40 ms·
Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower than it was in 1983 (2017)
- ineedasername 7y agoWhen comparing to amber/green screen interfaces, hatred of the mouse is odd. Sure, for a simple search interface the text interface was fine-- search field, arrow down through results. But for anything more complex you end up having to tab between a dozen or more fields. ERP interfaces we're especially tedious in this regard, so the author's nostalgia for the "solved" problems of that age aren't completely warranted, and the mouse is at worst just as bad.
- aj7 7y agoAs Pauli said, “That’s not even wrong.”
- joncrane 7y agoKind of related: does anyone else notice how long it takes to change channels on the TV these days? It used to be instantaneous when cable first came out and at some point it became this laggy experience where you'll press buttons on the remote and the channel takes forever to change. I hate it and it's one of the reasons I don't have cable any more.
- taeric 7y agoIt is interesting to see just how much more information is in a second of video than it used to be. That said, I'm not sure that counts for the latency by itself. Pretty sure it doesn't. :(
- wbl 7y agoIt takes time to pick up the MPEG2 scheme and start decoding.
- java-man 7y agoall they need is to create to a low rate channel with slowly updating snapshots of all the programs being transmitted. i don't know anyone who does that, but it is damn trivial. (former middleware engineer)
- wolfgke 7y ago> all they need is to create to a low rate channel with slowly updating snapshots of all the programs being transmitted. > i don't know anyone who does that, but it is damn trivial. Getting this standardized in an international standard is far from trivial.
- java-man 7y ago"they" usually write requirements for set top middleware and control the broadcast. the problem, i think, is not that it is difficult (Musk launched a massive electric car company and spacecraft to ISS in the relevant time frame), but that "they" don't care about the users. pretty much anything cable and satellite tv companies do is against the user. there is very little (if any) innovation in the industry, and that's why they will eventually die.
- Pelam 7y agoYou may well be hitting a deeper point here. Many of the strongest AND weakest consumer technology experiences are influenced by standards in some way. Positive Examples: pluging in an usb headset, electrical sockets, sms. Negative examples: Trying to hook up your laptop in a random conference room, transferring a large file locally between 2 devices from different vendors. Maybe with ever increasing conplexity and capability the annoyances fall between industry actors and solutions would need first multiple parties acknowledging the problem followed by succesful coordination.
- jaywalk 7y agoThe Ericsson MediaRoom IPTV platform (used by AT&T Uverse in the US) does something similar to this, but it's only used to show a small window to preview the highlighted channel while you're scanning the guide.
- rohan1024 7y agoAlso, TVs kinda started having a black screen in between switching of channels. At night that becomes incredibly uneasy for eyes.
- ryanianian 7y agoMy favorite "the world is terrible" curmudgeon observation is how awful hotel TVs (and hotel TV remotes) are. Every single hotel room TV I've had the displeasure of using in the last N years takes more than 20 seconds to turn on after multiple button-presses, starts out on a terrible in-house channel at high volume regardless of the last-watched channel+volume, takes multiple seconds to change channels, and has no real TV guide option to let you see what's on. This plus HDMI ports are regularly inaccessible and it's nearly impossible to use streaming sticks (roku) due to web-based wifi portals that only work half the time if you have an ad-blocker enabled.
- arethuza 7y agoCareful what you wish for - many years ago I worked for an interactive TV company that focused on the hospitality market. One large chain of hotels seriously asked if we could do a remote control with three additional large buttons at the top for "Beer", "Burger" and "Porn". Turns out getting like that manufactured in the quantities we were looking at is a nightmare - so it didn't happen. Edit: Clearly it would have been easier to have one button for "Beer, burger and porn" - but that has only occurred to me now.
- javajosh 7y agoSounds like a legit app, though.
- logfromblammo 7y agoThe usual problem I have is that I need to switch to DHCP based DNS to register my MAC address to the room number, then switch back so the hotel can't screw with my DNS lookups. It might not be your ad-blocker or script-blocker; it might be your DNS settings.
- papito 7y agoHotel remotes. You all triple-sanitize them, right? And then burn them....
- 7y ago
- wolfgke 7y agoThe central reason is that modern video codecs use I-frames and P-frames (sometimes also B-frames; even though as far as I am aware, these are not used for TV broadcasts); see https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Video_compression_picture_types&oldid=916270429 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Video_compression... I-frames are only sent, say, once or twice a second. When a channel is switched, the TV has to wait for the next I-frame, since P-frames (and B-frames) only encode the difference to the previous I-frame (or to the previous and next I-frame in the case of B-frames). If you are aware of a possibility for efficient video compression that avoids this problem, tell the HN audience; the really smart people who developed the video codecs apparently have not found a solution for this. ;-) Otherwise complain to your cable provider that they do not send more I-frames to decrease the time to switch between channels (which would increase the necessary bandwidth).
- jasonjayr 7y agoCache the most recent iframe on the network and have the STB pull + display the cached iframe till it catches up? This would enable fast channel scanning/flipping at the very least ...
- wmf 7y agoIIRC Microsoft did this in their IPTV platform.
- fortran77 7y agoNo. It's not a codec problem. They can leave it on the last decoded frame and fade it nicely to, say, the average color for the 1 second without going to black, and you don't have to be a super decoder genius to implement something that's a little less aesthetically jarring.
- wolfgke 7y agojoncrane was complaining about the time to change channels. This approach does nothing to decrease this time.
- athenot 7y agoWhen working on digital settop boxes a decade or 2 ago, channel change latency was one of the toughest problems. Eventually we (collectively, the whole industry) gave up and settled for 1 second as acceptable. Channel surfing quietly went away. When your i-frame only comes so often, there's not a whole lot you can do. Nowadays, that problem is solved by reducing actual live content to a strict minimum; everything else can be on-demand.
- criddell 7y agoThese days they should be able to guess what 20 channels you might change to and start recording those in the background. I've always suspected the reason it's slow is because you press the remote button, the DVR sends that to the provider, the provider has to verify that you can do what you are asking it to do, then a response comes, then the change can start.
- jaywalk 7y agoNope, the STB has everything it needs to decrypt the channels you have access to. Tuning live TV channels happens 100% on the box. The only exception (a technology called Switched Digital Video) is just a way to save bandwidth on the cable, nothing to do with conditional access.
- criddell 7y agoIf I unplug my internet connection, my box won't let me do much at all. If I press pause or fast forward it just tells me the operation isn't authorized.
- fortran77 7y agoYes. They can fade out the old screen with "snow" until the next MPEG stream starts to decode.
- BubRoss 7y agoIt depends on the TV or tuner box. Some are very fast and some are very slow. It is something you have to test before buying if you can.
- jeffhuys 7y agoYeah, it sucks though that most tv providers supply the lowest-specced box they can provide. For my parents it was bad when they bought a 4k television, and the box "supports" that, though since some firmware update it starts lagging every 20secs. Dropped frames and the usual video-"smudge". I hope they get a (FREE) update soon. Because this is just a broken promise. And I'm not even talking about the Netflix "app" that's on there. Holy s#!t that's slow. Or the TV-guide. They now resort to teletext because that's much faster... I mean...
