6 ms·
I'm really surprised that this might be pursuable in California. At first, as Williams is a chip guy, I thought it might be in Texas where you can screw employ
by gumby 7y ago
I'm really surprised that this might be pursuable in California. At first, as Williams is a chip guy, I thought it might be in Texas where you can screw employees six ways from Sunday (up to and including successfully asserting IP ownership of the contents of someone's head, as the DSC case showed).
California is much more strict, and several of the assertions don't appear to hold up in my understanding of employment IP law (IANAL but have hired many people and have dealt with several close employee cases on both sides - company and employee -- over the years). The lines in the law are pretty clear and broad.
Most strikingly to me from the complaint is the fact that apple claims that he 1> used his design knowledge to found another company (jeez, people do this all the time) and 2> did so while working at apple (ditto).
The worst thing you can do is use Apple's property to start another company, which is a strict no-no. But apple doesn't claim he used an apple-issued phone (or computer) to set up NuVia, and if they thought that it would be a trump card they'd brandish right up front. Instead they have the weak "knowledge" grounds which is pretty vague.
Likewise they claim he solicited employees, but non solicitation clauses are likewise no longer enforceable in CA as of this year.
This smacks of intimidation: they don't care if they lose; they want others to know that if you leave apple to start a company or work for a competitor they'll sock you with an expensive and distracting legal battle. Which is pretty sad given that Apple was on the receiving (and losing) end of such a case a few years ago...relating chip design!
- ChuckMcM 7y agoPretty much, I expect California to dismiss unless he has a contract where he waived his rights.
- lambdasquirrel 7y agoWell that's the thing, you can't waive your rights. That's the whole point of these clauses being unenforceable. This is a really disappointing move on Apple's part. The guy isn't pursuing something competing with any Apple product, or even anything trying to sell back to Apple. He's just going off and doing something else.
- edw 7y agoI take no position on the enforceability or the wisdom of the case. That said… It seems completely reasonable to me that there will be ARM-based desktops and laptops from Apple in the next five years and that they plan to offer them in hardware or software configurations that are suited to server work; macOS Server is still a thing. I three-quarters expected, when the new Mac Pro was announced a year or two ago, that it would be the first ARM-based desktop Mac. I was wrong, but I think I was wrong on timing, not on whether it would eventually happen. Apple cares a lot about having control of every key technology that makes up its offerings.
- Despegar 7y agoYeah this is almost certainly about chips intended for future Macs.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y ago> macOS Server is still a thing It is? With no server hardware except for maybe a rack-mounted Mac Pro ( which doesn't really strike me as server grade hardware)[0] and most of the actual server services gutted[1]? [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_Pro#Mac_Pro_Server https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_Pro#Mac_Pro_Server & https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_Mini#Mac_mini_Server https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_Mini#Mac_mini_Server [1] https://9to5mac.com/2018/01/24/major-changes-macos-server/ https://9to5mac.com/2018/01/24/major-changes-macos-server/
- thetinguy 7y agoI have seen many macos server installations on Mac mini.
- briandear 7y ago> The guy isn't pursuing something competing with any Apple product, or even anything trying to sell back to Apple. That isn't true. "Williams boasted about starting a new company with technology that he was working on at Apple, that he believed Apple ‘needed’ and that he believed Apple would have no choice but to purchase.”" > He's just going off and doing something else. Also not true. He started the company to sell tech he developed at Apple, back to Apple.
- Despegar 7y agoThey're alleging breach of duty of loyalty and breach of contract. He was setting up and soliciting Apple employees for his new business while employed at Apple. If he left and tried to poach his former co-workers that would have been fine. And he did sign an Intellectual Property Agreement, which is included in the filing on page 15. https://regmedia.co.uk/2019/12/10/apple_v_gerard_williams.pdf https://regmedia.co.uk/2019/12/10/apple_v_gerard_williams.pd...
- gamblor956 7y agoBoth of those activities are permissible under CA law, and the second activity (recruiting) is explicitly not illegal as of 2019... And Apple is not alleging violations of their IP. They are alleging that he learned non-Apple-IP things during his time at Apple and is now using that knowledge at his new company.
- Despegar 7y agoAs far as I know there are no non-solicitation or non-compete agreements involved in this case at all. It all hinges on the fact that he was employed by Apple and owed them his undivided loyalty.
