36 ms·
Bill to crack down on robocalls passes Senate
- freedomben 7y agoAs a consumer I sort of like this (I do worry about unintended consequences tho), but as a developer this absolutely sucks. It's already a massive PITA to make use of telephony (SMS/voice calls) through AWS and the like, and this will only make that 10 times worse. Even at a medium-sized company that spends 5 figures a month on AWS services we got totally burned by this. Amazon has also done an abysmal job at facilitating between the deveopers (us) and the carriers. They will just shut down your production system without warning and yet their API will still return 200s as tho everything is fine, while silently sending your SMS to the bit bucket. Then when you open a support case it will take a while unless you pay for support, support that you only need because they are returning lies from the API and you have no way of finding out what is wrong without a support agent looking at the system. Yeah I'm still pretty pissed. I will pay more for Twilio until something drastic changes.
- coldpie 7y agoAt one point I was getting four bullshit calls a day. I'm beyond the point of caring. Charge everybody five thousand dollars per minute. Require a blood sample for every phone call. Burn the phone system to the ground. I don't care, make it stop.
- freedomben 7y agoThere will be a lot of less secure accounts then. Even tho I don't like SMS for 2FA, it is the only thing that many consumers will use. If you want to destroy the ability to send any SMS programmatically, the loss of security will be only one unintended consequence. We also use a robocall for the devops team when the site goes down. We can't afford to hire a human to do it, and that would be stupid anyway. That's a pretty useful feature that would suck to lose.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Even at a medium-sized company that spends 5 figures a month on AWS services we got totally burned by this Good! I send all calls not in my contact list to voicemail, and then rarely check the voicemails. Businesses need to find a better way to reach me than autodialing.
- freedomben 7y agoFirstly, our customers specifically have to enable it, and can easily disable if they don't want it. Secondly, I don't see why the AWS returning 200s while silently discarding our stuff is the right way to handle this. If you want to block our numbers (which I aboslutely think you should be able to do) the API should return something that tells us that instead of pretending like everything is fine.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> If you want to block our numbers...the API should return something that tells us that As a consumer, I disagree. When I send a message to spam, it doesn't let the spammer know they should switch the e-mail address they're sending from. If I block a phone number, that's not something for the dialer to know.
- freedomben 7y agoTo be clear, it wasn't consumers that blocked our numbers, it was AWS. I wrote my previous message sloppily. AWS was sending our messages into the bit bucket and returning 200s. Our customers not only wanted the messages, but were complaining to support that messages were not getting through.
- alexbanks 7y agoHow do I stop receiving garbage bags of coupons and advertisements that I did not request, in my mailbox every single day?
- codegeek 7y agoYou mean Physical mailbox at your house/apartment ? Good luck with that. I am willing to pay $5/Month to USPS if they stop sending paper spam to my mailbox but that's how they supposedly stay afloat today since they don't have enough funding.
- colejohnson66 7y agoGet your Congress critters to support funding the USPS. They get a lot of money from those ads.
- bobbydroptables 7y agoOr better, get them to abolish USPS. 99% of the things you get in the mail should be handled by email. The other 1% of critical things are frankly handled better, faster and more reliably by private carriers.. For better or worse it's almost 2020, not 1820. Let's start acting like it.
- void445be54d48a 7y agoUPS and FedEx charge too much, and I do regular media shipping, so No, do not abolish them. If I could direct all of my tax money that goes to the US military into the USPS I would do that. Give them more money.
- bobbydroptables 7y agoThe fact that you personally use a heavily subsidized, underpriced service is not really an argument for keeping it on a national scale. "I personally use and like a service" is a different statement than "it's in our national interest to continue gifting that service $10b per year in subsidies and benefits".
- AareyBaba 7y ago"ensures providers make robocall-blocking services available for free" In practice, this means AT&T outsources the blocking service to a 3rd party company. In order to use that service you have to surrender your contact list to that 3rd party so they can determine if someone you know is calling and understanding their EULA will make your head spin. This is what I have on my company issued phone. Personal data is the oil of the 21st century.
- irln 7y agoI'm reminded of this thread The FCC Has Fined Robocallers $208M, Collected $6,790 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21492782 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21492782. Enforce collection of the fines in the first place would be a good start.
- shantly 7y agoQuick solution: fine phone companies instead, since it's easy to collect from them. Give 'em 6 months notice and I bet spam and scam calls are nearly eliminated before the notice period's up and you barely end up collecting any fines.
