4 ms·
A wild untrained human animal isn't that bright. We can probably operate above the crow level, but maybe not by much. What makes us special is persistent colle
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
A wild untrained human animal isn't that bright. We can probably operate above the crow level, but maybe not by much.
What makes us special is persistent collective learning and abstract communication.
Unlike animals, generations of humans don't have to keep re-solving the same problems. As a species we have cumulative persistent memory for techniques and abstractions. That's the real game changer.
But it took a surprisingly long time - tens of thousands of years - for our brains to make this ability central to culture. And there's no guarantee that if we re-ran history we'd do it again on the same scale.
- jdck1326 7y agoIt seems like you're suggesting that there aren't massive biological differences between a wild human and a crow. This is false. Humans have many biological faculties that crows simply do not have. For example, the wild, untrained human still has the biological faculty of language. That is, there is a reason why no animal other than a human has been shown to be able to learn a language. The reason is that they do not have the biological faculty of language. You suggest that "generations of humans don't have to keep re-solving the same problems/" This is correct, but in many important ways it is not because of our culture or because we learn from our elders. But rather it is because of our genetics. An example of this is that children who are not taught a language will spontaneously create their own. Normally this won't happen, because children can't survive without adults, and adults will teach the children language. But something very close has happened a few times, an example, in itself far from conclusive, but still illustrative: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaraguan_Sign_Language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaraguan_Sign_Language
- carokann 7y agoThis whole story is extremely interesting.
- hchasestevens 7y agoThat's a little misleading. An individual child will not be able to fluently acquire language if not exposed during the so-called "critical period"; see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child for plenty of examples. _Groups_ of humans with no common means of communication will form pidgins ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pidgin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pidgin ) as an (essentially grammarless) means of communication; children then raised in an environment where they are exposed to this pidgin will transform it into a true language. Nicaraguan Sign Language has actually proven to be a fascinating example of this in action; many of the first speakers of the original pidgin are, now that successive generations have learned and adapted it, unable to competently produce utterances in the now-language.
- z3t4 7y agoI we where that stupid we wouldn't be able to learn new languages as an adult.
- vageli 7y ago> I we where that stupid we wouldn't be able to learn new languages as an adult. That is after successfully having acquired a language already. What the critical period theory suggests is that if no language is acquired during that period, subsequent language acquisition is not possible.
- rolltiide 7y agoMany Bird species have a language that is both taught and spontaneously created It would be an aberration for a crow’s calls to be arbitrary
- DagAgren 7y agoCrows do this to some extent. They gather collective knowledge and pass it on to their offspring. If you act maliciously towards a crow, it will teach its friends that you are dangerous, and they will all warn each other if you approach. This will keep happening even after the original crows are dead, because they will teach their children that you are an asshole, too, even though those children may never have seen you do anything wrong.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoYes, and that's a step up from a blank slate for every generation. But humans take it much further by creating powerful abstractions, and transmitting specifics and abstractions in a form that survives the death of the original creator. I can read Newton's Principia online, or take an undergrad physics course. His insights are still shaping our world view even though he's been dead for centuries now. Only humans have worked out how to abstract the intelligence from individuals into lasting communications that don't require face-to-face transmission. Unfortunately we've only done this about selective topics. Personal relationships and political and economic systems still work relatively badly because they don't have anything equivalent to the cumulative summary, insight, and abstraction processes at the core of science and technology.
- mettamage 7y agoSo would you then argue that before humans invented writing, they were on the same levels as crows. Crows have an oral tradition, and so did humans in that time, therefore they're about as equally smart, back then?
- jancsika 7y ago> A wild untrained human animal isn't that bright. We can probably operate above the crow level, but maybe not by much. That's such a misanthropic statement I don't even know where to begin. Just sticking to the kinds of structures a human and a crow can build in the wild, it's still obvious to the untrained observer that the human is well beyond the crow in terms of intelligence.