- Causality1 7y agoIt's patently absurd that a modern cable box chugs just when flipping through the channel guide. The provider has control over the software and the hardware so it should be butter smooth all the time.
- magduf 7y agoDoing that would take extra work, and cost more money. Why should they bother, when the dinosaurs who still watch cable TV aren't going to pay them any more for this butter-smooth experience? The people who care about such things have all moved to on-demand streaming services.
- agumonkey 7y agoAnalog TV were real time at the speed of electrons minus some layers of inertia (capacitance say). Nowadays there's many layers of various quality, and software reactivity is a factor of so many things.
- Koshkin 7y agoTo be more accurate, the speed with which electrons move through the wire is rather low (which does not matter, of course, because the signals are carried by the electromagnetic forces which propagate very quickly).
- mrlala 7y agoThis I do agree with. I haven't had cable for years and years, but when I'm at someone elses house I am baffled how insanely slow it is. That would drive me NUTS on a day-to-day basis.
- doctor_m 7y agoModern cable systems are more akin to satellite broadcast systems than they are to the terrestrial broadcast systems of yore. There's an order of magnitude more content on cable these days. When you tune a channel now, instead of simply tuning to a frequency and demodulating the signal, content is spread across many frequencies, each of which carries a QAM-modulated MPEG transport stream that carries many programs. It takes longer to tune QAM than baseband analog or even PSK. So the physical frequency change takes longer than it used to do. Once frequency is tuned, decoder may need to check provisioning in order to be able to decrypt whatever program you've requested, so that adds to the time it takes.
- post_break 7y agoI don't know who can afford cable any more to be honest. The only people I know who pay for cable are in the 45+ age range and they only use it because they just leave it on 24x7 or to watch the weather.
- hateful 7y agoI remember when this happened, when it went "digital" and I know why it takes a second to switch channels, but it ruined the experience for me. While, at the time there was ways to watch video on the computer or from a DVD or VHS, I still liked to "channel surf" every once in a while. But that requires switching channels fast for an random amount of time based upon what was on and how long it took your brain in that moment to absorb it. And sometimes you'd stop and go back. But with digital, most of the time the load time was longer than the time I'd be on that channel in the first place. It'd take minutes to go through 10 channels as opposed to seconds. Channel surfing was its own activity for me back then - and it was ruined. Nowadays there's youtube - but it's hardly the same thing.
- ajmurmann 7y agoIt's not only switching channels, even just turning the thing on. Also switching between inputs takes a long time, a large part of which is spend in the menu. The only thing I ever do is switch between AppleTV and PS4 and adjust volume because the PS4 is orders of magnitude louder than the AppleTV, yet so of that always feels super clunky if I have to use the TV remote.
- OGWhales 7y agoAlso navigating through the "guide" is simply horrendous.
- m463 7y agoThe problem is that (mpeg video frames, mpeg audio frames, streaming latency, hdmi decoding, etc...) all introduce a delay for reasons. The answer: put an ad in there.
- rohan1024 7y agoAfter reading this headline I felt like I was having Deja Vu. I wasn't, it was posted 11 hours ago [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21831931 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21831931 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15643663 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15643663 (posted two years ago)
- saagarjha 7y agoThe other one is still on the front page…
- dang 7y agoI marked this one as a dupe and was about to merge the threads, but the discussion here actually seems to be better than yesterday's. There's clearly a major appetite for this topic, so perhaps we'll break with normal practice and leave this thread up.
- Multicomp 7y agoI agree. I went to click this link thinking it was the link I saw yesterday that looked intersting but hadn't clicked at the time, now I'm doubly excited to find that there are multiple threads covering the same thing. Additional: anyone know of a good F# library for the gui.cs framework? Before I manually write bindings I figure I can throw a quick query out there.
- OGWhales 7y agoSeems everyone commenting on the post from earlier today totally missed the ultimate point of his post, which was UI bloat and failing to take advantage of keyboard efficiencies. It's almost like the large majority of them only read the title...
- bokbok8379 7y agook boomer
- cabaalis 7y agoWhat is this? Are these tweets? It's like reading a programming language where vast amounts of syntax is optional. This style of blogging is making the world worse.
- FemmeAndroid 7y agoThis is a website that 'rolls up' tweets. Here's the original tweets: https://twitter.com/gravislizard/status/927593460642615296 https://twitter.com/gravislizard/status/927593460642615296
- dang 7y agoWe've changed the URL to that from https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/927593460642615296.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/927593460642615296.html. The community is divided on which interface it prefers, so we usually break the tie by linking to the original source, which the site guidelines call for anyhow. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- wwarren 7y agoYeah. It is a tweet thread, which is such a bad idea that 3rd party apps have appeared to make reading them easier (threadreader for example). Unfortunately threadreader and its ilk can't make the content any better formatted or grammatically correct..er.
- daddylonglegs 7y agoTwitter is a great (as in terrible) example. I only enable javascript for a few websites so - when I click on a link to twitter - I see the twitter page being rendered and then this is all erased and twitter puts up a screen demanding that that I click on a link to see the content. After this click and a further page load I get to see a few hundred characters (the actual message) and a ton of rubbish, all of which was downloaded and rendered the first time round.
- Someone1234 7y agoThis is a very hard rant to read. The examples either aren't factually true or are poorly explained and the "solution" is largely nebulous. I feel like this topic has merit and with a well written article with real examples (both 2019 and 83) it could be something special, but this isn't that. I'd be interested to know how many upvoted based on the title/what they expected this to be, rather than after having tried to read it. Most of the replies from the older thread are about the title alone (or being critical of the content).
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoI found the list great and it fit the twitter format well. I usually don’t like twitter but it is what it is and this seems like what it is good for. I disagree about mice but everything else hit the nail on the head for how frustrating it is to be using basically supercomputers and still be sitting around waiting on code bloat.
- kibwen 7y agoI upvoted it, but I have mixed feelings about it. I agree with the overall sentiment that it's ludicrous how much slower everything feels on computers these days: we're able to do more complex things than ever, which is great, but it's hard to rationalize why even the simple things that we've been doing forever have become so sluggish. My first job out of college was to migrate an internal inventory management system from a in-terminal keyboard-based application (which nobody could be hired to maintain, as they stopped teaching IBM-RPG to college grads twenty years before) to a webapp. As part of gathering requirements I learned how to use it, and god damn was it fast. I watched salespeople and warehouse stockers alike fly through the menus so fast that they didn't even need to wait for screens to draw before advancing (and the screens were snap-quick to draw!), they just conjured the paths they needed from muscle memory and batched up a dozen keypresses and boom, done. I felt awful imposing this new laggy webapp on them, though I did make sure to at least leave the familiar keyboard shortcuts. But at the same time I think the author is somewhat overselling the idea that keyboard interfaces are just as intuitive as mouse interfaces. To use the application above as an example, when we showed the new webapp to people who only had cause to use this system occasionally, they were able to navigate it more easily and professed to prefer it over the old one. Contrast this with people who used the system all day, who grumbled at the loss of productivity and need to re-learn things. Keyboard shortcuts are great for power users who have cause to master an application thoroughly. For occasional users who don't need to master it and don't want to learn anything, a mouse will get them up and running faster. And, of course, there's still no excuse for how much lag and slowness we willingly endure in our modern UIs.
