4 ms·
Some feminists surely do, but conflating some with all is a fallacy of composition that hinders discussion. Your reasoning in the rest of the comment seems rath
by anigbrowl 7y ago
Some feminists surely do, but conflating some with all is a fallacy of composition that hinders discussion. Your reasoning in the rest of the comment seems rather questionable and veers into seeming even more like a generalization.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- taneq 7y agoI thought we’d decided “not all X” arguments were inadmissible?
- Quarrelsome 7y agonot all Hacker News posters are full of shit? Help out, I'm kinda lost now.
- twic 7y agoThis is untrue rather than inadmissible.
- wongarsu 7y agoHowever GP didn't say "all feminists", only "feminists". If I say "Germans eat bread for breakfast" that's generally understood to mean "In general Germans eat bread for breakfast" or "A majority of Germans eat bread for breakfast". Treating it as if I said "Every German eats bread for every breakfast" would be constructing a straw man. People generally understand that there is variation in every group, even if they don't explicitly put that disclaimer on every sentence.
- jarekkruk 7y agoIt is not exactly comparable. Prostitution is an important issue in feminism. Statement "environmentalists support nuclear power" would be a better analogy, because many environmentalists are for nuclear power and many are against.
- anigbrowl 7y agoI'm not convinced the comment I replied to is a valid generalization capturing what the majority of feminists believe.
- jandrese 7y agoThere's even a well known shorthand for the subset of feminists that carve out exceptions for sex workers: SWERF. Sex Worker Exclusionary Radical Feminist. This is not a new issue.