- sillysaurusx 7y agoThen I hope the case is thrown out. Companies have no loyalty to us. Why should we have loyalty to the company? Ah yes, because they have money and power. Sounds familiar. I think I get the argument – "how could society function if every employee were allowed to actively sabotage the company they worked for?" – I just don't buy it. Most people have no interest in doing such things. The law of large numbers seems to guarantee it won't be a big problem in practice. And I'm more in the "Let employees have civil liberties" camp than "Let companies protect themselves from any conceivable harm." And besides, we have a clear remedy for employees who sabotage their companies: fire them. From a cursory reading, it sounds like this person used his technical expertise to go start a startup, and tried to recruit some of his peers to leave their cushy bigco job and go help him. Y'know who else did that? Shockley Semiconductor.
- riazrizvi 7y agoI haven't seen a tech employee contract in the Bay Area where you are not asked to waive your rights. The question is, is it enforceable?
- NonEUCitizen 7y agoNo. Companies have to include a document informing you that "in California, portions of the previous pages we just asked you to sign might be unenforceable."
- ssalazar 7y agoUgh. So the next step is to make legislate against flagrantly inserting specious waivers of rights in employment contracts to prevent this sort of thing.
- unlinked_dll 7y agoWhere are you seeing this? All the contracts I've seen in California have a disclosure sheet of the law, specifically non-solicitation and IP ownership (on company time/premises with company resources) and don't ask you to waive rights.
- riazrizvi 7y agoI need to go home to check the wording on the two contracts I quit over but they essentially said any idea I have while employed belongs to the company. Though it was subtle. They said my ideas belong to me if I come up with them on my own, unless they relate in any way to a software business, and neither company was willing to put any definition/boundary on what their software business was limited to. Which essentially puts a limit on you developing ideas related to your trade. (The California Law was written to stop companies preventing professionals from being able to practice their trade). My initial expansive statement is based on this personal experience and on discussions with recruitment agents and senior developer friends who have been in the area longer than me, they all told me it is the norm in the industry. Though I admit most of my professional career has been spent on Wall Street and the City in London, so I don't know, maybe I'm misguided?
- robomartin 7y agoI wonder if someone has published a State-by-State comparison of employment/contract law relevant to tech workers. If found this document, which deals with non-compete and non-poaching: https://cdn.americanprogress.org/content/uploads/2019/04/02054652/State-Noncompetes-table1.pdf https://cdn.americanprogress.org/content/uploads/2019/04/020... I'd be nice to see comparisons that might include intellectual property issues. The other permutation would be the difference in legal treatment with and without an explicit contract. In other words, what do the laws say in each State if someone just hires you and you do not sign any contracts at all vs. the legality of various signed agreements (for example, non-compete).
- foobiekr 7y agoI am watching a friend in Texas go through this right now. He has been planning on leaving his current employer for some time, and his plan was to start a company that is only vaguely in the same space (basically going after an open area of a market adjacent to his current employer's space, not competing directly) but is now enmeshed in a battle over a very broad non-compete that he signed with his current employer which employment lawyers are telling him is enforceable (even if he relocates to the valley, which was the plan) for a period of two years despite basically being broad enough to prevent him working for companies vaguely related (along the lines of "does it involve networking?"). It's still in progress, but it's one of those things that immediately rules Texas out as an option. It's really amazing how bad it is out there [1]. [1] https://www.beckreedriden.com/50-state-noncompete-chart-2/ https://www.beckreedriden.com/50-state-noncompete-chart-2/
- eternalban 7y agoThis is more than merely annoying. Our means of livelihood are held hostage to corporate interests. Is there such a thing as software workers' lobby or something? The problem appears to be that, we developers negotiate individually at hiring time against corporations that are effectively acting collectively.
- monknomo 7y agoIn most professions, this sort of lobbying is done by a workers union
- sudosysgen 7y agoYou're thinking of a union. There should be a software developers' union.
- sparky_ 7y ago> Most strikingly to me from the complaint is the fact that apple claims that he 1> used his design knowledge to found another company (jeez, people do this all the time) and 2> did so while working at apple (ditto). IANAL, but my impression having read through the actual file is that most of the claims are on the basis of this fellow allegedly having done all these things while employed at Apple. Apple alleges that he was routinely working on his own business, conducting phone calls related to that business, etc, while in the office, and that he was actively recruiting his coworkers before he had left the company. I'm never a fan of big companies stomping on previous employees, but it sounds to me like the crux of the case is based around point (2). Had he quit the company and then founded his startup and poached his old coworkers - that would likely have been consistent with the law. But if he did indeed do these things _while still actively working there_ then his contract would have been in place at the time and therefore breachable.