- acheron 7y agoOne that got worse and then better again at least in my experience is boot up time. Old computers running MS-DOS I remember booting up very quickly (unless you waited for the full memory self test), then for quite a long time it took forever to get into Windows no matter what you did to try to speed it up. More recently things start up pretty quickly again; I think it's mainly hardware (solid-state disks being the major improvement), but I do think Windows seems to do a little better software-wise too. (Linux and BSD I haven't used as a desktop in a very long time so I'm not sure where those are now. OSX I don't have much of a sense of, partly because it just doesn't need to fully reboot as often as Windows.)
- dexen 7y ago>but I do think Windows seems to do a little better software-wise too Windows 10 does a little trick to speed up boot - when you perform a shutdown, Windows 10 saves a mini-hibernation image to the hibernation file. When you perform normal boot, it can start up quite fast[1]. This gives noticeably shorter boot time especially on spinning rust drives (i know, i know, $CURRENT_YEAR). However if you perform a "reboot" instead of "shutdown + power on", you'll get the full length boot of notably longer time. [1] assuming the hardware setup is sufficently unchanged
- Narishma 7y agoThat's the first thing I disable after ever Windows 10 update (it keeps getting reset for some reason). If you have a dual-boot setup, it can result in a corrupted partition if you try to access your Windows 10 partition from another OS when fast start is enabled.
- duxup 7y agoI distinctly remember watching the Netscape Navigator logo for long periods of time waiting for a page to load.
- wolco 7y agoYou should have turned images off.
- duxup 7y agoI wonder if there was a "images are ruining the internet" panic like the the modern day "Look my blog is just html, why can't everything be that way?" rants?
- marcosdumay 7y agoThe web, not the internet. Yes, there was. For email too.
- MiddleEndian 7y agoI just remember wishing it was faster. Now that it's faster I still wish it was faster.
- sonofaplum 7y agoThere are some good points here, but of course I am going to ignore those to talk instead about the stuff I disagree with! The section about google maps follows a form of criticism that is widespread and particularly annoys me, namely => popular service 'x' doesn't exactly fit my power user need 'y', therefore x is hopelessly borked, poorly designed, and borderline useless. There is always room for improvement, but all software requires tradeoffs. One of the things that makes a product like google maps so powerful is that it makes a lot of guesses about what you are actually trying to do in order to greatly reduce the complexity and inputs required in order to do these incredibly complicated tasks. So yes, sometimes when you move the map some piece of data will be removed from the screen without your explicit consent, and yeah, in that moment that feels incredibly annoying. But balance that against the 100s or 1000s of times you used google maps and it just worked, perfectly, because it reduced the number of inputs needed to use it to the bare minimum. Google maps doesn't need to fit every use case perfectly, and while its fine to talk through how your hyper specific use case could and should work, remember all the times that it seamlessly routed you around traffic from your office to your house in one touch while you were already hurtling down the highway at 70 mph.
- PostPost 7y agoThe example for maps is not a "hyper specific use case": "The process you WANT: pick your start and end. now start searching for places in between. Your start and end are saved. When you find someplace interesting, add it to your list. Keep doing that, keep searching and adding." That's a common use case. The problem with Google maps (and the problem with a lot of modern software) is, as you say, it makes a lot of guesses. The definition of a good user interface is "to meet the exact needs of the customer, without fuss or bother"* Google Maps is great for finding directions to a very specific place. But after mapping those directions, doing almost anything else destroys that route. If I have to (and I do) open multiple map tabs, or repeatedly enter the same route info after making a search (if I'm on a phone) it is not a good UI. *https://www.nngroup.com/articles/definition-user-experience/ https://www.nngroup.com/articles/definition-user-experience/
- sonofaplum 7y ago
- brosinante 7y agoHas anyone ever also noticed how cars are always heavier than the bikes we used when we were children. And how much more air you need and how much longer it takes to fill a car tire with a hand pump. Also, remember when none of us was a portuguese author and we used paragraphs rationally and wrote things down without splitting them into 200 letter long strings because we used mediums made for rants and did not need a separate app to wrap it all into something vaguely resembling text? Also has anyone noticed that time passes and things change?
- black_puppydog 7y agoThe point of the rant was that in IT, and from a user perspective, they keep changing for the worse rather than the better. Calling this sort of thing out, when the entire industry keeps professing they're "making the world a better place", is valuable IMHO. I happen to agree with a lot of the examples.
- ryanianian 7y agoYour comment is ad-hominem (dismissive) and does not contribute to the conversation. You can dislike with the style/syntax of the article but the point it's making isn't "things change" it's that "things change for the worse" complete with several examples which other commenters here either support or disagree with, but helpful comments mention central points in the article in good-faith conversation.
- brosinante 7y agoI prefer to see it as continuing the argument in the same tone as the original - ie not particularly truthful and set in tone and content to support a skewed point of view and appeal to sentiment rather than anything else.
- xpe 7y agoI am not confident you are using ad-hominem correctly. From the Merriam Webster online dictionary: “1 : appealing to feelings or prejudices rather than intellect an ad hominem argument 2 : marked by or being an attack on an opponent's character rather than by an answer to the contentions made made an ad hominem personal attack on his rival” (Here on HN, I think that #2 is the most common usage.)
- thedaemon 7y agoWell, I think it's much more valid to claim it's much slower than 2000. Take for instance, Microsoft Office products. On a business class desktop, i3-i5, they are much slower than they were in 2000 in all aspects. Software has become slower as computers have zoomed in speed.
- seriesf 7y agoWe have a whole generation of programmers who believe that developer productivity is the most important thing, but this ceases to be true as soon as you have any users at all.
- geogra4 7y agoI agree I think this is generally more accurate. Browsing the web, writing documents, and navigating around (modest sized, not enterprise size)spreadsheets feels much slower than it did in the late 90s/early 2000s. I won't go back as far as 1983, but maybe 2003?
- blackearl 7y ago>Mice are bad. Mice are absolutely terrible. Bah humbug, I hate modern technology! This luddite author should go into goat herding if they hate modern tech so much.
- Deleriumm 7y agooops you pressed a key, your results are erased Every damn time!
- thibaut_barrere 7y agoSorry, but in 1983 I was using CLOAD and CSAVE, and it took very long minutes to save & load anything (on cassette!).
- Isamu 7y agoWell, in 1983 I was waiting all day for my program to load from floppy. Then maybe I had to swap disks out and wait again. But yeah, if you had one of those awesome 10 Meg drives, things would load fast! Then you would run out of memory if you were doing anything ambitious.
- BuildTheRobots 7y agoReminds me of John Carmack complaining that it was quicker to send a packet of data internationally compared to drawing on screen: https://www.geek.com/chips/john-carmack-explains-why-its-faster-to-send-a-packet-to-europe-than-a-pixel-to-your-screen-1487079/ https://www.geek.com/chips/john-carmack-explains-why-its-fas... More relevant to the article, I fully agree with the authors upset at trying to do two parts of the same task in google maps, it's entirely infuriating. Edit: duplicate submission: one directly on twitter, this one through hte threaded reader. The other submission has >350 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21835417 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21835417
- znpy 7y agoin 1983 there was no network delay to edit a document. nowadays it's "in the cloud!"
