5 ms·
> He said there is a potential for violation if DOT > and the public were misled by "engineering-quality > work"- even if the authors did not claim to be
by pyre 16y ago
> He said there is a potential for violation if DOT
> and the public were misled by "engineering-quality
> work"- even if the authors did not claim to be
> engineers.
Isn't this essentially saying that you can be too smart/thorough for your own good, and that the government is going to punish you for not getting a license to use your abilities? What the hell is 'engineering-quality work' anyways? Talk about an amorphous term...
- hvs 16y agoI think it is in reference to: "When you start applying the principles for trip generation and route assignment, applying judgments from engineering documents and national standards, and making recommendations," that's technical work a licensed engineer would do, Lacy said.
- amalcon 16y agoGiven that I first read the terms "trip generation" and "route assignment" when I was in high school, and in reference to SimCity, I think we can safely assume that the problem is actually the recommendation. There's some legal precedent* in blocking unlicensed people from making recommendations, notably pertaining to legal advice given by people who are not members of the bar association. On the other hand, Will Wright could clearly not be held liable if some loony city planner tested his designs out in SimCity. Also, individuals are generally permitted to represent their own interests with legal argumentation, and this guy is apparently someone with an interest. * -- Ironic though it is given the subject matter, I am not a lawyer, this is not legal advice.
- jacques_chester 16y agoI too am not a lawyer, seek professional advice before relying on stuff you saw online etc. The basic rule here in Australia is: 1. Give all the legal advice you like, just don't be surprised if you're sued because it's wrong. Non-lawyers do not enjoy solicitor's indemnity. 2. You cannot give legal advice in exchange for any form of payment, unless you have been admitted to the bar.
- arch_hunter 16y agoThis is sounding a lot like a profession making it illegal for others to do anything that could decrease their own income.
- jefe78 16y agoAgreed! I shouldn't need an M.D. to stitch you up!
- jonathanwallace 16y agoGood thing you don't. Stitch away. Just stick to friends and/or people who won't sue you.
- steverb 16y agoOr yourself. Stitches aren't that hard to do. If you can get a hold of a medical stapler they're even easier.
- CodeMage 16y agoSure, as long as you don't claim you have an M.D. and I don't care that you don't, then we're okay.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- joe_the_user 16y agoIt's more like if someone stitches me up, in an emergency, after warning me they aren't a doctor, they will be sued by the AMA for "doctor-level work".
- jrockway 16y agoNo, not really. This is more like if you're dying and someone gives you CPR but didn't pay $20 to renew their CPR certification, the CPR certification board goes after them for "practicing lifesaving without a license". In other words, utter fucking bullshit.
- notaddicted 16y agoYou're refuting the weakest possible interpretation of his statement. "This" is essentially saying, that it is possible to mislead the public by producing work that has some of the qualities of engineering work, but is not actual engineerng work. The alleged violator clearly started with the conclusion, and put together some official looking research to support it ... one of the many things you learn not to do in engineering school.
- pyre 16y ago> The alleged violator clearly started with the conclusion, and put > together some official looking research to support it So he was biased for his own argument? As much as people try to be unbiased, I think that it's probably impossible for humans to be completely impartial. If the arguments in the recommendation are so weak/faulty then the DOT engineers should be able to rip it to shreds with a counter-argument. I'm having a hard time caring about the fact that the guy put together a 'professional-looking' analysis without having a professional license. He didn't represent himself as a professional engineer, and he was putting together information for to present his viewpoint to his local representatives.
- brudgers 16y ago>"one of the many things you learn not to do in engineering school." Practicing engineers, however, figure out how to do what the client wants within the limits of the law. I usually don't link to youtube videos, but this pretty much sums up the real world: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9BUyWVg1xI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9BUyWVg1xI
- Anechoic 16y agoThe alleged violator _clearly started_ with the conclusion What are you basing this on?
- sliverstorm 16y agoone of the many things you learn not to do in engineering school. I always start with the conclusion- "I want this to do X"- and then I throw together something that will hopefully do X. If you don't know what your desired conclusion is, you'll get utterly lost and unfocused along the way.
- tyhjnmyh 16y ago> He said there is a potential for violation if DOT > and the public were misled by "engineering-quality work" Could be a problem here. If I make a complete balls-up of a project would the public be misled into thinking that the government had done it - even if I wasn't a government employee?
- pyre 16y agoClearly the DOT employees engineers that are severely lacking if someone is able to put together a report of 'engineering-quality' that bamboozles them into doing something that doesn't make sense.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- glenjamin 16y agoAs I see it, either his report is solid and contains no factual errors or incorrect assumptions (and thus is "engineering quality work") - in which case since it's correct then there should not be any issues in following its conclusion. Or alternatively, his report contains fallacies and invalid conclusions - but by extension is no longer of engineering quality.