23 ms·
How Complex Modern Headlights Can Be
- clouddrover 7y agoAudi's latest headlights are essentially projectors and fast enough to run animations: https://www.engadget.com/2019/11/19/audi-e-tron-headlight-tech/ https://www.engadget.com/2019/11/19/audi-e-tron-headlight-te...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mnw21cam 7y agoYeah, no. Not agreeing to that. Could someone please sue engadget/Verizon for GDPR violation?
- globular-toast 7y agoFrom a road user's point of view, Audi's headlights are my least favourite. In the UK, emergency vehicles use blue lights. If you see a blue light it is unambiguous and you can be sure that an emergency vehicle needs to get by. Seeing a blue flicker in the peripheral vision will therefore demand your attention. However, so many times this blue flicker turns out to be Audi headlights. I know what they are doing but whatever it is it's too clever. Cars are far too dangerous to play around with this nonsense.
- ken 7y agoSubtitle: "But, we won’t get it in the US." It's amazing to me that carmakers can introduce features on headlights "so as not to blind oncoming drivers" -- as if they know they've been blinding us for years. It also suggests these headlights might not have the functionality to keep from blinding drivers ahead of them. My rear view mirror has a dimming switch, but my side mirrors don't. I would avoid driving at night entirely if I could, but in the winter that's simply not feasible. What am I supposed to do when traffic blinds me? Is it legal to wear an auto-dimming welding hood behind the wheel?
- zuppy 7y ago... but this is not what they are saying. They would be blinding you with the high beams, which will always be on now, unless they wouldn't have come with the system that brings blind spots around incoming/other traffic. This is the quote from the article: "This allows for things like keeping your high beams on without blinding oncoming drivers" I would advise you to go check an oftalmologist and not trying to be an asshole. I don't have this problem.
- cesarb 7y ago> My rear view mirror has a dimming switch, but my side mirrors don't. Aren't side mirrors being replaced by cameras?
- black6 7y agoInstead of a piece of silvered glass which requires no power input and always works? K.I.S.S.
- Luuseens 7y agoKeep in mind that you lose some of your ability to judge the distance with camera/screen setup due to no depth perception. There are no 3D camera+display setups that I'm aware of yet.
- bluGill 7y agoI understand they are in Europe, but in the US regulators demand the simple always works mirrors. This is of course subject to change as different pros/cons become known.
- magduf 7y agoNo, at least not in the US. It doesn't matter if cameras are better and safer, the US regulators won't allow it for decades if ever.
- a3n 7y agoAhem. Semi truck driver here. Enough drivers to notice leave their brights on when approaching me from behind. I think that they think I can't see the lights because I have no rear window and a big trailer. I have six big side mirrors, three on each side, and unless you're tailgating me (a rant for another day) your lights are shining into my eyes like a police interrogation. Dim them down, thank you very much.
- Junk_Collector 7y agoIt's almost funny that it's not permitted in the US because the technology behind the headlights are from Texas Instruments.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoStart counting up all the different components along with their various failure modes and you quickly realize these are not systems you want to be responsible for keeping in working order much beyond its designed lifespan.
- michaelt 7y agoI got an airport transfer in a car with smart headlights a few weeks ago. It was pretty neat - when the road was quiet it lit the road quite broadly, but when there was oncoming traffic it would deactivate the 'pixels' that could have dazzled the oncoming driver. I also got the impression it cast extra light at road signs (although maybe the route I was driven just had very well lit signs) My country gets dark at 4pm at this time of year, so driving in rural areas involves a lot of switching between main beam and dip beam - and getting mad at oncoming drivers who don't switch early enough. So these smart headlights seem like a good thing!
- gdrulia 7y agoWhile I bet they work brilliantly for the driver of the car, for the oncoming traffic it's really annoying. It leaves light spots in my eyes every time I drive in the night and encounter cars with such headlights, as it doesn't deactivate those 'pixels' quick enough for me not to notice. Overall it might be an improvement, but it depends on your situation. As for extra light at road signs, I believe I've read somewhere that newish signs have ability to reflect near ultraviolet as visible light, and this makes them extra reflective for headlights with ultraviolet range, more so then what you would expect for the given visible light that you see. Although I'm no expert in this and not sure if that actually the reason for why some signs popout so much.
