5 ms·
I would be very careful about making that large a generalization (that all else being equal, women would prefer to stay home over working). Childcare is mind n
by cortesoft 7y ago
I would be very careful about making that large a generalization (that all else being equal, women would prefer to stay home over working).
Childcare is mind numbing work, especially with young kids. Sure, some women (and men) would prefer that, but a LOT of women prefer office work over raising children.
"why not to enjoy life instead of spending 50-60 hours at the office?" is really selling short how much work raising young kids is. It is NOT enjoying life to stay home with toddlers. Maybe once they start school and you get hours to yourself, but before that it is way more time consuming than working at an office.
I know, I have done both. I took long paternity leaves to care for both of my kids, and while I love being able to bond with the kids, I was so happy to be able to go back to work. The freedom I have at the office compared to being home with the kids was night and day. Just being able to go to the bathroom when I need to, to get food when I want..... young kids are non-stop work.
I LOVE being a dad, but the weekends are way more stressful than the weekdays. Wrangling kids is way harder than programming computers.
- flatiron 7y agoI totally agree. I work from home programming so my dad office and my programming office is the same place. Taking conference calls and browsing HN is way easier than wrangling 3 kids 5 and younger.
- davidw 7y ago> I would be very careful about making that large a generalization (that all else being equal, women would prefer to stay home over working). Especially within earshot of my wife. Stuff like that pisses her off to no end, with good reason. She's smart and accomplished and very much enjoys the challenges of a professional career.
- jariel 7y ago" Stuff like that pisses her off to no end, with good reason. She's smart and accomplished and very much enjoys the challenges of a professional career." No, it's not with 'good reason'. If your wife is 'smart' as you say, then she (and you) will recognise that generalisations having nothing to do with your particular situation. That women may be inclined to want to 'stay home' more than not, has nothing to do with the obvious fact that many women (such as your wife) 'want a career'. That your wife is 'pissed off to no end' to hear what might be actual fact it actually the problem with society. You're afraid to talk about it, as is everyone in the press because it 'upsets some women' to hear some genralizations which may be true. It's actually very problematic that your wife is 'pissed off to no end' when she hears data that might not be consistent with her lifestyle - because it closes down needed conversation. Second - your statement "she's smart and accomplished" is arguably sexist and denigrating to the very 'smart and accomplished' women who chose not to have a career. My belief is that most women do want some kind of meaningful work, until the time they want to have children, in which case things change. At this time, my bet would be most (definitely not all) want to focus on the kids, but have 'some kind of option' that keeps them professionally engaged to the world, but with 'maximum flexibility'. These choices may not be 'careers' in the sense we think of them. Example: women studies years to become licensed acupuncturist, works hard to set up practice and community, then settles down with partner, working with a limited number of clients while raising young children. The work requires intelligence, it's 'helping' (or at least people think it is), it's social, it's independent, it's 'green', it's related to the community etc., and it's not exactly high stress / corporate / careerism. Given an array of life choices for women - something like this example I believe would be highly popular. In my own life, if you replace 'acupuncturist' with 'therapist', 'designer', 'homeopath', 'makeup consultant', 'massage therapist' it would cover a good many number of the women that I know. Of course it has nothing to do with the other good number of women that I know who are engaged in more or less professional career paths.
- ChaosDegenerate 7y agowell, somehow the society at large has no problem with exactly opposite generalization: that women prefer to work over staying home with their kids. It is an individual matter, I agree. With most women definitely having the preference of staying at home. But for that the right partner is needed, i.e. one who provides enough resources for her and her kids. If this is not present she will go to work. We decided as a society to frame it different just not to face difficult truth, which is society becoming poorer. It's just so much easier to say that somehow nowadays women prefer working to following their maternal instinct. As a man you are wired to compete with other males for resources to be brought to your partner and offspring. I'm sorry but this is just how it works. Women define male attractivness based on his socio-economic status. Of course if you don't want your wife (and other females and society at large) to look down at you, you will eventually go back to work and work your ass off. She on the other hand, can but she doesn't need to. It's not like you or pretty much anyone will look down at her for not working. Current social fashions aren't going to change five milion years of evolution of the species.
- watwut 7y agoWomen marched for right to work and education. It was not males forcing them to, it was literally movement by women.
- ChaosDegenerate 7y agoOf course they did. So that they can work. But don't have too. Great deal if you ask me.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoThe right to do something is different from the want to do something. How many people have fought for their right to vote? And yet how abysmal is voter turnout every year? The desire for education is very different from the desire for work. I am not saying there are no women (or even the majority of women) who want to work because it is their choice. But I think we are making it a gender issue when really it isn't. Do most men want to work or do they have to? Social mores have dictated the man be the provider for centuries, if not millenia. I think it depends on the individual more than the gender.