- sansnomme 7y agoIt's a dangerous path when you force intermediaries to intervene and apply censorship. The path to having ML algorithms analyze every single call you make and receive is paved with intellectual laziness. Would you make the same arguments about end to end encryption? Quick, let's put backdoors in everything so we can feel safer.
- concerned_user 7y agoBut it is also very dangerous to do what telco's did, they connected circuit network that was designed as a network of trusted peers to the untrusted network of public internet without implementing proper gateways and/or enforcing certain rules. So slapping them with fines is more of a reap what you sow thing than punishment.
- cameldrv 7y agoSimpler solution: At the end of a call, the recipient can dial some number, like * SPAM, and the phone company who routed the call to your number is charged 25 cents. Presumably the routing phone company will pass this charge back down the chain until it reaches the caller. You must dial * SPAM within 2 minutes from the end of the call for the charge to take effect. There is no appeal. If you don't like a call for any reason, you can dial * SPAM, and the caller is charged 25 cents. Since the report must be immediate, VOIP providers only need to require a deposit for two minutes of calling volume, and they can throttle their customers to make sure that the reserve is always present. Callers don't need to be verified or have good credit, they just need to have 25 cents.
- jessant 7y agoHow will carriers determine if a phone call is legitimate? How will I be able to determine if there are false positives? How will I report false negatives?
- viraptor 7y agoAnswer to all 3: FCC is to decide this in the next 12-18 months. Read the actual bill if you're interested in details. https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/151/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/151...
- post_break 7y agoCan we please just force the measure on to phone makers? You could solve this in one firmware update to add a white list. In my contacts? You get through, if not? You go straight to voicemail.
- eunoia 7y agoThis exists as an iOS feature. Not sure about Android.
- post_break 7y agoI currently can't do that. I can turn on DND and miss every notification, but I can't filter my calls with a whitelist.
- viraptor 7y agoThis would only cause more apps leaking contact lists. It's a temporary patch for you, but it wouldn't actually punish the callers or force them to stop in any way.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- meremortals 7y agoThere should be something like ReCAPTCHA for suspicious calls on the caller and a Spam flagging option for the receiver
- mullingitover 7y agoIt'd be great if there was a simple way to flag spam calls and sms, assign originating phone networks a score based on their spam flags, and disconnect bad players from the network entirely if their scores drop below a certain range.
- dwmcqueen 7y agoAre political automated calls "robocalls" or are they (strangely) exempt.
- OrgNet 7y agoI don't know but political calls can be worst because they could be microtargeting you.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoWhy is that worse than scattershot spam calls? You get called either way.
- throwaway2048 7y agoBecause certain types of political messaging would be highly effective if carefully targeted, but would be a massive scandal if they became more publicly known.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoSo, the problem with targeted calls isn't the unsolicited communication, but that if politicians could send customized messages, they might sometimes send evil ones?
- throwaway2048 7y agoNot even necessarily evil, but it allows you to promise everything to everyone without being easily called out on it.
- OrgNet 7y agoIt is 2 different problems but if a call in unsolicited and political, it could have great consequences if they are micro-targeting millions of Americans.
- 7y ago
- dzdt 7y agoColor me cynical, but I don't see how the dollar amount of the fine matters if it can't be effectively collected anyway. Recently it was revealed that the FCC had collected a few thousand dollars of $208 million levied in fines. [1] How is a bigger fine different? [1] https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/the-fcc-has-fined-robocallers-208-million-its-collected-6-790-11553770803&ved=2ahUKEwippoPhysLmAhVEMt8KHcvQAboQFjAAegQIARAB&usg=AOvVaw0q4byU7X6mFI5N9jFXY6p7&cf=1 https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https:/...
- hanniabu 7y agoWho receives this fine? What are the funds put towards?
- nathancahill 7y agoNo one apparently. $6,790 collected means you're losing money to collect it.
- JohnFen 7y agoAs I understand it, if a law does not otherwise specify where the proceeds of fines go, then they go into the US' general fund.
- dredmorbius 7y agoAmortised across all calls, the fines amount to a half-penny per call, if assessed and collected. Which I pointed out a month ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21494828 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21494828 48 billion calls, $208 in assessed fines, $6,790 collected.
- hinkley 7y agoI wonder what success rate it would take in order to be worth someone's time and effort to set up an agency to collect these fines, and then how big the fines would have to be to make it worth the cost of doing so. Like if the fines hit $400 million, a group that could only deliver a 10% increase in collections might still be worth doing.