- tangue 7y agoI won't go back to 1983 but I have an old Mac with Snow Leopard and Text Edit is way more responsive on the old Imac than on my new Macbook pro. I know there was some change due to security, but I definitely feel this one. And I won't talk about the Adobe Suite ...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kabdib 7y agoI had an Atari ST in a closet, and decided to get rid of it a while back. I pulled it out to test it. The boot sequence, all the way to a desktop with a mouse that moves, takes less than one second. If you boot from a hard drive, maybe another second. For a while I just kept hitting the reset button, marveling at the speed at which the ST came up. Most machines I work with these days take minutes to get rolling. Okay, I know that systems are bigger and more complicated now; buses have to be probed and trained, RAM has to be checked, network stuff needs to happen, etc., etc., but minutes? This is just industry laziness, a distributed abdication of respect for users, a simple piling-on of paranoia and "one or two more seconds won't matter, will it?" Story time. A cow-orker of mine use to work at a certain very large credit card company. They were using IBM systems to do their processing, and downtime was very, very, very important to them. One thing that irked them was the boot time for the systems, again measured in minutes; the card company's engineers were pretty sure the delays were unecessary, and asked IBM to remove them. Nope. "Okay, give us the source code to the OS and we'll do that work." Answer: "No!" So the CC company talked to seven very large banks, the seven very large banks talked to IBM, and IBM humbly delivered the source code to the OS a few days later. The CC company ripped out a bunch of useless gorp in the boot path and got the reboot time down to a few tens of seconds. When every second is worth money, you can get results.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zozbot234 7y ago> The boot sequence, all the way to a desktop with a mouse that moves, takes less than one second. That's an exceptional case though - the GUI OS was hardwired in ROM. The Amiga was an otherwise comparable machine that had to load much of the OS from disk, and it did take its time to boot to desktop.
- kabdib 7y agoEven when the OS was loaded off of a hard drive, the boot time was still about 2-3 seconds (I did measure this). Not really exceptional. It took maybe a minute to load off floppy disk. That is STILL shorter than the POST time for every machine I work with these days, with the possible exception of the Raspberry Pi in the closet.
- buboard 7y agothread reader loads fast, that's because it doesnt force you to watch the page "booting up" and then its equivalent windows hourglass (ajax spinners). Maybe we should try a browser without javascript ...
- baybal2 7y agoI like programming in C, but it seem that C in GUI dev is slowly dying. GTK is truly the last bastion, and even it took a hit with GTK 3.0
- cjbprime 7y agoI wanna know more about these super fast library computers. The public library I worked in in 1999 used computer terminals that were just doing full-screen telnet sessions to a remote Internet host. It was like connecting to a BBS from my home modem. Random other info: One time the application on the remote host crashed and dropped me to a Unix shell. ls showed the directory had around 50000 files. The system's name was "DS Galaxy 2000".
- zrm 7y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth's_law
- mikro2nd 7y agoAh, the same Nickle's Worth who said (iirc), "Europeans call me by name. Americans call me by value."
- cgh 7y agoI agree with much of this mainly because as a teenager in the ‘80s, I witnessed the speed and efficiency of secretaries navigating Wordperfect’s non-GUI. The POS ui in the tweet thread is similar. There’s certainly room to rethink the use of GUIs everywhere for everyone.
- alexnewman 7y agoThank G-d. I have been saying this for year. Code is: - Getting less stable - Getting less speedy - Getting less efficient I blame the fact that old programmers and young programmers do not have the appropriate relationship.
- Diederich 7y ago> in 1998 if you were planning a trip you might have gotten out a paper road map and put marks on it for interesting locations along the way In 1998, I used https://www.mapquest.com/ https://www.mapquest.com/ to plan a road trip a thousand miles from where I was living, and it was, at the time, an amazing experience, because I didn't need to find, order and have shipped to me a set of paper road maps. In the 1970s, when I had a conversation with someone on the phone, the quality stayed the same throughout. We never 'lost signal'. It was an excellent technology that had existed for decades, and, in one particular way, was better than modern phones. But guess what? Both parties were tied to physical connections. Google Maps is one product, and provides, for the time being, an excellent experience for the most common use cases. > amber-screen library computer in 1998: type in two words and hit F3. search results appear instantly So that's a nice, relatively static and local database lookup, cool. I wrote 'green screen' apps in Cobol for a group of medical centers in the early and mid 90s. A lot of the immediate user interface was relatively quick, but most of the backend database lookups were extremely slow, simply because the amount of data was large, a lot of people were using it in parallel, and the data was constantly changing. Also: that user interface required quite a bit of training, including multi-modal function key overlays. This article has a couple of narrow, good points, but is generally going in the wrong direction, either deliberately or because of ignorance.
- msla 7y agoI don't know, I can compile code perceptually instantly and get optimizations which perceptually instant compilers didn't do in 1983. I know that Turbo Pascal was very fast when it came to compiling Pascal, and I certainly appreciate the effort which went into making that happen, but Turbo Pascal didn't turn string handling code into SIMD operations after turning a recursive function into an unrolled loop. Partly, this was due to the fact the IBM PC did not have SIMD operations in 1983, but the rest is because modern compilers run complex optimization passes in tiny fractions of a second. Also, I'd like to see this person say that operations on computers were perceptually instant while logged into a PDP-11/70 or (let's be a tad generous) a VAX-11/780 with a half-dozen other people all trying to use it at the same time. Yes, faster computers existed in 1983. Didn't mean the likes of you got to use them.
- regulation_d 7y agoIn aggregate, search is orders of magnitude faster because it's so much more accurate. When was the last time you had to think about your search terms? The other day I was thinking about the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon, but I couldn't remember the name of it. So I googled "when you suddenly notice something everywhere" and Baader-Meinhof was first result. Go back to 1983 (maybe even 2003) and let me know how long it takes to structure your search terms so you get the right answer.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> When was the last time you had to think about your search terms? Literally every day because Google has become so ridiculously bad at guessing what I want. I'm trying to tell it what I want, but it keeps throwing out words or adding synonyms or whatever else the fuck it does.
- Koshkin 7y agoThis also reminds me of the conspiracy perpetrated by the industry to remove the antiglare treatment of laptop screens and at the same time reduce the screen area by changing the aspect ratio. All this, of course, was done solely for the benefit of the consumer. (Oh, that, and a wild ornament around the keyboard.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Pxtl 7y agoThis seems to be conflating several separate problems 1) I can't manipulate data in my resultset well enough in google map. 2) Searches are too slow. 3) Mousing is bad. Now, you can argue that those are related. The first two are an argument for moving away from full-page post/response applications to SPA-style applications where the data is all in browser memory and as you manipulate it you're doing stuff on the client and pulling data from the server as needed, desktop style. The latter? I don't know why he had to go back to DOS guis. Plenty of windowed UIs are very keyboard friendly. Tab indexes, hotkeys, etc. > GUIs are in no way more intuitive than keyboard interfaces using function keys such as the POS I posted earlier. Nor do they need to be. This is where he loses me. I remember the days of keyboard UIs. They almost all suffered from being opaque. You can't say "the problem is opaque UIs" when that describes the vast majority of keyboard-based UIs. While there are obviously ways to create exceptions, GUIs are intrinsically more self-documenting than keyboard inputs, because GUIs require that the UI be presented on the screen to the user, and keyboard inputs do not.