- jawns 7y ago> Childcare is mind numbing work > It is NOT enjoying life to stay home with toddlers. > I was so happy to be able to go back to work > the weekends are way more stressful than the weekdays I have to say, this kind of perspective on being a parent puzzles me, even though it's pretty widely held. Honestly, many parents I encounter seem almost as if they'd prefer to be their child's aunt or uncle than their mom or dad. Certainly not in title, but possibly in terms of responsibilities. I get it, raising kids is HARD. But the sense of purpose I feel about writing code that helps my company's investors become slightly richer is totally unlike the sense of purpose I feel about teaching my child about the alphabet, even if many days it feels like a slog. I like this quote from G.K. Chesterton about the importance of this work. Chesterton is talking specifically about a mother, but I think it holds true whether the primary caregiver is a father or a mother: > To be Queen Elizabeth within a definite area, deciding sales, banquets, labors and holidays; to be Whiteley within a certain area, providing toys, boots, sheets, cakes. and books, to be Aristotle within a certain area, teaching morals, manners, theology, and hygiene; I can understand how this might exhaust the mind, but I cannot imagine how it could narrow it. How can it be a large career to tell other people’s children about the Rule of Three, and a small career to tell one’s own children about the universe? How can it be broad to be the same thing to everyone, and narrow to be everything to someone? No; a woman’s function is laborious, but because it is gigantic, not because it is minute. I will pity Mrs. Jones for the hugeness of her task; I will never pity her for its smallness.
- jedberg 7y agoThink of it this way. Imagine if when you went to work, you only got to do the "fun stuff" for a hour a day, and the rest of the day you just filled out paperwork and moved things back and forth in a predetermined pattern. And work lasted from the time you woke up to the time you slept. Being a parent is the greatest joy I've ever known, but the joyful parts are the punctuation on the mind-numbing toil. That toil is only bearable because of the fun bits, but it's still there. Being a parent is very important work, and can bring great joy, but it's possible to both love the joy and hate the toil in between.
- josinalvo 7y ago
- tasogare 7y ago> but a LOT of women prefer office work over raising children Do you have any statistics about that? I once saw a map of Japan, which is a place were a good job can still provides for a while family, showing that in every prefectures of Japan except two, more than half of women preferred to be stay at home mom. In two more others it was half-half. Of course there is the cultural context, but it’s interesting that when given the choice for real, most of women would indeed chose not to work. Also, if one look at jobs that are prized by women, teacher arrive in a very good position. And teaching is basically rising others people kids on an industrial scale.
- JoeAltmaier 7y ago...assuming that women in Japan can choose at all.
- ChaosDegenerate 7y agooooopssss... and what do we have here? A little colonizer mentality? ;-)
- danbolt 7y agoJapan is a lot more conservative of a society compared to North America and Europe. I've known University-educated women in Japan suddenly halt their careers to entirely cook and clean for a household. I don't think that's a totally un-apt comparison.
- dang 7y agoWe've banned this account for perpetuating flamewar on HN. Your first comment in the thread was provocative but was possible to read as good faith. Your replies are not—you're tossing Molotov cocktails, and making it clear that you're uninterested in using HN as intended. That's not cool. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.
- 7y ago
- stvswn 7y agoYour point about childcare being difficult is absolutely correct, but I don't know if you're correct that a "LOT" of women (I assume you mean counterintuitively more than the commentor implied) would not want to stay home to raise them, all things considered. Based on personal relationships with my wife, sisters, and close family and friends I believe it is very, very common for mothers to find returning to work very difficult (even though it's a lot of work to stay home). I don't think anyone intends to imply that there aren't men who feel this way, that there aren't women who don't feel this way, or that the reason for anyone feeling this way is because work is hard and staying home with kids is easy.
- maerF0x0 7y ago> I would be very careful about making that large a generalization (that all else being equal, women would prefer to stay home over working). The conversation I rarely see people having is wether a people group (men or women, for example) has a long term positive/regret recollection of the choice. I understand that most of the messaging today is that women can (and should) pursue paid employment and so naturally that becomes the narrative that people repeat. But 30 yrs later do women generally regret entering the workforce to the detriment of having / raising children? Anecdotally I know many men regret spending so much time at work and not being more involved in their children's lives, could it also hold true for women?
- JauntTrooper 7y agoSo true. We have two kids under 3. I am far more drained taking care of them for a day than I am after a day in the office. We pay $42,000 a year in childcare (2 kids, $1,750 /month, which is one of the cheapest options in our area). After taxes its 90%+ of my wife’s entire salary. It doesn’t make financial sense for her to work, but she’s good at her job, and she’s in a career where taking years off is punishing (law). Honestly though, a big part of it is she wants to work, stress and all. It makes sense to me. As for me, I would prefer to stay home with them instead of work, but I am the primary earner and am also in a career that punishes people severely who take time off (finance). So here we are.
- ChaosDegenerate 7y agowomen these days... having kids is too much work, let someone else take care of them. I feel bad for you brother.
- cortesoft 7y agoMen these days... having kids is too much work, let someone else take care of them.
- deogeo 7y ago> I would be very careful about making that large a generalization Sure - but then, lets also not generalize in the opposite direction. How many women get to work, versus how many have to work?
- agumonkey 7y agoI think most parents are exhausted to their knees with kids. But they also ~all say that it's their life's blood (I mean the energy, not blood ties obv.). A job rarely gives you that much meaning.
- cortesoft 7y agoI know I think I am a much better parent having daycare during the week. I am able to give a lot more to my kids when I am with them since I get that break. I think overall, it improves our relationship.