6 ms·
I always wonder about qualifications and if anyone is paying attention what is really required to do a job. I worked for a tech company that was acquired by so
by duxup 7y ago
I always wonder about qualifications and if anyone is paying attention what is really required to do a job.
I worked for a tech company that was acquired by some big valley tech company. They couldn't find any of the fancy CS degree folks they were looking for in the valley so they decided to "try" bringing a few of us over from this nobody company (that they had picked up just to absorb customers, we were just the folks left over after the layoffs because they didn't want to deal with supporting those customers themselves).
I didn't finish college, and I was warned that this was high tech stuff and they usually hire some pretty smart people to do it.
So out to the valley they fly me and some others and first day i'm absolutely overwhelmed ... by how simple a job it was they were doing, and some pretty poorly.
They were so invested in their resumes and being in the valley I don't think they really understood that day to day the job was basic troubleshooting. At one point one of them showing me how things worked asked "What do people do in Minnesota for work?" I told him "The same thing you're doing..." He found that hard to belive.
In about 6 months a handful of us from nobody company were churning through work at twice the rate of the other folks and with higher customer satisfaction scores (it was basically technical support)... and engineering was asking that critical cases be transferred to us "for efficiency".
Ultimately the job was customer support some mild technical skills / ability to learn / take good notes / ask good questions / the ability to formulate a theory, test it, and so on.
I knew dozens of people who could do that job at a third the cost, but they'd never hire them.
Years later I change careers and I sit through interviews where they hum and haw about my lack of CS degree again ... for a job maintaining their wonky CRUD app.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> by how simple a job it was they were doing There’s a world of difference between a college degree with no experience and no college degree also with no experience. There’s a significantly smaller difference between a college degree with ten years experience and no college degree with ten years experience.
- noir_lord 7y agoI’m a techlead who is in charge of mentoring the juniors on my team, most of who have a CS degree. There is a world of difference between work and a degree, particularly in the UK where a CS degree varies widely. It’s a surreal experience to be teaching people who on paper blow me away on academic qualifications on the other hand I’ve decades of producing code that produces value, experience with business side of things and knowing how to get stuff done mostly on time and mostly on budget which by the standards of our industry is pretty good. Not the only one at my company either, the senior dev/tech lead side of things is about 50/50 degrees/no degree depending. The CTO and Head of Software Engineering are firmly on the a CS degree is only a weak signal at best that someone will make an effective commercial developer. Not like we are doing crud of the week either, we have VR division, are solving complex problems and have about 4K employees (only about 100 devs though).
- soup10 7y agoYoung people don't understand that succeeding in college and succeeding in the real world are two different things. Nobody cares if you graduated from mit with a 4.0. We care if you can succeed at the job and are worth the king's ransom great developers get in this market.
- dzamie 7y agoWe find it "hard to understand" because job opening descriptions tell us that a degree and/or an excellent GPA are minimum requirements for anything that doesn't pay minimum. And to pre-empt the inevitable "5 years experience is just as good," that 5 years can't come unless you either a) got that degree 5 years ago to get a job for that experience, b) managed to befriend a hiring manager, or c) started a company. What an applicant can or can't do means nothing if they don't make it to the part of the hiring process where they can demonstrate it, at least without blatantly lying on their resume.
- mrrsm 7y agoI think the other option is just networking and having a good portfolio that shows off your skills. Granted that leads you to point b that you made as you will likely befriend people who are in positions to hire you or suggest to others to hire you.
- duxup 7y agoTo be clear I don't mean to criticize the skills that a CS degree provides, nor anyone with one. I wish I had the time to go back to school and get one. I would do it if I could afford to do so in a heartbeat. I wasn't a very good student in my early years, but during a career change took a class and found I loved it, but that time has passed for me for now (kids and career obligations for now). And honestly after I changed careers to a more coding centric career I certainly see the value. I do think the differences you describe VERY MUCH depend on the tasks / job, and are not universal by any means.
- vecter 7y agoIIUC you were doing technical customer support. I'd be surprised if companies have a CS degree requirement for that job.
- CydeWeys 7y agoI'm guessing not a CS degree, but a degree period.
- slackfan 7y agoYou would be surprised, but it's fairly common practice.
- duxup 7y agoThey sure did. In fact after the company was acquired again later (well a few acquisitions later) I had moved on and was thinking of changing careers when a former coworker(s) and a manager contacted me desperate for help. I was only mildly interested but I agreed to interview at the new company. Their system rejected me for no CS degree, it was an automated email from their HR system ;) I had years of experience with some of their proprietary systems, but nope. Before they could fix that glitch I had reconsidered and told my friends I wanted to move on (more so based on my personal interests).