- ehnto 7y agoMousing is bad. It really is a cumbersome tool. I do a lot with my workspaces so that I can avoid using it.
- Pxtl 7y agoI never disagreed with that.
- riversflow 7y agoHmmm Most Millennials I know who are technical absolutely love mice because they grew up using them, and most of them have extensive PC gaming experience to boot. I’m the Linux/CLI junky among them and even I don’t find mousing cumbersome—to use someone else’s words, it’s an amazing, first class input device. Same goes for trackballs. By comparison touchscreens are a joke, there’s no depth of input like with a mouse(RMB,LMB,etc) and every action requires large physical movements. I’m used to seeing people fly through menus with a mouse at speeds people here expect to only to see from keyboard shortcuts. Just because mousing is cumbersome for you, doesn’t means it’s universally true at all. I know keyboard shortcuts are fast, but it’s a lot to memorize compared to menus which typically have the same basic order. File|Edit|View|...|Help
- azinman2 7y agoI think this is a case of selective memory. I’m restoring and programming for an old Mac Plus, and it’s anything but blindly fast. Booting, opening an application, hell even dragging a window has visible refresh of the contents behind it. Windows used to take forever to boot (still isn’t that fast), and anything requiring networking was orders of magnitude slower.
- lolc 7y agoWhat bugs me about these nostalgic rants is that somehow the convenience of today should be mixed with the frugal interfaces of the past. So you couldn't be bothered to find a better route planner and defaulted to Google Maps? Which you got for free, instantly available? And now you're unhappy because it doesn't do exactly what you want? Please spend some effort on your tool selection before you spend time ranting. And let's turn this around: Did you at some point in 1990 wish you'd brought a map? How did you resolve that? Google Maps on a pocket computer would have been a marvel back then!
- cgh 7y agoHis general point is that the point and click interface is a blunt tool and there is room for specialisation. The POS example in the tweet-rant is ugly and non-intuitive but the perfect tool for the job. I'm not sure how I'd improve Google Maps exactly because I haven't really thought about it, but I do find it frustrating enough that I end up breaking out the good old BC Backroad Mapbook from time to time[0]. 0. https://www.backroadmapbooks.com/ https://www.backroadmapbooks.com/
- 8bitsrule 7y agoI got mad just yesterday at a new transit system interface with a map. It has moving icons to represent the present locations of buses. I clicked on a single point in the map, and it popped open a big black box of information. So big that it covered the icons of interest. Hmmm. If I could move the box to one side, I could leave it open ... nope, the box won't move. Bad enough. So I wanted to close the box. That took a minute, because you couldn't just click anywhere inside, you had to click at one single ... and unmarked ... location. Here? Here? Here?
- derpherpsson 7y agoThe reason for this is, among other things, systems programmers wrote the UIs in 1983. Today random twenty-years-old web-muppets write the UIs. The system programmers of 1983 were used to low-level programming, and most of them had probably written code in assembler. Web programmers seldom have that deep understanding of the computer. At least, this is true from my own personal experience.
- KaoruAoiShiho 7y agoIsn't it obvious, it's because webapps get data from very far away and back in the day the data was right there.
- JohnClark1337 7y agoThis whole thing reads like an old man yelling at kids to get off his lawn
- johnklos 7y agoEven reading that stupid post is slower because the poster can't be bothered with capitalization, punctuation, or complete sentences.
- krick 7y agoYeah, this looks like a collection of badly written twits. Who types like that?
- variable11 7y agoGoogle is trash and their execs and engineers belong in jail.
- Tempest1981 7y agoEarlier discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21831931 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21831931
- exabrial 7y agoSpeed is always the #1 feature: https://varvy.com/pagespeed/wicked-fast.html https://varvy.com/pagespeed/wicked-fast.html
- jkaptur 7y agoFor those interested in metrics, Dan Luu wrote a really cool article that measured input latency on computers from different times: https://danluu.com/input-lag/ https://danluu.com/input-lag/
- halfcreative 7y agoI don't understand the purported problem this man is facing when using google maps. Like step by step what is going on that google maps erases what you're doing. I've never had a problem as described, and seeing these other comments mkaes me question whether I'm using google maps in a drastically different way than the common person, or if the people complaining about this issue is using it weirdly, or if theres some different version of google maps that we are using. if I open up maps, type in the location i want to go to, click 'directions' and add my starting location i click and drag all over and move the map around, zoom in and out to look at the route and my info does not disappear. I click add a destination if i want to add a destination. if i want distance from the center of town, I change the starting location of my directions to the center of town. For the people who face issues with google maps, can they please describe to me what you are trying to accomplish and the steps you take that results in the info on screen disappearing? I'm genuinely curious on what I might be doing differently to have such a seamless experience vs the awful experience described.
- zwieback 7y agoThis is two years old - a lot of stuff in this rant already sounds totally obsolete. Early web apps were crap and we're still learning how to do stuff that works on both phones and PCs but the sentiment expressed here seems off base now.
- slowhand09 7y agoThis post is GOLD! I'd prefer Wordperfect or MSWord in DOS over any of them in Windows. Same with 1-2-3, Supercalc, Excel. Windows version are so kludgey. I could write 3x as fast as I can now.
- ttctciyf 7y agoOr Wordstar.. :) Remember when you could see and edit embedded format codes in your word processor? Surely that never happened!
- hsnewman 7y agoSo whats with the punctuation (no upper/lower case, no commas, periods, etc)?
- posmonerdo 7y agoOK, boomer
- jborichevskiy 7y agoI agree with a lot of this. Every app wants you to "experience" its data solely in its walled garden with no ability to cross-compare data. Say I want to find a coffee shop on the way to somewhere but also one which appears in a list of great coffee shops on a separate Reddit post I found. Pretty much impossible on mobile, and a major pain on desktop. At the very least, give me the ability to hide records/items/instances I've already seen as I'm working my way through several searches or lists. Often times searching things on Yelp and Google feels like re-reading the same list, just differently ordered over and over again.
- PaulHoule 7y agoThe "things shifting around" may be very deliberate. I've noticed that many advertising-supported pages (say trade publications such as 'FierceWireless') are a disaster on mobile with ads and other intrusive pop-ins causing page elements to move all around to the point where it isn't worth trying to click anything because it won't be there by the time your finger gets there -- but "oops!" you clicked on an ad so the cash register goes KA-CHING!
- kingkawn 7y agoI wish everything was optimized for speed of interaction above all other metrics. Make it so.