- dr_orpheus 7y agoYes, lots of modern road signs that are put in have a flourescent coating on them. [1] [1] https://www.3m.com/3M/en_US/road-safety-us/resources/road-transportation-safety-center-blog/full-story/~/fluorescent-traffic-signs-explained/?storyid=e33bd3e0-36b0-44c0-b416-1b87324b2755 https://www.3m.com/3M/en_US/road-safety-us/resources/road-tr...
- y4mi 7y agoEspecially good for pedestrians and bikers which aren't detected by their shitty smart features. And the drivers long since forgot how to actually do it manually
- dajohnson89 7y agoI don't miss owning (maintaining) a car.
- ddorian43 7y agoThis highly depends on where you live.
- dingaling 7y agoWe have a ten-year-old car and the only complexity in the headlamps is a ratchet to adjust vertical and horizontal axes whilst in a garage. More modern cars are becoming so complex so quickly that I am reluctant to embrace one even if full EV. Car reviews that state "packed full of technology" are like a warning sign to stay clear.
- bluGill 7y ago> More modern cars are becoming so complex so quickly that I am reluctant to embrace one [snip]. Car reviews that state "packed full of technology" are like a warning sign to stay clear. People have been saying that since that 1980s at least. Today cars are more reliable than ever, and complexity is part of how they got there.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sterwill 7y agoMy 2006 Mazda MX-5 is super reliable and has very little modern car "technology"--the kind that requires firmware updates, Internet connectivity, phone apps, paid software upgrades, etc. I'm not claiming there isn't complexity in its design, just that the subsystems behind the driving and comfort controls are simple and reliable. The switches are physical buttons and they toggle pins on a microcontroller or make/break a relay contact. This is so much better than poking through touch panel menus.
- 7y ago
- durnygbur 7y agoI hope the bright rectangle and other dynamic features will not blind me when having this insanely complex headlights behing my back, or heading me from the left side, or... actually the stricter road regulations regarding headlights in US are not a bad thing at all.
- blakesterz 7y agoSome of this stuff isn't available in the US yet, I caught this... "Again, it’s worth mentioning that here in America, a land comprehensively crisscrossed with thousands of miles of dark back roads and a whole nation’s worth of wandering deer, this technology is bafflingly illegal." Apparently they're working on it, here's something from last year that says "coming soon"... https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2018/10/nhtsa-proposes-new-headlight-rules-automakers-ready-to-rock/ https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2018/10/nhtsa-proposes-new... "One one hand, this proposed change should help lousy drivers from burning out your retinas on a lonesome country road. But, by the same token, you may no longer have the delicious opportunity to blast them with the brights once they’re within a few feet of your car to let them know to lower those damned high beams."
- sys_64738 7y agoK.I.S.S. Do they never learn?
- robohoe 7y agoNo wonder most headlights cost up to (or even more in some cases) $2000.
- NightlyDev 7y agoLazerlights are freaking expensive. Well above $10k was normal a few years ago.
- linuxftw 7y agoMore technology nobody asked for driving up the price of automobiles. We can expect the 'safety' lobby to ensure this tech is mandatory in all new vehicles, driving up the baseline price of automobiles once again.
- pure-awesome 7y agoThis seems so much more complex than it needs to be. Basic solutions are consistent, predictable, reliable, cheap, repairable, replaceable. Surely there are simpler solutions to the "blinding headlights" problem?
- grumple 7y agoThat was already mentioned in the article - you turn them off. Short of that, no, you’ll have to have headlights that direct themselves away from cars. You could also have some auto-tint on windshields, or drive using some advanced heads up display instead of using your vision directly.
- pure-awesome 7y agoSorry, I don't completely follow. What was mentioned? That there are no simpler solutions to blinding headlights? The article is very positive about these complex headlights - the only negative mentioned is the price. I, on the other hand, am quite doubtful about them. There is so much you have to get right to have them run consistently. Such a complex piece of equipment is more likely to break or go wrong in some way, or e.g. perhaps misjudge the wrong thing as being a car and so switch off at an inappropriate time. Is there a manual override, at least? GPS that takes into account road curvature? That doesn't sound sufficiently fast and accurate. I'll admit I am ignorant of the tech. It is entirely possible this has all been taken into account, and it works well, and the risk/benefit does work out. Otherwise they probably wouldn't be rolling it out. My experience with complex computerised systems and software, including in cars, leads me to be distrustful. And there are innumerable instances of advanced technological systems being peddled where the good old fashioned manual way just works better. I say this not as an old Luddite, but as a relatively young software developer. But hey, reliable software can be built, and has shown itself to be useful in many instances. I'd need to do more investigation to come to a proper conclusion, but my first instinct is to be doubtful. EDIT: They don't need to work perfectly. The main question is just, do they work better than humans on average and when it's important?
