2 ms·
Well, as I said before -- there are lots of caveats. But I hope that professor loses his bid to introduce another sound-bite into the statistics world, because
by timr 16y ago
Well, as I said before -- there are lots of caveats. But I hope that professor loses his bid to introduce another sound-bite into the statistics world, because it's not correct to blindly say that the data are "worthless" simply because they're voluntary responses. We make useful inferences from voluntary response data all the time (c.f. every political poll ever conducted, where people can choose not to respond). The correct question is: does the voluntary response process result in a systematic bias that will affect the conclusion in question? But that's neither short, nor catchy.
In this case, there's a strong argument to be made that the samples could skew young (if for no other reason than because younger people frequent sites like HN more than older people). It's also quite possible that the demographics for HN and for slashdot are different in a way that would make the HN audience skew younger. But the voluntary response process itself? I think it's a stretch to claim that it'll cause a measurable bias in age distributions, across two different surveys, spaced a decade apart. You'd have to argue that younger people in 2011 are more likely to answer a poll than younger people in 1998 were to answer a poll. Possible? Sure. The most likely source of error here? Nah.
In other words, if you're going to pick (and you should!), pick on the BIG, OBVIOUS differences between the data sets...not the little ones.