- dwheeler 7y agoIt is absolutely true. I don't know of any current computer that comes close to the low latency of the 8-bit Apple //e for example. Here's a survey: https://www.extremetech.com/computing/261148-modern-computers-struggle-match-input-latency-apple-iie https://www.extremetech.com/computing/261148-modern-computer... That survey shows that the Apple //e latency from keypress to screen display of 30 milliseconds is something current computers don't even approach, even though their processors are far faster. Here's another article: https://www.pcgamer.com/the-latency-problem-why-modern-gaming-pcs-are-slower-than-an-apple-ii/ https://www.pcgamer.com/the-latency-problem-why-modern-gamin... Of course there are reasons for this. We demand a lot more functionality. But there are costs to the functionality. In addition, most systems are not designed to minimize latency or jitter. I believe we could do a lot better, but it would require that more hardware and software developers care about it.
- WaltPurvis 7y ago"There's no reason for Twitter to use a mouse. There's nothing mousey about this website, not a damn thing twitter: i need to navigate through a linear list and perform one of four actions on discrete items, almost all text-based" He's apparently never bothered to learn Twitter's built-in keyboard shortcuts. You can do almost everything on Twitter without touching a mouse.
- oneeyedpigeon 7y agoAny reference? Closest I can find on Twitter's site itself is this [1] but the second shortcut (l to like) doesn't work for me. [1] https://help.twitter.com/en/using-twitter/how-to-tweet https://help.twitter.com/en/using-twitter/how-to-tweet Edit: OK, it works, when you use default keyboard controls (e.g. tab) to select the tweet first. I'd assumed it would work from a 'single tweet' page without having to do anything else first. Overall, looks promising, but not as nice as the keyboard controls in gmail, for example.
- Aaronstotle 7y agoI worked at a Fry's for about a month, this was back in 2014 and they were phasing out the blazing fast POS system he mentions and moving to a web based one. Nearly every employee hated it and it made everything much slower.
- ktm5j 7y ago> one of the things that makes me steaming mad is how the entire field of web apps ignores 100% of learned lessons from desktop apps I can't agree with this enough. The whole of web development in general really grinds my gears these days. Stacking one half-baked technology on top of another, using at least 3 different languages to crap out a string of html that then gets rendered by a browser. Using some node module for every small task, leaving yourself with completely unauditable interdependent code that could be hijacked by a rogue developer at any moment. And to top it all off now we're using things like Electron to make "native" apps for phones and desktops. It seems so ass-backwards. This current model is wasteful of computing resources and provides a generally terrible user experience. And it just seems to get worse as time passes. :/
- themagician 7y agoI’ve gone back to making simple HTML pages for all sorts of projects. Even trying to avoid CSS when possible. It’s funny, in a way, because the “problem” with straight HTML is that it was straight hierarchical (and thus vertical) and so a lot of space was wasted on wide desktop displays. We used tables and the later CSS to align elements horizontally. Now on phones straight html ends up being a very friendly and fast user experience. A simple paragraph tag with a bunch of text and a little padding works great.
- NerdFlanders 7y agoWhat a pointless rant. I somehow was expecting something along the lines of "less delay in actions" but got some guy rambling about how he hates gmaps and mice.
- arpa 7y agoSo you hate the mouse. Mouse is an benevolent dictator. It tries to help. You want to know who Stalin is? Fucking touchscreens. You're blind? Fuck you. You have Parkinsons? Off to the death camp you go. You want to type in your pocket while paying zero attention to the poison screen which is taken up by half by an idiotic keyboard on which you will continuously mistype and be moronically autocorrected to a point where you WILL LONG FOR THE GOOD OLD DAYS OF TYPING WITH T9 - enjoy the bullet to the back of your head you sexual deviant. You will drag, pinch, stretch, lick the glossy oh-so-fragile glass screen, you will fucking obey the tech giants that want your eyes glued to the screen so you can see more ads until you lose it and start loving the uncaring big brother and all the pain you are brought from him. Mice are evil. Pshaw.
- MadWombat 7y ago"amber-screen library computer in 1998: type in two words and hit F3. search results appear instantly" Bullshit. The search results appear instantly if you are searching a small text file in an editor. But if your app is actually fetching the data from somewhere, a dBase database on a network disk mounted from a Netware server, good luck. You type your words, you hit the search key and then you wait. There is no indication that anything is actually happening, no spinning things, not progress indicator, nothing. You cannot do anything while you wait either (multitasking is not a thing in DOS, remember?), you just sit and wait there hoping for the best. And this is an application that is trying to keyword search few megabytes of data over a local network. Not an application doing a fuzzy search on hundreds of terabytes of data across half a planet...
- CrankyBear 7y agoExactly so. I used those computers back in the day. I actually designed library software in the 80s. Users today would go crazy waiting for the hard drive a 10Mbps Ethernet connection away to slowly pull data out of dBase database.
- foreigner 7y agoThis especially drives my crazy about my phone. I'm not talking about using it as a web browser or handheld computer, just basic phone functionality like making a call. It's so damn slow! WHY?
- tartoran 7y agoBloat
- tom_ 7y agoAs somebody that actually uses a computer from 1983, i question the conclusion. The speed of modern pcs is surprisingly bad, relatively speaking, but this mainly just means they aren't as much ridiculously quicker as they probably should be. (The main issue cited is not meaningful, in my view, as computers from 1983 just couldn't do graphical maps at interactive frame rates at all.)
- Vaslo 7y agoI don’t know, I had a Commodore 64 back in the 80s and loading those games was painful
- dmead 7y agoi got really annoyed when new motherboards starting not including ps/2 ports for keyboard and mice. not surprising my railgun accuracy in quake 3 started to decline in quake 3 after that. I blame the ports.
- jcadam 7y agoHey, the purpose of a computer is to consume electricity while running IA-mandated corporate policy enforcement and virus scanning software. That we provide users with monitors and input devices so that they can use any remaining spare CPU cycles on whatever machines just happen to be located near their desks to help themselves do their "jobs" is just icing on the cake. They should be grateful if opening a modestly-sized word document takes less than 10 seconds.