- macNchz 7y agoDespite all the innovation in the headlights themselves, it seems that a significant portion of drivers these days can’t seem to remember to turn them on. I am constantly trying to get cars in front of me on the highways near NYC to realize their lights are off at night. It’s an interesting study in UX, I think: https://www.autotrader.com/car-news/heres-why-so-many-cars-drive-around-their-headlights-night-265587 https://www.autotrader.com/car-news/heres-why-so-many-cars-d...
- lloeki 7y agoI’m borderline thinking the secret agenda behind daytime running lamps is actually not related to daytime at all. Many (all?) modern cars have an auto mode for night lights but it seems to endlessly baffle people as to how they work. At some point it seems you can throw all the UX you want, some are hell bent to skip on being attentive to basic driving safety anyway.
- rob74 7y agoFortunately (at least where I'm living) automatic headlights are already more widespread than the fancy "matrix-lighting" headlights, for the simple reason that a light sensor on the windshield is cheaper than two state-of-the-art headlights. But, I confess, if anybody would move the switch from "Auto" to "Off" on my car, I might join the people driving without lights for some time before I would notice it...
- empath75 7y agoI have kids that like to play with switches and it has happened to me a couple of times.
- lagadu 7y agoI'm like that too. Furthermore I have a story about that: A couple months ago I found myself driving a car that didn't have automatic windshield wipers. I drove in the rain for a couple of minutes without turning them on and only realized what was happening by the time I asked myself "why can't I see anything?".
- 7y ago
- uptown 7y agoPerhaps it's just my eyes getting older, or changes to headlight tech and/or car design is a contributing factor, but modern headlights at night seem more blinding than I ever remember them being in the past.
- LMYahooTFY 7y agoI'm with you, and the worst part is the color temperature. Between brightness and this ridiculous fad of high Kelvin blue headlights, driving at night on the highways of major traffic areas is awful. It's the luminous equivalent of people who utterly ignore decibel limits of their vehicles to the detriment of pedestrian ears. I wonder about the high Kelvin headlights causing retinal damage, there is some research I recall reading about related to blue light filters. To think we'll all be blinder and deafer for this is quite agitating.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoWhat's frustrating is there's actually a very elegant solution to this problem, but it requires buy-in from all manufacturers. If you use polarized glass at 45 degrees for both headlights and windshields, you effectively cancel out the lights when sitting inside a car (it's not perfect, but they'll be incredibly dim). You could easily adjust it to be brighter (assuming everyone agrees on the standard) if people object to not being able to see oncoming headlights. But it's meaningless unless everyone does it, and it won't work for cars already on the road.
- wffurr 7y agoIt also doesn't work for people not in cars.
- magduf 7y agoThat won't work. The problem with polarized glass is that, by its very nature, it's filtering out ~half the light. This is why cameras don't normally come with polarizing lenses: it'll make them perform worse in low-light situations. So you won't be able to see quite as much, with half the light blocked. Of course, our eyes are logarithmic, so this might not be that big a deal, and it might be worth it, but you'll never get the US government safety agencies to agree to this. They already forbid anything which reduces light transmission through the windshield below the "AS400" line (the optional tint strip near the top). They already won't allow aspheric side mirrors because those "confuse" drivers (even though cars in Europe have them).
- davidmurdoch 7y agoThis is one of the reasons I love my 20 year old car. My wife's 10 year old car's headlight bulb went out. I had to remove the front bumper to get the headlight out to get to the bulb. When I opened the back of the headlight there were bits of colored plastic all over; the insulation on the dozens of wires inside had dried up, cracked, and were flaking off - probably do to the motion of the adaptive lamps, exposing the bare wires. If any of these bare wires shorted out it could easily have started a fire. Both headlights were like this.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>If any of these bare wires shorted out it could easily have started a fire. You misspelled "blown a fuse". Except for the ~1ft run from the battery to fuse box basically everything in a modern vehicle has a fuse preventing it from catching on fire.
