7 ms·
How Trolls Overran the Public Square
- haydn3 7y agoIt's just a matter of what people are interested in, and having an attitude that clearly shows you're not interested in that topic, will draw everyone who's not interested in that topic to follow you. That's why trolling is so popular.
- larnmar 7y agoSpeaking of eternal September, I feel like some of the latecomers need to be educated on the actual meaning of “troll” (eg this writer, and most journalists). A troll is someone who posts deliberately provocative content for the purposes of deriving shits and giggles from the outraged responses of others. A propagandist is not a troll. A paid shill is not a troll. A person who sincerely holds views which you dislike is not a troll. Only a troll is a troll. This being so, I’m not convinced that trolls are a significant issue at this point, although partially it’s getting harder to tell due to Poe’s Law.
- mc32 7y agoTrue but then that writer would have a much smaller ax to grind...
- jtdev 7y agoAgreed, I’ve noticed a trend where people call anyone who publicly expresses a view that they disagree with a “troll”.
- throwawaybbb 7y agoHeretic is so passe.
- furgooswft13 7y agoThe proper term is "flamer". Political Twitter is mostly flamers, not trolls.
- draw_down 7y agoMmm, that one is a bit of an overloaded term, at least in America. But I agree with the general sentiment here; it especially drives me nuts to see people calling others “trolls” for saying things they don’t agree with.
- CPLX 7y agoThe problem is the two concepts are symbiotic. You start out a conspiracy with trolling and people doing it for the lulz and the reactions, and eventually you end up drawing in the unstable and mentally ill as true believers. Which can lead to unpleasant outcomes, like pizzagate or Qanon.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoOnce the trolls realized that they could convince enough people to join or believe them to impact the real world it was over for internet freedom. The people that have held power for generations don't like losing that power. It's a shame that we'll lose most of the good parts of the internet along with it too, and all we'll be left with is a platform for entertainment of the most clicks. The internet can't route around broken culture.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> The internet can't route around broken culture. That explains quite a bit. So many of us thought that the internet was going to change society for the better. Instead, society changed the internet for the worse. Utopian visions always have the problem of dealing with the humans that we have, not the humans that we wish we had.
- logosmonkey 7y agoHumanity has and will continue to be the downfall of many a grand vision.
- enobrev 7y agoThe internet simply became a better mirror. It becomes more human every day. This is what humanity actually looks like on a larger scale. Now that we can see ourselves at a scale we've never been able, we have an opportunity to make adjustments at scale, which is a process that takes generations.
- henrikschroder 7y agoOne thing all the conspiracy nut circles have in common, is that it's always YouTube videos that they use to try to convince the non-believers of their preferred kind of crazy. So I wonder what role YouTube monetization plays in this. How much money can you make grifting the gullible off of YouTube ads? As for q-anon, there's plenty of characters straight up selling merchandise, which should clue you in to what kind of operation it actually is. It wasn't that long ago that YouTube decided to de-monetize all antivaxx videos. Has that had a noticeable outcome? If amoral grifters can't make money peddling bullshit ideas, do they do it less? Are there fewer antivaxx videos being made today, than a year ago? Are fewer people being sucked into that particular conspiracy bullshit today, than a year ago?
- catalogia 7y ago> "A propagandist is not a troll. A paid shill is not a troll. A person who sincerely holds views which you dislike is not a troll. Only a troll is a troll." It's orthogonal to all of those. Not all propagandists are trolls, but some certainly are.
- allovernow 7y agoI think people started using the term as a cheap dismissal before it recently morphed into such a catch all for "anyone who disagrees with me." Incedentally, there's a weird sort of paradox in the nature of online communication. On one hand, you have a medium where information spreads instantaneously and one could expect, given that we are all exposed to effectively the same global platform, that language might homogenize and evolve more slowly. On the other hand, it's interesting to see how internet lingo tends to shift in meaning seemingly even more quickly than IRL language. There's some deeper conclusion here somewhere regarding the nature of human language but I'm having trouble conceptualizing it.
- notacoward 7y agoJ. Bradford DeLong is hardly a latecomer. He has been around longer than most of those reading this, quite likely including you. You might feel he needs to be corrected, but "educated" is an attempt to claim relative authority that might not be deserved (even if it's relevant).
- hirundo 7y ago> social media ... undermined the democratic process ... right into people’s ears and hijack their brains ... by swarms of “influencers,” propagandists, and bots "Hijack their brains" is quite a violent metaphor. It's a frame designed to justify strong countermeasures. But what alternative is there that isn't more dangerous than the status quo, with the potential to become a Ministry of Truth? It's either a free market of brain hijackers or a list of officially approved brain hijackers, take your pick.