- ttctciyf 7y ago> Suppose during my regular game development everyday life I've installed Photoshop recently and I want a look at a screenshot of the game - someone reported a problem or something. > So I double-click on the thing ... one ... two ... three ... four ... five ... six ... it's about seven seconds before I can actually see the image. [...] > So that's really slow and I'm going to talk about that for a bit, but there's an element of severe irony to this which is that as soon as I double click this thing within one second it draws an image and it's a pretty high resolution interesting image. It's just not the image that I care about. > So obviously it's not hard to start a process and draw an image on the screen in much less than seven seconds. They just don't manage that. > Now. I gave a speech a year ago that started this same way. That was 2016. It's now 2017 and of course a new version of Photoshop has come out and of course what will align directly with my point in the next few slides: they've made it worse. And the great way in which they've made it worse is: say there's some operation that you want to do maybe once in a while like create a new image... So I'm going to go to file, new ... Urghh. And that menu takes - it probably takes about a second to come up. > And you might think "Oh, well, you know it was just all these assets were cold or something.. Maybe they come off the hard drive. It'll be faster next time." And it's like: "Well, let's test that out. Nope." Like every time. I'll use the keyboard shortcuts. File. New. Nyeaarghh. [...] > Imagine if the people who programmed this were trying to make VR games. Everybody would be vomiting everywhere all the time. > Well what machine am I running this on? It's actually a pretty fast machine, it's a Razer Blade laptop with a pretty high-end i7 in it, and you can talk about how fast the CPU is or the GPU is and some arbitrary measurement and I'm going to discuss CPU speeds here and I want to say in advance that none of what I'm about to say is meant to be precise or precise measurements. I'm making a general point. > And the general point is that the CPU of this thing would have been approximately the fastest computer in the world when I was in college. Or the GPU would have been the fastest computer in the world in the year 2000 or thereabouts. > Now you might say "That's a really long time ago. This is ancient Stone Age." Well. Photoshop was released in 1990 before either of those dates. And Photoshop 6, which I used heavily during my earlier days in game development is from the year 2000. And this is what it looks like. This is a screenshot of Photoshop 6. It's got all the same UI that Photoshop has today. It's got all these same control widgets and it's got our layers and channels and all that stuff. Today the UI is a different colour but apart from that it's essentially the same program. > Now I don't doubt that it has many more features. But you have to ask how many more features are there and what level of slowdown does that justify? - Jonathan Blow, Reboot Develop 2017: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=De0Am_QcZiQ&t=155 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=De0Am_QcZiQ&t=155
- rticesterp 7y agoI was driving across country, became tired and had to check-in at a roadside motel a few weeks ago. It was 3AM and the clerk took about 15 minutes to complete the check-in. She apologized several times and said "this was so much faster back years ago when we had DOS. There's too many clicks, screen freezes and confirmation with the newer computers". She was older so I'm assuming by newer she means POS systems built within the past 20 years
- awinter-py 7y agoThe maps feedback is spot on -- as a consumer I want a decision support tool that helps me run searches reliably and quickly. I think G wants to show me a maximum of three things at once so they can optimize ad clicks. G maps had the option to be excel and instead chose to be the bottom shelf of the cereal aisle. It's fine to treat your users like consumers instead of power users, but that opens a hole in the market for a city-aware, mobile-friendly GIS tool.
- peter_retief 7y agoAbsolutely agree, I remember when hospital clinical data was captured by keyboard hotkeys with no mice. It was quick to learn and lightning fast to capture and search. Along came progress in the form of a visual basic frontend. Network traffic escalated, frozen screens became common, data was corrupted, the computer that was supposed to save time sucked up the energy of busy professionals. This was 30 years ago and it is still in use.
- coupdejarnac 7y agoThe human condition in a nutshell. We have to relearn the same lessons every 20 to 30 years and probably much more often in the software world. Progress is mostly sideways instead of forward.
- AStellersSeaCow 7y agoTo call this rose-tinted glasses when considering how things worked in 1983 is a massive understatement. A counterexample: in 1983, enter two search terms, one of them slightly misspelled or misremembered, hit f3: "no results", spend 10 minutes trying to find the needle in the haystack, give up and physically search for the thing yourself. Enter two search terms slightly incorrectly now: no of the time it will know exactly what you want, may even autocorrect a typo locally, get your accurate search results in a second. When things were faster 30+ years ago (and they absolutely were NOT the vast majority of the time, this example cherry picked one of the few instances that they were), it was because the use case was hyperspecific, hyperlocalized to a platform, and the fussy and often counterintuitive interfaces served as guard rails. The article has absolutely valid points on ways UIs have been tuned in odd ways (often to make them usable, albeit suboptimally, for the very different inputs of touch and mouse), but the obsession about speed being worse now borders on quixotic. Software back then was, at absolute best, akin to a drag racer - if all you want to do it move 200 meters in one predetermined direction then sometimes is was fine. Want to go 300 meters, or go in a slightly different direction, or don't know how to drive a drag racer? Sorry, need to find a different car/course/detailed instruction manual.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoSoftware in the 80s was: extremely low throughput but excellent latency. We could really do better on the latter category here in the 21st century.
- qxga 7y agoPart of that was the widespread use low-resolution, high refresh rate, zero-latency (CRT) monitors, and the use of hardware interrupts instead of a serial bus for input.
- romwell 7y agoAll of this is absolutely no excuse for the ridiculously high latency everywhere now. Want to give me fancy autocorrect? Fine. But first: * Make a UI with instant feedback, which doesn't wait on your autocorrect * Give me exact results instantly before your autocorrect kicks in * Run your fancy slow stuff in the background if resources are available * Update results when you get them... if I didn't hit "enter" and got away from you before that. It's not that complicated. We've got the technology. And also, there's still no fucking reason a USB keyboard/mouse should be more laggy than their counterparts back in the day.
- rayiner 7y agoComputers jumped the shark in 1998. I remember dual-booting NT4 and BeOS on a PII 300 MHz with 64MB of RAM. Connected to a 256 kbps SDSL modem, it’s the best computing experience I’ve ever had. You could do everything you can on a modern machine. Indeed, even more, because the modern versions of software like OneNote and Word are neutered compared to the ‘97 versions. It feels like all of this effort has been spent making computer interfaces worse. The only improvement I can point to between MFC and a modern web UI is DPI scalability. Besides that, there are tons of regressions, from keyboard accessibility to consistency in look, feel, and operation.
- geogra4 7y agoYes, that late 90s/early 2000s nirvana. I could perfectly browse the web and write documents and send emails on a PowerMac G3 without too much fuss. Only things like photo/video/audio manipulation were really lacking from machines at the time compared to today.
- Multicomp 7y agoI don't know if it's the baby duck syndrome, rose tinted glasses, or 'back-in-my-day-ism', but I agree with you wholeheartedly. Computing for me peaked in about 2002-2005 (I'm young, sorry), coasted okay until about 2010, then began gaining weight until today where I have a sense that computing latency is like a type 2 diabetic man having his midlife crisis. Either he loses some weight, or he has a heart attack and dies. I agree on your point re: number crunching for rendering videos, manipulating photos, audio DSP etc.
- ptx 7y agoMFC UIs will scale if you use dialog units and configure the manifest to disable auto-scaling, won't they? I guess I'll soon find out what the problems with it were, as I'm working on a Winforms app that currently runs in auto-scaled blurry mode.
- dddddaviddddd 7y agoI've considered using a PowerBook G3 as my main computer, but there are two practical limitations: can't get new batteries, and no support for modern cyphers/encryption.
- bluSCALE4 7y agoThey guy hates the commoditized web. Get in line. It's not about what you want, it's about what the service you're using is trying to sell you.
- annoyingnoob 7y agoWhen I worked on an IBM mainframe, everything we did had a guaranteed response time built-in. We had to plan and engineer the required response time. Seems like we have forgotten to care about response time.
