much easier in authoritarian states, because authoritarians typically hate and fear honest domestic political dissidents even more than they do foreign information agents.
- tzs 7y agoThere is a difference between honest anonymity and dishonest anonymity that can probably be exploited to help. People who need anonymity for purposes such as expressing opinions that could get them in trouble with their government, religious community, abusive family, employer, school, etc., generally do not need complete anonymity. They just need to be anonymous from the adversarial group that would penalize them for their comments. Such people will usually be able to have contacts that they can trust with proof that they are legitimate, and who are sufficiently outside the influence of the adversarial group that they can openly vouch for the comments from the anonymous person without fear of reprisal, and openly explain how they verified the legitimacy of the comment author. Certain contacts would probably end up being used by multiple anonymous commenters. For example, Amnesty International might serve as a contact for people who want to write anonymously about their government's human rights violations. People who need anonymity for criminal activity or for disinformation campaigns would have a harder time finding a contact to vouch for them that their targets would trust.
- jrochkind1 7y agoIf the government finding out who you are would result in imprisonment or death, would you want to entrust your safety to Amnesty International's opsec practices? Against a state actor?
- codedokode 7y agoState attackers can produce as many valid identification documents as they need.
- samdoidge 7y agoI'm sure it is related to the fact they can report N new users to shareholders. I can't see what else explains their complete lack of dealing with obvious fake/spam accounts.
- jsnell 7y agoI'd challenge your entire premise that it's easy to create those accounts. The market price of low-tier bulk-created Twitter accounts seems to be $160/1k accounts. That's not bad. It's in line with services like Linkedin ($175), Hotmail ($150), Yahoo ($120) and Facebook ($150). The only large provider that does significantly better is Google ($300).
- shkkmo 7y agoThat seems pretty easy to me. I'm not sure what premise you think are are challenging by posting prices per account that are under 20 cents each....
- jsnell 7y agoThe part where @latchkey thought Twitter was doing a bad job at policing bulk account creation, and @samdoidge though it was obviously because they want those bulk accounts. In fact Twitter appears to be doing about as well as most of their peers in preventing bulk creation. 20 cents a pop for a process that should take 10 seconds and should in theory be easy to automate and parallelize for anyone with even basic programming skills? If it were actually easy, that'd be a goldmine.
- shkkmo 7y agoYou seem to have a very different definition of easy than I do. That Twitter does an equivalent job of policing bulk account creation as their peers just means that it is also just as easy to create accounts at Twitter's peers.
- aritmo 7y agoDo these account creations require to supply a mobile phone number?
- Terretta 7y agoWith [redacted subset] it’s possible to use an account creation path that doesn’t trigger a phone number requirement. A single misstep or threshold crossed, though, and even that path will trigger the requirement.
- lopmotr 7y agoWhat's wrong with creating fake accounts? Nobody has to listen to what they say. This worry about disinformation seems to be the idea that people see multiple accounts making some claim and wrongly conclude that it represents a popular opinion, and so believe that claim themselves. But that's a ridiculous way to form beliefs even without fake accounts. Just the selection bias of people who would use a particular service already makes it non-representative, let alone whatever algorithm the service uses to decide what messages to show you. And of course popularity doesn't make a claim true anyway, even if you do get a good sample. What if they're not even fake accounts, but some big group (like a country) just organizes its members to post particular things? Should those users be banned? Or a business pays people to promote their products (the business model of influencers)? What if that organizing isn't particularly formal but is gently guided in one direction in the form of propaganda or advertising (nationalists and fans)? Now do we have to ban all users from some country because they've been too brainwashed by their local propaganda to be trusted as acting like independent human beings? Ban all Christians? They seem to keep repeating the same false information like robots, and somebody might get fooled into believing it.
- objectivetruth 7y agoQ: "What's wrong with creating fake accounts?" A: signal:noise ratio gets worse when there are tons of noisy bots spamming everywhere. Q: "that's a ridiculous way to form beliefs" A: Yeah, but that IS how the (vast?) majority of society changes their beliefs so it does matter. Q: all your other implied questions A: it's against the ToS. People who don't like that fact are SoL.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]