- dwmcqueen 7y agoCan we loop in automated political calls as robocalls?
- myself248 7y agoUntil we start hiring mercenaries to set the law aside and hunt these people down across borders, I doubt a dollar will ever be collected. Heads on pikes optional.
- TylerE 7y agoGo after the providers. Someone is providing them a gateway.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoRemove their common carrier status and enforce content filtering? I know this is just a knee-jerk comment, but I hope on reflection you can see how catastrophically terrible that idea is.
- TylerE 7y agoAt some point the cure is in fact not worse than the disease. Robocalls are so bad at this point that, if I could get away with it, I wouldn't have a phone number, at all. I also think that common carriers can still ban such activity. The common carrier statute says carriers may not "unreasonably discriminate* against customers. I have to imagine most sane individuals would consider cutting off customers engaged in obviously illegal activity as, in fact, reasonable. Just like USPS can turn over packages containing drugs to the Feds.
- 542458 7y agoSome days my call log is a solid wall of dozens of calls coming from (ostensibly) Chad or Nigeria or whatever that are pulling the one-ring scam. The number is different every time so there’s no blocking it. It’s out of control.
- TylerE 7y agoAround here they mostly spoof local numbers. E.g. My number is ABC-DEF-1234, I'll get calls from ABC-DEF-7899.
- coding123 7y agoWhy are the updates on Shaken/Stir gone totally silent?
- AdrianEGraphene 7y agoThe overall structure hasn't changed much, but STIR/SHAKEN is a core component of the TRACED act.
- issa 7y agoMy phone number was listed for my business about a decade ago. I get non-stop robocalls about healthcare every time open enrollment rolls around. I just block everyone that isn't on my contact list, but would love a better solution.
- matmo 7y agoMost of the spam calls I get these days are just silence. I'll answer them occasionally and just listen, but even after 5-10 seconds no one says anything. Who benefits from that? I really don't get it.
- nlfwhulsdhouv 7y agoOften they are waiting for you to say something before they start. I'm not exactly sure why but I think the strategy is to make it sound more like a real phone call.
- raverbashing 7y agoSounds like the overtargeted ads on the web selling you stuff you just bought. Though most of spam calls are either scams or just barely that
- smokinn 7y agoI suspect it's this scam: https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/n8ho3a https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/n8ho3a Spoiler Alert: Don't read below if you don't want the podcast episode ruined. You're not the one being scammed it's the telco. From the episode: JAMES: The way that the toll-free industry works is that it's a reverse payment system, right? So you have a toll free number, I call you, I don’t pay. Right? The--the remote end pays. PJ: So-- so that I knew. But what I didn’t know is that when a company has a toll free number and they pay the phone company a dollar or whatever, the phone company takes that dollar, and shares it with every other phone company that helped make the connection. [MUSIC] PJ: So like I’m making this up but if I call Jodie right now, I’ll place the call and it’ll go to like an AT & T tower near me, and then a Verizon Tower in Manhattan, and then over to a Sprint tower to New Jersey, to Jodie. JAMES: So there’s 1, 2, 3 hops down the chain. Each one of those, you know, for a 1 dollar phone call, is getting maybe ten cents, right? Carrier 2 is getting ten cents. Carrier 3 is getting ten cents. PJ: So, it’s actually even less money than that. But, there’s so many of these calls happening every single day, that even though the phone companies might just be dividing fractions of penny each time, those fractions of pennies add up to like millions of dollars. ALEX: Right. PJ: And so what happened a few years ago apparently, is some brilliant person was like, "Huh, I would love to take some of that money." And what they did was go to some shady telecom company somewhere, like Crazy Eddie’s Phone Service and they were like, "Listen, I am going to place a ton of 1-800 calls though you, and when you get paid for them, share that money with me." JAMES: So, the more phone calls I can make, and the longer that those phone calls stay up, the more money that I make. PJ: OK, so how does that get us to spooky phone calls from nowhere JAMES: Aha! So, let’s think about that, right? PJ: OK. JAMES: I send out a bunch of phone calls that are just silent, right? It takes you what, a second, two seconds. “Hello hello, damn it.” Hang up the phone, you’re done, you're gone. So how do you keep people on the phone, right? You appeal to their curiosity. PJ: Right.