- jdsully 7y agoIts quite possible for even fused circuits to cause fires. If there is a high resistance short then it will heat up without drawing enough current to trip the fuse or breaker. I don't know how common this is in cars, but it is quite common in household wiring. It was especially problematic with aluminum wiring used in the 70s but can happen even in copper circuits.
- davidmurdoch 7y agoExcept cars do spontaneously light on fire sometimes: https://abcnews.go.com/US/bmw-recalls-million-vehicles-fire-risk/story?id=50922136 https://abcnews.go.com/US/bmw-recalls-million-vehicles-fire-...
- cj 7y agoSlightly off topic: But to anyone with a new(ish) car: do you constantly get people flashing their brights at you in protest of your "modern" headlights being an order of magnitude more blinding than old headlights?
- black6 7y agoIn my older car I constantly flash other people with "modern" headlights believing the high-beams to be on, when, in fact, it is the low-beams which are blinding me.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThe increasingly tall front bodywork on which the headlights are located certainly isn't helping.
- black6 7y agoAnd, at least where I live, the need for the locals to put lift kits on trucks without some downward adjustment of their headlamps.
- Jamwinner 7y agoIf you are getting flashed, hve the dealer re aim your headlights or reconsider your choice of car. People who blind other drivers should be taken off the road.
- aphit 7y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7q6ORbVApjY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7q6ORbVApjY
- ce4 7y agoYou may want to add some description. Links without any surrounding text are not very helpful.
- GistNoesis 7y agoWhile building my vision-based following robot, I encountered a quite funny phenomenon with its headlights. The robot uses led strips to highlight its path when it detects that the luminosity from the camera is not enough using simple PID control loop. In normal situation, it is working as intended making the robot more robust to illuminations change. But every time the robot crashes into an object or wall, it flashes its headlights like if it is trying to call for attention. What is happening is when it crashes the objects are usually really close to both the leds and the camera so suddenly it hide exterior light and it's very dark for the camera so the robot turns the leds on, but because the objects are so close a lot of light is reflected back and suddenly it's too bright so it turns the leds off and the cycle repeat : My "auto-exposure" control loop couldn't keep up and is no longer stable. The robot had inadvertently acquired a very crude active-light obstacle avoidance / distance sensing system. To add to the complexity of modern headlights, you can now envision that to efficiently exploit this sensor you can plug in a neural network to actively control the headlights to give itself a sense of depth perception. Add multiple robots into the mix and let them evolve a headlight communication strategy/protocol... Here was a little fun dose of complexity to tingle your light-bulb...
- MS90 7y agoThat would certainly be something, especially if we can see car pricing become something like this: Boring sedan, MSRP $25,000, Boring sedan (with AI headlight option), MSRP $1,750,000
- lnanek2 7y ago>> Lamps to be steady-burning >...which effectively rules out dynamic-matrix light systems like Porsche uses. Good! I'm constantly getting flashed by smart headlights and auto-leveling systems that simply don't work well. I wish we could go back to simple lights that work and don't constantly flash me every time another driver hits a bump or their smart algorithms screw up.
- ben7799 7y agoFor sure.. it is not a great hardship to have restrictions on these systems here. These systems are most prevalent on expensive European brands that have terrible reliability ratings. Totally obvious when you see which cars are blinding you too usually.
- NightlyDev 7y agoThis is so insanely true. It is the most annoying thing ever. "Well, it's not supposed to do that..." You don't say!
- magduf 7y agoIt probably isn't "smart" headlights that are flashing you on bumps, those are normal and perfectly "dumb" lights. The problem is that modern headlights are designed to direct much more light downwards, so that you can see the road, and less light upwards, so you don't blind oncoming drivers or waste light directing it into empty space (you need some to see vehicles and obstacles straight ahead of course, but you need more pointed downwards). When the car hits a bump, or crests a hill, then "downwards" becomes pointed directly at oncoming traffic. If anything, quick-reacting "smart" lights would be more helpful here. Generally, when people like you complain about this stuff, what you're really asking for is for everyone to go back to extremely low-output headlights where you couldn't see almost anything at night. I don't see how that's an improvement.
- tsomctl 7y agoMy daily driver has extremely low-output headlights (old school sealed beam headlights). They work great, my eyes adjust to them just fine, except when I'm around other drivers with modern headlights.