- myu701 7y ago> I'd be surprised if companies have a CS degree requirement for that job. I wouldn't be as there are not a lot of 'technical support' degrees. Someone once told me something to the effect of "the two people groups that understand a program the most are the developers and application support", which I interpreted to mean that just because you didn't write the program doesn't mean you don't gain close familiarity with its problem domain, inputs, outputs, behavior under adverse conditions etc.
- beardbound 7y agoI worked tech support for years and completely agree with that statement. I work in test automation these days and try to meet regularly with support to figure out what usage patterns are like and what pain points people are actually having in the field. My current company is too small to have a dedicated support team so I just get all the emails for the engineering team, but as we grow I plan on implementing something similar. Good support people are worth their weight in gold and I feel like they get dismissed too often in the field. It seems like that's starting to change though as I see better pay at startups for support positions.
- draw_down 7y agoMmm, I would not expect big-tech Silicon Valley to be the place where the best technical support comes from, nor would I expect holders of "fancy" CS degrees to be particularly good at or motivated by that work. Not many people who want to be big shots someday are digging into what makes support tick. For better or worse.
- john_moscow 7y ago>I knew dozens of people who could do that job at a third the cost, but they'd never hire them. That isn't the point. The point is to blow up your valuation to multiple billions without making a dime in profits by making all sorts of vague and pompous statements. Like claiming that you only hire the best (and actually hiring the people based on their ability to make buzz) and then dump it on the unsuspecting retail investor from outside the Valley. This will prevail until the public investors stop drinking the hypergrowth kool-aid and start demanding actual profits. May take another decade though.
- Smoosh 7y agoEveryone's licking the toad, hoping it will turn into a unicorn.
- LoSboccacc 7y agothey didn't seem to learn from the dot.com era, it if anything they learned better to pass the bucket to small investors right before the collapse to retain most profit from the bubble while hiding toxic investments into derivatives
- rifung 7y ago> Ultimately the job was customer support some mild technical skills / ability to learn / take good notes / ask good questions / the ability to formulate a theory, test it, and so on. > They couldn't find any of the fancy CS degree folks Fascinating.. I wonder if their creating a high barrier of entry actually backfired and caused them to hire less competent people? My hypothesis: people with CS degrees are fairly high in demand, and on average are qualified to get much "better" jobs than customer support. This being the case, if you require a CS degree, you end up with predominantly the people who were unable to get a better job elsewhere, who are less capable whether it be due to motivation, intelligence, or something else. Note this completely assumes that software engineering jobs have better compensation/benefits than customer support and I acknowledge I don't know your previous employer's specific case. I also don't want to knock any customer support people, so I hope you will excuse my liberal use of the word "better": I only mean better in terms of compensation and I understand there are more important things than money.
- kryogen1c 7y ago>I wonder if their creating a high barrier of entry actually backfired and caused them to hire less competent people? A property manager told me once that if you are having problems finding good tenants that you should lower prices. Perhaps counterintuitive, no? He claimed that it opens you up to a much larger pool of people that allows you to discover better tenants.
- jjeaff 7y agoInteresting. I've heard the opposite. Charge more money assuming that higher income individuals tend to have more to lose when it comes to apartment damage or getting evicted.
- wolco 7y agoI still think money isn't the only factor. A poor family can make better tenants because they need the place to function and need a stable home. A rich college student with rich parents will sue you to death over anything if they choose to break the lease or a dispute arises.
- vanusa 7y agoAt one point one of them showing me how things worked asked "What do people do in Minnesota for work?" I told him "The same thing you're doing..." He found that hard to believe. I've long suspected that much of what the algorithm testing craze (and other grilling on "strong CS fundamentals") in the current default hiring process boils down to is -- they just want to have some kind of vague reassurance that the people they're hiring are somehow "better" than the folks the other companies are hiring. Even if the standards of "better" (and they means of measuring it) are - when we think about it - pretty dubious. (To head off some of the tangential discussion that would otherwise likely ensue from what I just said: I don't dispute the value of doing some algorithm testing -- the point is that a lot of places seem to overtest these days, and it seems also that the only reason they're doing it is because they think that's what other companies - or at least the ones they'd like to fantasize that they're emulating - are doing).