- JohnFen 7y agoI'm exceeding skeptical that this law, or STIR/SHAKEN, will actually be effective. I hope it will, though. It would be nice to be able to answer my phone again.
- throwaway771100 7y agoWho gets fined, the caller or the company who enables robocalling (I’m looking at you Twilio)
- jermaustin1 7y agoI agree with this. Broadband.com has been a thorn in my side for years now because of this crap. Every single one of the non-spoofed numbers I look up are owned by Broadband.com, and I'm pretty sure the spoofed are probably flowing through them, as well.
- musicale 7y agoThis is interesting. If US companies are originating the robocalls, fining them sounds like a great idea.
- daguava 7y agoThis law talks the talk without walking it - many MANY fines have been distributed, but the organization issuing them has no power to actually collect them. When the collection starts, let me know.
- viraptor 7y agoThis law basically says: FCC has a year to figure out the answers. I'd hold off criticising it until anything is known about implementation.
- EGreg 7y agoHow do we actually get the robocallers these days? They call from spoofed numbers. And even if we can, would we get any of the money? PS: I read this book and 9 years ago they might have worked: https://www.amazon.com/How-Sue-Telemarketer-Stephen-Ostrow/dp/0615338178 https://www.amazon.com/How-Sue-Telemarketer-Stephen-Ostrow/d...
- riyakhanna1983 7y agoI'm wondering if it is possible to eliminate the use of phone number altogether? It was needed in old days, but today we use apps like Whatsapp and FaceTime.
- dima55 7y agoI don't know who "we" are. YOU can feel free to not have a phone number.
- cmcd 7y agoIf you want to move away from phone numbers I don't think Whatsapp is a good place to go..
- riyakhanna1983 7y agoYou get the point though. The idea is to create something that replaces phone number.
- musicale 7y ago> Over the summer, Pai announced that the Commission would be moving to make overseas robocalls and malicious text message spoofing illegal after Congress passed new rules that required them to do so in 2018. The problem isn't overseas robocalls originating in the US - it's robocalls originating from outside the FCC's jurisdiction.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoDoes the US care about other countries? I would be quite happy if they managed to enforce that worldwide by simply not working with the companies that don’t provide caller id.
- viraptor 7y ago> The term “voice service”— (A) means any service that is interconnected with the public switched telephone network and that furnishes voice communications to an end user using resources from the North American Numbering Plan See https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/151/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/151... This makes it irrelevant where the call originates. If the call is received on a US-allocated number, it's covered.
- noobermin 7y agoHow did this pass? I'm surprised like say TurboTax or other people who benefit from dysfunction didn't lobby to keep their profits. It's also humorous the related protocol is termed STIR/SHAKEN.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoBeing able to say "I stopped those robots from calling during dinner" has a ton of political value, and the robocallers likely have some plan ignore the new laws anyway.
- partiallypro 7y agoVerizon informed me of a new plan to block Robocalls, I think you can pay $5 a month to block them or something...pretty ridiculous. That doesn't include text spam.
- viraptor 7y agoThat will go away. From https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/151/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/151... > NO ADDITIONAL COST TO CONSUMERS OR SMALL BUSINESS CUSTOMERS.—The Commission shall prohibit providers of voice service from adding any additional line item charges to consumer or small business customer subscribers for the effective call authentication technology required under paragraph (1). It doesn't mean they'll be blocked at no cost, but the authentication system for all parties needs to be free and the enforcement for scams is on the provider. Effectively - you wouldn't pay anything extra once this is implemented.
- dang 7y agoWe changed the URL from https://www.axios.com/bill-to-crack-down-on-robocalls-passes-senate-97ecc50c-e4f9-4068-8b5b-4e5b9a796ddc.html https://www.axios.com/bill-to-crack-down-on-robocalls-passes... to one that has a bit more information. (via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21838912 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21838912)
- 77544cec 7y agoCollaborative filtering is better than law IMO. My phone company shipped a phone app in the app-stores that you're supposed to use in replacement of the default phone app. It comes equipped with collaborative filtering to weed out robocalls: when one rings your phone, the phone app displays it as such as well as the number of people who have reported it. I used to have one robocall a day, but not anymore. It looks like this simple technology has made robocallers give up.