- joshowar 7y agoWhat kind of structure would you build in the wild, if you'd never seen a house, or hut, or lean-to? Think you'd just arrive at these ideas on your own? Think you'd even consider building your own at all? Or would you just keep walking until you found a cave? We depend more on our collective intelligence and teachings than you think.
- jancsika 7y ago> What kind of structure would you build in the wild, if you'd never seen a house, or hut, or lean-to? For an instructive example-- a crow's nest of sticks, leaves, etc. Especially if that human comes up happens to come upon a crow's nest in the wild. Notice that the human can probably scale that design to fit their own larger stature. Now imagine a crow coming upon a little 1x1 dugout crawdad battle arena, or a little lattice-structure of sticks that encloses a caddisfly larva collection of a 9 year old. If you saw a crow observe and then build that you'd have quite a research paper on your hands. But we're probably going to get stuck in physical differences so let's change the subject and just give both animals a stick. One of them uses it to extract a morsel of food from a hard to reach area. The other uses it to mark time according to either the moon cycle or possibly something else that lasts that long. I.e., this animal has created a calendar. Using historical evidence please tell me which animal performed which feat? The thing is-- I really do find the intelligence of crows fascinating! I just don't get the desire to pair that with the "human's aren't such hot shit" trope.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoI think you are making of conflating how a socially raised human would behave in the the wild with how a feral human would behave. Despite nearly 8 billion people on Earth, we have very little data on human cognitive development when isolated from other humans.
- dexen 7y ago>What makes us special is persistent collective learning and abstract communication. No; passing on knowledge isn't quite sufficient. The key difference is our ability to manipulate objects with hands, and our ability to harness external sources of energy, starting with fire. Cetaceans (in particular orcas and dolphins), chimps, crows, they all are known to develop & pass on language, culture, and knowledge like hunting tricks. Cetaceans, and also octopuses have relatively high intelligence. The former live in long-running packs (pods), and pass on their distinct cultures, language dialects, and hunting habits. The later live with little to no contact with their parents, and have to discover everything from grounds up. Both have been around for much longer than humans. Neither have progressed anywhere near close to having a technological civilization, and are on relatively similar level.
- tachion 7y agoI beg to disagree. I can't quote the sources from the top of my head, but the comment about persistent collective learning and communication seems to be the science view on the matter last time I checked. For example, some non-primates animals and some primates can and in fact use tools to various degrees. The energy harness and fire is a consequence of doing/being able to do these things, not the condition.
- discreteevent 7y agoI watched a documentary once that demonstrated how smart chimps are but the main point of it was to demonstrate how they do not pass on much to their offspring. Also it theorised that this is why humans didn't co-opt chimps. You can't communicate with them. A relatively dumb dog is better. i/o is more important than calculation when it comes to getting things done.
- allendoerfer 7y agoHumans are amazing teachers. If we see someone fail, we can imagine the specific reasons why and try to overcome them. Other animals like chimps also see the mistakes, but they won‘t adapt, they will just show how it‘s supposed to be done over and over.
- marcosdumay 7y agoI don't think the expression "wild untrained human" even makes sense. There haven't been any wild untrained human ancestor since a long time before humans appeared. Also, most smart animals have persistent knowledge that they pass from one generation to the other. We are just smarter than those other animals. Tens of thousands of years ago, humans were already a force not to be messed with. Hell, a million years ago our ancestors were already on the business of extinguishing their predators.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mettamage 7y agoThere are still wild untrained humans. In most cases, it's a very sad state of affairs when that happens since a lot of child neglect has to occur. But I'd argue that children that have been fed but other than that left alone for 10 years, classify as an "untrained" human. It's sad, but they do exist. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child (thanks boatswain for providing the link in another comment)
- antisthenes 7y ago> Unlike animals, generations of humans don't have to keep re-solving the same problems. As a species we have cumulative persistent memory for techniques and abstractions. That's the real game changer. We also don't have to spend 80-90% of our time in a struggle for survival against the elements during this crucial learning period. Humans in developed countries are typically provided for, while doing the majority of their learning.