- spike021 7y agoIMO the 'testing' done these days for CS interviews is just a by-product of the "big" "OG" companies starting out with a lot of "top university" grads/students. So when those guys needed to hire new recruits, they wanted a way to screen them that resonated with what they were used to: rigorous testing and exams. So they replicated the kinds of tests they needed to pass to get into Stanford/Ivies/MIT/etc. and the ones they had during coursework and produced the basic idea of what SDE interviews are now. And since that became the standard from the beginning, it's what remains now.
- tooMuchCensor 7y agoFew real world programming problems are straight forward enough to test on. Or at least I don't expect computer science to turn into a physics/chemistry/math level of science. I think it's hovering around medicine. Where there is a seemingly art form to deal with the realities of our too complex biology.
- ben7799 7y agoThere are pretty clear differences in what a BS in Computer Science represents from different schools. 1st Tier schools a Bachelor's degree holder has most of the fundamentals of mathematics within computer science. Complexity of algorithms, complexity of operations on various data structures, models of computation, problems that can be solved with different models, etc.. 20 years on from going to school it took me a long time to figure out a lot of schools don't cover almost all of that until you're working on a Master's degree or Ph. D. It's really surprising. I think some of CS questions in interviews are because the degrees are so variable. I don't think this is a problem when you're hiring a Mechanical Engineer or a Civil Engineer who is licensed. All the schools need to teach to a uniform enough standard that their graduates can pass the licensing requirements. CS is a mess. The Top Tier schools seem like they may be so much better that a Bachelor's degree is worth more than a Master's degree from other places.
- Koremat6666 7y agoThis is complicated by PERM process for green cards. While many companies might not give damn about college degrees it is safe for them to advertise the job as if it requires college degrees. Just open the San Jose Mercury news and see all those job postings. There will be ads like "Want an individual with Masters Degree or Bachelors degree with 2 years of experience with courses in AI, Database and Web Programming". There might be artificial factors requiring the factories to hire people with white collar education.
- mastazi 7y agoI was in your same position until I decided to just get the degree. It was a positive experience that I now recommend to anyone in the same position, because: 1. The hands-on subjects will be very easy for obvious reasons 2. The theoretical subjects are going to be extremely interesting to you, because you will be able to investigate the theoretical basis of things that you've learned from experience - when a subject is very interesting to you, automatically it's less hard to study. 3. Studying at a relatively mature age is actually awesome! Studying feels more like a privilege and less like a chore. And the interaction with younger students is probably not going to be as hard as you think.
- duxup 7y agoI wish I could do that full time. I took some time to take a class for a career change and I LOVED IT, i was shocked how much I enjoyed it, but don't have the time / resources to go all in at this time. I completely echo your sentiment about taking classes at a mature age being completely different. I was not a good young student but I found myself excited EVERY DAY for class when I was going. It was so much fun. There were a few of us older students and we were always excited with a handful of younger students.... the rest of the students looked like they were greatly inconvenienced by going to class (admittedly I probabbly did too at that age). The difference taking classes now vs then is night and day for me. There was a core group of us who worked together a lot showing up early / staying to help each other, and it was about 30% older and 70% younger and it was a great experience.
- bsenftner 7y agoThe same thing happens if interested in a graduate degree. The work is not nearly as hard as it is claimed to be, and ones real world work experience dwarfs graduate school projects. When completing, one gains confidence as well as realizes what a load of BS these degrees really are.
- 0xffff2 7y agoI don't really agree with this for all people. I'm sure it's true for some, but I'm less sure that it's widely applicable. I got a CS degree from a fairly well ranked (somewhere in the 25-50 range) school. For context, I went to school several years later in life than most undergrads, but I wasn't a developer during the intervening years. I came into university with nothing more than a hobbyist's knowledge, but through continued extracurricular activities and paid internships, I kept myself perpetually well ahead of the curve. 1. True, and the ability to complete over-engineer undergrad CS projects just because you have the time to do so is often a lot of fun. 2. Didn't work that way at all for me. I already had a better theoretical understanding than the undergrad curriculum was designed to teach me, so I was constantly bored. I didn't even do particularly well in the theory-focused classes because tests often asked to regurgitate what the class taught rather than asking for an explanation of the theory that was the subject of the class. 3. I find this one utterly baffling. How anyone could consider studying (as distinct from learning!) a privilege is totally beyond me.
- megablast 7y agoNobody with a CS degree wants to do tech support.
- user5994461 7y agoWondering whether it was a second grade company and a low paying position in SV? If you're any good and in SV, you try to move up role or move up the ladder, ain't staying in a low paying support position. The opportunities are everywhere waiting to be taken. It's kind of a brain drain. If you're any good and in side Minnesota, it might be quite harder to move up.