- JimmyRuska 7y agoAs more time passes you just have to put your phone on do-not-disturb and only allow star'ed contacts. It might be useful to make a call forwarding service where they have to enter some number code to get transferred to you, kind of like a captcha, maybe something like plivo or twilio can do this. After putting my resume with my work number I also get a crazy amount of recruiters in India call centers using fuzzy keyword matches to recommend poorly fitting jobs. It also looks like the spammers are picking up in sophistication. Like a prerecorded voice asks me if I want an extended warranty and a few questions to do automated voice recognition screening of the call before transferring it to the India call center for sales. You can say potatos to every question and they will still transfer you, but the call will drop if you say "no". Once the India call center collects information from you they pass you to some guys that sound like they're in the US for the final sale.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- technofiend 7y agoHow I killed 99% of the unwanted calls to my "home" number using callcentric routing rules: #1 - Calls from the real estate broker who wouldn't take no for an answer: number is disconnected. #2 - Calls from Anonymous / Private numbers: number is disconnected. #3 - Calls with "high" spam probability: number is disconnected. #4 - Ring my VOIP gateway when I'm inclined to take calls. (Currently toggled manually). #5 - Everyone else: Voicemail. I had previously scripted downloading my contacts and adding a routing rule that let people in my contacts ring through but disabled that rule. Just need to update my script for google's oauth changes. Callcentric also offers a interactive voice recording (IVR) options for things like press 1 to talk to a person or even press a randomly generated digit to talk to a person. I haven't bothered with using an IVR since this system works for me. You can reproduce this system yourself using Asterisk or other open source PBX software if you don't want to pay callcentric for a phone number. At home I use a Gigaset voip gateway and DECT handset [1]. The nice thing about doing it that way is 1) the handset doesn't need to speak tcp/ip and so is light, cheap and the battery lasts for days, 2) if I need a second handset it's trivial to add one. [1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B014A781GS/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B014A781GS/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b... I realize the stereotype is HN readers have no use for the PSTN any more and wonder why people ever answer the phone, but I find it convenient for some things and it lets me stay in touch with older relatives who are less inclined to text / e-mail / insta / whatever-du-jour vs use voice.
- ponsin 7y agoLet me guess, this won't include politicians robocalling before elections
- jcadam 7y agoMy mobile number has an area code for a place I haven't lived since 2012. I'd thought about changing it to match my new location, but then I realized that since I'm no longer in contact with anyone in my old area, I'm able to safely assume any number calling from it is a robocall. I get several of them a day. So I think I'll keep my old number. So I think there's a possible solution: Pick a new mobile number with an area code for a place you don't know anyone and have no reason to receive calls from.... then block/ignore all calls originating from it.
- jp42 7y agoThis is exactly what I am doing. however recently I noticed that robocallers are getting smart, there is increase in calls from area code that I live.
- heliodor 7y agoI've been trying to find an Android app to do exactly that. The main ones don't seem to do it. Any recommendations?
- hangonhn 7y agoI'm in the same situation. Does anyone know of an phone blockers that work on regex or just area code?
- yellow_lead 7y agoI just installed an app to do this. It is on F Droid and I believe does not require root. So far it's working out extremely well. https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.kaliturin.blacklist/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.kaliturin.blacklist/
- smt88 7y agoWhatever spam blocking I get from Google Fi + latest Android on a Pixel phone has completely eliminated spam calls. I went from getting 3+ per day to zero.
- jzl 7y agoOf note: https://xkcd.com/1129/ https://xkcd.com/1129/
- NeoBasilisk 7y agocool maybe I'll start answering my phone again someday
- ananonymoususer 7y agoI wonder what sort of hoops I'll need to jump through to create an "attestation" for my SIP provider that proves the legitimate spoofing of my outbound VoIP calls (to my main business number) is okay. As of right now, they have no way to do this. I expect that my outbound VoIP calls will begin to get automatically blocked at some point...
- paul7986 7y agoSilence all unknown calls on the iPhone takes much of the pain away from these nuances. I just see I missed a call and if its important let me know via a voicemail. I still have to delete these robocalls' voicemails which is annoying but less then having them ring my phone especially while I'm using it. Interrupted by a spammer it was the worst!
- chairmanwow 7y agoI had this feature turned on until I missed food delivery 2-3 times in a row.
- riyakhanna1983 7y agoI know I'm repeating my argument, but why can't we create something that replaces phone number? Phone numbers are being used to track and scam people -- either through phone calls or text messages.
- turkeydonkey 7y agoAh, perhaps that explains the recent notice I got from ATT gifting me with their spam call notification service.