9 ms·
The article includes an interesting note at the end: > “I am skeptical of the ability to license advanced nuclear reactors and deploy them on a scale that woul
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
The article includes an interesting note at the end:
> “I am skeptical of the ability to license advanced nuclear reactors and deploy them on a scale that would make a difference for climate change,” adds Fetter. “But I think it’s worth exploring because they’re a centralized form of carbon-free electricity and we don’t have a lot of those available.” At least in the US, it might be the only way nuclear power gets another chance.
I think that's a fair assessment. It's probably not going to make a lot of difference but it is still interesting to explore and invest in.
Regarding solar and battery, mass production capacity is basically the biggest hurdle here. Demand seems to be taking care of that (i.e. people are building so-called Giga factories to take care of this) but we're still an order of magnitude or two off to take care of most of our needs. Just the process of ramping up production is going to cut cost further. And of course at the current price levels, battery + solar is already highly competitive with just about everything else. Of course in the process of ramping up production, there are likely to also going to be massive technical improvements that will further drive down cost and performance.
And just to pre-empt the argument: darkness is temporary and local, which means it is much less of a problem than some nuclear proponents seem to claim. Basically, if your panels don't provide enough power when it is cloudy, install more. If your battery runs out in the middle of the night, buy a bigger battery. If the area you live in is susceptible to extended periods of darkness (aka. the polar night), import power using cables. On the other hand, if, like most of the population of planet Earth, you live closer to the equator this is not going to be an issue.
Nuclear is still going to be useful but just not as our primary source of electricity. The safety and securitt concerns alone would make this impractical. Even if we can deliver this technically and produce these things cost effectively, you'd still need a lot of security measures to prevent people from doing silly things like creating dirty bombs with the nasty stuff inside. Imagine a few tens of thousands of these things, it would be a nightmare from a security point of view.
- doikor 7y agoDarkness is temporary (in the sense of nights) only when close enough to equator. Here in Finland even as far south as you can go solar efficiency drops to almost nothing for a good 4 months a year. And in the north it goes to literally to nothing. And it isn’t very safe to rely on other counties for electricity over this period. Doing that basically hands the keys to freeze a sizable portion of our population to an external entity (government) Though even now we aren’t independent when it comes to heating over the winters. We have to import oil, gas and coal. But with those one can have strategic stockpiles to last over the next/current winter at least if things go bad. Kind of similar for nuclear fuel. We have stockpiles for years but don’t mine it here (we could but economically much cheaper to buy from Sweden and Russia). Just much easier to stockpile that stuff. But yeah for the vast majority of the whole planets population solar with batteries should work just fine.
- jacquesm 7y agoI would be highly surprised if the habitable zone of our planet in 'sustainable' mode would be the exact same habitable zone in 'unsustainable' mode.
- marcosdumay 7y agoI wouldn't. We are roughly distributed by local food availability, and that correlates well with solar power availability. The one large difference is that food is easier to import. But I am pretty sure we can solve the energy long distance trade problems.
- pfdietz 7y agoExpensive nuclear is not going to save your energy-hungry industries when the cheap energy is available at low latitudes. Boreal countries will be energy ghettos in a solar powered world.
- doikor 7y agoOur energy hungry industries are building nuclear with their own money. And even with the delays of olkiluoto 3 they want to build more (but are having a hard time getting the permit). TVO Teollisuuden voima (heavy industries power) is the company that built, operators and owns half of the nuclear plants in Finland (one of the owners of TVO owns the rest) If they can get the financing from private markets to build more I say let them. None of the current/future plants were built with government money outside of them being the backer for the insurance.
- pfdietz 7y agoYou do not contradict what I wrote. Yes, your industries are going with nuclear. No, they will not be able to compete toe-to-toe with equatorial countries getting solar at $0.01/kWh, as they will likely be able to in a few years.
- 7y ago
- andromeduck 7y agoYou can do that but the capital effiency and overall system effiency will be even more atrocious. I think we need a good mix of both.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoWhy do you think so? Solar + battery is already considered the cheapest option. How would spending more be a better form of capital efficiency?
- ethbro 7y agoDiversification.
- agumonkey 7y agoIs it a lot more funding than space ? because spatial exploration, as cute as it can be, is somehow a lot less critical.
- neuronic 7y agoThat's very easy to say, and I am definitely NOT saying you are wrong. But I'd be somewhat careful. Space exploration has in the past provided us with lots of information that we can use to understand our own climate and planetary systems. Not only that, but the often mentioned advances in material sciences and other areas might end up helping us much more than the sunk cost at the beginning.