- jdsully 7y agoI'd be worried about what happens to the GPS headlights when the map data gets out of date. On my car the out of date maps are now quite noticeable.
- MS90 7y agoOr, say you come up on the scene of an accident where a car has gone off the road at night. You pull your car off the road to illuminate the scene of the accident with your headlights but they stubbornly refuse, turning all the way to max deflection one way or another in an attempt to point at the road. About a month ago I came upon this exact scenario and had to use my headlights to light up the wreck. Wouldn't have been great if they weren't cooperating. Though I'm sure (I hope) there'd be a way to disable the GPS tracking.
- neuralRiot 7y agoThese are just another “feature” to compensate for inattentive drivers, like adaptive cruise control, auto emergency brake, lane assist and so on, the problem is that the less a driver has to pay attention to, the more bored and distracted will be.
- kcolford 7y agoExcept if a driver is performing the same task over and over then they will eventually get bored of it as well, leading to the same distracted end result.
- neuralRiot 7y agoAnyone driving a manual transmission can tell you that an automatic makes you feel bored and less “connected” to the car and road, now you don’t need even to pay attention to oncoming traffic to lower your lights or even brake. Who’s gonna pay less attention?
- magduf 7y agoYou're expecting drivers to be perfectly attentive 100% of the time, and never have any human failings. That's unrealistic.
- buro9 7y agoI've just got back from the Lake District in the UK where I've been driving a 2019 Range Rover Sport. I hired this vehicle just in case the weather conditions demanded it and for driving roads like this: https://www.visitcumbria.com/amb/wrynose-pass/ https://www.visitcumbria.com/amb/wrynose-pass/ What I discovered though, was "Intelligent High Beam"... which was an automatic head light mode that looked (from the driver perspective) like it used an LCD matrix over the high beam. It would fade up from the normal beam, flood the road, and then if a car was in front or approaching it would block out the parts of the scene in which those vehicles were present. It turns out it is this: https://www.osram-continental.com/en/products/smartrix.html https://www.osram-continental.com/en/products/smartrix.html It's something else to have full visibility of the sides of the road (where sheep wandered freely) and still not be blinding anyone in front or oncoming, and to not have to think about it at all. More than that, road signs were singled out and side obstacles made visible... whilst not blinding anyone. Within a couple of days I took this fully for granted, and not a single vehicle we passed flashed their lights at us (which I'd expect if we'd blinded anyone). Now if I buy a car I'd like lights like this.
- Ntrails 7y agoGrowing up in rural England I learned to Drive at night with dipped lights. Most of the roads are single track and the thing I damned well want to know is if something is coming the other direction. I actively control the high beams, raising and lowering in order to allow me to see what's coming and maintaining visibility on the road as appropriate. Automatics just assume you want all the light all the time bar when someone elses lights are already there.
- buro9 7y agoThe lights didn't prevent or reduce that ability.
- Ntrails 7y agoOf course they do. Your ability to see the high tips of light (not a great phrasing, can't think of a better wording) from something around the corner is predicated on it being dark up there. If your own lights are on high, then it isn't and you simply cannot distinguish as early (and this especially applies if the other driver has dipped lights).
- thrower123 7y agoI'm really sick of people taking simple technology that worked well and Rube Goldberging it up into complicated, non-serviceable garbage. I'm seriously considering buying a rebuilt automobile from the 80s or 90s to avoid this kind of crap - they are surprisingly cheap at auction for anything that's not super popular. Also, I'm still baffled that the left-foot stomp pedal for switching between low and high beam settings on headlights went away in favor of yet another thing hanging off the steering wheel. Especially in automatics where you aren't using your clutch foot anyway.
- pierrebai 7y agoHow blinding modern headlights can be. My neighbour onthe other side of the street regularly blinds us in teh kitchen when parking in his driveway. It doesn't help that white or blue is the new default color for new headlights.
- DoctorOetker 7y agoIs there a reason headlights and windshields dont use the properties of circular polarized light? reflections reverse the circular polarization state. standardize the polarization filter on windshields and headlights, and unreflected direct light (from other cars) can be filtered out, while softer diffuse single reflections (from both your own headlights and those of others lighting targets like road etc) pass through the windshield... For cyclists and pedestrians one could make "night glasses" that do the same as the windshields... and similar bicycle headlights with circularly polarized light