4 ms·
You've missed a fairly large FOR - people who support freedom & liberty. The arguments against prostitution centre around its second order effects on greater s
by roenxi 7y ago
You've missed a fairly large FOR - people who support freedom & liberty. The arguments against prostitution centre around its second order effects on greater society and is a crime with hypothetical rather than actual victims.
The argument that there should be a victim of some sort before criminalising something is compelling. It is difficult to argue that the prostitutes feel they are victims of prostitution without discovering that other crimes are already being committed without criminalising prostitution.
I have a much easier times justifying criminalising alcohol from principles than it is to argue against criminalising prostitutes, so I don't see why the one with obviously terrible second order effects is considered to be OK and not the other. We have to accept that we already tolerate a level of background things-slipping-through-the-cracks for the sake of liberty and general comfort.
- istjohn 7y agoFreedom and liberty is one argument for legalization, but I don't think there are enough hard core Libertarians to be a major force in this debate.
- roenxi 7y agoIt isn't a particularly hard-core position. They aren't a major force in the debate but there will be a very substantial demographic who don't care one way or the other but are in principle happy to leave well enough alone. They'd probably have a mild preference for not arresting people for no reason. Prostitution has been legal in Australia since around the 90s. Nobody particularly cares^. The only people who it has implications for are people who choose to be involved. ^ Ie, it doesn't crop up in politics as an issue. Lots of people care. Nobody is making a big deal about it.
- istjohn 7y agoI agree it's not a hard core libertarian position. I guess I just meant I don't think there are that many people who consult their libertarian principles to decide their views on an issue.
- jessaustin 7y agoOne might speculate that libertarian principles are only held by a small number of people, but why would such principles not play just as important role in decision-making as other principles, like e.g. judgmental moralism? Do freedom lovers feel less deeply than freedom haters?
- istjohn 7y agoAs a rule? Yes. The religious right is a far more powerful force in American politics than Libertarianism.
- bitwize 7y agoThey will be outnumbered and shouted down by conservative Christians on one side and radical feminists on the other, who will raise a panic that legalizing prostitution will lead to sin and debauchery/women being exploited, respectively. This is a MUCH bigger problem in the US than in Australia.
- imtringued 7y agoUsually women are fighting for more or the same rights. Why would they fight to restrict their own rights?
- tumetab1 7y agoMaybe you can check the feminist movement history. For example, many were against abortion for various reasons, one of them was that it allowed men to pressure them to get one. You can read prostitution legalization as a right to choose to use your own body for profit or you can read prostitution banning as the right for not being used for profit from your body. Many imagine is a simple thing but all the other values come into play. Some people think a embryon is more important that a women choice. Some think that right to sell your body is more important than to legally allow women oppression through sex work.