- creato 7y agoI think this position is based on thinking that the social media users that have risen to the top of the influencer pile got there by some organic reflection of society. I think that's bullshit, and changing that feedback loop of incentives that exists between social media companies and these users does not necessarily (or even likely) imply a "ministry of truth".
- patcon 7y agoI empathize with the concern. My mindblown moment in fretting over this was a realization inspired by social physics research and complexity science: Just enforce a shape of the social fabric instead of worrying about specific content within that social fabric. Maintain edge quotas, not information quotas. We have tons of research on what are "healthier" shapes of network topology than what we've built.
- trophycase 7y agoDo you have any additional reading on this? I've always been interested in these topics of social network topology or systems theory or what have you but struggle to find good information on it.
- patcon 7y agoYay! Social physics :) There's a great Authors at Google talk by Sandy Pentland, about his book of the same name. Gives a good overview of the book, but 100% still worth a read after watching, esp if you are someone who works with (or would like to work with) large groups of people -- event organizing, companies, community, group facilitation, etc. https://youtu.be/HMBl0ttu-Ow https://youtu.be/HMBl0ttu-Ow
- pokoleo 7y agoIf you're interested, the Revolt of the Public is a similar thread: https://www.amazon.com/Revolt-Public-Crisis-Authority-Millennium/dp/1732265143 https://www.amazon.com/Revolt-Public-Crisis-Authority-Millen...
- FriedBread 7y ago> "There is now a near-consensus – at least among those who are not completely steeped in social-media propaganda – that the current public sphere does not serve us well." Anyone who doesn't agree with my conclusion obviously shouldn't be listened to because they're part of the problem. I don't know how you can un-ironically say "We need to stop handing off responsibility for maintaining public space to corporations and algorithms – and give it back to human beings. We may need to slow down, but we’ve created democracies out of chaos before. [...]" while arguing for more institutional gate-keeping. The, mostly, free discourse we have on the internet today is more democratic than it was prior to the Gutenberg revolution or the rise of radio. The author just doesn't like the results so they insist we need to go back to the older simpler way where the aristocracy gets to decide what ideas are acceptable because they know better than the common man what's good for him.
- patcon 7y agoAt risk of losing some people by stating some loose observations and findings with faux-confidence: Dense networks of human relations tend to lead to those humans creating specific network topologies in which liberal values tend to emerge. In places where the network is sparsed (relative to elsewhere), it is here we find reduced empathy for distant others, mistrust, populism, higher social distance between any two random nodes overall, and also bastions of socially conservative thought. My growing belief is that most social conservativism is network damage to the social fabric. But if that sounds slippery, don't worry: there is no need to purge it, as reducing the average path length in the network will see that happen on its own. Pluralistic values and greater ability to form consensus arises in spaces where we re-weave the social fabric into the sorts of topologies that cities tend to permute through on their own. Be very skeptical due to my lack of citing sources, but I share the above in earnest with this comment left in haste <3 EDIT: to be clear, I believe there is also some "illness" in the progressive left as well, due to their social distance from certain groups as well. The network is sick. A healed network will be some place in between, at a place we can all live with :)
- shsyejehxtd 7y agoThis seems mostly like handwaved logic though, why don't you consider liberalism a form of populism for example? After all, the political values you're describing arise by your own admission in areas of high density. How can something be populist and yet also targeted towards a population that you've defined as being the more minor or otherwise less dense? Not that it'd be correct either, but I could take the same elements you've used and describe Liberalism as xenophobic towards anything that doesn't share its values. I really am trying to see how you arrived at the point you did but it mostly just seems like you decided one side was wrong first and developed your explanation afterwards.
- bjt2n3904 7y agoWe responded to them. That's how. Flat earthers were never taken seriously. A bunch of kooks. Then the History channel "documentaries" hit, interviewing the flat earthers and giving them air time. Facebook crusaders constantly posted memes making fun of flat earthers, and "disproving" them a la XKCD #386 [1] Counter-intuitively, their numbers grew. Just goes to show that no exposure is bad exposure. The old solution was the best: do not feed the trolls. [1] - https://xkcd.com/386/ https://xkcd.com/386/
- mikedilger 7y agoI don't share the experience of this author. I don't often encounter trolls. What I encounter instead is intense differences of opinion, difficult to reconcile, and a lack of respect and manners not because the people at the keyboards are trolls, but because of the psychology of arguing anonymously with an unknown and imagined "enemy". I don't believe "traditional gatekeepers" is a good solution to the intensity and the chaos.. I think the right solution is just time. Social norms need time to adjust, on many fronts. We are in a period of upheaval, but as Jimmy Eat World says "it just takes some time, little girl, you're in the middle of the ride, everything, everything will be just fine..."
