6 ms·
Maybe the masses are saying "This isn't working for us! We don't know what would work for us, but this isn't it!" And I wonder how long until this comes to th
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Maybe the masses are saying "This isn't working for us! We don't know what would work for us, but this isn't it!"
And I wonder how long until this comes to the USA...
- notduncansmith 7y agoI couldn’t find a source for this photograph, but my dad showed it to me a few years ago and I feel like it perfectly captures the tone of the current global civil unrest: https://i.pinimg.com/236x/c0/e4/06/c0e406018cc6b42ad0a2562f89fe4de1--protest-signs-protest-posters.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/236x/c0/e4/06/c0e406018cc6b42ad0a2562f8...
- adamsea 7y agoAgreed. I think the beauty of the phrase "shit is fucked up and stuff", is that the problems we face are so overwhelmingly obvious that we don't actually have to articulate them. And since the usual way calls for change are defused is by arguing about definitions, terms, assumptions, etc, in many ways articulating what shit is fucked up is counterproductive to change.
- sandoooo 7y agoI think you will find that when you do articulate, absolutely everybody has a different interpretation of exactly which parts are fucked, and how to unfuck it, and who exactly should foot the bill. Perhaps some of them think you should, or people of your income bracket, or people who share your other demographic traits. Presumably you have a different opinion. And, of course, differences in opinion is anathema to a good protest march. The true beauty of the message is that it's vague enough to get both you and the guy next to you (and the guy you would both intensely dislike if you knew the full extent of their opinions) to all come out and smash shit up at the same time in a coordinated manner.
- malandrew 7y ago> The true beauty of the message is that it's vague enough to get both you and the guy next to you to all come out and smash shit up at the same time in a coordinated manner... ... but the hidden ugly side is that you and the guy next to you will not agree on how to rebuild things once you're both done smashing stuff. What really scares me is not only how fragile things are, but how expensive it's going to be to get back to the level of wealth we enjoy today, assuming it's even likely we are able to (which I'm not so sure about).
- larnmar 7y agoIt already did, in 2016.
- notduncansmith 7y agoOnly that still isn’t it.
- dragontamer 7y agoI'd argue that message started in Occupy Wall Street. The problem is if you run around and protest without any real goal, you end up with a big nothing burger 7+ years later.
- gmueckl 7y agoIt is easier to be against something than it is to be for something else. A lot of revolts break down after they remove the power they are opposed to because the participants are not united by a common constructive vision for an alternative.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThat's an interesting take on both Trump's and Bernie's campaigns. To at least some degree, I think it fits. But I was thinking about several percent of the country marching in the streets. That's not something we've seen yet.
- m0zg 7y ago>> several percent of the country marching in the streets Unlikely to happen here seeing that unemployment is at a 50 year low and wages are rising.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoBut some of those protests are in prosperous places. The economy has been getting better for a long time in Chile. Hong Kong isn't hurting, either - or at least wasn't until the start of the protests.
- smsm42 7y agoSome argue it already did, in November 2016.
- tempsy 7y agoI don't think it happens until the next major recession. Even if you aren't personally benefiting from the equity bull market there's too much easy credit and rates are too low. As soon as that goes and the people at the bottom are really screwed then we see something akin to Occupy Wall Street at 100x the scale. In general I do think easy access to consumer credit is the difference between the US and everywhere else. It numbs over systemic issues and provides the illusion that things are better than they really are. AFAIK credit is much harder to come by in other countries, which is why seemingly small things like an increase in gas prices, transit fares, or a small tax blow up in other countries when it wouldn't have the same effect here.
- Infinitesimus 7y agoMy bet was on the next recession being a trigger of significant societal change (or vice versa like a big political upset ) ... but I don't know anymore. I look around and sure, a few people are talking about recession concerns but most people don't seem to care. Credit is cheap of course you'll finance that house at 3.5% or buy the new 40k car at 2%. Spend spend spend is how we keep things afloat in hopes that when the music stops, _we_ aren't the ones left holding the bag. I agree that easy credit has this awesome ability to mask over deep societal problems. We spend enough to not worry that we've built a lot of things on sand that may not hold up in a bad storm and it's so strange sometimes to watch. I'm hoping we can avoid another 2008 or something worse but the current system seems unsustainable longterm. Something has to give for as long as we expect more money in the future
- sandoooo 7y agoInteresting thing is, this message is universal. You can drop it in at any time, any place in history, and it will make sense and be supported by a significant demographic, quite possibly everybody. So if you have the tools to amplify this message until it's all that anyone sees, and everybody knows that it's all that everybody else sees, you can cause revolts at your convenience. You don't even need to dirty your hands with direct message shaping - which comes with consequences such as getting your head chopped off - just moderate all the competing messages a tiny little bit harder, and bob's your uncle. As a direct example, notice how the author judges the size and effectiveness of revolts based on how prominent they are on youtube. Which is just an algorithm tweak away for the right people.
- ilaksh 7y agoAndrew Yang is running for president on a basic income platform. Why would someone downvote this? It's a statement of fact.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoBecause Yang running on basic income is very much not the same as the Hong Kong protests, or the Chile protests, or the Sudan protests, or... (For the record, I didn't downvote you. I can't - you replied to me. I probably wouldn't anyway.)
- AcerbicZero 7y agoPerhaps. Protests aren't exactly revolts, and revolts aren't exactly revolutions. Until people start banding together in distinct geographical locations and drawing up alternative systems of government (or skipping straight to direct, but loosely organized, physical opposition to the existing government) it seems likely it can be contained and ideally, addressed. That said, the current connected world has probably reduced the available reaction time between each stage of escalation, so getting complacent wouldn't be advisable.
- sandoooo 7y agoMaybe the masses are saying "More stuff for <people like me> and <people I like> and less stuff for <people I don't like> and <people with stuff I want>".
- Porthos9K 7y agoIt already happened. It resulted in Trump getting elected.