- geofft 7y agoThe response (https://regmedia.co.uk/2019/12/09/applevwilliamscounter.pdf https://regmedia.co.uk/2019/12/09/applevwilliamscounter.pdf) claims that caselaw in California makes it clear that you can plan to start a new company, do some administrative work, etc. before leaving. You can't poach coworkers before you leave (if the contract is found valid, which they're attacking on other fronts), but you can certainly talk with people outside the company and say "Hey, I'm quitting in two weeks to found this company we both plan to join" etc.
- ksec 7y ago>claims that caselaw in California makes it clear that you can plan to start a new company, do some administrative work, etc. before leaving. Before leaving I assumed that is after he handed over his resignation? Not sure if the administrative work or poaching is before or after that.
- gumby 7y agoNon solicits are no longer enforceable in Californian
- briandear 7y agoHe started the company using Apple tech while working at Apple with the intent of taking that tech and selling it back to them. This isn't the same as a non-compete -- this is an intent to compete with Apple while still at Apple. A non-compete means you can't compete after you've left the company -- but taking Apple IP he created at Apple, to start another company with the intent of selling them a derivative of that IP -- that's definitely not ethical and a pretty clear breach of the employee contract. This has nothing to do with a non-compete. Non-compete means you can't work for a competitor -- that non-competes aren't enforceable doesn't preclude the enforcability of using Apple IP. Additionally, the non-disclosure agreements are enforceable and the tech he is using was most certainly covered by multiple NDAs, independent of a non-compete. Also, the enforcement of an employee non-solicitation clause, which prohibits former employees from reaching out to former coworkers to try to hire them at their new workplace, is also not the issue here -- non-solicitation clauses prevent former employees from poaching current employees -- true, those aren't enforceable under California law, but what is enforceable is that this solicitation happened while the guy was still working at Apple, potentially using Apple resources or facilities. Non-competes and non-solicitations aren't valid in California, however those don't apply while the person is still working for the company in question. The basis of the suit isn't that he started his own company -- it's that he started his own company while working at Apple with the intent to compete with Apple, using Apple-owned IP and Apple employees. If Apple had a helicopter project and an engineer was working on it at Apple, he couldn't take the plans for the helicopter, recruit co-workers then start a helicopter company using those plans. He could leave Apple, then develop his own plans for a helicopter, then hire Apple employees -- that would be legal under California law, but what would be a breach of contract would be using the specific IP developed while at Apple. The other question isn't about "enforceable" contracts in so much as the fact that the guy signed a contract when he was hired at Apple. Enforceable or not, he agreed to the employment terms and probably happily accepted Apple stock and other compensation in exchange for his work on developing IP for Apple -- IP that he is taking to his new venture specifically to sell it back to Apple. Regardless of the enforceability of the contract, it's pretty sleazy.
- donarb 7y agoThis is a bit more than the article alleges. Reading over the lawsuit, as a high ranking employee, he had access to employee records including salary, bonuses and RSUs, just the type of information he could use to leverage recruits at Apple to come work for him. Also as a high ranking employee he had access to not only Apple's proprietary information about chips, he also knew about corporate strategy and future business plans. His business plans included designing chips that he knew Apple was planning to use in the future and could undercut the pricing of other competitors.
- Mikeb85 7y agoThis is a textbook example of where a non-compete can be enforced. The whole point of non-competes is to prevent a manager from leaving one business to start up a competitor. And yes, that includes soliciting employees, clients, etc... He'd be fine if he was just an employee going from one company to another, but a manager taking a bunch of employees to start up a competitor is definitely a situation where a non-compete is enforceable.
- harshalizee 7y agoThis happens literally all the time, everywhere. Those employees are independent individuals who are capable of deciding whether they want to go or stay. Why should that be enforceable by a non-compete?
- Mikeb85 7y agoManagement jobs are different. You're paid a premium to, essentially, be above employees; both in terms of freedom and pay, but also responsibility and loyalty.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoWith regards competition, what server chips is Apple producing exactly?
- Mikeb85 7y agoNuvia can claim they're targeting only servers, but ARM chips are something Apple uses plenty of...
- nwallin 7y agoDo you live in California, and/or can you comment on California's laws regarding non-compete clauses? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-compete_clause#California https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-compete_clause#Californi... > Non-compete agreements are automatically void as a matter of law in California, except for a small set of specific situations expressly authorized by statute.[26] > There are limited situations where a reasonable non-compete agreement may be valid in California. > Where the owner of a business is selling the entire business, or is selling the goodwill in the business, the seller may be bound by a non-compete clause.[31] > When there is a dissolution or disassociation of a partnership.[32] > Where there is a dissolution of a limited liability company.[33]