10 ms·
Implicit bias also guides interests and choice. Many women I meet today simply did not consider the possibility of an engineering career, not that they were fo
by jayd16 7y ago
Implicit bias also guides interests and choice. Many women I meet today simply did not consider the possibility of an engineering career, not that they were forced out of it.
We look to outcome equality to gain some kind of insight into this.
- izzydata 7y agoIt sounds like informing everyone that these options exist is part of creating a more equal opportunity. If two people didn't have the same information for available options then there wasn't an equal opportunity.
- jimbokun 7y agoI'm not following you. Girls don't know that there's such a thing as programming or Computer Science degrees?
- izzydata 7y agoIf they aren't convinced it is a real option than they didn't have the same opportunity. Either way it isn't a problem that can be solved by pushing people into the field to create a more equal ratio.
- jayd16 7y agoIt's about internalizing the idea that it's a feasible choice you give actual thought to.
- jimbokun 7y agoHow to distinguish between "I didn't know that was a feasible choice for me" and "I know what programming is like and I don't want to do that as a career"? How many girls and women fall into each category?
- jayd16 7y agoI'm not sure I understand the question. As phrased I think you have a natural understanding of the difference. Are you asking how we measure that nationally?
- jimbokun 7y agoI mean what are the relative sizes of those two groups, maybe worded it awkwardly.
- Impossible 7y agoThe majority of people fall into the first category, regardless of sex. There are a lot of people who with exposure might consider software development as a career, but didn't think of it as an option. For various historical reasons (exposure to programmable computers, video games, adults that can explain or teach programming, access in school, peers that program, role models, etc) the people that tend to realize programming is a career option and understand what that career might entail tend to be white and asian males. That isn't to say there aren't many white and asian males that also don't know programming is a career option. Now that "tech" is so important and lucrative I'm sure this is changing to some extent, but this is a recent trend that's probably 5 years old at most. Tech wasn't viewed the same as it was now in 2012-2014 and felt like a much more risky and inaccessible field. Now it looks a lot more like any other high paying corporate job.
- jimbokun 7y ago5 years old? Are you joking? The Dot Net bubble in the 90s was arguably the biggest news story of the decade. Everyone knew there was tons of money to be had in tech, and stories of people landing jobs at startups after learning a little bit of HTML.
- Impossible 7y agoI'm aware of the dot com bubble. My point wasn't that people weren't making money, my point is tech looked risky and new, especially the web based companies that dominate now. Microsoft, IBM, Oracle etc were stable jobs but they were for engineers/nerds. There was money to be made back then of course but money isn't the only thing that makes jobs attractive. Social and cultural status and stability are important as well. A doctor is a safe, high paying, high status job. Tech is only just now starting to look that way to mainstream people.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoI remember high-school guidance counsel lists being dominated by things like "actuarial" and "insurance salesman." After reading that I would have rather worked in a restaurant my whole life. Absolutely had no clue what to go into and they didn't help much. Perhaps they were at a greater disadvantage because the internet revolution was about to hit.
- tenpies 7y agoI just hate that the emphasis seems to be strictly based on careers with high income. There is no focus spreading equality or equity or informing everyone when the career is about social good, life satisfaction, or blunt quality of life.
- zarkov99 7y agoYes, don't forget all the shitty careers, with long hours, danger, and significant health hazards. Not much equality of outcome on those either. Somehow no one is claiming sexism is the cause of disparity for those.
- foldr 7y agoActually, a lot of people are saying that sexism is the cause of disparity in those cases. It's a commonplace observation that sexism harms men as well as women. Historically, the professions you're alluding to have been closed to women by men. So for example, the reason that women couldn't serve in the military until relatively recently is not that women used their power and influence within society to get a pass on military service. Rather, it's that men didn't want to let women serve.
- zarkov99 7y agoReally? Below is a list of the top 8 most dangerous jobs in the US. Which ones do you think would have equal gender representation if there was no sexism? 1 - Logging workers 2 - Fishers and fishing workers 3 - Aircraft pilots and flight engineers 4 - Roofers 5 - Refuse and recyclable material collectors 6 - Structural iron and steel workers 7 - Truck drivers 8 - Farmers, ranchers and agricultural managers
- foldr 7y agoThat list is obviously a bit whack (how can being a pilot possibly be the third most dangerous job in the US?) But yeah, many of those jobs have a skewed gender distribution in significant part due to sexist stereotypes.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoIn school way back in olden times, most of the girls in my class would say "oh, I hate computers," when the subject was brought up. Odd, because I loved them. I don't hear this anymore from the grown-up-on-iPad generation.
- pm90 7y ago> In school way back in olden times, most of the girls in my class would say "oh, I hate computers," I'm pretty sure most of the boys said that too.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoNever heard that once from a boy, but perhaps ~ten times over the decade from girls.
- TulliusCicero 7y ago> Many women I meet today simply did not consider the possibility of an engineering career And I'm sure many men simply did not consider the possibility of a career in female dominated professions, like nursing or elementary education. I think there's certainly something to the idea that we internalize stereotypes and that can restrict our options, but I'm skeptical that it generally explains large differences in career preference today. For example, women were once stereotyped as not being doctors or lawyers, but that didn't seem to stop them from joining those fields en masse. If internalized stereotyping didn't matter enough to stop them then, for those fields, why does it matter now for engineering?
- jayd16 7y agoWell it's certainly an open question, although here's something that's just struck me. Careers that were dominated by women were in the orbit of doctors and lawyers, those being nurses, paralegals and secretaries. If you're thinking about being a nurse, why not consider being a doctor? I'm not sure STEM professions had these associated careers.
- foldr 7y ago>For example, women were once stereotyped as not being doctors or lawyers, but that didn't seem to stop them from joining those fields en masse. If internalized stereotyping didn't matter enough to stop them then, for those fields, why does it matter now for engineering? The fields you mention made serious efforts to counter sexism. STEM hasn't, yet.
- manfredo 7y agoSTEM hasn't made serious efforts to counter sexism? That starkly contrasts with my observations. For the entirety of my life (I'm over 25) that I can remember I've encountered programs and initiatives working towards getting women into STEM. All of the companies I've worked at instituted hiring policies that favor women (e.g. giving women 2 chances to pass a technical phone screen instead of one). And we're not alone in this. Microsoft and Intel have both instituted policies of witholding bonuses unless diversity quotas are met, and Facebook gives recruiters more points - which count towards performance reviews - for recruiting diverse candidates[1]. 1. https://www.payscale.com/compensation-today/2019/03/tie-bonuses-to-diversity-goals https://www.payscale.com/compensation-today/2019/03/tie-bonu...
- naasking 7y ago> Implicit bias also guides interests and choice. The existence of implicit bias is contentious. All purported tests to measure its existence have failed replication.