3 ms·
Here's an idea. Instead of a two stage question and answer format, add a third stage. First is the question from a regular user like me. Second stage is someone
by analog31 7y ago
Here's an idea. Instead of a two stage question and answer format, add a third stage. First is the question from a regular user like me. Second stage is someone with more knowledge re-phrases the question. Third is the answer. This would create a growing body of well-asked questions and good answers.
- mark-r 7y agoThe problem is that stage 2 is impossible. The thing that makes the question unanswerable is missing information, or a genuine misunderstanding on the part of the asker. It's very rare for phrasing to be the problem.
- gumoro 7y agoSometimes the asker is missing a concept, and it's not always impossible to comment about it and rephrase the question to make it answerable & more useful to keep for posterity. It's far from the majority of questions, but not awfully rare either. Some of those are worth salvaging.
- mark-r 7y agoIf you understand enough of the question to rephrase it, you probably understand it well enough to answer it too. Adding a middle step just gets in the way. I've answered questions like that, and it's gratifying when it turns out your understanding was correct.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoAnd it is terribly annoying when someone changes the question and it no longer leads towards an answer that is useful for the asker.
- gumoro 7y agoYes, that's why I thought OP's idea of explicitly separating the derived "better" questions interesting, instead of allowing anyone to edit the original question and steer the discussion in a different direction. This is an interesting format that leaves room for multiple directions to explore… which SO does not want to do as they insist so much on focus.
- gumoro 7y agoI upvoted because I find the idea of an explicit third stage interesting. But SO does offer the ability for experts to edit questions already, in order to keep the simple Q&A format with two stages, so it's "by design". I'm not arguing which design is better... I'd actually like to see your idea implemented :)