8 ms·
Retired USAF General Makes Eyebrow Raising Claims About Advanced Space Tech
- jessriedel 7y agoWhat a horribly written breathless article. Does anyone know if a simple summary of the lecture available?
- trimmedarticle 7y agoHere's a no JavaScript version of the article that reduces the page size by 78% - from 7.66 MB to 1.71 MB: https://beta.trimread.com/articles/692 https://beta.trimread.com/articles/692
- duelingjello 7y agoAnd, that's an awesome app. Even does reader views. TY.
- maxander 7y ago“Technology to get an individual from anyplace on Earth to any other place in less than an hour” ... so, a mobile-platform-launched ICBM that you can climb into. I’d believe that the military would have developed that for that sake of some capability or other. It’s not relevant to any plausible civilian application, however. (The speculative SpaceX suborbital rocket thing, IMHO, is not credible evidence against my point. :) )
- etrautmann 7y agoThis is exactly right. They could have developed an ICBM based person delivery rocket but it won’t be more exotic than that. The defense department does not generally have undiscovered physics in their back pocket, modulo some nuclear secrets.
- steve19 7y agoThe problem is that you can't just launch a ICBM without risking Russia or China lobbing a few (hundred) back, regardless of the destination. It is less a tech problem than a political one. A stealth ICBM on the other hand... now that is a scary. If any other nations got wind of that we would have another nuclear arms race.
- justin66 7y agoICBM launches are detected via satellite primarily based on the extraordinary infrared output of a powerful rocket motor. A "stealth" ICBM would not really get you much, would it?
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> A "stealth" ICBM would not really get you much, would it? Stealth may help avoid interception during the midcourse phase, though: https://media.nti.org/pdfs/10_5.pdf https://media.nti.org/pdfs/10_5.pdf: > Midcourse Phase – “Largest Intercept Window” > The midcourse phase allows the largest opportunity to intercept an incoming missile. At this point the missile is no longer under power, so it follows a more predictable path. Depending on the interceptor launch location, multiple interceptors could be launched, with a delay between them to see if the first ones were successful. Since the interceptor has a longer time to engage, fewer interceptor sites are needed to defend larger areas. > Unfortunately, a longer period in space provides an attacking missile the opportunity to deploy countermeasures against a defensive system. However the defensive system also has more time to observe and discriminate countermeasures from the warhead. But I think you're right that it a stealth ICBM wouldn't achieve as much as one would naively assume, and boost-phase detection would still invite retaliation.
- justin66 7y agoWhen it comes to clever hypothetical changes to ICBMs, I remember one of the options floated late in the cold war was using a highly reflective coating that would hopefully ameliorate the effects of lasers (since we were taking interdiction with high-powered lasers more seriously then). I bring it up because I'm pretty sure it would be at cross purposes with a stealth coating. I bet that given sufficient satellite coverage and image processing, ICBMs might remain visible throughout most of their flight, making radar stealth a moot point. I hope the world will not go too far down the road of building out measures and countermeasures to update our nuclear weapons systems, but I think you'd have to add that possibility to the long list of possible countermeasures when doing your planning.
- dwnvoted2hell 7y agoYou're right. The article is basically clickbait. Tech already existed, and modifying to make it human habitable is hardly a huge jump, even by 1960's standards.
- greedo 7y agoLaunching the platform is one thing, having it land or deploy something that a person can exit from in rough terrain is quite a different thing.
- gnode 7y ago> a mobile-platform-launched ICBM that you can climb into. The Titan II GLV was a human-rated adaption of an ICBM. Conceivably you could even put people in a truck launch ICBM.
- gremlinsinc 7y agoWow.... this reads as an amateur trying to clone Buzzfeed, and marry it with the enquirer...while only hiring writers from fiverr. No organization, jumps all over the place. Very hard to get through, and my god the hype...it's everywhere.
- lykr0n 7y ago"...United States military and its industry partners may have already developed next-generation technologies that have the potential to drastically change the aerospace field, and human civilization, forever..." I believe it. I remember how the Bin Laden raid was executed with stealth helicopters- low noise and radar profiles. Came out of nowhere. And wasn't there a report on how the Navy hinted at all the UFO sightings were from tech they had to make ghost jets?
- duelingjello 7y agoConflating tinfoil, deep fakes and specialty stealth together isn't helpful. The claim the general made is without evidence, and possibly without merit. He could be wishing for things that are vaporware aspirationally, like John McAfee does, and the press gobbles it up as clickbait/chumbox fodder.
- jerome-jh 7y agoAnd the article is so vague we can hardly call that "claims".
- dogma1138 7y agoThey didn’t came out of nowhere. The US used “stealth” helicopters in Vietnam nicknamed the quiet one https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stealth_helicopter https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stealth_helicopter It allowed them to send covert missions into north Vietnam, ironically it was initially developed for commercial civilian purposes as a quiet helicopter can be used for helicopter taxis and inner city travel more easily. The US having stealth versions of the Blackhawk has been rumored since the 90’s it was less about if they can make them but if there’s an actual budgetary justification for them. For the bin laden raid they used what essentially was scrapped prototypes and one of them crashed on landing during the raid. RAM, low signature composites and acoustic improvements are hardly technologies that can described as which will drastically change the aerospace field.
- wil421 7y agoI don’t believe the helicopter crashed due to its stealth features. It was too close to a wall and had problems with lift.
- sneak 7y agoWith SpaceX doing booster landings now in full view and ICBMs and their ilk being well known for 50 years, is the claim that the tech to transport a person from any terrestrial A to B in under an hour being non-developmental (i.e practically feasible) really eyebrow-raising? I personally would be surprised if several ICBM-having militaries have not quietly developed something along these lines in the 70s, 80s, or 90s. There is even tech flying today to make it relatively practical/economical now that the boosters are being reused, as we always speculated was technically feasible. What’s the big news here? Am I missing something? I also assume that with the SR71 being as old as it is, the USAF has to have a couple of secret hypersonics by now that can get from any A to any B in the upper atmosphere in a few hours even non-ballistically.
- nradov 7y agoModern military ICBMs are solid fueled and thus can't really be used for human launches. They cause too much oscillation and vibration, and would effectively shake the crew to death. Some human rated spacecraft use solid fuel rockets as boosters only; the majority of thrust is delivered by liquid fuel engineers. So just having ICBMs doesn't really get you anywhere for delivering people.
- autisticmind 7y agoI think thats the future of air and space travel. https://patents.google.com/patent/US20060145019A1/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US20060145019A1/en