- arminiusreturns 7y agoComing from the ops side and as a user, I blame a focus on abstractions away from fundamentals that lure new and old developers alike into overcomplicating stacks. For example, I would say some significant percentage of both websites and electron-style apps don't need anything other than pure HTML5+CSS3. Javascript only if necessary. Not here are 5 different Javascript frameworks! Of course there are cases where a framework is applicable, but I'm talking about the vast majority of cases. Then on top of all that are 20+ javascripts advertising and spying per page and pages become unusable without a good js blocker (umatrix is my favorite). Some of this is technical and some of it is business, either way developers need to focus on the fundamentals and pushback against dark patterns. Now on the desktop side, this is also why I am a CLI junky who lives in a terminal. CLI apps don't get in the way, because most of the time you are just dealing with text anyway. There are many websites that ought to be a cli app at least via api. This is also one of my criticisms of companies trying to force people into the browser by disallowing api clients. It was the constant bloat and spying that finally spurred me to go gnu/linux only many years ago, and things are only getting better since then. It requires a change in how you do your computing, yes. It may not be easy (higher learning curve), but the rewards are worth it.
- microtherion 7y agoThe author must have lived in a different 1983 from me. I remember Commodore BASIC freezing up for a minute to perform garbage collection on its 30K of heap if you created too many temp strings. The C-beams glittering in the dark were pretty cool, though.
- dang 7y agoDiscussed yesterday as explained here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21835519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21835519
- domador 7y agoIronically, this rant is posted in chunks on Twitter, making it hard to actually read it in a fluid manner. How about a blog post with paragraphs instead?
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoI used to know a computer music academic who used to attempt to run FFT convolution and other DSP processes on an Atari ST. One time he started a process, went away on holiday for two weeks, and it was still running when he got back. These days it would be much faster than real time - not just native, but in a web browser.
- mtm7 7y agoRelated: I was bored last Sunday, so I decided to install Sublime Text. I'm normally a VS Code user, but VS Code is built on Electron and it felt a little sluggish for certain files, so I wanted to give something else a try. I've been using Sublime all week and it feels like an engineering masterpiece. Everything is instantly responsive. It jumps between files without skipping a beat. My battery lasts longer. (I don't want to turn this into an editor debate, though. Just a personal example.) If you would've asked me a month ago, I would've said that engineers cared too much about making things performant to the millisecond. Now, I would say that many of them don't care enough. I want every application to be this responsive. I never realized how wasteful web tech was until I stopped using it. And I guess you could say the same for a lot of websites – we bloat everything with node_modules and unnecessary CSS and lose track of helping our users accomplish their goals.
- efdee 7y agoWeird to compare an IDE and a text editor, though.
- pmarin 7y agoVS CODE [1] is a text editor. Visual Studio [2] is the IDE. [1] https://code.visualstudio.com/ https://code.visualstudio.com/ [2] https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/vs/ https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/vs/
- efdee 7y agoVS Code has Intellisense, an integrated debugger, and much more. What makes it not an IDE?
- NoGravitas 7y agoVS Code and Sublime Text are comparable, though: they're both extensible text editors, not real IDEs.
- SAI_Peregrinus 7y agoVS Code ~= VS. It's a text editor, not an IDE (unless you consider things like VIM to be IDEs because you can use plugins to do IDE-like stuff with them.)
- 333c 7y agoAs I scrolled through this, using my mouse to click the heart on a number of the tweets, I really understood the point he makes about actions that don't need to use a mouse. When I program in vim and run things on the command line, I don't use my mouse. Even when I browse Reddit, I don't (often) use my mouse because of the RES extension, which lets me browse with keyboard shortcuts. I haven't really thought about how much easier things generally are when I'm not using my mouse, and I wish there were a similar extension for other websites. Does such an extension exist for Twitter, or for HN?
- sproketboy 7y agoWho cares what a faggot commie says?
- lez 7y agoReading through the comments it would seem that the article is a false alarm. The count of upvotes dictates the opposite. My opinion is that the baseline for what we achieve as good (and quick) service has been slowly lift up by the industry. At the same time specific design practices were implemented to ease our frustration about slow service, and "feel" at least that the service is quick.
- krick 7y agoIt's a common trend. Headline with a popular opinion says something a typical HN user is inclined to agree without even reading it, so there will be a bunch of upvotes and some "me too" comments (disguised as personal anecdotes). But those who actually clicked on the link will find a number of issues with the content of it and will tell about it here. And here we are, lots of likes and comments suggesting it isn't really worth attention.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- strathmeyer 7y agoBefore web tracking webpages would load instantly.
- donohoe 7y agoIn December of 2018, the average news article took 24 seconds to load, consumed 3.58MB of your data plan, and Google scored it a Speed Index value of 11,721 (a Speed Index of 3,000 or lower is considered good). It has gotten worse this year.
- christopoulos 7y agoI feel like it’s a behavior encouraged by Googles Material design or derived projects: slide details in and out of the screen (google maps pin details, for example), hide input boundaries (no border on search text input fields), tons of sporadically placed spinners. I really dislike that tendency in design and behavior and find it counterproductive.
- tikiman163 7y agoJesus Christ on a cracker people, are you all really this stupid? The difference between 1983 and 2017 is the magnitude of information and functionality. In 1983, a whole MB of ram was what super computers ran on. Your average desktop typically had around 2 KB of ram. My desktop today runs 16 GB, that's 8 million times more data. First of all, when data sets start to get that big it becomes a monumental task to organize just the execution order of the compiled code. Second, the main thing the bitch from the article is complaining about not being able to do is something you just can't do from the phone UI. Google has a trip planner app that specifically helps locate interesting landmarks between the start and destination points, and even plan where to stop for gas or find a hotel for the night all from a single tab. For having spent so long writing his rant, I'm surprised he never tried googling a trip planner app. It would have been faster and prevented him from proving what an idiot he is.
- ksaj 7y agoI got a Raspberry Pi 4 with 4G of RAM. It is so much faster at booting and logging in than my Mac Pro, by far. And that Mac Pro has a whole lot more cores and memory, etc. How much LESS am I getting out of of the Raspberry Pi? I'm not exactly sure. I just know I can reboot in seconds and get back online while my Mac is still be showing that stupid grey logo screen. Of course, the Raspberry Pi can't come close to running Logic Audio and 5 virtual machines simultaneously doing other things in the background as I generally do on that Mac. But the boot up to useful state speed metric favours the much lower spec'd device by far. For daily stuff like going from OFF to editing an office document, the Mac is sloth slow. It's a very interesting and wide divergence of competencies when it comes to performance and ability. We are definitely witnessing the later part of the Law of Diminished Returns when it comes to updating and upgrading computer equipment. I can't say whether or not we've reached the apex, but we sure are close if we haven't. Today, anyone can have a super computer. But nearly nobody does.
- elproxy 7y agoExplained before the advent of computers as Jevons’ Paradox
- msla 7y agoI don't know, I can compile code perceptually instantly and get optimizations which perceptually instant compilers didn't do in 1983. I know that Turbo Pascal was very fast when it came to compiling Pascal, and I certainly appreciate the effort which went into making that happen, but Turbo Pascal didn't turn string handling code into SIMD operations after turning a recursive function into an unrolled loop. Partly, this was due to the fact the IBM PC did not have SIMD operations in 1983, but the rest is because modern compilers run complex optimization passes in tiny fractions of a second. Also, I'd like to see this person say that operations on computers were perceptually instant while logged into a PDP-11/70 or (let's be a tad generous) a VAX-11/780 with a half-dozen other people all trying to use it at the same time. Yes, faster computers existed in 1983. Didn't mean the likes of you got to use them.