- ipython 7y agoSocial norms work because there is self-regulation. But how does self-regulation work if there are no aligned incentives? Why would trolls living thousands of miles away give a hoot about your precious democracy? They don’t stand to gain anything by following some “social norms”. In fact, you can profit quite well writing drivel to engage the communal lizard brain of a population, liberally peppering your content with advertisements. So while yes I do think that we are in the middle of rapid upheaval, things will get much worse before it gets better. I wonder if the solution will look like Stevenson’s idea of “stream editors” - AI or even humans who sort through the constant noise to filter only the information deemed trustworthy or relevant. Then we have gatekeepers once again.
- allovernow 7y agoI think part of the problem is that the word troll has been (probably somewhat deliberately) bastardized to mean "anyone who questions my views."
- trophycase 7y agoSimilar to what you said, I often see people arguing against strawmen, or even arguing strawman on strawman. To the point where internet discourse is a simulacrum of real life politics.
- ggm 7y agoEditing (as in, have an editorial, and remove content or submitters you don't want) and shadow-banning (which isn't entirely the same. Its social engineering) Anonymity drives this too. But, some people need pseudonomous status to feel safe. Does this include making trolls feel safe? What else is there other than pay-to-participate? I have participated in NZ "nethui" where the different sides of editorial policy, and anonymity come up. Why people troll is a good question. Some people are deeply unhappy and have arrived at a place where they feel good by making acts of depression happen in other people. "Why should you be happy if I cannot" The hate-language and violence towards minorities, women, gays and trans is especially evil. We now have a world where its ok to write things, which in times past were clearly encitement to violence. This last paragraph will possibly attract attack on the specious grounds its anti-men. This is symptomatic of the problem.
- danShumway 7y ago> There is now a near-consensus – at least among those who are not completely steeped in social-media propaganda – that the current public sphere does not serve us well. I mean, is there? There's near-consensus that the current public sphere has some significant problems. It doesn't follow that the old sphere was actually all that great, or that the Internet is a failed experiment. Are there really people who would seriously advocate that life was better before the Internet? Did none of these people grow up in a rural area? While I'll be the first to pile on companies like Facebook and Twitter, and I'll be the first to say that I don't like the general direction the Internet is going right now, my goal isn't to regress back into isolated pockets where fewer people have voices. It's been an interesting experience recently to find myself regularly needing to defend an idea that I figured was self-evident -- that it's good for people to be able to communicate with each other. > But as the Internet began to spread to each household and then to each smartphone, fears about the danger of an “eternal September” have been confirmed. I'm relatively young, but I'm still old enough to remember some of the more toxic gatekeeping arguments I heard in Open Source/gaming/general "nerd" communities, and it's really weird and uncomfortable for me to hear people today so easily reference the same phrasing as if it was entirely prophetic, rather than deeply problematic.
- scarejunba 7y agoSeems like a problem that other people have. My Twitter feed is great, my Instagram feed is a source of happiness, and I go on Facebook to find fun events my friends are going to. Listen, you know the old saying about smelling shit everywhere you go.
- notacoward 7y agoI kind of agree, and kind of not. I've said many times that your Twitter/Facebook feeds are mostly what you make of them, and that curating those feeds is an essential skill. I also very deliberately curate my Facebook feed to bring me joy instead of anger, though my Twitter feed is a bit more like Fight Club. On the other hand, curation is a skill. Many struggle with it even under relatively benign circumstances, let alone when dedicated and well-funded adversaries are deliberately infiltrating and abusing otherwise-positive conversations. By "adversaries" I mean not just political propagandists but also corporate ones BTW. Thus I'm a bit hesitant to suggest "just curate your feed better" as a complete solution. People need help. That help might combine education, structural change, and APIs (e.g. to support opt-in shared filtering and block lists). Probably all three.
- Khaine 7y agoThe Public Square was much better served by forums and BBSs that came before them. Now that corporations have taken over the Public Square, they have become beholden to those who complain the most. Amazingly, South Park predicted a lot of this with their Cartoon Wars episode[1] in that bowing to pressure from one group, means bowing to pressure from all Groups. Previously the web was thousands of independent forums and sites with their own rules. They were small enough and diffuse enough that you couldn't bring a large amount of pressure to force a forum or site to change. Now, everything is owned by a small number of companies that this is a feasible approach to silencing opponents. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartoon_Wars_Part_I https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartoon_Wars_Part_I